Is SEO effect of NAP Inconsistency A Hoax?
-
Is the effect of NAP inconsistency on search rankings basically a myth to justify business citation management services? I've been doing SEO for over 10 years but only recently started doing local businesses. I have yet to find any sort of published study that clearly shows a significant ranking effect by correcting an inconsistent NAP on any business directory site other than Google and Bing Business Listings. In fact, the publishers of any such articles claiming NAP inconsistency has a significant negative SEO effect are almost always businesses or people that are charging for such services. Gee, could they be a little biased?
Obviously if you have an incorrect address that is far from the actual address, correcting it will help your ranking (think 3-pack) in the area close to your business but that's not really the type of ranking effect I'm talking about here. I'm talking about a missing suite #, or an old address that is 1/2 block away from the new address but still the same phone number, or identical address but different phone (a toll free versus a local number). That kind of stuff.
Of course you don't want to have an incorrect address or non-working phone number on places like Superpages, Yelp, Yellowpages, etc, but does anyone know of any place I can find good factual proof that having inconsistent NAPs on these sites has any significant effect on rankings? I'm sure some of the big SEO companies have the data to determine the effect. Or is this more of a "tin foil hat" / herd / OCD mentality on this subject that no one can prove (or disprove?)
-
Hi MrSem,
Yes, the limitations you've pointed out are, unfortunately, baked into the environment. There's no way to prove impact in a vacuum. You can't stop competitors from making changes on their end that could be positive or negatively impacting the rank of your business at the same time that you are cleaning up your citations. Search results are so dynamic, it's rarely possible to be 100% positive in stating causation, with no margin for error, because even if you can control what your company is doing, you can't control what competitors are doing in the same time frame, or as you mention, a Google update occurring in that time frame, or even a bug. So, basically what you have is industry practitioners over time noticing apparent cause and effect. When practitioners state that citation cleanup appears to impact search visibility, it's based on more formal studies like Andrew's (above) and on what they notice across the board with clients, over time.
As for what is actually being cleaned up, that's easier to define. It's going to be resolving inconsistent NAP+W, hours of operation, categories and duplicates, much of the time. It can also include remedying incompletions.
I understand your skepticism. Toothpaste manufacturers have a vested interest in telling you their product will make your teeth whiter. But there's an important difference here that shouldn't be overlooked: the things we've come to think of as local search ranking factors originate in the early study of local search results being performed in the trenches by very small agencies. Going back more than a decade, you can read through the blogs of folks like Mike Blumenthal, sharing what they are discovering moves the needle, client by client. That's not quite the same as the toothpaste company, because the scale was very small at the dawn of Local. You could chalk the corpus of local-related blog posts over the past 12 or so years up to being mere sales pitches, but I think if you start reading backward from 2017, you'll see it really wasn't that way. Just as in organic SEO, it's been a voyage of discovery
-
It's nice to see there is at least something out there. However both articles lack the necessary details about the work that was done to lend them credibility in my eyes. The first one is just a graph. There's several flaws.
The first one I already mentioned but I'll discount it since there's no way around it. And that is, there could be a gazillion reasons why the rankings of those businesses went up that have nothing to do with making the citations more consistent. I don't see any major algo updates during those periods though so that's good - so I'll give the benefit of the non-doubt here. And I'll have to also go on a limb that there were no significant changes in the backlink profile and the website content of the majority of the properties used in these assessments - realistically, there probably was, but let's disregard it for argument sake.
Here's the missing piece - what types of NAP changes were made? Specifically, I'd want to know what percentage of the NAPs where the city was changed, were they changed to a more densely populated area which naturally will get more 3-pack/map user impressions?
I'd say without someone like the new Matt Cuts confirming it's a significant ranking factor, it's still a mystery. Those two reports of course were put out by companies that sell Local SEO services. (But who else would take the time to do them? LOL)
I think the bottom line is improving the consistency of your NAPs can only help your business. But I think claims about it having a significant effect on organic rankings are still far from proven.
