Does having shorter URLs help with rankings?
-
Hello here.I own an e-commerce website (virtualsheetmusic.com), and some of our most important category pages have pretty long URLs. Here is an example:
http://www.virtualsheetmusic.com/downloads/Indici/Violin.html
I am evaluating the possibility to shorten URLs like the above to something like:
http://www.virtualsheetmusic.com/violin/
But since it is going to pretty hard and time consuming (considering the custom system we have in place on that site), I am trying to find out if it really matters and worth doing it from a SEO stand point. I am aware that from a user prospective shorter URLs are preferable, and we plan to pursue a better URL architecture on our website in the near future just for that, but this question, at the moment, should be strictly related to SEO.
Any thoughts on this topic are very welcome!
-
That's a great idea Dana, thank you for the suggestion. I will try that with some of our less performing category pages, then I'll post the results here.
Thank you again!
Best,
Fabrizio
-
Hi again Fabrizio,
Have you thought about experimenting with a couple? Perhaps choose two categories that may have slipped from page 1 to page 2, or even the top of page one to the bottom of page 1. re-write the URLs and then track the results. If you get the desired result, then move on gradually to update the others. This way you mitigate risk, but still find out whether or not it's something you might benefit from.
Just a thought.
Dana
-
Wow, thank you so much guys for your replies and insights, and thank you Dana for your kind reply! I am so glad to know about your daughter
The fact is that actually we have pretty good rankings for our major category pages such as the violin page above (currently ranking 6th for "violin sheet music") but we have noticed tat we have been dropping down, gradually and steadily. We used to be at the first spot with "violin sheet music" with that page from 2003 to 2011.
So... I personally don't like to risk losing traffic from those very important category pages, that despite are not indexed at the top spots, are still giving us a lot of traffic since we are anyway on the 1st page. What do you think?
Thank you again!
Best,
Fabrizio
-
Hi Fabrizio,
Mike's answer is a good one and I would also definitely recommend Dr. Pete's post.
What I would like you to be aware of is the risk in what you are wanting to do. If you are already ranking well, for the love of all that is holy in this world, leave your URLs alone. Here is what Dr. Pete had to say about the "risk factor:"
"All Change Is Risky
I know it’s not what the motivational speakers want you to hear, but in the real world, change carries risk. Even a perfectly executed site-wide URL change – with pristine 301-redirects – is going to take time for Google to process. During that time, your rankings may bounce. You may get some errors. If your new URL scheme isn’t universally better than the old one, some pages may permanently lose ranking. There’s no good way to A/B test a site-wide SEO change.
More often, it’s just a case of diminishing returns. Going from pretty good to pretty gooder probably isn’t worth the time and effort, let alone the risk." - Dr. Pete Meyers
You need to manage expectations on this one if you decide to go forward and make stakeholders aware that they could be looking at a significant downside (decrease in traffic and links) immediately after implementation. That doesn't mean that there couldn't be a significant upside eventually, but there are no guarantees.
I love your site by the way. My daughter and I have been subscribers on and off for years. Cheers!
Dana
-
Hi Fabrizo,
Shorter URLs are preferred. In your example I personally feel it makes sense to remove download and indici from your URL struture, because that information does not mean anything to me, the user (maybe it does to someone who plays violins... so that statement might not be true, but to me that information is irrelevant).
Now are you going to go from page 2 to page 1 with a change like this... maybe? There aren't any hard facts that will say how big of an impact that will make; however, the closer a keyword is to your domain in terms of your URL, the more weight is assessed to it in terms of keyword association - if that makes sense. So...
domain.com/downloads/Indici/Violin.html appears less relevant than domain.com/violin/ if a user is searching for "violin".
Also, Dr. Pete wrote an article a few years ago on changing URLs for SEO purposes. I think that all of the information still stands true for today.
Hope this helps,
Mike
-
Fabrizo,
Google loves when all your keywords, Page titles, Meta Descriptions all are in the same order, length, spelling and so forth, even though meta keywords show little or no effect as of late. Same goes for the URL's.
A perfect page would have the exact same URL, as Page title, Keyword, and meta description. So if your starting from scratch that may be a target to aim for. As far as URL length there may be a limit but its going to be a high number like 2083 characters.
I guess probably the best yay to choose the URL is to take a look at the Page Title name guidelines which is 20 to 70 characters. Now you can match the URL to page title with 70 characters.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
My client redesigned their site. Once it went live, ALL of their rankings disappeared. Even branding. Help?
Does anybody know why this might happen? When we made the new site, we just changed the skins. The source code was the same, the content was the same. Even when I search their brand name and their city, their URL won't show up. When I search their URL into Google, it won't even pull up their homepage: it only pulls up /contact-us and some other subpages. Any tips on what I should be looking out for?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | TaylorRHawkins1 -
How Does Yelp Create URLs?
Hi all, How does Yelp (or other sites) go about creating URLs for just about every service and city possible ending with the search? in the URL like this https://www.yelp.com/search?cflt=chiropractors&find_loc=West+Palm+Beach%2C+FL. They clearly aren't creating all of these pages, so how do you go about setting a meta title/optimization formula that allows these pages to exist AND to be crawled by search engines and indexed?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | RickyShockley0 -
Why have my rankings dropped?
I have a client who has just seen his average page rank creep up from around 39 to 34 over about two months, then it appears to have dropped back to position 40+ in the space of a week. I believe he's made a lot of changes to targeted keywords, so I'd like to think it's simply because his old targeted keywords are dropping and new keywords still have to build their rankings. But I'm also worried in case he has over-optimised and might get getting penalised. Any advice on where to start digging?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | muzzmoz0 -
Robots.txt Help
I need help to create robots.txt file. Please let me know what to add in the file. any real example or working example.?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Michael.Leonard0 -
Trouble ranking
I have a site that got messed over pretty hard by a BigCommerce issue. They used to rank but then Big Commerce had a glitch that set every page on the site to a https which was auto set, by their system, to not be indexed. This caused the entire site to go missing. It was then fixed by me, only to have the same glitch happen again. I again fixed it, and BigCommerce released a patch to resolve the issue. They admitted blame to my client and said it can take a while to resolve. It has been a few months now, and google is slowly recrawling the site. It has about half the pages indexed. The pages that are indexed do not rank at all. I was wondering if you guys see any major flags that would cause this or if it is still related to the big commerce glitch. link
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Atomicx0 -
Google tagged URL an overly-dynamic URL?
I'm reviewing my campaign, and spotted the overly-dynamic URL box showing a few links. Reviewing it, they are my Google Tagged URLs (utm_source, utm_medium_utm_campaign etc) I've turned some internal links to Google Tagged URLs but should these cause concern?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Bio-RadAbs0 -
If I had an issue with a friendly URL module and I lost all my rankings. Will they return now that issue is resolved next time I'm crawled by google?
I have 'magic seo urls' installed on my zencart site. Except for some reason no one can explain why or how the files were disabled. So my static links went back to dynamic (index.php?**********) etc. The issue was resolved with the module except in that time google must have crawled my site and I lost all my rankings. I'm nowher to be found in the top 50. Did this really cause such an extravagant SEO issue as my web developers told me? Can I expect my rankings to return next time my site is crawled by google?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Pete790 -
Pages On Subfolder Not Ranking
A subdirectory/folder on our website doesn't seem to rank for any keywords where the same type of pages on the same competition level keywords rank perfectly fine. For awhile the pages weren't getting indexed but were crawled regularly. Can't seem to figure the problem out.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | bprimeelitellc0