Welcome to the Q&A Forum
Browse the forum for helpful insights and fresh discussions about all things SEO.
try to open my site using your cellphone
Let me make this clear, my full flash website is perfectly NOT SEO friendly ..
but what caused it to be that SEO Friendly, that is because of the HTML .. Currently I have submitted a blog post in regard to this case study (how to make a full flash website SEO friendly), looking forward to it 
Let me give you an example
http://www.google.co.id/search?q=ikt
The search result for my site (ikt.co.id) is ranked first, and have additional sitelinks (4 links, for about, news , etc)
But because my site is extremely new I still dont have the access to Sitelink under 'Site Configuration' on my Google Webmaster 
That is what I am trying to say that this configuration will not always be available to all 
Here is the message i've got
"Google has not generated any sitelinks for your site. Sitelinks are completely automated, and we show them only if we think they'll be useful to the user. If your site's structure doesn't allow our algorithms to find good sitelinks, or we don't think that the sitelinks are relevant to the user's query, we won't show them. However, we are always working to improve how we find and display sitelinks."
Which is quite false, because google has indeed generate a Sitelink for my site but the configuration is not available to me (webmaster) yet
Or in some cases, you need to wait for next report generation
For example, my site's Ranking Report is generated every tuesday
And I added new keywords on friday (that perhaps have never been crawled by SEOMOZ Bot) , in this case I need to wait until the next tuesday when SEOMOZ Bot generates new Ranking Report
My apology , but i disagree only on one thing
"... you can almost guarantee yourself ..."
On a topic that is perfectly on grey zone like this (where not even the Google Webmaster prohibited it directly) , i know that i wont be able to guarantee it myself (even when it is backed with huge amount of correlated data)
All I am saying is, PERHAPS based on the correlation data made by mad scientist in SEOMOZ, the effect for links coming from Comment on Blog is not correlated to high rank , but as said by many correlation is not causation .. Again many on-going debate is running for this kind of discussion but no one can say "i guarantee it " (unless if uncle google decided to participate in this discussion himself) xD
my 2 cents
AND the Sitelinks is not ALWAYS available to all
I would go with .html and drop the end "/"
so /make-money-online/how-to-make-a-million-dollars-in-1-year.html
I dont have a point to prove this, but google like static content more then dynamic content, a plain html files (in my humble opinion and faulted research) always ranked better then the one generated by xxx.php?whatever=1&A=2
... my 2 cents
Seriously you should be looking forward to my blog post (currently they need to review it for technical accuracy, which may take some time) but it is a post about how to make your Flash website as SEO friendly as possible...but until then I can only tell you, "Even the good-old HTML , we need A LOT of optimization to make it PERFECT for indexing..." , i have tried so many ways to make my Full Flash website SEO friendly, and let me tell you, none of them are as powerful as any optimized HTML page 
That is why in my blog post here, I am going to explain how to make your Flash website as SEO friendly as those normal optimized HTML page (and it really works)
Hopefuly the blog post is approved in time
I would say put them below or AT the content... because some times when you put it at the top, they would ignore it (they have not read anything on your site to have an opinion of plussing your page), .. after they scroll through the page and read your content, they finally realized the piece of information they've stumbled upon your page is one piece of art that might rivaled even the best piece of novel they read somewhere... What we would want to happened of course, that they are given the PLUS button / SHARE Button at the right place where we think they might appreciate your content...
Does that make sense? xD ( again this is an opinion, and because i think it made sense,I also employ this into my site ikt.co.id )
Hmm anyone notices ? that when i search 'Dejan Seo love' , the one without hyphenation scored better... while 'Dejan seo love_s_' gives a different result ...
And when we searched 'dejan seo testing' although the hyphenation scored better but the result for the one without hyphenation has all words BOLDED out like this 'Did you know that dejanseolovestesting.com.'
Hmm google indeed works in mysterious way xD
PS : It is too bad that your title is "Dejan Love Testing" i wonder if you have a "Dejan Loves Testing" that the result would be different?
Supposedly we have 6 cities, City A ~ City F
City A ~ C (3 cities) is a ghost city
We can easily make City A, showed additional results for City D and E, while City B shows additional results for City E and F, and of course City C showed results for City F and City D..
In reality, i think one city is surrounded only by 3 ~ 4 cities right? so there will be no city that will have exactly the same neighborhood
If you want you can even kick the additional listing into overdrive by giving some randomization
For example
http://www.stand-out.net/Movitel-Cuffed-Jeans-pr-7703.html (not my site)
You can see the "More From Humor" Section always randomized 3 more items that has Humor Brand (try refreshing the page to see the randomization)... there is no way that you will ever have a duplicate content this way
Again, dont try to built a page for SEO, but built them for your customer first, you will definitely have a very happy customer if you showed them additional result from nearby cities instead of just BLINDLY redirect them to another city
Good luck
In my opinion, i think there is no problem ... But if you want to be on a safe side , why not filled it with useful information instead?
