Drop in keyword rankings with a multi-region website
-
Hi everyone,
I know that variations if this question have been asked on this forum and have been answered by Google also.
Google's response seems to be clear that "Websites that provide content for different regions and in different languages sometimes create content that is the same or similar but available on different URLs. This is generally not a problem as long as the content is for different users in different countries."
This was our approach when launching a new .co.nz website recently to coincide with us opening a new office in Auckland. Our original site is still our .com.au site. We went with a new domain name over a sub directory or sub domain for the reasons in the same Google article.
After launching the NZ site in February and steadily growing some rankings, we've noticed in the last week or so a drastic drop in our keyword rankings (and traffic) for no apparent reason. There are no apparent issues in Search Console or with the Moz Site Crawl, so I'm wondering what's going on? I know rankings can fluctuate widely, especially when you're not on page 1 (which we're not) but the sudden and drastic drop did concern me.
Currently, our AUS site's content is basically being replicated on the NZ site (e.g. blog posts, about us, company history, etc.).
I just wanted to bounce it off you all to see whether you think it could be the "duplicate content" on the NZ site, or could it be something else?
I'd really appreciate your input!
Cheers,
Nathan
-
Ah, all very helpful, thanks!
Some interesting bits to pull apart here, I think:
-
hreflang tagging is unlikely to improve your rankings for any given language/territory/page/keyword; rather, it's more likely to prevent the wrong content from showing up in the wrong territory. Make sense?
-
I'd try to manage expectations around "restoring" rankings. What if your performance dropped because of strong competitor activity, changing consumer behaviour, or other factors? Whilst your international setup is part of that picture, the reality is much more complex. I'd try to shift the conversation away from working out ways to / waiting for your rankings to "restore" from a magic bullet fix, and start talking about the many strategies and tactics you might deploy to improve rankings gradually moving forwards.
-
I'd be _really _nervous of outsourced link building. If you're handing money to a third party to get you links, you're only a small amounts of semantics away from buying links outright. What are the doing, exactly? Are you producing exceptionally high quality, useful information and resources, which they're helping to shine a spotlight on - or are you paying them a fee for them to magically acquire links? It feels like, of all the possible risks and causes of your problems, this is the area I'd want to scrutinise the most; and in the meantime, start looking into ways in which your pages can earn links without having to pay a mysterious third party!
-
-
Hey there!
No worries, thought you'd just missed it or something.
OK so I've added the correct hreflang en-AU and en-NZ values to both the .co.nz and .com.au pages.
I've also gone into Google Search Console and confirmed that the .co.nz was targeting New Zealand which it is. I've also gone into Crawl and done a 'Fetch as Google' for the home page and blog page of .co.nz plus 'linked pages.' There are no hreflang errors.
I've also checked all pages on both sites and all correctly have the 'rel=canonical' tag.
Re the blog posts, at this stage we don't have the resources to write different content for each site. We're happy to keep writing the blog posts for the .com.au site and duplicating it for the .co.nz site AS LONG as our SEO isn't being negatively impacted. Our clients/markets/services are very similar — almost identical and just differ in location (i.e. Australia vs New Zealand).
The above was completed about 4 weeks ago now and we still haven't seen an increase in rankings for the .co.nz site (or back to where we were) — only for a couple of keywords that we're actually not targeting.
Just a couple of questions:
1. How long does it usually take for the hreflang tag to kick in and restore rankings?
2. How long does it take to actually get some keyword rankings for the new .co.nz site, considering that our .com.au site is performing reasonably well (although it is 5+ years older)?
3. Is there anything I'm missing here that I could do? Should I be really worried that the .co.nz site isn't ranking for our top 10 targeted keywords since launching the site back in February (6 months ago) or is it normal to break the '51+' ranking for at least some of the keywords. Sorry, a difficult question I know. In addition to Moz, I'm also tracking rankings on Ahrefs.
4. I'm outsourcing some of the link building, but I'm monitoring it closely. Could that be a reason for a drop in rankings also?
I know some of the above is a little hard to answer, but I'd really appreciate your help!
-
Yikes, sorry, I didn't see your responses. Sorry for the delayed response!
Your understanding is correct. It doesn't matter whether the content is duplicated within a single domain, across multiple domains, or multiple subdomains - if it's duplicate but targeting different languages and/or territories, then you need to use hreflang tags to manage that. If the pages are the same in all but phone number (where the phone number is targeting a different territory), that's exactly the kind of situation where you should be using hreflang tags.
