Hi Robert,
Thanks so much for the thoughtful answer. I can fix the problem with the title tags and the H1 tags. Your insight into the meta description was helpful. But how much variation does there need to be not to get dinged for duplicate content?
Unfortunately I cannot change the main structure of the site. For better or worse I am stuck with it and will have to make it work as best as I can from the SEO standpoint.
Your help and insight is MUCH appreciated!
Shara