Shorter URLs
-
Hi
Is there a real value in having the keywords in the URL structure?
we could use the URL:
Mybrand.com/software/tablets/ipad/supertrader.html
Or instead have the CMS create the shorter version mybrand.com/supertrader.html
and just optimize this page for the keyword 'supertrader ipad software'
-
Thanks for this awesome recommendation!
Do you see any problem in shorting only the software (money making) category, while leaving other categories long?
such as
-
Hi Mozter,
I tend to agree with Cyrus on this issue, and both answers have already provided a great deal of insight.
But.. I'll throw my own two cents in as well, just in case you're still torn. There are Pros and Cons to each approach, as already mentioned. This dilemma most commonly arises when optimizing eCommerce based sites with multiple categories and subcategories, and a lot of times the best approach depends on the industry in question.
A little bit of keyword research is always important and will likely shed a lot of light on how users search for products in a particular niche. Google's Keyword Tool and SEOMoz's Keyword Difficulty Tool are both great resources.
Cyrus already noted several benefits of a shorter URL structure, and I'll expand on that as it relates to commerce driven platforms.
Like over-optimization, keyword cannibalization can be a major issue when optimizing products within the same category. For example, the URL you mentioned will likely have several similar URLs:
Mybrand.com/software/tablets/ipad/supertrader.html
Mybrand.com/software/tablets/ipad/product2.html
Mybrand.com/software/tablets/ipad/product3.html
and so on...
The result of this structure is that you have multiple URLs that are competing to rank for the same keywords (software, tablets, and ipad) and 9 times out of 10, all of the URLs will rank lower in Google, rather than a single URL ranking higher in the results.
If you were a potential customer, what would you search for? "SuperTrader Software for Ipad Tablet" or "SuperTrader for Ipad"? My guess would be the 2nd.
Assuming a more short-tail keyword search i.e. "Ipad Software", again you'll have multiple URLs containing those keywords, and likely a lower ranking for each.
Also remember, the shorter the URL, the more relevance that is placed on each keyword in that URL.
My suggestion is to use a flat structure that contains more descriptive keywords such as:
Mybrand.com/tablet-software/ (Category Page w/subcategories for each OS)
Mybrand.com/ipad-software/ (Category w/ software products for Ipad)
**Mybrand.com/supertrader-ipad/ **(Product - SuperTrader for iPad)
Mybrand.com/android-sofware/ (Category w/ software products for Android)
Mybrand.com/supertrader-android/ (Product - SuperTrader for Android)
This should allow better optimization for long-tail and short-tail keywords and help to avoid multiple URLs competing for the same keywords. It will be much easier to process for the user as well.
Also "Apps" may be a better choice than "Software" but I'm sure the competition is much fiercer.
Finally, on a side note, if you're using Magento as your CMS, I'd suggest removing the ".html" URL suffix from the URLs and Categories and replacing it with a trailing slash by going to System --> Configuration --> Catalog --> Search Engine Optimization. I'd be glad to help you with enabling the shorter URLs and Rel Canonical Meta Tags to best optimize this structure in Magento as well. If you're running another eCommerce Platform, I got nothin' for ya.
Hope this helps and good luck.
Anthony
-
Hi Mozter (nice username
I liked Martin's answer, so let me just add my own 2 cents.
Yes, there are advantages to having keywords in the URL, but there are also drawbacks as well. The keywords can not only be used as a contextual signal for Google - improving your rankings in some cases, but keywords can also help your click-through rate when the URL appears in search results.
Then there's the downside.
- Longer URLs are harder to share socially
- Longer URLs tend to rank slightly worse, for whatever reason
- Keyword stuffing / Over-optimization
Finally, many SEO believe in creating a flat directory structure, meaning most pages of your site should be as close to the root directory as possible. i.e. homepage.com/your-page-here. In my opinion, this is a better solution that having several directories in the same URL like homepage.com/keyword/keyword/keyword.
In cases like this, it's best to default to the user and try to optimize for their experience.
Hope this helps. Best of luck with your SEO!
-
"edit - sorry my iphone bunched my post up!"
Hi
Having the keyword in the URL is helpful in a number of ways;
1.) relevancy to the page
2.) branding
3.) easy of navigation (user experience)
4.) categorisationIt would be far better to include the keyword in the URL for the above reasons but also for future development of ur site.
For example, how would you target the title, page content, alt tags, images, technical info, metadata etc for search engines once you have say 5 different types of tablets? Rather than using ur short URL where all the products are competiting on the same page for rankings it would be much better for each to have a seperate page on ur website.
This will help you not only build targeted, keyword rich, relevant and helpful pages that have seperate rankings but will help to improve your conversion to sale & help lower bounce rates as you customers will land on a page of products they have searched for, as opposed to searching through a page of similar products for what they want.
Hope this helps but I can expand on this if you need!