-
Great question, MrSem! Now, full disclosure: I do work for Moz and we do have Moz Local, and I want to validate your comment about not feeling certain whether you can really trust statements made by folks who offer citation management as a service. I can see why you'd feel that way - makes sense to ask a question like yours. So, if even given my work here at Moz, you can still find some value in my explanation of the role of location data management, I'd like to take the time to reply.
Here's one case study you might like to look at, in which Local SEO Guide fixed 8000+ citation issues for a retailer with 1,300 branches, with a documented increase of 23% in Google local pack visibility across 6000 tracked keywords: http://www.localseoguide.com/our-work/case-studies/local-retailer-citation-cleanup/
Here's another in which Mockingbird saw a 27% increase in traffic following citation cleanup using both Moz Local and Yext: https://mockingbird.marketing/mockingbird-case-study-local-optimization-nap-cleanup/
You can find other studies like this, and Moz has done some internal case studies of its own with customers where we've seen similar numbers resulting from citation/duplicate cleanup.
When it comes to citations, I think of their role in two ways:
-
We know Google draws data from a variety of sources. If Google is drawing in bad data about your business, it's not a good thing. So, this is on the SEO side of things: defending your Google presence by ensuring that the sources Google draws from are accurate and trustworthy.
-
From a consumer standpoint, bad data is a trust and revenue killer. One Placeable study found that a whopping 73% of consumers lose trust in a brand if its listings contain misinformation (https://searchenginewatch.com/sew/study/2338839/73-lose-trust-in-brands-due-to-inaccurate-local-business-listings-survey). And, you have only to experience the annoyance of calling an out-of-service phone number or arriving at the vacated building of a business that has moved to form a very negative impression of a local brand.
For me, point #1 is table stakes in Local SEO. Between the numbers in studies like the ones I've linked to, and my own experience of seeing Google pull wrong data from various places, a clean citation profile is a must in a competitive market. But, beyond this, it's that 2nd point that really gets me: if you miss out on "being there" at a consumer's point-of-decision because your listing on Citysearch or Yelp or Foursquare is incorrect, who knows how much revenue you've just lost? Some statistics say that a customer is worth 6-7 times as much as the dollar amount of his initial purchase. So, you may not just be missing out on one $60 sale of a yoga mat. You could be missing out on $420 dollars of sales over time. You might not only be missing out on a single purchase of a $4,000 engagement ring; you could be losing $28,000 in lifetime sales. So, for sure, you want to be in the right places, at the right moment, with the right data.
Hope these thoughts are helpful, and that others in the community will join this interesting discussion. It's a good one!
-
-
I have read those same countless articles but can´t think of any study on it, neither any respectable person in the industry elaborating on it. We pay attention to maintaining consistency in the NAP´s (don´t sell it as a service though) just as good business practice and always had the idea it would be good for SEO as well. Now i am not so sure if there is any impact there.
When i see people mentioning ".. even the slightest variations...will hinder a search engine´s confidence" my hairs standup as i have seen over time that many NAP´s from clients have natural variations, sometimes parts of the address are abbreviated, order of words changed, a small insignificant part of the address omitted, phone numbers with international codes and without, with extensions and without, Names with Ltd and without. Doesn´t make any sense to me that these would already hinder the search engines´s confidence as they are natural (google always claims to like natural).
Very interested to see if someone will come up with a credible source for this
-
I've probably read the same "countless articles" but none of them even referenced any anecdotal evidence, let along a careful study. I agree the study would be difficult because in the time between correcting the NAPs and the search engine picking up the corrections everywhere, there could be other factors that affect your ranking. But if you are doing SEO for 100 local businesses, then you can pretty much determine with some degree of certainty whether it's essentially a myth or not.
