Moz Crawler suddenly reporting 1000s of duplicates (BE.net)
-
In the last 3-4 days we've had several thousand 'duplicate content' warnings appear in our crawl report, 99% of them related to our on-site blog. The blog is BlogEngine.Net, but the pages simply don't exist. The majority seem to be Roger trying quasi-random URLs like:
/?page=410/?page=151
Etc. etc. The blog will present content for these requests, but it is of course the same empty page since there's only unique content for up to /?Page=10 or so.
Two questions:
1. Did something change recently? These blogs have been up for months, and this problem has only come up this week. Did Roger change to become more aggressive lately?
2. Suggested remediation? On one of the blogs I've put no-index no-follow for any page that has a /?page querystring, and we'll see what effect that has come next crawl next week. However, I'm not sure this will work as per:
http://moz.com/community/q/functionality-of-seomoz-crawl-page-reports
Anyone else had dynamic blogs suddenly blossom into thousands of duplicate content warnings? Google (rightly) ignores these pages completely.
-
Hate to bump my own question, but it appears I spoke too soon about no-index,no-follow solving this. The duplicate errors went away for about 5 days, but then yesterday spiked with the same problem. I've confirmed that no-index, no-follow are present on the pages being detected as bad.
As per the best practices document:
http://moz.com/learn/seo/robotstxt
Using meta robots no index no follow is the recommended option:
Block with Meta NoIndex
This tells engines they can visit, but are not allowed to display the URL in results. This is the recommended method
But it apparently isn't working, as evidenced by the new surge of duplicate errors. Is there anything else I can do? I don't want to explicitly block Roger in robots.txt as that seems rather backward. Should Roger be included the Bad Robots List?
-
Peter -
Thanks for the clarification. I understand the philosophy at hand, and I kind of even understood it before I had asked the question. I'm handling these with a mix of canonical and no-index/no-robot.
Related to that, update:
By marking the superfluous pages no-index/no-follow the error count for the site has diminished by about 10,000 and the warning count by about 28,000 so that seems to be the way to go. The pages that had content are 'low value' in this context, since that content was readily available elsewhere.
-
Hi there!
Thanks for writing in with a great question.
We definitely count those dynamic URLs as duplicate content. While we are pretty sure that search engines can figure this stuff out and know which URL to index, it's still considered best practices to canonicalize or otherwise direct crawlers to the original URL (as far as I know. I'm not a professional SEO so you might be better off asking the Pro Q&A community at www.moz.com/community/q - they are all SEOs like you).
Since some dynamic URL generators can cause problems for crawlers, we do try to be overly-inclusive of these issues rather than overly-exclusive. We want people to know about potential issues with sites, even if they're not really issues in the scheme of the site owner's specific SEO implementation plan.
In sum, we'd rather leave those judgments up to you and at the same time, provide you with the data you need to make these decisions. I hope this helps explain our thinking here! However, if you think that our crawler might be having issues, and you do not want to post your site urls here you could always send us a support ticket at help@moz.com. That way can can examine it a bit further and provide some insights into why our crawler thinks this way!
Hope this helps!
Peter
Moz Help Team.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Duplicate meta descriptions
Hi all,
Reporting & Analytics | | Roi_Bar
Google webmaster point me to duplicate meta descriptions problem between pages with difference URL but have the same canonical URL.
What could be the reason? https://treato.com/ParaGard,tired/?a=s
https://treato.com/ParaGard,Tiredness/?a=s
https://treato.com/ParaGard,tired/?a=s
https://treato.com/ParaGard,Tiredness/?a=s gKUSXsU1 -
No Data in Custom Report set to 'Hit' Scope
Hi Guys, Been having a problem recently with a custom report I have set up... I want to find out number of sessions, bounce rate, session duration etc for different dimensions on my site - store area, store name, product type etc but I cannot seem to get the data to filter through to the report I have set up when 'Session' scope is selected. If I set it to 'hit' then I do get the data but this will only record the first instance of a dimension being triggered (from what I can gather) rather than all dimensions that might be triggered during a complete session. Has anyone experienced similar problems? Thanks, Dan
Reporting & Analytics | | SEOBirmingham810 -
Webmaster Tools Suddenly Asking For Verification of Site Registered for 5 Years
Google Webmaster Tools has been successfully installed on my website, (www.nyc-officespace-leader.com) for more than five years. Suddenly, today I have received a request to Verify this Site". This makes no sense. The only possibility I can think of is that this is somehow tied to the following events in the last month: 1. Launch of new version of website on June 4th
Reporting & Analytics | | Kingalan1
2. Installation of Google of Tag Manager
3. Sudden Increase in number of pages indexed by Google. Unexplained indexing of an additional 175 pages. About 625 pages should be indexed, while 800 are now indexed. In the last month ranking and traffic have fallen sharply. Could it be tat these issues are all linked? But the strangest issue is the request to verify the site. Does anyone have any ideas? Thanks,
Alan0 -
Best way to handle duplicate title on Home page?
Moz reports two links to the same Home page ad duplicate titles ... http://myhjhome.com/index.php
Reporting & Analytics | | ElykInnovation
http://myhjhome.com I'm not sure if I should just 301 redirect http://myhjhome.com/index.php to http://myhjhome.com, or if there is a better way to handle that? Or should I comb the website and make sure all links to the Home page dont include index.php? Just looking for some extra help here, learning as I'm going, thanks!!0 -
How do I fix apparent duplicates
I'm auditing a site and would appreciate your help with possible explanations and solutions as to why Google Analytics in the Content Drilldown page is showing what appears to be duplicate pages. (Refer image) I'm wondering if I have got my head around the rel=canonical tag because the page I'd consider a duplicate "page/" has a Canonical tag pointing to "~/page.html" This is the tag from the page Locations/ rel="canonical" href="http://www.domain.com/Locations.html" /> so am unsure why both versions of the page are generating views. Shouldn't the Canonical tag work like a 301 redirect? I'm unsure how the pages using the path page/ are generating so many views because I have not been able to find them and they are not indexed by Google. Unfortunately the site is built using a Propriety CMS I'm not familiar with. exK4EqrU25
Reporting & Analytics | | NicDale0 -
SEO Moz Errors
We have SEO Moz Errors and warnings showing up, yet we have cleaned them
Reporting & Analytics | | RNK
up. The same errors were showing up in Google's Webmaster tools but after we corrected them they do not show up as crawl errors in Webmaster tools.
Why is SEO Moz different and why does it continue to show corrections already made.0 -
Best use of Keyword Rankings report
is there a guide for getting the most out of the keyword ranking tool? I currently have 250 or so keywords, some move up, some move down on a weekly basis but generally trend up. That's about as much info as I gain from it though. anyone got any good tips? thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | benj450 -
Webmaster Tools shows 0 visits, Analytics shows 1000s?
Webmaster Tools reported a "Big traffic change for top URL" for one of our sites about three and a half weeks ago. WT traffic is 0 since that date. However, our analytics data shows no significant decline in traffic. The WT alert was received on Nov. 16. There was a significant dip in GA visits Nov. 22 but it recovered and I'm seeing no other indication that this is a penalty. What could be going on?
Reporting & Analytics | | IMM0