Why Did Our Site Disappear for 6 Months?
-
Hello! The company that I work for recently hired a company to do their SEO. After they took over we fell out of the search engines for our keywords for 6 months! (I had previously done the SEO using Moz, but had to step down due to my husband getting cancer. He's all better and I'm back.
)
We contacted the SEO company recently to find out why the only way we could be found in the search engines was if we searched on our name. The reason they gave was Penguin, Panda, and Hummingbird. I personally don't believe that would cause our site to disappear for 6 months then miraculously reappear for our keywords a few days after us complaining.
One of my main concerns is they have submitted us to 140 directories and 20 social bookmarking sites. How do I tell if these are good or bad sites? A few of them I've clicked are suspended and one Google warns about malicious content and to leave immediately - so those are obvious.
Thanks for your help!
Kelley Insana
-
If a client is employing me to remove poorest backlinks identified at audit stage, I usually make 3/4 approaches to webmasters first, and see how that goes - and usually manage to take down the majority of spammy backlinks that way.
-
Thanks Peter
I've reached out to 100 webmasters and had 2 reply…… so I'll try the disavow option.
Thanks for the link.
-
Hi David
First step would be to remove the link herself from those sites if she could get access. If that didn't work then at least try to contact the sites and ask them to remove the links
But if she is unsuccessful with those routes she would be to go through Google Webmaster Tools and start a process of disavowing those links one by one. This video by Google's Matt Cutts may help explain: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=393nmCYFRtA
Peter
-
I think it is true that many web developers think that because they build websites they also need to do SEO. But they are different disciplines and unless they have people with both disciplines in-house they may not be any good at SEO.
Yes, they need an understanding, but sometimes a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Without checking out what the web development company has to say about SEO - and I don't suggest you post their name here - it's difficult to say, but what you have described does make it sound that something with the SEO was not good!
Peter
-
Hi All
If Kelly did want to remove a link from a directory - how would she do this?
Assuming she doesn't have passwords to the site and the spammy webmaster won't reply to any removal request?
-
Is there a way to find out if a company is a legitimate SEO company? They also did the web design for our site and did a fantastic job on that end of things. It's the SEO that's questionable.
-
Hi Kelley
I agree with your view of rightwingeye.com. It's just farming links.
If you have lots of incoming links to your site from sites like this one then yes, it is a risk. They will be serving very little link equity individually, but collectively they will deliver more, However, having links from sites like these is not worth having compared to the fall out if your site is seen as harvesting links from a lot of low quality sites.
Peter
-
Hi Kelley
This response would alarm me "The reason they gave was Penguin, Panda, and Hummingbird". If they are siting this as a reason that means they were 99.89% likely doing something wrong to begin with.
Having crappy directory links isn't necessarily bad unless they make up the majority of links you have. Although you should never spend time trying to get listed in crappy directories, its a waste of time. Just look at the link and say would I "ever" visit this site for anything ever? If the answer is no, you likely have no reason to be listed there.
Peter pointed out one possible reason, another could be canonical tags point or looping on themselves. In general it sounds like the company used was horrible, and it is a boon that you're back.
Hope all is well with your husband, and welcome back.
Don
-
The recovery days after you complaining is probably a coincidence. They would have to get really lucky that your site just happened to get indexed right after they fixed something.
What dates did you see your traffic decrease? From when to when? That's the best way to figure out what kind of penalty you may have received. If it doesn't match up on dates, then we can help you diagnose what happened from the work logs that the SEO might provide.
Cody
-
Thanks Peter,
I will see if we can get the robot.txt file and see if that has anything to do with what happened.
As far as the directories go, so far none of the ones I've checked have any content. They are just straight directories with links such as this one http://www.rightwingeye.com/ In my opinion linking to directories like that are not good, but I could be wrong. I will check them with Open Site Explorer. If I discover bad ones do I need to remove our website from them? Or doesn't it matter?
-
Hi Kelley,
Welcome back to Moz and glad to hear your husband is better.
It sounds that the SEO company are spinning a yarn or two! Penguin and Panda are reasons for losing ground, but Hummingbird - at this stage! No, I don't believe that.
It's difficult to explain why your site has disappeared for so long and then to come back so quickly. Could it be that for some reason the SEO company put a robots.txt on the site that disallowed any indexing of the site other than the home page? I have seen that happen once before where the result was only a home page was indexed. It might be worth checking the date/timestamp of the robots.txt on the server to see when it was last updated.