So a "published study" to me might be someone like Brighlocal, say... We took 20 local business clients with NAP inconsistencies and monitored their rankings for two weeks on a daily basis and took the 10 of those 20 with the least variation in daily rankings and submitted corrections to their NAPs at the same time using the same method. We performed no other on-page or off-page SEO for the next x weeks. At the end of the "study" the rankings of the 10 businesses changed as follows....
Now of course there's still going to be external factors that can affect the ranking but over time if you looked at similar data for more and more businesses you could be able to present fairly clear data that it makes a difference.
I've been doing Internet Marketing for almost 20 years and over that length of time you gain increased wisdom and gut instinct on things. I'm not saying I can prove the NAP corrections make no significant difference in your ranking, but from all the articles I've read, the claims sure seem a bit fishy. I've seen this before in other industries. The presentation of misinformation, that on the surface makes sense, but really is just designed to make people think they need a product or service. That's the downside of the Internet, anyone can make any claim without basing it in actual fact. Gee, the term "fake news" comes to mind.
Maybe if you could point to one of the countless articles written by someone very well respected in the industry I can pose the question "Specifically how were you able to determine that?"
Actually here's an article I ran across recently. Not sure how I stumbled on it and definitely wouldn't consider the author a widely respected publisher. But he says:
https://www.stlouisdigitalmedia.com/blog/local-seo/what-is-nap-consistency/
"when search engines are crawling the web they can – and will – notice even the slightest variations in a business name, address, phone number, and/or website address. These variations can hinder a search engine’s confidence."
Okay, the first thing that popped into my head when I read this is "what specifically are you referring to regarding _confidence_ and how does that affect my organic ranking if the address and phone are correct but vary slightly from my other listings?"
Or, tell me why this matters so much and how you determined this? Oh, you offer Local Search Marketing Services! Great! I can pay you to help me avoid the issues you are eluding to!
My gut is telling me using general descriptions like "hinder a search engine's confidence" means this author either is basically regurgitating something he heard elsewhere, also with no detailed justification, or is just making stuff up for the purpose of generating business.
Is everybody so sure the Emperor is actually wearing clothes?
-
I'm not sure what dictates a "published study," but I have read countless articles on how important maintaining consistent NAP-info on business listings. But I'm interested in seeing what other people have to say, so I'll comment to follow this thread.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Advanced SEO - Locations vs Service Areas
Hi we have a Roofing business that has an office "corporate headquarters" in Lincoln Nebraska- We have also setup service areas or "address locations" in other states and cities we service. The remote addresses we have are through the UPS store locations giving us an address in the areas- Knowing that Google GMB wants us to list these as service locations and not physical addresses- they have told me directly we are setup okay with separate GMB pages for each location- they say we just need to "hide" the addresses in GMB. Question: If we "hide" the local address on "all" of the local listings how will this affect the local SEO? It seems like not having a physical office will hurt the local presence- or moreso- having an actual office will help it? Can anyone give input and opinion of setting up "Service Areas" vs "Locations" as it relates to SEO and SERP placement? Many thanks in advance.
Local Listings | | murraycustomhomescom1 -
Local SEO Issue or Penguin? Or both?
