Why does SEOmoz assign such a high Domain Authority to subdomains on blogspot, typepad, wordpress.com, etc.?
-
I thought it was generally accepted that the search engines treat joesmith.wordpress.com and www.wordpress.com as completely different domains. In which case, a cute but obscure blog like http://monkeysalwayslook.typepad.com/ has no business having a DA of 95.
-
Did you know we have a feature request forum at https://seomoz.zendesk.com/forums/293194-seomoz-pro-feature-requests where you could submit that idea?
Do keep in mind that we don't have access to Google's algorithm either, so it would be our idea of how it is influenced, not what Google thinks about it.
-
Getting a quick look at my competitors' high-DA inbound links is helpful to me as I assess the strengths and weaknesses of their link profile. Right now, I have to filter out a bunch of fake-high-DA wordpress, typepad, and blogspot blogs -- and meanwhile, I don't have a clue how Google actually feels about those subdomains. This annoys me. So a change like the one I am proposing would make me less annoyed.
Obviously I understand that finite resources go into developing these tools, which is why I'm not demanding that this be changed!11!1eleventy
-
That may be true, but my question was...how EXACTLY would you use that data to make a business decision?
The point I was trying to make is....
Google devalues a tremendous amount of links based on spaminess and other factors. PA and DA were not fully aligned with PR previously. They did offer insight into a site's backlinks but we accepted it could differ from Google based on various factors such as:
-
Linkscape does not crawl as deeply or as fast as Google
-
OSE also cannot differentiate between a "good" link and a bad one.
-
OSE also cannot differentiate between a sidebar link, a footer link and an in-content link
Please don't get me wrong. I like OSE and use it daily. I often see SEOs and site owners trying to use PA or DA in a manner that, in my opinion, it is not effective. I use PA and DA as an indicator, not the determining factor.
For example, I may see a new site which is well designed, has fantastic content and a passionate owner. I know this site will grow over time and would gladly pursue a link from it. On the other hand, I may see a site with great PA and DA, but it is not ranking well due to Panda issues. Clearly these issues affect the value of any links received.
There are many other examples I can share but the point is, you can use the PA and DA as-is and gain value from them. Penguin is undergoing a major update which will likely further change the link landscape. There is so much volatility related to links right now it is hard for a software company to invest money devising a link measurement system which will likely need to undergo a major change before it is published. My two cents.
-
-
It would make the SEOmoz data more in line with actual rankings. I would guess that treating these UGC subdomains as their own domains with their own DA would make DA correlate a bit better with rankings.
-
The couple of times I've found my content duplicated on a Wordpress.com domain, they've removed the content or banned the blog (which was entirely copies of other peoples' content) right away.
-
One example that may be relevant is the franchise owners who asked a question last week.
What if you are in London competing with:
We know (strongly believe) that Google treats subdomains as a separate site and subfolders as the same domain. London.somefranchise.com may have a "real" DA of 14 and you use that info the way you use any DA info. That's not the site you want to partner with if someotherlondonfranchise.com has a DA 40.
Meanwhile, the main somefranchise.com may have a DA 89 so you pursue a relationship with London.somefranchise.com because their DA is 89...but it's not. Having the subdomain's actual DA would help.
-
You can offer that suggestion to SEOmoz here: https://seomoz.zendesk.com/forums/293194-seomoz-PRO-feature-requests
Can you help me understand how this information would be helpful? What if SEOmoz made the exact change you were requesting. How can you use that data to make a difference for your site or the sites of your clients?
-
While that all may be true, they do have the ability to enforce their terms as they see fit, and do so at times.
-
I guess my question should actually be "Why doesn't SEOmoz treat this kind of subdomain differently from other subdomains, since we're pretty sure Google does treat it differently?"
-
"There are specific standards which must be maintained."
I don't believe that's true. UGC companies always mention lots of things you're not supposed to do in their TOU, but that (to use another acronym) is pure CYA. They do not proactively patrol the UGC they host. They have extremely limited legal liability for that content (in the U.S., at least). Content on a wordpress.com subdomain is not particularly likely to be good or trustworthy.