How do you tell if the 140 + 20 sites are good or bad? Only really by going through each one checking their content and also perhaps checking them in Open Site Explorer. Target the ones you have identified already first and then begin to go through the others.
I hope that helps. All the best to you.
Peter
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Has anyone noticed an Adwords algorithm change early this month?
I was digging into one of my accounts and noticed that previous well-performing ads were not being shown this month. My settings are set to Optimize for conversions: Show ads expected to provide more conversions but whichever way I look at the data, ads that were doing well previously are now only being shown about 0.1% of the time. Has anyone experienced this before or know of a possible Adwords algorithm change?
Industry News | | Snaptech_Marketing0 -
What shall I call my site?
With all the google changes and social media focus on seo, I am in a bit of a dilemma and any opinions welcome. My husband has a very small horseback riding company based in a tiny mountain town of Costa Rica and I cannot decide whether to call it by the company name or by a more generic name that is likely to be picked up by the search engines ( I do believe the importance of domain name is less than it used to be in terms of search with all the new google changes). The two names are www.horsetrekmonteverde.com (bear in mind that his customers come from the States and horse trekking is not commonly used) and www.horseridingcostarica.com One mentions Costa Rica, the other not as you can see. Also not many people have beard about Monteverde. However I am trying to do some strong branding! What would you do?
Industry News | | Llanero0 -
Best ranking Magento sites?
What would be your top 10 Magento sites in terms of SEO and ranking? I'm looking for examples of Magneto sites that have been set up correctly and are ranking well. Especially recently launched sites that have managed to get themselves ranking well in competitive markets! Cheers
Industry News | | OnlineAssetPartners0 -
Sitelinks Disappeard For My Site
Hi Guys I noticed that all the sitelinks for my site has disappeared. Could it be because of recent changes that I made to the site or maybe because I submitted a new sitemap for my site? Should I ask the googlebot to fetch my site now again after I submitted my sitemap and also ask to re-index it? I also read somewhere else that Google could be re-indexing my site and thus still needs to determine what my sitelinks is going to be. If somebody could please give me some advice on this I would appreciate it. Thanks Dave
Industry News | | DavidZA10 -
"Links To Your Site" In Webmaster Tools
How often does Google update the "links to your site" data. It seems that it has been static for about a month now even though we have made a lot of changes Does anyone have any idea? If you have made changes to your links (i.e removed links, updated anchor text, etc.), do you have to wait for this information to be updated to measure the impact? Or is that whenever Google crawls those pages/sites and sees changes there is a adjustment. Thanks
Industry News | | inhouseseo0 -
Alexa Site Audit
Hello All, I run an Alexa Site Audit report for my client. Is it normal that my Alexa site audit report will be public i.e. S3 URL for downloading the PDF file was open to anyone knowing the URL. No re-direct to login etc was there? Yes the S3 URL is funny but Google bots have ways to find this funny URLs so is this normal? If you have tried Alexa can you repeat the problem i.e. typing your S3 report URL? can you get it to? or is it just me. I have asked Alexa about it. I think there should be some security. Thanks.
Industry News | | SEO_Z0 -
How do you value a site that generates no income before it's sold?
Hi, I'm currently creating a number of sites which target the wedding market. Each site is localized and specific to a niche within the wedding market. The intention is to create the site, rank it in the top position of Google and then sell it to a local business within that niche and area. The problem that i am having is that I don't know how to place a value on each site. I have factors taken from Google (using Market Samurai) so I know the broad and phrase match traffic details as well as the Google PPC average prices. My initial thought was to use the Google PPC price and multiply that by the number of organic visitors the site would receive if it was ranked #1 on Google. I appreciate that the PPC figures may be higher than what an advertiser would actually pay per click so I conservatively halved the Google PPC figure given in Market Samurai. Is this a good way of valuing the site or do I need to look at the value per customer to the business that I am trying to sell the site to and work from a conversion factor based on the number of visitors that the site would receive. If the site received 500 visitors per month and 5% of those became customers multiplied by the average profit per customer - that would give a monthly value of the website. I am very unsure as to what the best approach is here and look forward to hearing any advice and ideas from fellow members. Thanks, Michael
Industry News | | XSMedia0