For example : I went to City X Hub Page... when it has absolutely no home at all, i think the visitor would be much more happier when they see certain information like "Duh... no one is selling home in this Ghost City, perhaps you would be interested in properties from nearest city around it such as Show some good home on City Y and City Z "
First thing first, where do you get that number from? is it from alexa ? or google analytics ? or any other sources?
In my opinion if you had a bounce rate that high showed up on google analytics, than you really need to made a further research where this bouncing visitors are coming from
Other than that, i would suggest you to improve your overall site design , some of the reason is explained here ( http://www.seomoz.org/blog/replicate-googles-panda-questionnaire-whiteboard-friday ), a site that looked good potentially attract customer and encourage them to stay a while and surf deeper .. (unless of course if your website is nike.com , where the brand trust can easily overshadow the lack of good site design)
I dont think we have that in SEOMOZ, but hey you can always request this feature over the HELPDESK (look to your upper right corner, open a new ticket on helpdesk)
wait a second... after i checked out your product pages... the pages looked different (between products)... you might not be penalized for this after all the content of the page (using your so called long tail keywords on product description) have successfully make certain product pages unique...
It is the best way! ... look no further seriously....
yes , so never ever take it down, especially when the old site has many backlinks to it already ...
If you are looking for a better way for localization (instead of /en /uk), i think it would be far better for your to purchase local cctld (.co.uk) instead... you can than mark it under your google webmaster tools, that the .co.uk is a content served for UK audiences... and it would be quite easy and much neater too
my 2 cents
Could you please share the site in question? we might be able to give a much more insightful thought
Dont take down the 301 before google has re-indexed everything is the best bet... it might take quite some time but it is a worthwhile wait
To tell you the truth it is actually very easy , but you have to familiar yourself with .htaccess HTTP REWRITE engine .. Seriously it took exactly 2 lines of code to detect and 301 redirects walla.mywebsite.com into www.mywebsite.com/walla
HTTP Rewrite is an extremely useful tool, if you are not familiar with them , please go here http://www.yourhtmlsource.com/sitemanagement/urlrewriting.html (or just google http rewrite redirect)
I think the search engine wont able to track this link at all ... When i tried to browse my site using the google bot (Google Webmaster tools) , my site always detected that google always have the javascript disabled...
However , what you showed us right now is only the script , where is the anchor link that will call this script? Most often people would do something like this on the anchor text
In which case the search engine would be able to successfuly tracked the links back to 'xxx.com'
have you check this out ? http://www.seomoz.org/marketplace
Notices is not something bad :), in fact the right usage of rel=canonical will actually prove to be very useful (rather then hurt your site) , if you have the site in question and the page where the rel=canonical points to, perhaps sharing it with us would help us determine if we should do something about it
You might not get the right response here, but i think you can go to the help desk and submit your ticket (look at the upper right corner, there is a HELP Link over there, you can find the helpdesk there>
If you are looking for the search engine usage for certain keyword, i think the Keyword Tools from Google Adwords have the answer you are looking for
I have not experienced this , do you still have the CSV for all of those inbound links? have you tried researching the missing links (such as which domain is the missing links coming from) ?
In my opinion, if none of those show up in your google webmaster, chance is Google has already ignored those links ..
That is quite high .. When you said you only receive 5 hits , may i ask you where do you get that information from? is it from google.com/analytics or your own pre-built hit counter?
It goes like this
1. you have to extract all of the text content and picture into external source first, for example the text all put into mysql and the pictures are on separate jpeg file
2. you can then program your flash to load that data externally
3. after that you can create a HTML version that utilize those text data (from database) and images (from that jpeg files) , this way whenever you change the data inside your HTML , the data on your flash changes too
4. You have to try display EVERYTHING in html first
5. for example , when people go to xyz.com it will open the HTML first, with all navigation menu available... you optimize this site first ....
6. after the HTML is working perfectly, you can then simply put all of that html under a div that we will override using SWFObject (when a flash player detected)
for example
ALL HTML Content goes here, it will be safely overriden by SWFObject when Flash is detected..
that is all i can say for now... I really wish my blog post has been approved so that you can read the detailed method with picture to guide you through your mission on making your flash movie seo friendly..
