Is this a possible Google penalty scenario?
-
In January we were banned from Google due to duplicate websites because of a server configuration error by our previous webmaster. Around 100 of our previously inactive domain names were defaulted to the directory of our company website during a server migration, thus showing the exact same site 100 times... obviously Google was not game and banned us.
At the end of February we were allowed back into the SERPS after fixing the issue and have since steadily regained long-tail keyword phrase rankings, but in Google are still missing our main keyword phrase. This keyword phrase brings in the bulk of our best traffic, so obviously it's an issue.
We've been unable to get above position 21 for this keyword, but in Yahoo, Bing, and Yandex (Russian SE) we're positions 3, 3, and 7 respectively. It seems to me there has to be a penalty in effect, as this keyword gets between 10 and 100 times as much traffic in Google than any of the ones we're ranked for, what do you think?
EDIT: I should mention in the 4-5 years prior to the banning we had been ranked between 15 and 4th in Google, 80% of the time on the first page.
-
Yeah! That was actually the first time I had even heard of Yandex. Of course the issue is that I haven't searched in the Russian version of our keyword using the .ru SE as I'm not sure about any linguistic differences that Google Translate wouldn't account for (it's a financial industry term).
I'm sure we're not ranked highly in the Russian version of the SE though, as we don't have a Russian version of the site! haha
-
Did you see Rand in the latest whiteboard Friday. http://www.seomoz.org/blog/smx-advanced-andy-atkins-kruger-talks-international-seo-and-yandex-whiteboard-friday
Interesting stuff about Yandex and their Algo.
-
You're definitely right about the discrepancies, I pay so much attention to Google that I had forgotten the other SE's show large discrepancies for many of our key phrases/terms.
My thought on the penalty for a certain phrase was that it had to do with the search volume of that phrase, but that's just speculation. I suppose only time and further SEO work will tell.
-
When did Google state they didn't penalize your site in rankings?
My reply was that a penalty is not for a specific term. If your site received a penalty, your entire site is affected (i.e. all terms). If I was to stretch for a corner case, it would be where your site might have a page using a copyrighted term such as "herbal viagra" where Google drops "viagra" from the keyword phrase due to pfizer's copyright.
You can have large discrepancies between Google, Yahoo and Bing. Each company is independent and using their own systems. This is even true between Bing and Yahoo who share a lot of information.
From my own keyword reports I have a site with the following ranks for the same term:
Google - 9, Bing 14, Yahoo 3
Google - 20, Bing - not in top 50, Yahoo - 49
There can definitely be major discrepancies between SERPs.
-
When did Google state they didn't penalize your site in rankings? I thought that's been a trend for years now when you broke the webmaster guidelines in a way that wasn't strong enough to be banned but strong enough to warrant penalty.
Sharing the URL of websites I work on seems like a bad idea to me, so I'll keep it to myself for now. The keyword is "highly competitive" 53%, as determined by SEOMoz's tool and our page has been optimized for this keyword for 5+ years now - hence why we were on page 1 from before 2005 - 2011.
Only once we were banned from Google were we unable to move above the first spot on Page 3, despite regaining #3 rankings in Yahoo and Bing. I don't usually see that large of discrepancies between the SE's, am I wrong?
My one thought is that this also coincides with the release of Panda, though our site has no duplicate content issues.
-
Google does not penalize a site by devaluing your ranking on a given term. They either remove you from their index completely, or they may devalue links to your site which would affect your domain as a whole.
I would recommend taking a very close look at how competitive this keyword is, how well your target page is optimized for it, and make comparisons with the competing sites who outrank you.
For any further details you would need to share the URL and keyword.
-
We are facing similar problem. Although our pages are regularly crawled by google but google doesn't show them on first page. Some are way behind after 100 pages.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google loves me. Yahoo and Bing not so much...
My site is ranked very high for my keywords on Google and Google Maps. But we come in 4 or 6 places lower on the other two search engines. Does any one have any pointers on the different types of algorithms they use? Many thanks in advance:)
Algorithm Updates | | MissThumann0 -
Google Panda July 2016
Hi Does anyone know what impact the recent slow Panda roll out may have? Obviously content, but would it perhaps include engagement/user behaviour factors regarding your on page content too? Thanks
Algorithm Updates | | BeckyKey0 -
What Ranking Factors Impact Google News Visibility?
