Link building too quickly
-
Hi all,
I have recently started trialing to outsource some SEO to a 3rd party, who obviously promissed white hat techniques and manual links etc.. All has gone well for the first month. But on speeking to another expert they point out that the search engines will spot inconcistencies in link building and penalise me.
I know there will not be a know ammount but as we stand at the moment, what is the current feeling of too fast.
Links built for me in one month were
100 directory submissions
80 bookmarks
16 search engine submissions
15 Article submissions
46 forum links
10 local classified searches
Is this too fast? , If to do I stop and create more inconsistency or continue at a similar rate.
Of course quality of link will be an issue, but how much.
Many thanks from SEO jnr
-
I was doing a search for a similar topic for a site we manage that has gained 50k links in the past 4 months, and I came across this article. I was a bit shocked at the answers I saw, and some of the ones that were voted as good. It's an old article, but I felt compelled to answer since this is still a relevant topic.
The link structure you showed is completely normal, and I would highly doubt you would see any negative impact from a strategy such as this. New sites and updated sites over time always receive new links. It's not about "how many" but more about "from where". I will address them one by one:
100 directory submissions
Great, as long as you have tested the directories that you are being submitted to. If they have high spam scores and low domain authority, could be a risk. You should ask what directories you were submitted to and research them to see if they have a blacklist history or are penalized. If not, I see no issue here at all. When we launch a site, we submit it to up to 450+ trusted directories, depending on the SEO plan level selected. All directories have been tested via Moz tools and other providers, to ensure the link health.80 bookmarks
Not sure when you mean by this, but as long as the places you are being added are trustworthy and somewhat related to what you provide, I wouldn't worry. Even non-related links can be beneficial, coming from the right source. Granted, everyone wants the perfect anchor text link such as "awesome product in CITY", but a "visit website" followed anchor link will not do you any harm coming from the right source.16 search engine submissions
If this is a page or URL submission through Bing or Google webmaster tools, it's a total non-issue. People submit hundreds of URLs per day, or even thousands for larger sites.15 Article submissions
"Submitted to where?" would be a better question than how many is good or bad. If these are legitimate articles through a legitimate source such as PrWeb or the like, you should have no issues. Just depends on where they are placing your articles, the article quality, and the linking domain.46 forum links
Could be good, could be bad, depends on how you were linked to, and the trust factor of the linking site. See above. You may also want to see if the linked is followed because if not, it holds little value unless it was posted on a relevant forum as helpful advice, that has good visibility.10 local classified searches
Not sure what this is indicating, but again, it depends on how the linking was done, and where the links are coming from.As to the people stating that having a lot of new, varied links is a great way to get banned/penalized, just NO. That is not true. You want link diversity and many places linking to you, and in the business world, you can't always keep posting great blogs/posts/pages/articles hoping and waiting for the links to come to you.
I have also never seen a link campaign that got someone penalized unless it was just blatant disregard for link quality or lack of knowledge.
Hope this helps...years later lol. Or at best, it will help someone that comes across this article in the future.
-
many thanks for your assistance. really appreciate it.
-
"Off site should i really remove ALL the previous links and then just work on Quality. Surely that level mentioned is not too excessive for any business trying to promote itself? or is it"
If you "built" the links, they should be removed. I would do such without hesitation.
To be clear, the overwhelming majority of "built" links are manipulative. There are some limited methods where you can create a link which offers value, but the ones you shared and the manner in which you shared them are the type you should pay (if necessary) to remove.
"I guess its the regular quality blog and off site I may struggle with getting the right level. Blogging is "OK", social media is "low to OK" and will work on these."
"OK" is not enough. Neither is "good" nor "great". You need to be exceptional.
When you perform a search for <insert keyword="">how many results are there? Let's say Google offers 1 million result pages. Where do you think an "OK" page ranks? </insert>
Strive to be nothing less then exceptional. Search engine rankings is a pure competition. If you do not have the "eye of the tiger" mentality, then you should consider hiring a quality SEO to promote the site. To be clear, any "link package" site should be avoided.
-
Ryan, Thanks.
My site ticks all the boxes with regards to design and quality build. All on site SEO, site map, meta tags, alt etc are spot on and not manipulative at all.
I guess its the regular quality blog and off site I may struggle with getting the right level. Blogging is "OK", social media is "low to OK" and will work on these.
Off site should i really remove ALL the previous links and then just work on Quality. Surely that level mentioned is not too excessive for any business trying to promote itself? or is it
-
"Ryan If SEO is not to manipulate or try to rank your site than what it is?"