Hey folks I have a fairly complicated SEO issue we have been looking at for a few years now. There are two parts to this problem so would be interested to get the input of the community here and any experienced in Penguin and Local SEO issues. I am going to have to change the names to protect the innocent a bit here as some of the issue relates to a competitor and a shared address. History My client originally worked for company A which we will call Events R us. He then set up on his own at a new address and lets call his company Fantastic Events. EventsRus never had a good website or SEO Fantastic Events set up a great website and really focused on adding tons of relevant content for all the myriad event options available and subsequently did really well. This is a few years back and they were also doing some article marketing on sites like ezinearticles.com to build links (1). As time went on they did get a bit carried away with these low quality links and were buying $5 spun content articles and other low quality links. They ranked really well for a few key terms. There was a suspected local SEO issue as fantastic events used the same office as their fathers business called fantastic finance and the citations / phone number issues etc all had to be cleared up (2). Fantastic Events and Events R Us remained friends and over time Fantastic Events moved to the same farm address as Events R Us so they could offer a wider range of services based on the farm (and ran by fantastic events) and to some extent run away from the address confusion with the same office and very similar name to the other fantastic finance business. Events R Us wanted some of the Fantastic Events success and built a new website and largely copied the website of Fantastic Events - at times even lifting entire pages of content but certainly mirroring the structure of the site. Fantastic Events tussled with them for a few years over this and over time they updated the content but the structure and services and address all pretty much mirrored what was offered on the Fantastic Events site. (3) Two companies - same address (it's a farm so whilst there are different barns I believe Google can only get as far as the farm gate so same address to all intents and purposes. Same services give or take. Events R Us was the older company overall by several years and was at the farm address many years longer than Fantastic Events (4). Fantastic Events starts running a blog and adding regular, useful event orientated content. The first true team building blog out there as far as we could tell and traffic tripled over a six month period. Penguin hits and Fantastic Events loses a lot of traction - this gets worse with Penguin 2.0. Both the homepage and the evening events page lose visibility and traction. The owner gives up on the blog to a large degree. Subsequent clean up happens and is rigorous - all bad links are pretty much removed and the remaining elements are disavowed. (90% of it is actually gone by now). Penguin 3.0 comes and no recovery at all. Nothing. If anything it gets worse and the once strong blog is now losing traction. Events R Us starts to do really well in search for exactly the same terms that Fantastic Events used to do well for. In particular one page ranks for exactly the same keywords and in exactly the same position (#1) as what was believed to be the primary traffic driver on the Fantastic Events site. It is almost like they exchanged positions and Events R Us went from nowhere to a strong footing with some national and local keywords and Fantastic Events fell from grace. A new website is built. All content is refreshed and bought up to date. Some light investment back in the blog. Some light link building is done around digital PR and infographics. Some initial movement in the right direction but overall this did not move the dial. Certain pages on the site that used to rank are nowhere - looks very much like a page level / keyword level penguin penalty. These same pages rank great, often first on the competitor site (an exchange of positions to some extent). Advice from myself and other esteemed consultants was to clean up, build some good links and wait for Penguin 4.0 to remove that eventuality. Also that the address issue could be causing some local SEO issue where Google believes the two businesses are one and has somehow merged the two with some local SEO filter or some such (same business with multiple websites at same address). Penguin 4.0 comes along and no improvements. Events R us sit pretty. Feeling is that the local issue must play a part here now that Penguin should be eliminated due to the extensive link clean up etc and there must now be some action to resolve this address / local issue. Issues low quality links - but cleaned up 100% now. same business name and address as fathers business initially older business copied the structure and content of newer business moved to same address as older more established business with very similar content older business now seems to have taken all the exact keywords and positions the newer business used to occupy Penguin 4.0 and no resolution. Local SEO issue seemingly remains Summary So we are left in a difficult position. The business does not want to move. But if there is some filtering or merging going on here then how can we get around this? The client is likely collateral damage to an algorithmic component designed to stop single businesses having multiple websites. I know there are reports of this happening but I have never seen such a thing for an innocent business like this but the nature of the address (two separate barns on a gated farm) and the history and similarities between the businesses makes this difficult. Things are somewhat desperate though - a move has to be made now. Even if that is a physical one. The client has considered a virtual address to take that variable out the picture but I have advised caution. I am even cautious about a change in physical address. Google has a long memory. If such a move was made at considerable expense would it help or would the other business retain Is the best option a new start? New brand, address, website, services etc - cut all ties with the historic Fantastic Events brand and by association the Events R Us brand. This is not a recommendation I can quickly or easily make so would be really interested to hear the feedback on anyone who has come across such a multi faceted and complex issue before. This is a tough one. We know what we are doing on the local front. We know what we are doing on the Penguin front. We know how to build links and authority. We are doing this work of the clock to help a long term friend / client get back to where they really deserve to be. The history is not spotty clean but the good work and effort far outway a short spell building dodgy links several years ago now. As an SEO consultant I don't want to advise for the company to rebrand and move offices at considerable expense but whilst I have a theoretical understanding of the issue how can we prove it and be sure this is the best possible advice? Thanks folks - hope this at least makes for interesting reading. This is something of an edge case. A good business likely caught up in a filter designed to stop abuse. Cheers
Local Listings | | Marcus_Miller
Marcus1 -
Yext Power Listings and SEO Question...
