Are Wildcard Subdomain Hurting my SEO?
-
I have some sites with a lot of categories (category, sub-category, sub-subcategory) and locations (country, state/territory, city). To avoid listing pages really deep in my hierarchy I used wildcard subdomains for the locations, but lately I have been told that might be hurting my overall SEO efforts.
I have a lot of URLs like https://city-state-country.example.com on one side of the domain and example.com/category/subcategory/subsubcategory on the other. In the middle you see stuff like city-state-country.example.com/category/subcategory/subsubcategory and everything in between.
Would I be better off moving the locations to the right side of the domain name? Then you might find stuff like example.com/country/state/city/category/subcategory/subsubcategory and everything in between. I think I could do the new rewrite rules fairly easily since every country slug is just two characters long.
-
@postalmostanything this is a tricky question that seems to be very simple at first. But let's dive a little deeper.
First thing to keep in mind is your budget and your business goals. If you are planning to dominate SERPs for each city or country, and you have the money to spend, the subdomains will give you much stronger local positions.
If this is your case, let's also consider if you want to have domains on country level or on city level: country level subdomains can be targeted in Google Search Console to a particular country, which will give you stronger position in each country.
City level subdomains are worth pursuing if your services/products are triggering the local three-pack. Eg. think of "hairdressers near me", etc. If not, most likely city-level subdomains is a dead end.Now, let's consider another variant of having a single domain with subfolder structure. The clear benefit of this approach is much smaller SEO investments in linkbuilding. And you can still target each folder to a specific country if you register these folders in Google Search Console as a separate property. The downfall -probably less chances to be on the top in some of the most competitive local markets.
There is a third approach as well - do a hybrid model: pick up the top markets that are most critical for your business, and decide on city/country granularity for this group of cities/countries. And then move the rest to one single domain.
Unfortunately, I cannot spell out the full decision-making tree for this subdomain/folder question. It is dependent on your business type and the history of your SEO efforts. But I hope that my clues will help you make the right choice.
Let me know if you have any follow-up questions. -
@postalmostanything
Subfolders are better then Subdomains in your case use a reverse proxy to rewrite your Subdomains to to subfoldersI recommend Fastly or CloudFlare
I hope this helps.
Tom
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Need Some Quality Vs. Quantity SEO Advice
We have a gallery here with our main categories of patches. https://www.stadriemblems.com/gallery/ If you click on one, say Fire Patches, you'll be taken to a page of just fire patches. https://www.stadriemblems.com/fire-patches/ But here's the kicker: If you notice of the fire patch page, there are also sub-categories to that. So if you click on say, Fire Rescue, you get taken one level deeper. https://www.stadriemblems.com/fire-patches/fire-rescue-patches/ I'm redoing this entire site (a project over five years overdue), and I'm wondering if it's really worth it to keep these three-level deep sub pages. I originally created them with long tail SEO in mind, making us be the only ones who come up when people search for very specific patches. But it's a big undertaking to redo all of them, and are they really adding any value?
On-Page Optimization | | UnderRugSwept0 -
What software do you use/work within for SEO?
Hi, Our site was put together in Dreamweaver and I'm not great at using html so I use Contribute to modify the info on our site. There are some limitations using Contribute so I'm wondering what other people use. Thanks for your input!
On-Page Optimization | | karlseidel0 -
SEO NEWBIE!!!
I am trying to get my website (and business) to the top of the search engines..just like everybody else here. 🙂 I have no idea what I am doing and I have to do this myself, because I do not have the extra money to hire somebody to do it for me. So, my question is... Where can I go to figure out how to do this? I don't know some of the "lingo" used. Like it slow crawled my sites and it wants me to fix a few things and I don't know what it is talking about. HELP!!! Becky
On-Page Optimization | | BeLaRouge0 -
SEO- SLIDER
Are sliders bad for SEO. I have a slider that uses HTML elements. The text in the slider is in the source code; however, the words are surround by unreadable code. Give me an example of good SEO friendly sliders for wordpress. Who uses what and why?
On-Page Optimization | | JML11790 -
Would removing high dynamic pages though nofollow help or hurt?
We have a sub-domain that is hosted by a third party. These pages are highly dynamic (change daily or more often) as they are product search results. Unfortunately they are raising several errors and warnings including duplicate page content, title missing or empty, long URLs, overly dynamic URL Would putting nofollows on the links to this sub-domain help, hurt or not affect page rank? As an example: Links in the middle of this page (prices) http://targetvacations.ca go to a page such as this http://travel.targetvacations.ca/cgi-bin/resultadv.cgi?id=16294922&code_ag=tgv&alias=tgv which is then redirected to a dynamic URL and presents the results.
On-Page Optimization | | TSDigital0 -
Best SEO extension or plugin for on-page optimization
I was wondering what you guys might recommend for a browser extension or plugin that would help developers optimize each page for specific keywords. I'm looking for a tool that will give me a grade on how well it's optimized with a recommendation checklist. I would use SEOMoz's onpage analysis tool but it doesn't have access to my private development environment (hence the need for a plugin.) Recommendations? Thanks!
On-Page Optimization | | net32SEO0 -
Can bad text URLs hurt pages?
If you have some pages that contain plain text URLs (not anchored links) that used to be good URLs, but are now bad, either because the website shut down or because it has been acquired by someone else and is now parked (or worse) - are those URLs enough to cause quality problems? For example: This information was brought to you by Waymaker http://www.waymaker.net These aren't the only ones. And yes, I know I should fix them, but there are probably 10,000 pages like it. I will fix them, but its not something I can do in a few minutes. (this one is easy to fix programmatically, but others are a lot more complex) So my question is: do you have actual experience that these are bad enough to cause ranking problems (making them low quality)
On-Page Optimization | | loopyal0 -
Landing Pages for Generating Leads - Must They Be Optimized for SEO?
Question about landing pages: There are landing pages created just for classified advertising. They are stand alone pages. And, are not linked to website (although one can
On-Page Optimization | | BlueBird33
get there via the url) The purpose of these pages is to generate leads. They are keyword rich in title, head and content Content varies, only by 30% Should those pages be optimized like websites? They have a nofollow tag, is that enough? Thank you for taking the time to answer. Peggy0