Has the Hummingbird Changes Effected the accuracy of MOZ?
-
Hello,
I am new to the forum. Can anyone tell me if the recent Hummingbird Changes have effected the accuracy of MOZ? Specifically, keyword comparison of competition.
Thanks,
Derek
-
Unfortunately, there's a lot about Hummingbird we don't know right now. I think Danny Sullivan's FAQ piece is the closest we have to reliable information, but that still leaves a lot of holes:
FAQ: All About The New Google “Hummingbird” Algorithm
Google claims that Hummingbird is a substantial rewrite of the core algorithm (more than just your typical update), and yet we haven't seen large-scale movements on many client rankings. So, what's going on? A couple of things, I think:
(1) As Peter said (and this seems to be pretty well confirmed), Hummingbird changes how Google interprets some queries, especially natural language queries, and attempts to find relevant results based on a more complex, semantic analysis of phrases, and not just keyword matching. It's unclear how this practically impacts your average query today (especially head terms and the "chunky middle"), but as voice-based searches become more common and people get used to natural language queries, the impact will increase over time.
(2) Hummingbird seems to have increased Google's ability to use historical information to personalize queries. This extends a long-term evolution and means that any given person might see a different result for an ambiguous query based on previous queries. Even now, searches like "weather" bring up local information, whereas they used to bring up generic information (like weather sites). Practically, we're not seeing this personalization impact affect a ton of queries yet, but we will over time. There are ways to check ranking using context and limited personalization, but it's technically very difficult. This is certainly a concern for rank-tracking tools, including ours (and something we're thinking about even now).
(3) Finally, I suspect Hummingbird laid the groundwork for an expansion of Knowledge Graph, not only in its pairing to more queries, but in how Google extracts data from the index to create answers. I'm seeing many examples in testing where Google is pulling answer-like information from websites beyond its current data partners. This is speculation, and it may not be connected to Hummingbird, but these changes are definitely coming.
(1) and (2) impact rank-tracking directly, whereas (3) impacts how we view ranking and signals the need to go beyond just counting blue links. We take both trends seriously, but getting from here to there is a gradual process, not just for technical reasons, but because our mindset as SEOs has to evolve.
From a competitive standpoint, you won't see huge changes in the short term. If a change impacts any given query, that impact is felt for both you and your competitors, in most cases. There may be isolated examples where a re-interpretation of a query means that you or your competitor rise or fall in ranking relative to the other, but our tools would see that and I expect that's a relatively small amount of searches right now. At this point, we're keeping our eyes open and trying to predict where Google is headed. Now that Moz Analytics is launched, we're working hard to be more agile and iterate new functions in smaller chunks and at a faster pace.
-
I don't think the Hummingbird update was specifically targeted at to improving Google Instant, but I guess it is likely that will receive an improvement because of Hummingbird. It's not something I have noticed to be honest, but it makes sense that it would.
Peter
-
Very well said Peter if I could I would give you two thumbs up. Do you think Hummingbird was to improve Google instant? I believe it was as it uses more contextual algo patterns to serve up answers to questions posed to the engine. Sorry to get off topic
-
Hello Robert and welcome to the forum
The recent Hummingbird update has no doubt shifted the SEO horizon, but that is true for all of us, Within that, I guess there will inevitably some re-tuning of the Moz tools and their analysis of data, but that is also true of other tools.
Fundamentally, Hummingbird is about Google increasing their focus on ranking information based on a more intelligent understanding of search requests. But Google has been heading that way for some time so there's not been anything totally revolutionary about the Hummingbird update. It's more evolutionary.
Just as there may need to be tweaks to competitor analysis for keywords, there will likely be tweaks to the way on-page optimisation is graded, but to reiterate, this will be true across the whole breadth of tools available on the Internet.
From my perspective, I respect Moz's position and the expertise and comprehensive analysis which both their tools and their team provide.
