Wouldn't this be an issue of duplicate content?
-
I'm currently in the beginning stages of doing SEO analysis for a new client. They're an IT support company here in Phoenix, AZ.
In doing some keyword research and competitive research, I've noticed that one of their competitors (who ranks in the top 3 for many of the targeted keywords), is doing something that I thought would surely be a duplicate content issue.
On their home page, they have dozens of links of zip codes in the Phoenix area. Each link leads to a page devoted to that zip code. Each page is identical, except that the zip code is changed in the header tag. Most of these zip code pages are indexed in Google.
Isn't this an example of duplicate content, or better yet, content spamming? I've seen this thing quite a bit with high ranking sites, and I thought these were the kinds of things that were getting taken care of in the post "Panda" era.
I might just be misunderstanding this whole thing, but any guidance or intel would be greatly appreciated.
-
I've got the same issue with a client of mine. Their competition is beating them on a lot of searches for their area. The competition site has a link to a 95% duplicate content page for every zip code in the state. Their page are similar to this:
Wet Basements in Minneapolis MN 55101
Wet Basements in Minneapolis MN 55102etc
The same content except for city name and zip code are changed out.
-
Agreed. I can't stand seeing this. Hopefully, nowadays I'd think this'll be harder to do simply because so many domain names will be taken.
-
I just saw this working well for a small web design firm in Victoria Australia. They created a separate page for all the towns in the area, linked to it from their homepage and were dominating SERPs for no reason apart from tricking google into thinking it was a larger firm than it was. That stuff annoys the heck out of me
-
That's what I'm thinking based on what I'm seeing - most of the high ranking sites are pretty bad overall. Lot of old, early 2000 looking sites and all that goes with that.
-
Hello,
I would agree with what was said, this is DEFINITELY duplicate content, and is also exteremely Spammy. I unfortunately see this as well on a lot of sites, especially for local SEO, without getting in to detail of these strategies. My view of this is that these concepts are adding absolutely no value to the web, and really should not be done by any legitimate online marker as a means of increasing rankings.
Here is a recommendation, since I don't belive that the "if you can't beat them, join them" approach would be helpful, why don't you create specific pages for each zip code/locality, and create unique content for every page. As a rule of thumb, I try to have 55% of content on any given page unique. Some strategies that work for me is to use local landmarks and events.
I think as google's algorithm progresses strategies like this will be beaten down, but who knows how long it'll take for that to happen.
Hope this helps
Zach
-
I see a lot of this for phone numbers too.
In reading your question though, I had to ask myself this question, "Are these sites ranking because there are no better alternatives?" If everyone in the space is using duplicate content/content spamming, they will all be in the results because no one is creating a site with better information.
I would view your research as opportunity. If you feel you need to connect with customers based on zip code, build better pages and become the best result for your users.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Can I use my keyword in brackets '( )'
I need to sort my product keywords in the countries: (UK) (USA) (Global) etc. What does putting my keyword into brackets do - does it negatively affect my SEO?
Keyword Research | | crocman0 -
How to Find a Competitor's Target Keyword for a Particular Webpage
I understand how to do basic keyword research and how to review a competitor's code (meta tags, etc.). But what is the best method for finding out what a competitor's target keyword is for a particular web page? For example, the URL www.example.com/about-us, what is the best method for finding out what their target keyword is? I have been using a keyword density tool to run the URLs and find the keyword or phase that appears most often but would think there is a better way?
Keyword Research | | rx3000 -
How does Google Tell which are the keywords you're targetting?
Hi! I've quite a number of synonyms and common related keywords and i know that it needs to be only at one page instead of many different pages. The keywords are: delivery service singapore, delivery service, singapore delivery service and delivery service in singapore. Do i need to have an exact variations of each in the content of the page so that google will know i want to target for these keywords. Because i'm trying to make my page to receive an A grade for all these keywords in a page? Do i need to split the keywords into 2 different page to achieve that goal? Thanks!
Keyword Research | | Caleb-Seah0 -
Aiming for long tails on a long piece of content, without over-optimisation and attracting Panda...