Separately, all pages should use canonical tags which reference the correct version of themselves (note, not the alternate/hreflang equivalent), as way of declaring that they're the correct version of that localised page. The hreflang tags take care of the relationship between the multilingual versions without the need to try and do anything clever with pointing canonical references between them.
The blog question is more complex. Are your audiences/products/services different enough in those markets to warrant a distinct content strategy? Does that make sense, strategically?
If the content is different, then you don't want hreflang tags on those individual pages, because you've no equivalent resource/page to reference. Challenging!
So, in a nutshell:
Use hreflang tags everywhere where you've very-similar/duplicate pages which only differ in terms of which territory they serve - regardless of which domain they're on.
Use canonical tags on all pages/templates, to reference the correct version of that page/template - but this shouldn't try and do anything clever in terms of its relationship with the hreflang tags.
Where content isn't the same between multiple sites/pages, don't use hreflang tags (but do still use canonical tags).
Make sense?
-
Also, would you recommend that I rel=canonical in addition to the hreflang tag for any pages on the .co.nz site that are similar (or identical) to the .com.au site — including the .com.nz home page? For example the home pages of both sites are almost identical except for the ccTLD and a phone number...
Just thinking if I do that, the .co.nz site will only rank for a few pages which are unique to itself (e.g. location page about the Auckland office which isn't on the .com.au site).
At present, all of the "product" pages are pretty much identical as are the "blog" posts.
Speaking of blog content, is it also ideal to write "different" blog content for the .co.nz site and the .com.au site going forward to avoid the hrefland and rel=canonical issues?
Sorry lots of questions I know!
-
Sorry for the delay!
OK I'll give that a go! Although everything I've read/watched from Google and others, seems a little unclear if it is required for a standalone .com.au (Aus) and a .co.nz (New Zealand) ccTLD — more for either sub domains or sub directories of the same domain.
Assuming that without the hreflang, Google views the content as duplicate content and that's the reason for the drop in rankings? Or is it something else?
Yes both sites are correctly targeted in Google Search Console.
Just need to figure out now the best way to do the hreflang now!
Cheers.
-
Ah, I definitely suspect that our candidate here is the hreflang tagging.
The use-case definitely extends to the same content/language targeting multiple different countries, and it's implemented in exactly the same way. For each page/URL, you'll need to point to the equivalent page on the other site (either via tags or in the XML sitemap).
You'll want each page to have an _en-_au and _en-_zn value.
I'd double-check that you're targeting the right regions for each site in Search Console, too.
I'd be very surprised if that doesn't fix everything pretty much overnight!
-
Hey Jono!
Thanks so much for your time and effort here. Really appreciated! Responses below.
- Are you using hreflang tagging between the sites/content; and if so, are you confident that this is correctly configured and maintained? No as I thought that was only required for sites for different languages. Both of our AUS and NZ sites are english. Maybe I've missed something here...
- How much is your content localised to the market in question - or is it just copied without variation? There is some localisation, more around the specific locations where we operate but the overall service offering and our blog posts are pretty much identical. The majority of pages are the same across both sites (e.g. About Us, Our Services, Testimonials, Blog) but there are a few pages which specifically describe each of our locations.
- Does your product/service/price/proposition or availability vary by location? They do slightly but overall the service is very similar. For example, we offer conference venues, meeting rooms and function rooms with a consistent service and pricing, but each location differs slightly in terms of where it's situated, its benefits and the services it offers specifically.
- How much does the competition vary by territory; who's beating you, and what are they doing differently? For AUS, most of the competition is made up of hotels and multi-listing sites plus some of our direct competitors who also specialise in conference venues, meeting rooms and function rooms but aren't hotels. Our main competitors have been around for a few years longer than us. Our NZ site only launched in February so early days.
- Has performance dropped on both sites, or just one? And are there particular pages or keywords which have suffered? No, our AUS site is performing well and increasing in ranking gradually. However, the NZ site dropped dramatically in 1 week and never made it back. Our highest spots were 24/28/29 and in that week, they dropped back to 51+. All pages/keywords were affected.
If you could probe these areas a little, we might be able to steer towards a better understanding of what's going on. So appreciated.
-
Hello!
Could I ask a few questions to help me understand the broader context?
- Are you using hreflang tagging between the sites/content; and if so, are you confident that this is correctly configured and maintained?
- How much is your content localised to the market in question - or is it just copied without variation?
- Does your product/service/price/proposition or availability vary by location?
- How much does the competition vary by territory; who's beating you, and what are they doing differently?
