Wordpress & On-Page Optimization
-
Seomoz,
Our current SEO provider built a squeeze page using Wordpress.
http://www.buddyrents.com/rent-to-own-furniture/spring-hill-34608/
The page has minimal links and the one drop-down menu links to other pages that look exactly the same with the exception of the page name and Google map.
Since the pages were built a 2 years ago there have been zero copy changes or code changes until a few weeks ago, yet the provider maintains that there is a maintenance charge to make sure the pages function correctly and are easily read by Google.
This sounds like a made up charge. Wordpress pages like these should be pretty stable and search friendly. Am I missing something?
Is this common to charge for SEO, On-page SEO and Maintenance for pages that have not changed and only rank if you actually enter the long-tail keywords that match the page title? They also don't create a lot of traffic, but the provider says they are essential to our online footprint. The pages have a PA of 1 and
the below on-page links (the exact same links for all 120 pages)
| Internal Followed Links | 23 |
| Internal Nofollow Links | 0 |
| External Followed Links | 3 |
| External Nofollow Links | 0 |Thank you in advance for your insight!
-
Daniel,
Sorry, C3 Media is the agency/ marketing department for Buddyrents.com. This is the site I am discussing.
Thanks.
-
Agreed. Sales is the ultimate measure. We are not able to complete sales agreements online, consequently lead generation is our key metric.
I have brought up the concerns with the provider. They responded that the branded traffic is part of their SEO results because some users seeing their links don't click, but then search the name. I don't buy it. Then when I asked them for a report of the monthly SEO/SEM. They responded with a link building report. I insisted that the report did not warrant the monthly spend and they replied...
"We are constantly changing our strategy depending on the competition and it would be like giving our secrets away. We use the spend as we feel necessary to generate leads. If you are happy with the leads then that should be the focus, not reports."
I think it is in our best interest to work with a partner who is willing to share information, so I want to move on. However, I want to make sure we have a plan and valid reasons before taking that next step.
Thank you and have a great day!
-
What about sales? isn't that the true measure of effectiveness? And the only one that counts in the end?
It's very easy to get caught up in semi-relevant (or downright phony) metrics. What difference does it make if you rank well on insignificant keywords? Or even if your traffic is up, but it's lousy traffic that doesn't generate sales.
A common "trick" used by SEOs of less than outstanding virtue is to optimize for not very competitive keywords. This is quite easily done and presents the illusion of progress. It can also generate really nifty reports with impressive charts and graphs. But to what end?
The fact that most of your traffic is coming from branded keywords is another alarm bell. It means that most of the people accessing your website are already familiar with your brand. But I'm betting that the whole of your web strategy is to reach new prospects.
If your competitors are getting almost all the non-branded traffic and you have other issues with your current firm, it may be time to move on. As mentioned before, you might want to give them one last chance. Talk about your billing issues and concerns with non-branded keywords.
I suspect what you really need is a deep data dive into the whole competitive web landscape. The findings should drive the strategy going forward.
Is your site by any chance www.c3medianetwork.com? if so, I must tell you there are serious issues on everything form on-page stuff to the diversity of your link profile.
-
You make some good points. So, let me ask you what is the best measure of SEO effectiveness?
If I look at overal traffic for our site, we are up 52% form last year, but compared to our two main competitors our traffic is minimal...competitors have close to 8x more traffic per month. Then in analytics the majority of our top performing keywords are branded. The provider sends ranking reports for 1st page SERP keywords, but the traffic we capture from those keywords isn't that great.
My understanding is that the traffic from non-branded keywords is a better gauge of SEO performance. We have never used PPC.
Thanks again for taking the time.
-
If the trust is gone, it may be time to move on.
Make sure you have a plan in place for a transition.
After all, however dissatisfied you are now, something is better than nothing.
But why not give it one last shot? Tell the company you are thinking of moving on, and see how they react. if you are otherwise satisfied with the company's performance, and it's just a matter of billing practices, the relationship might yet be salvaged. It could be as simple as moving to a monthly blanket charge, rather than itemized charges for different services.
Again, I don't know what your contract says, so I'm just taking some guesses here.
-
Hi Daniel,
My gut has made me raise my eyebrows a lot lately. I am finding that much of my day is spent trying to figure out if the charges are valid. Unfortunately, it is difficult for me to question SEO practices, when I am not an expert. We have seen "good" results with the main website, but I feel we are paying for "accessories" that aren't really necessary.
The trust is gone and I feel it is time to move on, but don't want to shoot ourselves in the foot.
Thoughts?
-
My objective is to find out what charges are bogus vs. real. We have had several instances as of late that has really made me question their practices. Including, when I have asked for a report of the the monthly SEO/SEM. They responded with a link building report. I insisted that the report did not warrant the monthly spend and they replied "We are constantly changing our strategy depending on the competition and it would be like giving our secrets away. We use to spend to as we feel necessary to get results." I know for a fact that is not a good answer.
If the choice is to find a new provider without losing the work that has already been done. What is the best process? Per the partnership agreement, we have full ownership of all online assets created for the company.