Hi, I'm currently in the process of optimising a new ecommerce site with tons of content.
Keyword Research | | azu25
We're really well-researching our information and are aiming for one page a week, so each page (such as category pages etc) is getting 5-7 days of research before the content is written, so that we know our info is correct and that more than enough content is available, rather than a simple 300-500 word article.
One category page in particular has the potential for maybe 4,000-6,000 words, or even more (I don't want to hit that, as it's not needed, but I'd like to go into enough detail about enough things to bring us up on top as the market leader) - Our biggest competitor is currently hitting around 2,500 words on the category page for their site and they're ranking for a lot of long tails. (Of course they're also getting a lot of links too!)
To put it simply, we have a better quality product and a range of options (we're one of the first [if not the first] in the UK to have several options for this product where you have the choice of going for the cheap option, or going for higher priced and better quality options etc), whereas our main competitor simply has one stand alone product. By default this gives us much more to work with regarding potential content. While building this site we haven't bothered to consider 'keyword density', as we're going for as white-a-hat as possible, but when it comes to long tails I'm finding that I may have to consider it for this page at least.
We have a few dozen long tails such as 'Where does X come from', 'Why is X so expensive', 'What is the difference between X and X' etc - You know the kind of keywords.
To help specifically with the long tails we've opted to include a FAQ section to that category page, but it seems that by doing this I have accidentally gone up to ~3% density on the 'X', which I suppose isn't too bad, but at the same time that one keyword has already made ~30 appearances in the content - and all we have done so far is the FAQ section.
I'm going through now and rewording it so that it's less 'keywordy' (although there does seem to be a limit to the number of times to can say 'it' before that starts to sound odd..), but was just wondering how you manage to write a long and detailed piece of content that is all specifically about one thing, without having to use that one keyword too many times, while also hitting plenty of long tails at the same time?0 -
Internal Linking inside page content
Hi! Actually, i have been getting down after i fix internal links on each page. What i have done is linked keywords to the concern pages from other pages on same website. But i see the result going down in the google organic list. is this bad practice? example: http://www.nortekk.no/vi-utforer/blikkenslager-15/ Keyword : blikkenslager 1. Internal link, i doubt on this. May be it is not good. please confirm and help me 2. Main keyword usage in document. Must i reduce it? Thank you in advance Vels
Keyword Research | | Webworld_Norway0 -
Analysing my Keyword Transaction from Analytics, HELP for Selecting for Content
Hi, From one year of transaction on my online store, http://www.furnacefilterscanada.com/ I have export my keywords that brought transaction in Google Analytics. I would like to pickup 10 keywords to hire a writter for content writting, but I need help in selecting the best keywords. I don't think I can attach .csv file to this question. I have copy and paste every keywords that has a transaction. If you see the same keyword 10 time, it brought 10 transaction. New to seo, I hope anybody can bring good suggestions Thank you, BigBlaze This is the list: <colgroup><col width="300"></colgroup>
Keyword Research | | BigBlaze205
| who sells venmar 3000 hepa filters in edmonton ab |
| who sells merv filters in edmonton |
| where to buy he225a agion antimicrobial pad in canada |
| where to buy hc26e1004 in canada |
| where to buy furnace filters online canada |
| where to buy carrier furnace filters |
| venmar hepa filters |
| venmar hepa air filters |
| venmar hepa 3000 replacing filters how to |