There are some people who would agree with you Christopher. I am not one of them. SEO is working with clients to help them understand and provide the maximum value to their site's visitors. Of course, that sounds nice but I will three of an almost infinite amount of examples of how this goal can be achieved:
- Some clients have very poor quality content when they come on board. We work with them to engage a professional, quality writer who can significantly improve the site's content. A few qualities of the resulting page are:
- easier to read and understand
- more likely to covert a visitor into a customer
- more likely to be +1'd, tweeted, liked, etc
- earns a better AdWords quality score
- ranks higher in search engines
- Some clients have low quality websites. A few issues we commonly find:
- broken links
- poor navigation
- server error pages
- poor design
Correcting these issues tend to improve the user experience and search rankings.
- Some sites do not embrace social media. By leveraging the power of sites such as facebook, pinterest and others, site traffic can dramatically increase leading to more social interaction, links and positive signals which can benefit SEO.
"Not all link profiles are as natural as SEOMOZ/SEL."
You are right. Most sites are no where near as spammy as the SEOmoz back link profile.
-
"I see (using open site explorer) my competitors have 10's of thousands of external links, so even if I kept at this rate it would be many years before I caught up. That is based on my current understanding, so how do I get to those levels, even if it is over a year or two?"
Hi Simon,
Your situation is very common Simon. At a very high level, here are the steps:
- Build the best quality site possible. There are literally hundreds of pieces to this puzzle but a few are:
-
hire a great graphic design to provide your site a high quality look and feel
-
engage a professional web developer to develop the best possible website
-
provide a mobile website which appears correctly in smartphones, ipads, etc
-
ensure your site works as intended i.e. no broken links, forms work correctly, etc
-
ensure the site appears correctly in various browsers (IE, FF, Chrome, Safari, Opera)
-
provide an intuitive layout along with solid navigation
2. **Provide the best content possible. **
-
Create "best on the web" type of content
-
Create content for users, not search engines
-
Ensure your content is engaging and relevant
-
Strive to provide content related to current events
-
Ensure any images are sharp and clear
-
The site's content should ideally encourage users to like / tweet / +1 / share / link
3. Promote the site.
-
Once you have a solid website platform with fantastic content, tell the world about it!
-
Use social media to connect with others who have an interest in your product / service
-
Read industry blogs to find current information and influencers
-
Ask your audience what content they want to read about
-
Take every opportunity to tell everyone about the site
-
Do you agree that I should get the links removed? should I remove some or all? any Thoughts?
-
All profiles are natural until you intentionally do link building. That is a good question you ask, everything we do is to help our site rank better in Google. The problem is the Google has a monopoly and runs the show, so they are the ones who make the rules (which change constantly as they refine and as SEO's attempt to exploit I.E. pagerank sculpting) and war has been declared against link buying and selling. You have the right to do whatever you want on the web, but Google owns Google and has the right to show what they want on the web. Since everyone uses Google you have no choice but to play by their rules and their rule now is if you get caught link building we will take action. Link build if you like, but you better know what you're doing or you will harm your business or worse your client businesses.
-
Thanks for the feedback and (probably well deserved) slap in the face. Tp you this may be a bleeding obvious question to some others, who are still learning then feedback is great.
I'm getting that there is the Quantity vs Quality issue here. Having had little experience of building an SEO link strategy, I am plainly not aware of how fast to go or the techniques of getting good links.
I see (using open site explorer) my competitors have 10's of thousands of external links, so even if I kept at this rate it would be many years before I caught up. That is based on my current understanding, so how do I get to those levels, even if it is over a year or two?
-
It all has to do with quality, nothing to do with speed.
Google won't punish a site for going viral, but they will punish a site for manipulative link building in an effort to manipulate ranking positions.
-
Ryan If SEO is not to manipulate or try to rank your site than what it is?Not all link profiles are as natural as SEOMOZ/SEL.
-
^ The Expert ^
Not too fast but too reckless.
-
Hi Simon,
I find it amazing that in 2013 questions like this are still asked.
The link plan you shared above is great.....if you are intentionally attempting to get your site penalized. This plan is a perfect outline of what some site owners look for in an effort to build links to a competitor's site and try to get them penalized.
You are absolutely free to earn as many links as you want to your site. Neither Google nor Bing would have any problem with it.
What you are talking about is building manipulative links in an effort to manipulate search rankings. It is a very bad idea. Those links are highly likely to damage your site. My recommendation would be to remove every one.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Think I'm ready to do some link building. Couple questions.
Getting ready to do some link building. I've got several lists of competitors' links, including a bunch of sites with broken links that would be a great fit to link to us. I've got a capable VA to get started work on reaching out to people. Just curious if this is the right game plan, seems a little simple: For this round of link building I'm thinking all the links would point to my root domain. -Find quality sites/links to go after -Find an email to the owner/webmaster -Have the VA send them a value proposition email(i.e. why it's good fit for all)...or tell them about broken links etc. -Follow up myself when a response is generated. -Hope/verify they link to us. Thanks for the help with the newbie questions.