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Submitted URL has crawl issue - Submitted URL seems to be a Soft 404 - but all looks fine
Google Search Console is showing some pages up as "Submitted URL has crawl issue" but they look fine to me. I have set them as fixed but after a month they were finally re-crawled and google states the issue persists. Examples are: https://www.rscpp.co.uk/counselling/175809/psychology-alcester-lanes-end.html
Technical SEO | | TommyNewmanCEO
https://www.rscpp.co.uk/browse/location-index/889/index-of-therapy-in-hanger-lane.html
https://www.rscpp.co.uk/counselling/274646/psychology-waltham-forest-sexual-problems.html There's also some "Submitted URL seems to be a Soft 404": https://www.rscpp.co.uk/counselling/112585/counselling-moseley-depression.html I also have more which are "pending", but again I couldn't see a problem with them in the first place. I'm at a bit of a loss as to what to do next. Any advice? Thanks in advance.0 -
Redirect URLS with 301 twice
Hello, I had asked my client to ask her web developer to move to a more simplified URL structure. There was a folder called "home" after the root which served no purpose. I asked for the URLs to be redirected using 301 to the new URLs which did not have this structure. However, the web developer didn't agree and decided to just rename the "home" folder "p". I don't know why he did this. We argued the case and he then created the URL structure we wanted. Initially he had 301 redirected the old URLS (the one with "Home") to his new version (the one with the "p"). When we asked for the more simplified URL after arguing, he just redirected all the "p" URLS to the PAGE NOT FOUND. However, remember, all the original URLs are now being redirected to the PAGE NOT FOUND as a result. The problems I see are these unless he redirects again: The new simplified URLS have to start from scratch to rank 2)We have duplicated content - two URLs with the same content Customers clicking products in the SERPs will currently find that they are being redirect to the 404 page. I understand that redirection has to occur but my questions are these: Is it ok to redirect twice with 301 - so old URL to the "p" version then to final simplified version. Will link juice be lost doing this twice? If he redirects from the original URLS to the final version missing out the "p" version, what should happen to the "p" version - they are currently indexed. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks
Technical SEO | | AL123al0 -
Preserving Social Shares Through URL Changes
We are making significant URL changes to our website. Because the URL is changing the social sharing buttons are not showing previous shared counts. I have read several resources like the one below that is linked to in several other similar questions. http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2172926/How-to-Maintain-Social-Shares-After-a-Site-Migration However I would love to get some insight from someone who has done this and there thoughts on the outcome. As an ecommerce site the "Social Proof" of products that have received social shares is a big deal to us. In Mike Kings example above the counts are being attributed to the OLD URL which is problematic over time. Our site has been up for over 12 years and has had several major changes to it, and I am certain there will be more in the future, being able to preserve the count on the current URL is ideal. While I agree with him that over time I believe social platforms will let data pass through 301 redirects, until then I need to find the best way to do this. Also with his example and others I have seen people mention than new likes from the new url can reset the counter. If you have gone through this and have ideas pleas share them. I look forward to your thoughts thanks.
Technical SEO | | RMATVMC1 -
Why are my URL's changing
My rankings suddenly dropped and when trying to understand why I realized that nearly all images in Google's cached version of my site were missing. In the actual site they appear but in the cached version they don't. I noticed that most of the images had a ?6b5830 at the end of the URL and these were the images that were not showing. I am hoping that I found the reason for the drop in rankings. Maybe since Google cannot see a lot of the content it decided not to rank it as well (particularly since it seems to happen on thousands of pages). This is a cached version of my site I am using the following plugins that might be causing it: Yoasts SEO plugin, W3 total cache. Does anyone know what is causing ?6b5830 to be added to the end of most of my URL's? Could this be the reason for the ranking drop? Thanks in advance!
Technical SEO | | JillB20130 -
Would you shorten this url, and if so how?
I designed the structure of my website way before I even thought about SEO. I run a website that requires me to categorize articles is somewhat deep nested categories so an example url would be as follows http://www.yakangler.com/articles/news/new-products/boats/item/1442-jackson-kayak-launches-the-big-tuna Would you shorten the url to somethign like this? http://www.yakangler.com/a/n/np/b/item/1442-jackson-kayak-launches-the-big-tuna If so how would you manage the redirects I'm unsure how to add a 301 redirect in my .htaccess file that wouldn't require me to add one for every single article. Could I do it with a rule that recognizes only the middle part of the url and redirect it accordingly? Thanks for any advice you might have!
Technical SEO | | mr_w0 -
Optimal Structure for Forum Thread URL
For getting forum threads ranked, which is best and why? site.com**/topic/**thread-title-goes-here site.com**/t/**thread-title-goes-here site.com**/**thread-title-goes-here I'd take comfort in knowing that SEOmoz uses the middle version, except that "q" is more meaningful to a human than "t". The last option seems like the best bet overall, except that users could potentially steal urls that I may want to use in the future. My old structure was site.com/forum/topic/TOPIC_ID-thread-title-goes-here so obviously any of those would be a vast improvement, but I might as well make the best choice now so I only have to change once.
Technical SEO | | PatrickGriffith0 -
Special characters in URL
Hello everybody, my question focus on special parameters in URL. I i am working for a website that use a lot of special entities in their URLS. For instance: www.mydomain.com/mykeyword1-mykeyword2%2C-1%2Cpage1.html I am about to make 301 redirect rules for all these urls to clean ones. IE: www.mydomain.com/mykeyword1-mykeyword2%2C-1%2Cpage1
Technical SEO | | objectif-mars
would become:
www.mydomain.com/mykeyword1-mykeyword.html I just wanted to know if anybody has already done this kind of "cleanup" and if i could expect a positive boost or not. Thanks0