Sorry to hear things are still bad for your site.  We are still suffering reduced traffic and have done a ton of work on backlinks, created a list of very old ugly backlinks and a few new ones that frankly must be negative SEO (yea all you people that want to jump in and say no it is not negative SEO ....that is very rare to non-existent...dont bother....I dont want to hear it....your are wrong...you are as niavie as you are a fool).

We have now sent 1000s of emails and or filled out contact forms for link removals from these sites .....and gues what.....ZERO reponces so we are creating a disavow file and will try and come back here and let you know how it goes.

More on the negative SEO.....we have some recent links (according the MAN himself) that are super suspect.  We did not ask for them and there is really no reason for thse site to link us except competitors trying to pile on the already diminised ranks.  Hey negative SEO guys.....Get a life...

I would love to throttle some penguins.

Our rankings are still fluctuating wildly.  Up and down 10 to 35 places from Moz campaign crawl to the next crawl.   This has been going on for months.  It makes little sense.  A keyword that is up 10 one crawl might be down 35 the next and the same keyword might then be up 45 in the next crawl.  It is just non sense.

Are others experiencing this crazy swing up and down ?

At the heart of every algo change is revenue not fairness.  To believe otherwise is to be naive.

+1 on the same thing happened to a few sites we work on.  We have now made all the changes we can to on-page and technical and will let that stew for a few weeks before we consider anything else.  Some traffic has returned but there is a long way to go.

In the mean time spending non-ROI money on PPC.  Ugh

Would sure be nice if the webmaster tool recommendations would keep sync with Algorithmic changes so you could properly react to all the silly black and white creatures.