| venmar hepa 3000 replacement filters |
| venmar hepa 3000 replacement filter |
| venmar hepa 3000 replacement filter |
| venmar hepa 3000 replacement filter |
| venmar hepa 3000 filter replacement |
| venmar hepa 300 filter calgary |
| venmar filters canada |
| venmar air filter replacements |
| venmar air exchanger hepa 3000 filter replacment |
| venmar air exchanger filter replacement |
| venmar 3000 replacement hepa filter canada |
| venmar 3000 replacement hepa filter |
| venmar 3000 canada |
| ulc furnace filters |
| two inch thick furnace filters in canada |
| replacement hepa 3000 filters |
| replacement furnace filters |
| pleated furnace filters canada 15x20x1 |
| online furnace filters |
| montreal furnace air filters |
| merv efficiency 11 filter |
| merv air filters in canada |
| merv 8 furnace filter 16x25x4 |
| merv 8 filter 16x25x4 canada |
| merv 8 air filters canada |
| merv 13 air filters |
| merv 11 furnace filters canada |
| merv 11 filters |
| merv 11 filter 20x20x4 |
| merv 11 air filters canada |
| merv 11 air filters |
| merv 11 air filters |
| merv 11 air filters |
| merv 11 air filters |
| merv 10 furnace filter |
| m8-1056 furnace filter montreal |
| m1-1056 furnace filters canada |
| looking for canadian furnace filter suppliers |
| lennox hcc16-28 filter |
| jean nichols filtration montreal |
| http://www.furnacefilterscanada.com/ |
| house air filters |
| honeywell merv 8 furnace filters canada |
| honeywell merv 10 furnace filter |
| honeywell media filter canada |
| honeywell humidifier hc22e1003 |
| honeywell hc26e1004 humidifier filters canada |
| honeywell hc22e1003 antomicrobial |
| honeywell furnace filters 20x20x4 |
| honeywell furnace filters 20 x 20 x 4 canada |
| honeywell furnace air filters |
| honeywell furnace air filter |
| honeywell furnace air filter |
| honeywell furnace air filter |
| honeywell enviracaire hc26e 1004 n |
| honeywell enviracaire hc22e1003 canada |
| honeywell enviracaire hc22e 1003 humidifier pad canada |
| honeywell canada humidifier pads hc22e |
| honeywell canada hc26e1004 |
| honeywell canada air filter |
| hepa 3000 replacement filters |
| hepa 3000 filters venmar |
| hepa 3000 filter replacement |
| heating filters canada |
| hc22e1003/u canada |
| hc22e1003 honeywell humidifier antimicrobial pad canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 canada |
| hc22e1003 |
| hc22e1003 |
| furnance filters online canada |
| furnance filters canada online |
| furnacefilterscanada.com |
| furnacefilterscanada coupon |
| furnace+filters+canada |
| furnace filthers canada coupon |
| furnace filterscanada |
| furnace filters purchase online |
| furnace filters online canada cheap |
| furnace filters online canada |
| furnace filters online |
| furnace filters online |
| furnace filters on sale |
| furnace filters montreal |
| furnace filters montreal |
| furnace filters m8-1056 |
| furnace filters m2 1056 |
| furnace filters edmonton |
| furnace filters canada online |
| furnace filters canada online |
| furnace filters canada online |
| furnace filters canada gift code |
| furnace filters canada coupons |
| furnace filters canada coupon code |
| furnace filters canada coupon code |
| furnace filters canada coupon code |
| furnace filters canada coupon |
| furnace filters canada coupon |
| furnace filters canada 18x25x1 |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters canada |
| furnace filters calgary |
| furnace filters 20x20x4 inch |
| furnace filters 20x20x4 |
| furnace filters 16x25x5 |
| furnace filters 16x16x2 |
| furnace filters 10x20x1 canada |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filters |
| furnace filter sizes |
| furnace filter online to canada |
| furnace filter canada shipping |
| furnace filter canada coupon codes |
| furnace filter canada 16x20x5 |
| furnace filter canada |
| furnace filter canada |
| furnace filter canada |
| furnace filter canada |
| furnace filter canada |
| furnace filter 24x24x1 edmonton |
| furnace filter 20x25x5 |
| furnace filter 20x20x5 honeywell |
| furnace filter 20x20x5 |
| furnace filter 18x20x1 |