I'm just at the beginning of a new analysis involving Google News visibility and ranking factors, and thought I could put the project out to you, dear SEO geniuses, to get your ideas and perspectives. Backgrounder: My company operates over 50 niche, disease-specific daily news sites, covering science, research and advocacy news about specific diseases. Virtually all of them are in Google News. They range in age from 3 years old to 3 months old. Varying degrees of page rank / authority Content on the site is completely niche to specific diseases, and we have a lot of sites for rare and orphan diseases. Most of the content is news, but we also have info/resources pages, blogs, and some short-form posts made for use in social media. The Project: I want to do an analysis of keywords in our news headlines and see how certain keywords correlate with articles that do well -- both in terms of search traffic and overall with users. Going to use our Multiple Sclerosis News Today website. Most of our search traffic comes from Google News. What I hope to gain: I'm curious to see if certain sets of keywords that relate to the disease, to therapies, etc. drive the most traffic. I want to compare these keyword lists to how well we rank in organic search for the same keywords (via news articles or info pages) to see if there is a connection. I want to also create a working keyword list of the best-performing keywords in the news as a way of cross-pollinating content production on our blogs, info pages, social content, etc. I want to increase my knowledge base of ranking factors specific for Google News. The last point is really something I wish I knew more about. I feel like there aren't many knowledge resources out there about Google News. Is it safe to assume that the same on-site and off-site SEO best practices that govern organic search engine visibility are at play in Google News, or are there independent factors as well? I'd love to get your thoughts. Thanks!
Algorithm Updates | | Michael_Nace0 -
What is the appropriate Robot.txt to unblock if Google cannot get all the resources from my homepage?
Hello everyone. I did some research as to why my website has decreased in the Google search rankings recently. After reading this Yoast article I believe it's because the robot.txt files I have set up on my wordpress website. The following is a screen shot of the results of a fetch & render query of my webpage.Googlebot couldn't get all resources for this page. Here's a list: URL Type Reason http://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Open+Sans:400,600,700,800%7CPT+Sans:400,400italic,700,700italic%7COswald:400,300,700&subset=latin,latin-ext Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/slick-contact-forms/css/admin.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/contact-form-plugin/css/style.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/hupso-share-buttons-for-twitter-facebook-google/style.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/latest-post-accordian-slider/css/lpaccordion.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/latest-post-accordian-slider/css/style.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/revslider/rs-plugin/css/settings.css?rev=4.1.1&ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/revslider/rs-plugin/css/dynamic-captions.css?rev=4.1.1&ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/revslider/rs-plugin/css/static-captions.css?rev=4.1.1&ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/wp-email-capture/inc/css/wp-email-capture-styles.css?ver=1.0 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/themes/infographer/style.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/themes/infographer/css/stylesheet.min.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/themes/infographer/css/style_dynamic.php?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/themes/infographer/css/custom_css.php?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/convertable-contact-form-builder-analytics-and-lead-management-dashboard/assets/css/convertable.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/google-maps-widget/css/gmw.css?ver=1.66 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-content/plugins/acurax-social-media-widget/style.css?ver=3.9.1 Style Sheet Denied by robots.txt http://www.kmollinslaw.com/wp-includes/js/swfobject.js?ver=2.2-20120417 Script Denied by robots.txt My current robot.txt settings are as follows; User-agent: * Disallow: /wp-admin/ Disallow: /wp-includes/ Disallow: */xmlrpc.php Disallow: */wp-*.php Disallow: */trackback/ Disallow: *?wptheme= Disallow: *?comments= Disallow: *?replytocom Disallow: */comment-page- Disallow: *?s= Disallow: */wp-content/ Allow: */wp-content/uploads/ ```What to I need to allow/disallow to allow Google spiders to properly read my website?
Algorithm Updates | | gamesotd0 -
Pages fluctuating +/- 70 positions in Google SERPs?
I've got some pages that appear somewhere around #25 in Google. Every now and then, it just goes away from the top 100 results for a few days (even up to a week) and then it comes back. I've got other pages that rank around #8 which falls down to about #75 for a while and then it comes back. But while a page may be gone from the top 100 results in the US, it still ranks at about the same place everywhere else in the world (+/- 10 positions). I've seen this happen in the past but never it happened so often. What gives?!?
Algorithm Updates | | sbrault740 -
Website dance on Google Map results and organic seo results
My website is daily showing different position on maps.google.com and for the last few days like yesterday it was on 21st position on some keyword and today it is no where and same with other keywords. Is this a Google Dance ?? what can be its period ? and what is tyhe solution to handle it ??
Algorithm Updates | | mnkpso0 -
Does google index non-public pages ie. members logged in page
hi, I was trying to locate resources on the topics regarding how much the google bot indexes in order to qualify a 'good' site on their engine. For example, our site has many pages that are associated with logged in users and not available to the public until they acquire a login username and password. Although those pages show up in google analytics, they should not be made public in the google index which is what happens. In light of Google trying to qualify a site according to how 'engaged' a user is on the site, I would feel that the activities on those member pages are very important. Can anyone offer suggestions on how Google treats those pages since we are planning to do further SEO optimization of those pages. Thanks
Algorithm Updates | | jumpdates0 -
If Google turns down the weight of keywords in domains then what will they be turning up?
Per Matt Cutts video "We will be turning that keyword in domain down." http://youtu.be/rAWFv43qubI So what will they be turning up?
Algorithm Updates | | Thos0030