REMEMBER to make a site SEO friendly, you have no other choice but to create a HTML Site first, after that override it with FLASH (when flash is detected)... and remember to put all data on EXTERNAL SOURCE, NEVER EVER inside the flash movie
http://ikt.co.id my site has ranked well on many keywords like "bikin website" , "flash seo" , and many others (only on google.co.id) , so i know this method works PERFECTLY
you can not open that page? 
i can already open that page and read the content xD
I uses the SEOMOZ Tool Keyword difficulty to check this up
"BIKIN WEBSITE MURAH" , 40% difficulty , i ranked #10
"BIKIN WEBSITE" , 40% difficulty too but returned much more results, i ranked #5
how can the 2 words keyword perform better then the 3 words keyword?? and those 2 words keyword "bikin website" on my site ALWAYS have the last word "murah" behind them... so it is always "bikin website murah xxx" , or "bikin website seo murah" ... and there also "bikin website murah promo" , so how can the 2 words keyword which return a lot more results perform better then the 3 words keyword ??
or you can read my soon to be published blog on seomoz for this
http://www.seomoz.org/ugc/how-to-make-your-dynamic-full-flash-website-seo-friendly-case-study
The site in question is http://ikt.co.id
The site is perfectly optimized (or even over optimized) for keyword "Bikin Website Murah" (in Indonesia it means "develop an affordable website")
currently if you search on both google.co.id AND google.com, it ranked on #10 (on google.co.id) and it ranked on #7 (on google.com), and both term only return 1.3 million results
I have A LOT OF pages that started with 'bikin website' , or 'website murah' ... there are a lot of them, and i have had a lot of backlinks on those pages too (have been manually building a lot of links, starting from creating a tutorial article and blog submission and many other way) .. the site has been perfectly optimized for that keyword
For example we have
http://ikt.co.id/blog-category/bikin-website-murah-promo-terbaru.html (for newest promotion)
http://ikt.co.id/blog/bikin-website-seo-murah-discount-40-sampai-31-juli-2011.html (for discount 40% promo that lasted untill 31 juli 2011)
AND YET, if you search on google.co.id for keyword "2000 likes facebook" , our lone page that i created when our facebook likes reached that amount, RANKED #1!! , and please let me tell you this term return 400 million results++ (on google.com this keyword ranked #19, on 500 million results++). And let me tell you it take that SINGLE page (which has absolutely 0 backlinks) 2 days to ranked #1 .... and her brother if you searched "1000 likes facebook" also show similar result (though not better then the sister)
How ?!? and Why ?!? , i dont understand this at all.... my domain does not contain any keyword, they uses the same engine and yet that lone pages which have absolutely no backlink ranked so well on a very competitive keyword, while my Target Keyword ranked poorly....
And what is even more bizzare?
"Bikin website murah" might not rank good, but "bikin website" ranked better x_x ... arghh i dont get it... why my site ranked poorly on easy keywords and ranked high on difficult keywords :(( ....
Why I am not smiling because those easy keyword is actually my primary keywords
I have opened a ticket and have got the reply from Shaun
The following is their answer
"
Thanks for writing in, and apologies that your on-page reports aren't showing up as they should be . Our engineers are aware of this oddity and are looking into a fix for it right now, and while I don't have an exact timeframe yet for when that will be deployed, but I do have an alternate method where you can set up on-page report cards manually. I know it's not an exact fix, but it's a solid workaround until the fix is pushed
"
So it seems that it is caused by some technical issues (that will be fix soon enough)
Thanks everyone for pointing me to the helpdesk , i will marked this question answered now
wait a second, are you saying that seomoz staff wont be looking at this forum post? T.T ... Oh I have written the blog and submitted them ... I used the MVC (Model View Controller) software architecture and write a great example using it with the all-mighty wordpress engine , well lets just wait and see when it got approved xD
Okay i have went to the helpdesk and make a request pointing them to this topic, hopefuly by tomorrow my problem will be resolved xD
no , its okay... i dont mean it that way either.
Anyway try to disable your flash player , and you will see that inside the homepage we have 89 links , i also have the same seomoz toolbar and currently are looking at the "Analyze Page" tools from it .. The links are all overridden by your browser when you have both the javascript and flash detected.
And if i am not mistaken, I have tried fetching the page as google bot (from google webmaster tools) and they fetched my page perfectly fine
Again i am not saying who is right or wrong, i have even given you the tips on this at the first post, try to view this website again after you disable your flash
Firefox
1. Tools > Addons
2. Go to Plugins
3. find the Shockwave Flash and disable it first, after that you can open ikt.co.id again and check that all are fine
again sorry i dont mean you any harm
Sorry to disappoint but my website is crawl-able
PS : Please try to open my website using your handphone / some pc with no flash player and you will see what i mean .. Our flash website is not your average flash website , in fact i am currently submitting a YOU MOZ Blog , on how to make a flash website as SEO friendly as any normal website
Currently i have a campaign running for 1 month+ now, it has 42 registered keywords and 40 of them already hit the top 50 (11 of them on top 10), but after i waited for 1 month , the on page report still 0 (yup not even 1 keyword)
whats wrong?
