Big problem with my new crawl report
-
I am owner of small opencart online store. I installed http://www.opencart.com/index.php?route=extension/extension/info&extension_id=6182&filter_search=seo. Today my new crawl report is awful. The number of errors is up by 520 (30 before), up with 1000 (120 before), notices up with 8000 (1000 before). I noticed that the problem is with search. There is a lot duplicate content in search only. What to do ?
-
Thank you again Alan.
Typo fixed.
-
I use Bing search API,
By the way, you want to change from GET to POST, not the other way around.
-
Alan,
Thank you for the great advice. If one has enough control over the eCommerce system, or the internal site search product, to change from GET to POST so these pages act more like real dynamically generated "search pages" than an infinite amount of "landing pages" I think that is a fantastic solution. It would keep merchandisers and others from linking to those pages - because we all know that they will continue to do it even if the SEO pleads on hands and knees for them to stop.
However, I have found it to be the case that most eCommerce businesses (from small mom-n-pop shops to fortune 500 companies) do not have the ability to do this because the internal site search functionality they use is out of their hands. Site search vendors like Endeca and Celebros serving enterprise eCommerce businesses don't typically hand over the keys to the client.
If you know any site search vendors or solutions that allow one to do this it would make a great contribution to this thread if you could share a few of them. I'd definitely look into recommending them in the future!
Thanks again!
-
The problem with PR leaks is that they are scalable, If you are losing 10%, then you get some quality links, 10% of them will be wasted, every effort you do in the future will be discounted by 10%.
There are ways to fix all these problems, for example I would make a search to be POST and not GET so that links to search pages can not be made and therefor search pages will not get indexed.
We work so hard to get good links, why waste them when you do?
-
I have tried different methods to fix this. First-hand experience tells me that oftentimes it is better to just block the paths (assuming there is better navigation on the site) from being crawled or indexed using robots.txt than to use a noindex,follow tag in order to save the pagerank you're sending via internal links. It is very easy for Google to get bogged down crawling around in the internal search results area.
Unless there are lots of links to search pages from top pages on the site, or a big list of search page links from every page (sitewide footer, for example) I really don't think the waste of internal pagerank is noticeable in the rankings, or worth salvaging if it risks sending spiders into a maze or a trap.
Yes, best practice is not to link to pages that you are blocking. In the real world though, search pages can be very useful to visitors, and to merchandisers who don't have the ability to create more targeted sub-sub-sub categories will often use them, and link to them on the site, as landing pages for promotional purposes (emails, PPC, sales...).
Everyone has their own strategies, and all we can do is make recommendations based on our own experience and knowledge. Thanks for helping out with this question Alan. Feel free to elaborate so Anastas has more input to help guide his decision.
-
as long as no one is linking to the search pages including internal links.
-
Hello Anastas,
I agree that you should block the search folder from being indexed. I'm going to assume that nobody is linking to your search pages and that you have other paths (e.g. SEO-friendly navigation, sitemaps...) for search engines to use to access your products).
I don't understand why you have formatted the disallow statement that way, however. Unless I'm missing something (and could be since I don't know what your site is) you only need to do this:
Disallow: /product/search*
And of course after doing this you should test it in GWT to make sure that A: You are blocking the pages you want to block, such as search pages with lots of parameters, and B: You are NOT blocking other pages you don't want to block, such as product pages. Here is more info on where to find the testing tool in GWT if you don't know: http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/webmasters/tbikAxJiIZ4
Let us know how it goes. Good luck.
-
Please I need help
-
I am using opencart. I dont know what to do. Before I had 50 errors, now they are more than 500 after this plug in. The plug in removed the previous errors, but now there are many different errors. I have 2 options:
1. Remove the plug in
2. Do something with new errors - the new errors are only because of search, I have dublicate page content because when you type PDODUCT NAME in search box, there is same content as www.mydomain.com/category1/PRODUCT NAME
Maybe this plug in removed the canonical urls in search or I dont know what.
In robots.txt there is row:
Disallow: /*?route=product/search
The duplicate content is mydomain.com/product/search&filter_tag=XXXXXX
Instead of XXXXX there are many paths.
I decided to add another row in robots.txt:
Disallow: /*?route=product/search&filter_tag=/
Do you thing it is correct or to remove the plug in?
I hope you understand what is the problem.