- Has performance dropped on both sites, or just one? And are there particular pages or keywords which have suffered?
If you could probe these areas a little, we might be able to steer towards a better understanding of what's going on.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Keyword SEO
Hi everyone! I am pretty new to SEO so all the help would be great. Does every webpage on our website need a focus keyword for example like tructiepbongda Just to note that I am using Yoast on Wordpress. Many thanks,
Technical SEO | | yenu0 -
Why my site is not ranking for any of the keywords?
We have a site for Property management software, we have done everything like set proper Title and descriptions, heading tags, robots tag is also ok, set schema and its ok with Google webmaster too also we are doing Social media promotion. can you please check our website and tell me what is the problem??
Technical SEO | | rootwaysinc0 -
Bing rankings question
Hi, We just wrapped up a website redesign about a month ago. The content stayed primarily the same. Once we launched the new site all of our rankings in Google stayed the same but we lost rank for all competitive keywords on Bing. I looked in Bing Webmaster tools and it doesn't show any penalties but it does show that we have too many H1 tags. I don't think the H1 tag thing is the issue but maybe. Do you know what could be causing this?
Technical SEO | | BT20090 -
Meta Keywords - Should I define them myself
Hi All, Im sure this has been answered somewhere but I couldn't find it. SEOQuake etc suggest you should define meta keywords. However I was under the impression that this was not best practice Can anyone confirm what I should do/ is best practice? Cheers Bowey
Technical SEO | | CFCU0 -
Is good webhosting and CCL Certificate, improve website Ranking?
I am wondering if good web hosting and CCL certificate help website to rank? any Idea!
Technical SEO | | AlexanderWhite0 -
Whats happened to my rankings
Hey everyone, I hope someone might be able to help me figure out what has gone wrong here. I have a website which was slowly growing in rankings. The domain used was a .net However, It is a UK based business so I shifted this to a .co.uk domain and then followed googles advice in webmaster tools for moving address. ie, copy site, verify in GWMT and then 301 the old site. Now the .net had 71 indexed pages out of 73. But after 2 months .co.uk only has 41 out of 73 indexed. At the end of last week I did change the theme on my website although the content / urls have all remained the same. I have gone to check my rankings this morning and the site has totally bombed. Even the own brand name does not ranking in top 10 pages. I have not done an major link building at all yet for the site and any links that are there are all high quality from industry related authority sites. Looking at GWMT the latest links all look ok, nothing spammy but one thing I did notice is that it shows the .net domain providing 193 links via 301and also individually a great deal of the links that point to .net but have shown in .co.uk What I would like to know if have I actually done something wrong? Should I just kill the 301 (i am loathed to do this as a few of the links to this took me a long time to get), after spending a great deal of money developing my site and just starting to see some nice progress in the natural rankings and google has gone and pulled the carpet from under me. I would understand if I was doing something wrong but I have made strenuous efforts to ensure the linking on this site is whiter that white. Oh, I have had no warnings in my messages at all. Thanks in advance for any advice.
Technical SEO | | easyrider20 -
Would moving a large part of our website onto a separate website be SEO suicide?
Hello, Our website currently has what I would call educational and sales pages - which sells our services and also a techy section for the developer community. The developer pages on the website have some of the highest authority pages that we have and equates for about 50% of the content. It has been proposed to move the developer pages onto their own domain - away from the main website. Now, would this crush a lot of the SEO benefit that we have on our main site? Does anyone know of a workable solution that would help retain the SEO. Would linking to our main site from the developer site help? It would be great to hear what people think, Thanks,
Technical SEO | | esendex0 -
Why did our site drop in Google rankings?
My site's URL (web address) is: http://tinyurl.com/3svn2l9 Hi there, We operate a travel site that lists numerous tours, accommodation and activities. Since 6th August 2011 we have dropped from top 10 SERP rankings of our pages to around result number 100 (page 10) and losing massive amount of visitors via Google Search. Our Yahoo and Bing rankings are still in the top10. We need your advice and quick! The last changes we have made are the following: -redirected the non-www version to the www version on the 1st August -bought advertising with a follow link in a sidebar that is being populated across the site (+4000 pages) about 2 months ago -added a blog to the website 2 weeks ago and posted 2 posts to date. Additionally, our website structure allows visitors (and bots) to see the same listings via different URLs which caused duplicate content. This has been the case since the launch of our website about 1 year ago. To prevent this duplicate content we have placed canonical tags on the individual listings pages. Why did our site all of a sudden plummet in the rankings?
Technical SEO | | Robbern0