Understanding Review Filters

Updated by Chima Mmeje — December 9, 2024.

Review filters are automated systems used by platforms like Google and Yelp to manage and sometimes remove certain reviews. They aim to combat spam and fake content using algorithms and AI to detect suspicious patterns. While manual intervention can occur, these filters primarily operate without human input, potentially causing legitimate reviews to be hidden or removed.

Filters assess reviews based on content, relevance, and authenticity using natural language processing and machine learning. This can inadvertently lead to the removal of genuine feedback, frustrating business owners. To minimize review loss, it's crucial for business owners to follow platform guidelines, avoid aggressive review solicitation, and diversify review sources. Yelp, for instance, prohibits review solicitation, complicating control over review outcomes.

Understanding review filters helps business owners maintain a credible online presence across various sites. These filters are vital for preserving platform integrity by eliminating spam and ensuring authentic content. Google and Yelp extensively use them, removing millions of reviews annually. However, filters can mistakenly hide genuine reviews, causing business owner frustration. By comprehending filter operations, businesses can reduce review loss and adapt to the digital content landscape.

Review filters are crucial for maintaining the credibility and revenue of platforms by combating review spam. These filters protect users from untrustworthy content and help preserve the platform's reputation. Google and Yelp, for instance, use these filters extensively to manage reviews, removing millions annually to ensure authenticity. However, filters can sometimes mistakenly hide genuine reviews, causing frustration for business owners. Understanding how these filters work allows businesses to minimize review loss and maintain a strong online presence while adapting to the evolving landscape of digital content.

Review filters are sophisticated algorithms designed to analyze and categorize online reviews based on their content, relevance, and authenticity. These filters employ natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning techniques to identify patterns and anomalies in reviews, helping to distinguish genuine feedback from fake or misleading comments.

Here’s a closer look at how review filters typically operate:

• Data collection: Review filters gather data from a variety of sources, including social media, review websites, and e-commerce platforms. This extensive data collection ensures a comprehensive analysis of reviews across different channels.
• Text analysis: Using NLP techniques, the collected data is meticulously analyzed to identify keywords, sentiment, and tone. This step helps in understanding the context and emotional undertone of the reviews.
• Pattern recognition: The filter then looks for patterns in the data, such as repeated phrases, suspicious language, or inconsistencies in the reviewer’s account. This helps in spotting potential fake reviews or spam.
• Scoring: Each review is assigned a score based on its perceived authenticity, relevance, and helpfulness. Reviews with higher scores are considered more trustworthy and are more likely to be displayed.
• Filtering: Reviews that fail to meet certain criteria, such as those with low scores or suspicious patterns, are filtered out or flagged for further review. This ensures that only the most reliable and relevant feedback is showcased.

By understanding these steps, business owners can better appreciate the complexity and importance of review filters in maintaining the integrity of online feedback.

Review filters offer a multitude of benefits for businesses, website owners, and online shoppers. These advantages not only enhance the credibility of the reviews but also contribute to a more trustworthy and efficient online environment.

• Improved accuracy: Review filters help eliminate fake or misleading reviews, ensuring that only genuine feedback is displayed. This accuracy is crucial for maintaining the trust of potential customers.
• Enhanced credibility: By showcasing authentic reviews, businesses can build trust with their customers and improve their online reputation. A credible review profile can significantly influence a customer’s decision-making process.
• Increased conversions: Reliable and relevant reviews provide customers with the information they need to make informed purchasing decisions, leading to higher conversion rates. When customers trust the feedback they read, they are more likely to complete a purchase.
• Time-saving: Automating the process of reviewing and moderating online feedback saves businesses time and resources. Instead of manually sifting through reviews, business owners can rely on filters to do the heavy lifting.
• Competitive advantage: Leveraging review filters demonstrates a business’s commitment to authenticity and transparency. This can set a business apart from competitors who may not prioritize the integrity of their reviews.

By utilizing review filters, businesses can ensure that their online reviews accurately reflect their products or services, providing customers with a more trustworthy and helpful shopping experience. This not only enhances customer satisfaction but also fosters long-term loyalty and positive word-of-mouth.

If you’ve come to this article because you’ve recently experienced review loss, particularly with recent reviews being filtered and not appearing on your dashboard, take the following steps:

• Revisit the relevant platform’s guidelines to be certain that no action on your part may have caused your reviews to be filtered. For example, be sure your lost reviews didn’t stem from a forbidden tactic like offering incentives in exchange for reviews, or that the lost reviews weren’t written by your staff.
• Visit the profiles and publications of your favorite local SEOs to see if any of them are mentioning a new widespread review loss event. If so, you’ll know you’re not alone and that someone has likely already reported the problem to Google.
• Visit the Google Business Profile Help Community forum and search for terms like “missing reviews” and “lost reviews”. There are always some reports of missing reviews in the forum, but assess whether you are seeing a large volume of these threads and read some of them to determine whether your lost reviews are conforming to a date or pattern being described by others.
• Create your own post on the forum, detailing the number of reviews lost, the date they were lost, and if possible, screenshots of the lost reviews (*note, it’s a good idea to periodically document your reviews for this reason, and also to understand that customers can sometimes screenshot their own reviews for you if they are still visible within their own Google profiles). If you are lucky, a forum volunteer expert may escalate your thread to Google if they feel you have legitimate cause for complaint in the loss of non-fraudulent reviews. However, be prepared for the reality that Google may never reinstate the reviews you’ve lost.
• Continue to acquire new reviews to replace any that have been lost, and diversify the number of platforms on which you are receiving reviews so that your reputation is still dynamic even when sentiment goes missing on a single platform. Be sure you are publishing reviews on your own website, because they, at least, are never in danger of being filtered or removed.

There have been multiple instances in which Google has mass-removed reviews either intentionally or as a result of a bug. Sometimes, particularly in the case of bugs, some or all of the reviews have been reinstated, but the ongoing work of review filters is a simple fact of doing business locally online.

Your best safeguard against damages from review loss is simply to develop exceptional customer experiences that regularly generate fresh reviews. 

It helps to know that the majority of customers prioritize recent review content. In fact, 39% of review readers use toggles (also known as filters) to be shown newest reviews first on their favorite platforms. 

While one of the headaches of review loss lies in the fact that overall review count is believed to impact local search rankings, it’s some consolation to know that if the reviews you lost are older, your new, incoming reviews will have a substantial influence on most customers.

Review filters are a necessity for large platforms attempting to manage millions of reviews at scale. When they work properly, they protect the public and local business owners from fraud, but we are still in the beginning stages of technology and accountability when it comes to digital content. 

It will be the responsibility of the publishers and regulators to ensure that filters are as fair and accurate as possible, and to put meaningful processes in place for platform users to experience resolution when mistakes occur. This is a developing scenario in which we have to hope for ongoing improvements.

• Responding to Customer Reviews
• Do You Need Professional Reputation Management?
• Building a Local Business Website
• Content Planning for Local SEO
• Local SEO Certification - In this six-part Certification, you’ll receive nearly six hours of on-demand, instructor-led content, covering the fundamentals, local competitor research, location data management, reputation management, and measuring and tracking success.
• In Real Life: Local SEO Tactics - In this course, local business owners learn how to get the most out of their SEO strategy using skills and knowledge they already have.
• The Essential Local SEO Strategy Guide - A comprehensive beginner's guide to SEO marketing for small businesses.
• The Impact of Local Business Reviews on Consumer Behavior | SEO Industry Report - Our local business review survey outlines key takeaways regarding the impact of reviews on consumer behavior and local business success. Learn more about the fundamentally important inclusion of online local business reviews in any local SEO strategy.