Link Building | | astahl110 -
Have SEOmoz members ever considered joining forces with link-building?
I really hope this isn't interpreted as gray hat or spammy, so please let me know if it is! I'm just always racking my brain to try to come up with creative link-building strategies. Since we're all SEOs who are presumably doing some form of link-building, what if we got together and examined one anothers' sites, to find opportunities for links? I'm sure that still doesn't make sense, so I'll try to clarify. OK, I've been seeing an in-house guy around here that works for a place that sells coat hangers. What if I had an existing blog post that mentioned coat hangers, allowing me to make that phrase a link to this site? LET IT BE KNOWN THAT I'M NOT SUGGESTING A FREE-FOR-ALL OF POINTLESS LINKS! I'm only suggesting this to be done in instances where it makes sense and makes copy more informative! I know a lot of kinks would have to be worked out (like making sure people are giving and not just taking) but I wanted to throw the general idea out there first to see if it's even a good idea.
Link Building | | UnderRugSwept0 -
Outsource Link Building?
Currently we are in the process of creating a new ecommerce website. The site is not live yet, but we have done all of the planning and brainstorming and now are just doing all of the dirty work to get things ready to go live. We are devoting a lot of time on merchandising and developing the site, but currently do not have the resources to put together a good link building campaign in house. Does anyone have any recommendations for outsourcing the link building? The last thing we want is to hire someone that submits to bad neighborhoods and only directories. Is there a good, better, best scenario we should be looking at for pricing, ect? Obviously, like most who are starting a new site, cost is an issue at least until the site gives some sort of sign of life. Also, we are in the Pittsburgh area. We don't need to go local with this, but if there is someone particularly good in the area it would be nice. Thanks in advance.
Link Building | | ClaytonKendall0 -
How many nofollow links should we build to have a natural link profile
Hi guys, As with many link builders we have been building lots of dofollow links for our site, so many that mainly our incoming links are dofollow. Some pages have 99.5% dofollow external links which I know is not very natural. In your experience in terms of percentage how much should you have in terms of nofollow external links in your link profile. I noticed SEOMoz has about 12-13% nofollow external links, shall I go with this figure? Thanks guys. David
Link Building | | sssrpm0 -
Please critique my link building plan
Hello, Here's my revised link building plan for nlpca.com Let me know if I'm off or missing anything. 1)Identify a list of competitors that are strong enough to have good backlinks (probably about 15 in our industry Look at top content for top competitors and see what type of content is being linked to. build infographics for each area we want to target based on top content Using OSE, analyze competitor backlinks and decide which sites might link to the infographics and which sites might just link to us if we asked them (our site is already an authority). In this step we would also expand the backlink analysis to include sites on pages 4-8 Only choose link aquisition for sites based on the following criteria: Age A lot of unique content A clean site Backlinks going to that site Facebook followers Which of course means high search engine rankings Publish infographics and do outreach
Link Building | | BobGW0 -
Link Building Strategy
Hello Everyone, We have about 15 clients who we need to do link building for but I am at a loss on how to even begin. Does anybody have any tips or tricks to achieving quality back links in a short amount of time? Any help is appreciated!
Link Building | | imageworks-2612900 -
Create content or more link building?
For those of you who have been doing white hat SEO for many years, I'm curious what % of your time (and/or how many hours/week) you spend on 2 activities: -- creating new, original content for your site -- work on getting links to your existing content I find that working at getting links via article marketing, guest blogging, forum posting, etc, is an open ended time suck that never ends. But maybe a necessary investment for sites that have fewer external links than their competitors (?). Adding unique original content to my site is also time consuming, and I'm not sure about the short-term vs long-term benefit of it. I'm curious if you guys who rank in top 3 positions of the SERPs split your time evenly between link building and content building, or if you spend more time on one than the other? And does the answer change for a site that's been around for a while and already has several hundred external links and several hundred pages of original content? Where should I spend my time on a site that is 8 months old, has about 90 pages of original content (all with good on-page SEO), and several hundred external links (with mostly relevant anchor texts)? My goal is to rank higher for the key terms people search on to find a service like mine. Currently I'm on page 1 in SERPs but not in top 3.
Link Building | | scanlin0 -
Link building? I really dont get it is there an easy way
I Have been using a link exchange website called linkmarket. I have been told that these kind of website dont really do you many favours but i have signed up for a year so i am currently still using it. What does everyone think? Also is there a proven way to get high quality links with out spending hours traling other websites and asking if they want to exchange links because the normall answer i get is NO!
Link Building | | WillFrank3