Please help
I have 2 campaigns, the one in question is for http://ikt.co.id
It is a great whiteboard post , actually although the topic they are talking is all about having many sites serving the same content in different languages, while for my question it is about site mirroring (where the site actually server exactly the same content in the same language)...
But I am glad that i read this, it seems that if rand was here with us, he would have no problem Geo Locating people by their IP and redirect them to another domain. Yes i know in that friday post, he mentioned that it would cause some of those foreign site un-indexable by google , because google is indexing our site from US. and that is EXACTLY what i want
currently http://id.ikt.co.id , i have set the robots.txt to not allow any of its page indexed, and for good measure i have also added a canonical rel on every single page to the http://ikt.co.id version.
Sigh, I really would like rand to confirm my conclusion, but it seems like, it is a bit too much to ask him to come here and give me a helping hand (i believe he must be very busy right now, with all of the future conferences coming up)
Anyway thanks a lot for your help
okay to make it much more clearer, i have just made the changes
vs
you can see that both of them share the same +1 google (Thanks to the cannonical) and when you clicked the tweet button on id.ikt.co.id , it will actually tweet the ikt.co.id version... all is good... Please tell me have i missed something important that might hurt my SERP?
Please help, thanks a lot
anyone with any idea of what did i miss? or am i doing alright? 
I will share you my situation okay. Every site hosted in Indonesia will be very slow for anyone not from indo. ANY site hosted outside indo, yes including any cloud host from any of those provider, as long as the cloud or the server is not located in Indonesia , then most indonesian will suffer for it... Yes that is how bad the situation is in indo... I will tell you what, my dedicated server is currently located in theplanet.com, and trust me, I have et to see any cloud that which node is located in Indonesia, the nearest I could find is Singapore....
But that is another matter altogether, isn't it? Do you have any information regarding my main question? Thanks a lot
They are served in both languages, visitor can switch them in real time, but that is not why I want to build an indonesia version, it is because I want the indonesia visitor to have the optimum speed loading my site. And of course I never want the link juices from any backlink to go to id.ikt.co.id, I want them all in ikt.co.id
I definitely don't want id.ikt.co.id to be indexed, but that is easy stuff. Now if I am redirecting my user based on their country won't it hurt my serp?
For instance, if not from indo open ikt.co.id/a.html, they wil open the right page, but when someone from indo loading that page, the page will contain nothing but a redirect to id.ikt.co.id/a.html .. Isn't this what they call content masking??
Target website in question is ikt.co.id,it is hosted in our server located in US, what I am going to do right now is create a new subdomain id.ikt.co.id that served EXACTLY the same content but it is hosted in our Indonesia server. Whenever people go to any page within ikt.co.id, it will detect their country, if they are from Indonesia, I will redirect them to our Indonesia server.
Okay, from SEO point of view I know there are couple problems such as Content duplication, and perhaps there are more.
I think to handle the content duplication I can cannonical all URL on id.ikt.co.id to the ikt.co.id version instead. The same thing for social sharing, all links shared will be the one from ikt.co.id, so all of those link juices go to ikt.co.id, and for good measure I can also set the robots.txt to tell them not to index id.ikt.co.id ...
All sounded good to me, until the I became paranoid and start thinking "have I missed anything that might hurt my SERP" ?
here is the question, did i miss something important, if i did could you please tell me what it is and if possible brought the solution you think might work into this discussion??
Again thanks a lot for your help 
WOW, that is one extremely SEO site you have there.... that is very nice , i wish that my site would have that kind of Search Percentage :((
still a lot to learn it seems... i am brb , i have to movie marathon the whole Pro Video for sure , there must be something that i am lacking as to why it caused my search : referral : direct = 1 : 1 : 1
PS : Thanks for the comment on the site, that is one of the way i used to get more traffic and back link (doing competition on thefwa.com , dopeawards.com , etc ) , and if i may say so those sources are currently my only high authority backlink source... this week i am going into article mode on some high authority site, such as the seomoz.org ( i am planning to post some extremely interesting article that shares some of the top secret of my own company to the public ), and posting a tutorial to activetuts.com .... if you have any other Great back link source, i am all ear xD
Thanks
