Do you bother cleaning duplicate content from Googles Index?
-
Hi,
I'm in the process of instructing developers to stop producing duplicate content, however a lot of duplicate content is already in Google's Index and I'm wondering if I should bother getting it removed... I'd appreciate it if you could let me know what you'd do...
For example one 'type' of page is being crawled thousands of times, but it only has 7 instances in the index which don't rank for anything. For this example I'm thinking of just stopping Google from accessing that page 'type'.
Do you think this is right?
Do you normally meta NoIndex,follow the page, wait for the pages to be removed from Google's Index, and then stop the duplicate content from being crawled?
Or do you just stop the pages from being crawled and let Google sort out its own Index in its own time?
Thanks
FashionLux
-
One tricky point - you don't necessarily want to fix the duplicate URLs before you 301-redirect and clear out the index. This is counter-intuitive and throws many people off. If you cut the crawl paths to the bad URLs, then Google will never crawl them and process the 301-redirects (since those exist on the page level). Same is try for canonical tags. Clear out the duplicates first, THEN clean up the paths. I know it sounds weird, but it's important.
For malformed URLs and usability, you could still dynamically 301-redirect. In most cases, those bad URLs shouldn't get indexed, because they have no crawl path in your site. Someone would have to link to them. Google will never mis-type, in other words.
-
Hi Highland/Dr Pete,
My apologies I wasn't very clear - fixing the duplicate problem... or rather stopping our site from generating further duplicate content isn't an issue at all, I'm going to instruct our developers to stop generating dupe content by doing things like no longer passing variables in the URL's (mysite.com/page2?previouspage=page1).
However the problem is that for a lot of instances duplicate URL's work and they need to work - for example if a user types in the URL but gets one character wrong ('1q' rather than '1') then from a usability perspective its the correct thing to serve the content they wanted. You don't want to make the user have to stop, figure out what they did wrong and redo it - not when you can make it work seamlessly.
My question relates to 'once my site is no longer generating unnecessary duplicate content, what should I to do about the duplicate pages that have already made their way into the Index?' and you have both answered the question very well, thank you.
I can manually set-up 301 redirects for all of the duplicate pages that I find in the index, once they disappear from the index I can probably remove those 301's. I was thinking of going down the noindex meta tag route which is harder to develop.
Thanks guys
FashionLux
-
I DO NOT believe in letting Google sort it out - they don't do it well, and, since Panda (and really even before), they basically penalize sites for their inability to sort out duplicates. I think it's very important to manage your index.
Unfortunately, how to do that can be very complex and depends a lot on the situation. Highland's covered the big ones, but the details can get messy. I wrote a mega-post about it:
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/duplicate-content-in-a-post-panda-world
Without giving URLs, can you give us a sense of what kind of duplicates they are (or maybe some generic URL examples)?
-
Your options are
- De-index the duplicate pages yourself and save yourself the crawl budget
- 301 the duplicates to the pages you want to keep (preferred)
- Canonical the duplicate pages, which lets you pick which page remains in the index. The duplicate pages will still be crawled, however.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What to do if lots of backend pages have been indexed by Google erroneously?
Hi Guys Our developer forgot to add a no index no follow tag on the pages he created in the back-end. So we have now ended up with lots of back end pages being indexed in google. So my question is, since many of those are now indexed in Google, so is it enough to just place a no index no follow on those or should we do a 301 redirect on all those to the most appropriate page? If a no index no follow is enough, that would create lots of 404 errors so could those affect the site negatively? Cheers Martin
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | martin19700 -
What should I do if same content ranked twice or more on Google?
I have a Bangla SEO related blog where I have written article like "Domain Selection" "SEO Tools" "MOZ" etc. All the article has been written in Bengali language. I have used wp tag for every post. I have submit xml site map generated by Yoast SEO. However I kept "no index" for category. I know well duplicate content is a major problem for SEO. After publishing my content Google ranked them on 1st page. But my fear is that most of the content twice or more. The keywords are ranked by post, wp post tag and Archive. Now I have a fear of penalty. Please check the screenshot and please suggest me what to do. uRCHf yq7m2 rSLKFLG
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | AccessTechBD0 -
Avoiding Duplicate Content - Same Product Under Different Categories
Hello, I am taking some past advise and cleaning up my content navigation to only show 7 tabs as opposed to the 14 currently showing at www.enchantingquotes.com. I am creating a "Shop by Room" and "Shop by Category" link, which is what my main competitors do. My concern is the duplicate content that will happen since the same item will appear in both categories. Should I no follow the "Shop by Room" page? I am confused as to when I should use a no follow as opposed to a canonical tag? Thank you so much for any advise!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Lepasti0 -
Duplicate Content For E-commerce
On our E-commerce site, we have multiple stores. Products are shown on our multiple stores which has created a duplicate content problem. Basically if we list a product say a shoe,that listing will show up on our multiple stores I assumed the solution would be to redirect the pages, use non follow tags or to use the rel=canonical tag. Are there any other options for me to use. I think my best bet is to use a mixture of 301 redirects and canonical tags. What do you recommend. I have 5000+ pages of duplicate content so the problem is big. Thanks in advance for your help!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | pinksgreens0 -
Copying my Facebook content to website considered duplicate content?
I write career advice on Facebook on a daily basis. On my homepage users can see the most recent 4-5 feeds (using FB social media plugin). I am thinking to create a page on my website where visitors can see all my previous FB feeds. Would this be considered duplicate content if I copy paste the info, but if I use a Facebook social media plugin then it is not considered duplicate content? I am working on increasing content on my website and feel incorporating FB feeds would make sense. thank you
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | knielsen0 -
Capitals in url creates duplicate content?
Hey Guys, I had a quick look around however I couldn't find a specific answer to this. Currently, the SEOmoz tools come back and show a heap of duplicate content on my site. And there's a fair bit of it. However, a heap of those errors are relating to random capitals in the urls. for example. "www.website.com.au/Home/information/Stuff" is being treated as duplicate content of "www.website.com.au/home/information/stuff" (Note the difference in capitals). Anyone have any recommendations as to how to fix this server side(keeping in mind it's not practical or possible to fix all of these links) or to tell Google to ignore the capitalisation? Any help is greatly appreciated. LM.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | CarlS0 -
How are they avoiding duplicate content?
One of the largest stores in USA for soccer runs a number of whitelabel sites for major partners such as Fox and ESPN. However, the effect of this is that they are creating duplicate content for their products (and even the overall site structure is very similar). Take a look at: http://www.worldsoccershop.com/23147.html http://www.foxsoccershop.com/23147.html http://www.soccernetstore.com/23147.html You can see that practically everything is the same including: product URL product title product description My question is, why is Google not classing this as duplicate content? Have they coded for it in a certain way or is there something I'm missing which is helping them achieve rankings for all sites?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | ukss19840 -
Google replacing subpages in index with home page?
Hi! I run a backlink building company. Recently, we had a customer who had us build targeted backlinks to certain subpages on his site. Then something really bizarre happened...all of a sudden, their subpages that were indexed in Google (the ones we were building links to) disappeared from the index, to be replaced with their home page. They haven't lost their rank, per se--it's just now their home page instead of their subpages. At this point, we are tracking literally thousands of keywords for our link building customers, and we've never run into this issue before. Have you ever run into it? If so, what's the best way to handle it from an SEO company perspective? They have a sitemap.xml and their GWT account reports no crawl errors, so it doesn't seem to be a site issue.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | ownlocal0