Dan,
Yes, I had low quality content and as I fix it up I am trying to add it back. I unfortunately noindexed, nofollowed about 100 posts. After I changed to noindex/follow, which is what I wish I had done with all of them.
To set the posts to get re-indexed I have to select - "index" "always include" and when it comes to the Meta Robots Advanced I select "None" and change nofollow to follow and the post changes to allow it to be indexed turning the little color ball from blue to green, but the nofollow does not change and it remains noarchive as well. I have tried this over and over and still will not let me follow with the post again. I did check the source code as well and verified that is shows nofollow,noarchive.
I am using the latest version of WP and the WPSEO plugin as well.
I have attached a screenshot of what my settings are after trying to save a noindex,nofollow blog post.
thank you
Mike