Hi, I was wondering if anyone that has used Yext's Power Listings has experienced any negative (or positive) organic SEO results. As you know if you've used Yext, it creates a ton of links from directories. I think they're mainly no-follow links, but wanted to check if anyone has had experience (either good, bad, or neutral) regarding impact on organic results. Thanks.
Local Listings | | mrodriguez14400 -
Local seo citation tools
Hi I have been manually adding my details to local/national directories in order to help my ranking in my google places placing. It is a bit of a grind, and I am aware there are tools out there. I was wondering if anybody has any experience with any of them? I am UK based. Also I was ranking for "Liverpool Photographer" on google places for a couple of months and it brought in quite a bit of work, although I have since slipped back to about 15th, so out of the visible results. I am mainly a wedding photographer so my home page was optimised mainly for "liverpool wedding photographer" Although I hired an SEO company who changed the home page title to "liverpool photographer", I cannot remember if I was ranking on places for this keyword because of this change or I was already in the results before the changes were made. So my question is how Can I rank for "liverpool photographer" and "Liverpool wedding photographer" on a places result at the same time? I hope this makes sense. Best wishes. David.
Local Listings | | WallerD0 -
Foreign languages and SEO: product description
Hi everyone, I have hit a brick wall with regards with the SEO of one of our sites. This is concerning a Belgium based webshop which sells toys. The server is based in the Belgium and the domainname ends also .be . They try to put as much possible dutch/belgium text on the website but the amount of this is very low compared to the english text on the website. The problem starts when they import product description from the main manufacturer which is in english. this means when the customer visits the website, it's dutch, but the product description is in english I have pointed out this but they pointed out the fact they import with 1 click 500 products, but it takes them ages to translate this to dutch. Now is my theory, the way they are doing this, will hurt their ranking a lot in the google.be search engine compared to their competitors to the point that less than 10% of their site is in dutch/belgium and the rest in english. I am thinking of the possibility of suggesting to let them use google translate to automatically translate the products before putting them on the website. It won't be a great translation, but it will stop hurting their ranking and will even contribute to increase their ranking. I thought they do this, and put a small link to the english version of the manufacturer. I would love to hear others thoughts on how to do this with as efficient and fast as possible.
Local Listings | | sami800 -
Best practice for local SEO when two offices handle different services?
Our agency has three main services - SEO, PPC and web design. We're in the process of setting up a new office in a different city where our PPC team will be based, while SEO and web will stay in the original office. How do we handle local SEO/Google My Business listings in this situation? Geo-targeted service pages and two separate GMB listings?
Local Listings | | CustardOnlineMarketing0 -
Swiss SEO Companies
Hello Moz Community! My name is Colby. I work with Comit Developers here in the US, but I currently have a client that is in need overseas. My client is looking for SEO work in Switzerland. We've never worked in this country, but we are willing to outsource to get a little help. I am looking for some smaller SEO companies in or nearby Zurich. Does anyone have any ideas? We are looking for companies who can charge fair prices. I'm not sure how expensive the Swiss market is for SEO, but I'd love some insight. Can anyone help me?
Local Listings | | ComitSEO0 -
How to do Local SEO for few cities in US while client is in Canada
Hi, How i can do the local SEO for few cities of US however client is Canada based. Client want to promote his business in US ( specific cities). Kindly suggest how it will be posible as client do not have address in US. Cheers!!
Local Listings | | 1akal0