-
Domain Authority, as assigned by SEOmoz, applies to the root domain. It is part of the fundamental definition of the term. All the details can be found here: http://www.seomoz.org/learn-seo/domain-authority
An important factor to consider is any subdomain on wordpress.com is owned by WordPress. There are specific standards which must be maintained. WordPress has the right to recall any subdomain for a variety of reasons, or perhaps no reason at all depending on their contract.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Functionality of SEOmoz crawl page reports
I am trying to find a way to ask SEOmoz staff to answer this question because I think it is a functionality question so I checked SEOmoz pro resources. I also have had no responses in the Forum too it either. So here it is again. Thanks much for your consideration! Is it possible to configure the SEOMoz Rogerbot error-finding bot (that make the crawl diagnostic reports) to obey the instructions in the individual page headers and http://client.com/robots.txt file? For example, there is a page at http://truthbook.com/quotes/index.cfm month=5&day=14&year=2007 that has – in the header -
Moz Pro | | jimmyzig
<meta name="robots" content="noindex"> </meta name="robots" content="noindex"> This page is themed Quote of the Day page and is duplicated twice intentionally at http://truthbook.com/quotes/index.cfm?month=5&day=14&year=2004 and also at http://truthbook.com/quotes/index.cfm?month=5&day=14&year=2010 but they all have <meta name="robots" content="noindex"> in them. So Google should not see them as duplicates right. Google does not in Webmaster Tools.</meta name="robots" content="noindex"> So it should not be counted 3 times? But it seems to be? How do we gen a report of the actual pages shown in the report as dups so we can check? We do not believe Google sees it as a duplicate page but Roger appears too. Similarly, one can use http://truthbook.com/contemplative_prayer/ , here also the http://truthbook.com/robots.txt tells Google to stay clear. Yet we are showing thousands of dup. page content errors when Google Webmaster tools as shown only a few hundred configured as described. Anyone? Jim0 -
Can I change the Competitive Domain Analysis Domains?
I need to change a couple of the competitors listed under Competitive Domain Analysis but I cant find how to do this? Can anyone point me in the right direction? Thanks Chris
Moz Pro | | ChrisMcIlroy0 -
We're back. THANK YOU SEOMoz!
To all the Mozzers reading this, I joined SEOMoz in a panic when we were seeing the first hints of an impending ranking crisis for our company website in October, 2012. We tanked in late December for our most important keywords. Simply GONE. Holy C---! It was devastating to say the least. Thankfully, we have a lot of work due to current clients and referrals, but the phone got quiet. That's a deadly sound.15 years of comfort zone gone. I still don't know precisely why it happened, it may have been a number of factors. But I've learned a huge amount through this crisis and can honestly say that I'm glad it happened. How weird is that? But what other fire under my butt would have gained me so much curiosity, fascination, engagement and excitement with deepening my scant knowledge? A week ago, we got our first report showing us that we have now gotten back our positions on page 1 for the 10 keywords that matter. It's continuing to improve according to today's report. So now that I've gotten somewhere- and I am well aware that it may not stick and there is still more to do -it's time to shout out a great big "Thank You". Truly, I don't think I could have survived this situation without SEOMoz and all you wonderful Mozers answering my frantic questions and lending your expertise and support to my situation. It wasn't only my own questions and the responses to those that helped me through this. I have been essentially addicted to reading a vast majority of all the posted questions because it's so dang interesting. So I've been learning bucketfuls from other people's questions and responses. My own personal SEOMoz education. It's only just begun. What an incredible culture and community we have here. I feel I can say "we" now because I am beginning to feel a part of it. And I'm not going anywhere anytime soon. I love this place. Thank you!
Moz Pro | | gfiedel11 -
Slowing down SEOmoz Crawl Rate
Is there a way to slow down SEOmoz crawl rate? My site is pretty huge and I'm getting 10k pages crawled every week, which is great. However I sometimes get multiple page requests in one second which slows down my site a bit. If this feature exists I couldn't find it, if it doesn't, it's a great idea to have, in a similar way to how Googlebot do it. Thanks.
Moz Pro | | corwin0 -
Does SEOMoz ever work?
Hi, I've signed up for the free 30 day trial and I'm on the edge of not actually subscribing to the service. I go through the Q & A boards which I find really interesting and hope I can add value there in the future, but the tools interest me more (and this is where the issue lies. Do they ever work? The Keyword difficulty tool just constantly says to come back in 20 minutes and I don't think the Rank Tracker has worked for at least half my freebie 30 days. Have the tools always been this flaky or is it a blip?
Moz Pro | | orlandovisiting1 -
help with the inbound links side of seomoz
Hi Can somebody help with the inbound links tool of seomoz, can you point me in the direction of how it works and the best practices to get the most from it. I know i have a lot more inbound links to the site in my campaign but its shows for example 114 links but when i click on show more it only shows 3 . am i doing something wrong? Any help and advice from how people use it , what for and what is best practice thanks.
Moz Pro | | Bristolweb0 -
How do I change domain settings for a campaign?
So I set it up one of my Moz campaigns as domain.com Rogerbot only hits 1 page. I am thinking I should change it to www.domain.com, but I cannot seem to find how to do this. Thoughts?
Moz Pro | | stubby0