I hope that helps,
Peter
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Moz Spam Analysis vs. GWMT Links to Your Site
Hi Moz Community, I have been conducting some link auditing and started comparing the Moz Spam Analysis tool with the links provided in Google WMT. It appears that the Moz Spam Analysis tools shows an aggregate of links that Moz may or may not consider spam, however when you download and look at Google's "Links to Your Site" list it provides every link iteration known to man that's pointing to the target website - without providing any hints as to whether or not a link may be considered spam by Google. The biggest concern I have here is that Google is picking up a lot of links, which I consider spam, that do not appear in the Moz Spam Analysis results. I guess the question(s) I have are: Does it make sense to compare these two data sets? Has anyone else tried this comparison and how did you use the information to make positive changes? Any recommendations when it comes to determining if an external link is spam/hurting/helping a website? Thank you!
Moz Pro | | GoogleDowner0 -
Moz Pro vs. Moz Analytics
Beta version has been out for awhile. Curious to know what people think of Moz Analytics. Personally, I'm having a hard time making the switch from Pro to Moz Analytics because I'm so used to the navigation and layout of Pro. What does everyone else think of the new Moz Analytics? Advantages? Disadvantages?
Moz Pro | | EEE31 -
Moz scores
Hi All, Could anyone please explain for me why the moz scores that show under SERPs in Google search show one set of values, but when i click on the SERP listing and go to that page, the Moz scores at the bottom of the tab the page is open in are completely different. I.E - SERP result Wireless Alarms <cite>www.wireless-alarms.net/</cite>Honeywell, Friedland, Response, Wireless house home intruder burglar alarms and wirefree doorbells chimes and accessories.<iframe class="SEOmoz-iframe" src="chrome-extension://eakacpaijcpapndcfffdgphdiccmpknp/html/serpbar.html#{" settings":{"dmr":false,"dmt":false,"mr":true,"mt":true,"serp-overlay":true,"toolbar-enabled":true,"subdomain-metrics":false,"serp-panel-open":true,"toolbar-position":"bottom"},"lsdata":{"feid":3,"fipl":3,"fmrp":2.0446037910058426,"fmrr":5.396862303226778e-12,"ftrp":1.8723654310590483,"ftrr":9.21604483751679e-12,"fuid":3,"pda":8.903939958502189,"peid":3,"pid":3,"pmrp":1.6026230610187469,"pmrr":1.3566326316606153e-10,"ptrp":1.025503845909542,"ptrr":1.4972548621304158e-11,"puid":3,"ueid":2,"uemrp":2.577887966559377,"uemrr":5.40110633420739e-13,"uid":2,"uipl":2,"ujid":2,"umrp":2.577887966559377,"umrr":5.40110633420739e-13,"upa":23.634692786039714,"utrp":4.9331532541404854,"utrr":1.9684091945588755e-16},"user":{"level":"pro","options":{},"proenabled":true,"aclurl":"http:="" moz.com="" users="" level?src="mozbar","loginURL":"https://moz.com/login","logoutURL":"https://moz.com/logout","apiRequest":"url-metrics","cols":"133146078688","expired":false,"accessId":"pro-RGFkZHlTbXVyZg%3D%3D","expires":1374925378,"signature":"tBSBXpLbBmk073ofsfBwnilmODw%3D","displayName":"DaddySmurf"},"serp":4,"host":"www.wireless-alarms.net"}"" scrolling="no"></iframe> Page result <label>Page:</label><label id="Page Authority" class="key lsdata">PA:</label> <label id="SEOmoz-data-PA" class="val lsdata">27</label><label id="mozrank" class="key lsdata" title="MozRank">mR:</label> <label id="SEOmoz-data-mR" class="val lsdata">5.30</label><label id="moztrust" class="key pro-only lsdata" title="MozTrust">mT:</label> <label id="SEOmoz-data-mT" class="val pro-only lsdata">5.61</label><label id="SEOmoz-data-uid">1,950</label> links from
Moz Pro | | DaddySmurf
<label id="SEOmoz-data-uipl">2</label> Root Domains<label>Root Domain:</label><label id="dom-pageauthority" class="key lsdata" title="Domain Authority">DA:</label> <label id="SEOmoz-data-DA" class="val lsdata">24</label><label id="SEOmoz-data-puid">100,262</label> links from
<label id="SEOmoz-data-pid">3</label> Domains<label>Subdomain:</label><label id="SEOmoz-data-fuid">19,953</label> links from
<label id="SEOmoz-data-fipl">3</label> DomainsThank you.Si0 -
Can you change the websites in your PRO Dashboard?