-
When you no index a page, any links pointing to those pages pour away link juice from you indexed pages. you should never no-index pages IMO
I assume you are using a CMS or some sort of plug in, this is a common cost when you do so. CMS create very untidy code, not good for SEO
-
The urls are: /product/search&filter_tag=%D0%B1%D0%B8%D0%B6%D1%83%D1%82%D0%B0
after = there are a lot of combinations. Is it correct to put this in robots.txt
Disallow: /*?route=product/search&filter_tag=/
-
Sholud I disallow search (in robots.txt)?
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Create 100% new content in existing page/URL?
We have about 30 pages of content that we are hiding from the website as these articles had some issues. If these pages ranked well, would you recommend that the new content is written within these pages? Meaning, we would replace the content that's in those pages with the same topic and keywords. Or do you think it's best to start a new page instead?
On-Page Optimization | | kvillalobos0 -
We recently updated a large guide that takes the place of the original. The original has some nice organic traffic to it and I don't want to risk losing it. Should I 301 redirect to the new version, or update all the info directly on the original page?
We don't have a lot of content that garners much non-branded organic, so this is something I don't want to risk losing. We do not have a whole lot of external links into the page either.
On-Page Optimization | | AFP_Digital1 -
What Next after Weekly Crawl Errors Fixed?
Hi MoZ Community! Moz weekly crawl used to report following errors : I have fixed them all over the time. Can somebody give an idea what to do next with the help of Moz or away from Moz to improve my optimization practices. I believe this is just start of the SEO. Or how is it if I focus link building efforts and start fighting for keywords. Also any suggestions about the web? Tanveer | Duplicate Page Content 4XX (Client Error) Title Missing or Empty 5XX (Server Error) Missing Meta Description Tag Duplicate Page Title Title Element Too Long (> 70 Characters) Title Element Too Short Meta Refresh Temporary Redirect |
On-Page Optimization | | Sequelmed0 -
Why Isnt My New Article Indexed?
I posted this article last night: http://www.londontri.com/325/tomtom-runner-gps-watch-review It didn't appear in Google's index this morning despite me pointing a few high quality links to it (not keyword optimized links, just links from high quality forum posts) On closer examination I thought that the problem could be due to a keyword stuffing penalty so I have made sure that I am not repeating too many words/word combinations using a keyword density checker but the article is still not indexed. Any ideas what could be going on?
On-Page Optimization | | ross88guy0 -
Why so many crawl errors?
Our site is showing it has a ton of crawl errors in the back end, mostly concerning duplicate content within our blog. The content is unique however. We know this for certain because it's done in house or put together by some of the freelance writers we work with. The site is for an RV dealership and we're using a template-based system from a well known company. Any ideas on what may be causing this?
On-Page Optimization | | BlakeArbogast0 -
On-Page Report Card is lacking
To SEOMOZ Developers: All my pages score A's in the On-Page Report Card, yet most are not indexed in the top 50 positions for Google!!! Don't you think there are other factors you're not considering when giving out A's? In other words, a page should not be awarded an A when it's not in top 50 ranking positions. That's seems to be a flaw in the Optimization Reports. There must be something my page is missing, but you are not pointing it out. Shouldn't your "A" requirements be more aligned with Google's ranking algorithms? In other words, most pages awarded A's should be found to be ranked in the top 50. And, most pages not ranked in the top 50 should recieve F's because they don't meet Google's ranking requirements. In other words, you should model your report card more closely to Google's ranking. Here's an example: Keyword: "enterprise time management" Page: www.stdtime.com/enterprise-time-management.htm
On-Page Optimization | | raywhite0 -
Are missing Meta Tags a big deal on a blog?
I show 272 missing Meta Description Tags after the crawl completed on my website. Pretty much all of those are from my website hosted wordpress blog. Should I be concerned about this?
On-Page Optimization | | webestate0 -
Crawl Diagnostics - Duplicate Content and Duplicate Page Title Errors
I am getting a lot of duplicate content and duplicate page title errors from my crawl analysis. I using volusion and it looks like the photo gallery is causing the duplicate content errors. both are sitting at 231, this shows I have done something wrong... Example URL: Duplicate Page Content http://www.racquetsource.com/PhotoGallery.asp?ProductCode=001.KA601 Duplicate Page Title http://www.racquetsource.com/PhotoGallery.asp?ProductCode=001.KA601 Would anyone know how to properly disallow this? Would this be as simple as a robots.txt entry or something a little more involved within volusion? Any help is appreicated. Cheers Geoff B. (a.k.a) newbie.
On-Page Optimization | | GeoffBatterham0