| furnace filter 18 by 20 |
| furnace filter 16x25x5 |
| furnace filter 16x25x4 canada |
| furnace filter |
| furnace filter |
| furnace filter |
| furnace air filters online |
| furnace air filters online |
| furnace air filters montreal |
| furnace air filters canada |
| free shipping furnace filters ontario |
| filtreur 20x20x4 |
| filtre+fournaise+montreal |
| filtre merv 11 canada |
| filtre fournaise montreal |
| filtre fournaise merv 11 20 1/4 x 20 3/4 x 5 1/4 m2-1056 |
| filtre canada |
| filtration lab filters for sale |
| filtration lab dpc-m11 |
| filterscanada com |
| filters in canada |
| filters for air conditioners canada |
| filters canada 16x25x2 |
| filters canada |
| filters canada |
| filters canada |
| filters canada |
| filters canada |
| filter canada |
| filter 20x20x4 |
| discount furnace filter shipping to canada |
| custom made air filters in canada |
| change furnace filter from 4 inch to 1 inch |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filters |
| carrier furnace filter replacement |
| carrier filters |
| carrier air filters |
| canada honeywell hc22e1003 humidifier pad |
| canada honeywell furnace filters merv 10 |
| canada furnace filters order |
| canada filters |
| canada filters |
| canada filter honeywell humidifier hc22e1003 |
| canada custom furnace filter |
| canada air filters furnace |
| canada 16x25x5 furnace filters |
| buy furnace filters online canada |
| buy furnace filters online |
| buy furnace filters canada |
| best place to buy furnace filters online |
| aprilaire filters 2400 |
| aprilaire 500 filter canada |
| antimicrobial watter panel hc22e1003 ottawa |
| air filters home furnace |
| air filters home furnace |
| air filters for house 15x20x1 |
| air filters for furnace |
| air filters for furnace |
| air filters for furnace |
| air filters canada 16x20x5 |
| air filter m8-1056 canada |
| air filter 16x20x4 canada |
| 5 inch furnace filter canada |
| 24x24x2 camfil filters |
| 24 x 30 inch furnace filters alberta |
| 22x22x1 filters free shipping in canada |
| 20x25x5 furnace filter + canada |
| 20x25x4 furnace filter canada |
| 20x20x4 furnace filters |
| 20x20x4 filter |
| 20x20x4 canada |
| 20x20x2 furnace filters |
| 20x20x1 furnace filter |
| 2 inch furnace filters |
| 18x24x4 furnace filter |
| 18"x 20"x1" furnace filters canada |
| 16x25x5 furnace filter canada |
| 16x25x4 furnace filters |
| 16x25x4 furnace filter |
| 16x25x3 furnace filters |
| 16x25x1 furnace filters canada |
| 16x24x4 furnace filters canada |
| 16x24x4 furnace filter canada |
| 16x24x2 furnace filters canada |
| 16x20x5 furnace filter |
| 16x20x4 furnace filters honeywell |
| 16x20x4 furnace filter |
| 16x16x1 furnace filter in canada |
| 16255 furnace filters for lennox |
| 16 x 20 furnace filter camfil merv 8 canada |
| 14x20x2 furnace filters |
| 12 by 20 furnace canada |0 -
Is there a better keyword tool than google's adwords keyword tool?
I have heard a lot of people say not to trust the results of google adword's keyword tool. Is there a better tool out there that i am not aware of that can judge local monthly and global monthly search volume?
Keyword Research | | adriandg1 -
Keywords and the role of 'in', 'for', 'to' and plurals
Hi there, I wonder if you can help. Google's keyword tool lists each of these keywords separately with its own Local Monthly Volume count: flats to rent in London flats to rent London flats for rent in London flats for rent London flat to rent in London flat to rent London flat for rent in London flat for rent London I'd rather not create 8 separate pages for this, which I think will be poor for the user and limit the range of keywords i can target. So my main question is: what should I do? a) How important is 'in'? Will a page written for 'flats to rent in London' do well against the 'flats to rent London'? b) The same for plurals: if I'm writing 'flats to rent' will it rank against 'flat to rent'? c) The same for 'to' and 'for': If i'm writing 'flats to rent in London' will it rank against 'flats for rent in London?' Thanks in advance dan
Keyword Research | | danfk0