Hello, I set a client's website in one of my 5 campaigns in my Pro Dashboard. But my client changed his domain. I don't see an option to change the domain server in the Campaign settings. Is it possible?
Moz Pro | | Eblan0 -
The change you wanted was rejected
Hello Dears when i submit my keywords i am getting this error The change you wanted was rejected. Maybe you tried to change something you didn't have access to. How can i solve this issues, Regards Noufal
Moz Pro | | Noufal0 -
Joined SEOMOZ but non changed.
hi. i am new SEOMoz and i joined pro monthly and create 2 campagnes but there are every thing shows me 0 and i guess nothing changed with before.. please see this.. | | StickerApt |
Moz Pro | | bratt
| Domain Authority | 1 |
| Domain MozRank | 0.00 |
| Domain MozTrust | 0.00 |
| External Followed Links | 0 |
| Total External Links | 0 |
| Total Links | 0 |
| Followed Linking Root Domains | 0 |
| Total Linking Root Domains | 0 |
| Linking C-Blocks | 0 |
| Followed Links
vs
NoFollowed Links****Followed Linking Root Domains
vs
NoFollowed Linking Root Domains | | ubdomain Metrics | canadastickerking | stickeryou | stickybusiness |
| 4.31 | Transparent 5.26 | 4.56 |
| 3.78 | Transparent 5.43 | 4.87 |
| 71 | Transparent 38,649 | 631 |
| 73 | Transparent 38,814 | 1,265 |
| 3,805 | Transparent 235,124 | 26,337 |
| 7 | Transparent 243 | 115 |
| 7 | Transparent 286 | 161 |
| | | | | | StickerApt |
| Subdomain MozRank | 0.00 |
| Subdomain MozTrust | 0.00 |
| External Followed Links | 0 |
| Total External Links | 0 |
| Total Links | 0 |
| Followed Linking Root Domains | 0 |
| Total Linking Root Domains | 0 |
| Followed Links
vs
NoFollowed Links****Followed Linking Root Domains
vs
NoFollowed Linking Root Domains | "No followed (0%)"
"No nofollowed (0%)" | Total Branded Keywords Manage brand rules Non-branded Keywords Week ending: 9/9 Change 9/16 9/9 Change 9/16 9/9 Change 9/16 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- Organic Search Visits 45 -18% 37 7 -14% 6 38 -18% 31 URLs Receiving Entrances Via Search 8 25% 10 4 -50% 2 4 100% 8 | Non-Paid Keywords Sending Search Visits | 20 | -10% | 18 | 6 | -33% | 4 | 14 | 0% | 14 | can any one help me what should i do with SEOMoz? all the keyword i set up tells me not in top 50 ranking.. i set up 12keyword for start.. and aslo i there is craw erros on my site but it can not be fixed because the page that getting erros are automatic quote pages and made php. and it should be duplicate pages it share with other pages, hard to explain.. but you will see what i am talking about it has duplicate title and content.. it should be like that.. http://www.stickerapt.com/quote.php i can not change duplicate erros is it gonna effect page rank? please help..ㅡㅡ0 -
Drop in number of Pages crawled by Moz crawler
What would cause a sudden drop in the number of pages crawled/accessed by the Moz crawler? The site has about 600 pages of content. We have multiple campaigns set up in our Pro account to track different keyword campaigns- but all for the same domain. Some show 600+ pages accessed, while others only access 7 pages for the same domain. What could be causing these issues?
Moz Pro | | AllaO0 -
Crawl complete, but nothing changed?
Hi everyone, According to my account, the crawl diagnostics were completed yesterday. However, the duplicate page titles that it mentions aren't correct. The changes that I implemented several days ago are not being shown in the report. When I click the duplicate page title links, the latest date in the graph is 3/26. However, it says the crawl was completed on 3/30. Does it take a few days for the reports to match what the crawl actually discovered?
Moz Pro | | beeneeb0