Thank you.
-
I am an SEO provider and this is probably another case of taking the money and doing nothing much for it. What are the objectives here?
-
It's really difficult to comment intelligently in the absence of more information about the overall relationship with you SEO Provider or what is spelled out in the contract.
But my gut tells me you are right to raise your eyebrows....
(to mix metaphors and body parts)
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Page links, header links, footer links
HI I have been hearing about links, you should keep to 100 Just look at this url http://www.powerwale.com/store/acdelco-sealed-vrla-iacdv5l--b-5ah-bike-battery/77031 and go for Recommend section, where you same product applies to different vehicles 1. im confused, should keep it or not?
Link Building | | Rahim119
2. Header links are less, Footer links are less, and in the future, we are planning to add more, will this affect SEO more than 100
i see many ecommerce sites, has menu showing many categories, more 100 categories links
3. Wht about link equity? If I have more links in header and footer page(all this will follow in the rest of pages).
4. More links in the header and footer shows that you are big ecommerce site.. Pls suggest, which is right way and go gain SEO value1 -
Best way to regular check backlinks & identify low quality and spammy links?
Previously my site was under manual penalty and then 80% of the links i removed and my penalty lifted. ( I am talking about 1 year before) Now i have few queries - What is the best way to regular check backlinks? what to do if a spammy link appears What to do about directories that link to us What to do with old links that are not good quality Now I have to check number of links and quality of links of website so which is the best method check? Thanks! dev
Link Building | | devdan0 -
Disavow & nofollow from same IP
I'm a web developer, and as such, we run a bank of half a dozen dedicated servers. I have 2 questions with regards to nofollow links There's half a dozen sites linking back to us from the same bank of servers (across 3 different IP's but all in the same facility) because we have donated our web design services and we're a sponsor. It's not a paid link, it's a sponsorship. Should I still nofollow the link? I run a couple of personal blogs on the same bank of servers. There's an absolute tonne of original content and a handful of links back to my shop. Because I own both sites, should I nofollow these links as well? I am doing a massive cleanup before the Penguin pops his head out again.
Link Building | | sparrowdog0 -
Getting a link from a blog on every page querying what OSE is suggesting
Hi Guys My client has been offered a link from someone within their industry on their blog. The blog has 20 categories and multiple (hundreds if not more pages within each category). The owner of the website has said that would be happy to give my client a link on each of their pages (including their homepage). They have done this for another couple of people who they like before, so I typed these domains into OSE and noticed that for each page it shows a link and also the page authority. Domain Authority of this blog giving the link is 71 Home Page PA - 76 About us PA - 60 it goes on.........the least PA being shown is 52 so lets for arguements sake say the other 18 or say categories are PA of 52 too. My question is surely the OSE is not accurate to imply that my client could be passed page authority from 18 categories at 52 each + home page of 76 + about me page of 60? Hopefully you understand the point I'm trying to make
Link Building | | RankStealer0 -
Fresh set of eyes on this page please. Why isn't it ranking?
Morning all, I'd really appreciate it if you could take a quick look at this page and see if I'm missing something here. The targeted keyword (wedding favours) is pretty competitive and the rank had been slowly improving until recently and we've now slipped to 25th on Google UK. I've added a "Pay with a tweet" button for our eBook which has been pretty well received (around 100 downloads) so far so the social side is better than our competition. I've also written a few guest blogs with links back to the page from a variety of sources. Here is the page analysis on OSE. If you could take a quick look and let me know if I'm missing anything here, it would be most appreciated! Thanks in advance.
Link Building | | Confetti_Wedding0 -
Tagged pages showing too many links
I'm confused - seo moz crawl shows I have lots of pages with too many links. 150 - 200 or so. I'm not sure how any of my pages can have that many links and they don't appear to to me. Here's an example: http://www.musicliveuk.com/tag/wedding-entertainment They all appear to be 'tag' pages. These pages are blocked by meta robots anyway so is this a problem and how do I fix it? I also am very confused by rel canonical. I have 300 odd pages with this warning. Is this good or bad? Plesae help!
Link Building | | SamCUK0 -
PPC Landing pages and SEO landing pages query
We do a fair amount of work on PPC and because of this a lot of our PPC landing pages also do quite well in SEO. We are thinking that the landing pages do well because they get a lot of traffic from PPC and therefore, maybe google can index and take note of these pages quicker? The pages that usually shoot right up the rankings are new pages used for long tailed keywords. So I have a few questions: Does the traffic from PPC actually have any effect on SEO rankings? If we were to create a page that was to act solely as an SEO landing page, would google take note if there was no traffic? Would simply linking from our main site to the landing page be enough to give it a bit of authority, in which we can build upon? Thanks in advance.
Link Building | | esendex0 -
How can influence a directory backling page on your website ?
Hi, Some good directories asked a backlink for having ours listed in their categories. But of course, I am not fan of putting their link on the home page, but creating a page exclusively for these backlinks is a bad thing to mister google ? thanks in advance !
Link Building | | thuraminho750