Duplicate content issue with trailing / ?
-
Hi ,I did a SEOmoz Crawl Test and found most pages show twice, for example:
A: www.website.com/index.php/dog/walk
B: www.website.com/index.php/dog/walk/
I've checked Google Analytics and 90% of organic search traffic arrives on the URLs with the trailing slash (B).
Question 1: Can I assume I've a duplicate content problem?
Question 2: Is it best to do 301 redirects from the 'non trailing slash' pages to the 'trailing slash pages'?
Question 3: For some reason every web page has a '/index.php' in it (see A&B) above. No idea why. Should it be a SEO concern?
Kind regards and thank you in advance
Nigel
-
Hi Nigel
You only need to 301 one of the pages, 301 is indicating a permanent move, so in the case you outlined above,
I would 301, A to B the decisions to use B was based soly off the value of the url you indicated. If for any reason you prefer the url's not use trailing slash then use A.
It also would not hurt to add a canonical tag to B
To be clear here, whether you use
website.com/index.php/dog/walk
or
website.com/index.php/dog/walk/
Does not matter as far as SEO is concerned, I would make my decision based off of which url has the highest position in Google, and be consistent with this method throughout my site.
Hope that helps,
-
Hi Irving
Thank you for your reply. You mention a good point regarding the sitemap.xml!
If I was to 301redirect pages A & B to a new page eg www.website.com/dog/walk/ then how would I also canonical A & B to the new page?
Surely once I have 301'd the A & B pages will be dead and redirecting traffic to the new page.
Kind regard and my apologies for any confusion.
Nigel
-
Yes, index.php should never show so 301 that plus the trailing slash to remove it
Ddefinitely canonical all of the pages to have the URL without the trailing slash
Make sure your sitemap xml files and internal linking structure does not have the trailing slash. if they do,, then fix them to reflect the proper URL
-
Thank you Highland & Donford.
Re my 3rd question, can I just clarify, should I now 301 redirect both A & B URLs to a new URL say www.website/com/dog/walk ?
Many thanks!
-
Question 1: Can I assume I've a duplicate content problem?
-YesQuestion 2: Is it best to do 301 redirects from the 'non trailing slash' pages to the 'trailing slash pages'?
-Yes 301 is best, barring that use rel="canonical" on the page you want to indexQuestion 3: For some reason every web page has a '/index.php' in it (see A&B) above. No idea why. Should it be a SEO concern?
-Yes, this is a concern, use the same method to deal with the problem. Directories on the server side are usually assumed to have an index, if not the server can choose what to display, this can be very bad sometimes. As such most CMS content management systems fix the problem by generating content for the index.php or .html pages. However, there can be duplicate content issues since there are 2 urls with the same content, use 301 to get rid of the index.php at directory levels, or use canonical tags.
Hope that helps,
Don
-
1. Google can generally tell the difference between pages that have syntactically similar URLs but it's considered a best practice to not make any engine do any guesswork whenever possible.
2. I would 301 one version just for uniformity but you should be fine as-is right now.
3. There's nothing wrong with that being in the URL. Google sees it as part of the URL and nothing more. I don't consider it aesthetic or user friendly but that's a different matter.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Duplicate Content for Locations on my Directory Site
I have a pretty big directory site using Wordpress with lots of "locations", "features", "listing-category" etc.... Duplicate Content: https://www.thecbd.co/location/california/ https://www.thecbd.co/location/canada/ referring URL is www.thecbd.co is it a matter of just putting a canonical URL on each location, or just on the main page? Would this be the correct code to put: on the main page? Thanks Everyone!
Technical SEO | | kay_nguyen0 -
Duplicate content issues arise 6 months after creation of website?!
Hi, I've had the same website for 6 months and fixed all original on-site issues a long time ago.Now this week I wake up and found 3 new errors: 3 of my pages have missing titles issues, missing meta description issues and also the Moz crawl says they all have duplicate content issues. All my rankings went down a lot as well. This site is static, doesn't even have a blog, everything is rel canonical and non-indexed. It's 100% original content as well. So how can those issues arise 6 months later? All my titles and descriptions are there and non-duplicate, and the content is original and not duplicate as well. Is this a wordpress bug or virus? Anyone had this happen to them and how to fix it? Thanks a lot for you help! -Marc
Technical SEO | | marcandre0 -
Duplicate content /index.php/ issues
I'm having some duplicate content issues with Google. I've already got my .htaccess file working just fine as far as I can tell. Rewriting works great, and by using the site you'd never end up on a page with /index.php. However I do notice that on ANY page of the site you could add /index.php and get the same page i.e.: www.mysite.com/category/article and www.mysite.com/index.php/category/article Would both return the same page. How can I 301 or something similar all /index.php pages to the non index.php version? I have no desire for any page on my site to have index.php in it, there is no use to it. Having quite the hard time figuring this out. Again this is basically just for the robots, the URL's the users see are perfect, never had an issue with that. Just SEOMOZ reporting duplicate content and I've verified that to be true.
Technical SEO | | b18turboef1 -
Duplicate Page Content Report
In Crawl Diagnostics Summary, I have 2000 duplicate page content. When I click the link, my Wordpress return "page not found" and I see it's not indexed by Google, and I could not find the issue in Google Webmaster. So where does this link come from?
Technical SEO | | smallwebsite0 -
See any issues with this tabbed content page?
When I view source, and view as Googlebot it's showing as 1 long page of content = good. However, the developer uses some redirects and dynamic page generation to pull this off. I didn't see any issues from a Search perspective but would appreciate a second opinion: Click here Thanks!
Technical SEO | | 540SEO0 -
Crawl Errors and Duplicate Content
SEOmoz's crawl tool is telling me that I have duplicate content at "www.mydomain.com/pricing" and at "www.mydomain.com/pricing.aspx". Do you think this is just a glitch in the crawl tool (because obviously these two URL's are the same page rather than two separate ones) or do you think this is actually an error I need to worry about? Is so, how do I fix it?
Technical SEO | | MyNet0 -
Magento and Duplicate content
I have been working with Magento over the last few weeks and I am becoming increasingly frustrated with the way it is setup. If you go to a product page and remove the sub folders one by one you can reach the same product pages causing duplicate content. All magento sites seem to have this weakness. So use this site as an example because I know it is built on magento, http://www.gio-goi.com/men/clothing/tees/throve-t-short.html?cid=756 As you remove the tees then the clothing and men sub folders you can still reach the product page. My first querstion is how big an issue is this and two does anyone have any ideas of how to solve it? Also I was wondering how does google treat question marks in urls? Should you try and avoid them unless you are filtering? Thanks
Technical SEO | | gregster10001 -
Duplicate Content Home Page
Hello, I am getting Duplicate Content warning from SEOMoz for my home page: http://www.teacherprose.com http://www.teacherprose.com/index html I tried code below in .htaccess: redirect 301 /index.html http://www.teacherprose.com This caused error "too many re-directs" in browser Any thoughts? Thank You, Eric
Technical SEO | | monthelie10