Is Search Visibility giving a fair comparison with your competition?
-
I dived into the Search Visibility metric and what it actually says. In short, I believe it to be an aggregated score for all keywords targeted.
However, our list of targeted keywords also include specific 'branded' keywords (and e.g. names of company leaders), which (presumably) aren't targeted by our competition. So what does the comparison with our competitors (i.e. Search Visbility x Competition graph) actually tell us? Isn't it giving a skewed impression?
(Or are keywords labeled as 'branded' not taken into consideration in the Search Visibility metric?)
-
It is important to keep in mind that the Search Visibility metric relates only to the keywords you are tracking, so it isn't exactly correct to say that the Search Visibility score is skewed if you are tracking branded keywords. This is an accurate visibility score for the keywords you are tracking.
You can definitely see the Search Visibility for all of your non-branded keywords by using the filters as you suggested, which will give you a different perspective of your Search Visibility versus your competitors.
However, you could say that, in and of itself, the score is somewhat skewed just by the fact that these are the keywords you have chosen to target, rather than the total Search Visibility for all of the keywords you and your competitors may be ranking for. If your competitors aren't specifically targeting the same keywords you are tracking, you may be ranking better for those keywords, but you may not necessarily be as competitive in the overall rankings for every keyword. Our metrics can only be calculated for the terms you choose to track, so it is really just a view of the keywords you are targeting and not necessarily the full picture of your visibility as a site overall.
-
Unless you truly think Kanye West-posts are the way to go to improve your business. If you believe that – no offense – your better score (in your SEO strategy) is better than mine.
But I get your point. The selection of keywords is only relevant to compare similar SEO strategies!
Thanks!
-
Vsibilty score is not good for comparing domains at all.
It's more of a metric that you can use to track a progress of a single website. Your visibility will start growing if you start ranking higher for more keywords, which means you're doing good.
As for comparison – it doesn't work because of difference in user intent for each query.
For example we both sell car parts, but I write a buzzfeed-style article about celebrities an their cars and start ranking for a very popular queries like "kanye west car", my visibility will skyrocket, but that doesn't improve my business or means that my SEO is better than yours. -
"I guess it would be logical to filter only Non-Branded keywords, right?"
That is a good idea. I keep mine in a separate campaign at semrush.
-
Hi EGOL,
For sure! I also think one should monitor the branded keywords. Precisely for that reason.
However, generally the total score of my keywords (including 6 branded out of 58 keywords) will skew the graph in the competition overview in my favor... (As I figure I'd normally perform better on 10% of the total set of keywords).
So in this competition overview I guess it would be logical to filter only Non-Branded keywords, right?
(And of course our imagination and decisions make the selection of keywords limited , but I figure that doesn't represent skewed data: because those are the keywords we truly and consciously aim for... not?)
-
Hi Igor,
Thanks! Makes total sense how the score is calculated!
Are you also suggesting that, in order to make competitive Search Visibility scores more comparable, it might be useful to either exclude your own branded keywords (easy through filtering) and/or include their branded keywords (kinda awkward)?
(Of my 58 tracked keywords, 6 are my own branded keywords).
-
I really like visibility metrics because they are a single number that summarizes my competitive standing for a large number of keywords.
Are visibility metrics skewed? Absolutely. They are skewed because we select the keywords - the boundaries of comparison.
If we pick a large number of keywords that are representative of the industry area in which we compete, then that might not be extremely skewed. However, since we define the basket of keywords ourselves, then we skew the metric in proportion to the keywords that we include that are specialties of our business.
I think that you should monitor the branded keywords of your business. Knowing what's happening there can tip you off to health problems of your own website or people who might be infringing upon your intellectual property.
-
Any organic visibility is always skewed. It's an estimate value that's based on data collected previously but it's still valid for comparison.
If you visibility is lower than that of your competitor it means that they rank higher for more keywords with higher search volumes, well sort of. They can rank first for a single keyword with 100,000 monthly searches and if you rank first for a 1,000 keywords with 10 monthly searches, their visibility is still higher.
All queries, including the branded ones are counted, they may not target your branded queries but they can compensate it with higher positions for more popular keywords and their own branded queries.Here's me trying to explain how it works:
You both rank for 2 keywords each, one common and one branded for each of you.
Common keyword - 10,000 searches
Your branded query - 3,000 searches.
Their branded query - 1,000 searches.You rank first for your branded query so 100% of people see it and like 90% are likely to click on it. You get 2.8 Visibility points from a keyword with 3,000 search volume.
They rank first for their query and with the same conditions get 0.9 points because their query gets only 1000 searches.
So far you're in the lead 2.8 vs 0.9 visibility points
Now if they rank first for the common query, everyone will see their website an like 70% will visit. They'll get like 7.5 points.
You rank 8th. A lot of people will see your website but only around 5% will visit it, so you get 1.8 points.Their total 8.4
Your total 4.6Now spread this across thousands of queries and you'll know how it works.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How long does it take, So i can see results of Kewords Ranking search on moz?
Hi, I m the new guy at the Neighborhood Can you help please with the question... how long does it take, So i can see results of Kewords Ranking search on moz? This is the popup note Message: Moz collects and updates campaign data weekly. Not collected means we have not yet updated data for this keyword. TNX
Getting Started | | YarivHPAZ1 -
Odd search page behaviour (missing description)
Hey folks, in our page crawl errors we are getting 1000's (literally) of missing description errors on our search page - see attached image for what I mean. I have no idea how these are being generated as crawled links? Any help would be appreciated as it would really clean up our errors! qAzah
Getting Started | | creative.digital0 -
Error Selecting Search Engine During Moz Campaign Set-Up
Hi, I'm setting up a Moz campaign for a new client, and when I get to the third step, "Choose the search engines for which you would like to track rankings," there's nothing to select. No drop down, or anything, just a blank field under the heading. If I try to advance, I get an error pop-up that says I must select a search engine. Has anyone else run into this problem? What should I do? GlWPAsc zAmzqFf
Getting Started | | tommyKPseo0 -
Long tail searches
I maintain a site that provides access to bankruptcy records. I want to try an optimize the site for searches involving the case name and generic terms like "bankruptcy filing". So, the keyword would be "(case name) bankruptcy filing". How do I use Moz to help when the number of case names is high (100,000+)? Any other suggestions for what to do when working on long tail matches?
Getting Started | | troller0 -
How does campaign manager pick up search terms
Does anyone know how Moz campaign setup. I have set up a campaign and Moz has identified a number of spammy keywords which we cannot find on the site. Please see the image. The site is datingreview.com Thanks Ed Gzy0UkO.jpg
Getting Started | | EdBen0 -
So the page-grader is giving my site an A, but it is ranking below some websites that the grader gives an F to. What is the point of the page grader?
Basically, I am new to this..very new. In fact, my field was neuroscience, and now I work in marketing.. I just started using seomoz, and for one website that I build. I followed all of the guidelines moz has to offer. On the grade section, I got an for a specific keyword. However, when I rate my site for that keyword, it does not even rank in the top 50. The keyword is even in the domain! Also, some sites that rank in the top 25 have an F rating for the same keyword. Why do they rank higher?
Getting Started | | Meier0 -
How do I differentiate traffic that is from google adwords vs organic searches?
Right now it appears to be showing both in the same category. I want to be able to see whats an organic click vs one from google adwords ads.
Getting Started | | allb831 -
Competitive Analysis
Ok I've installed a few tools over the past week but I'm pretty sure at one time in MozPro I entered three competitor's domains and a list of KWs and it showed our ranking vs theirs for Google and Bing. I cannot for the life of me figure out how I did it or how I see the data. Is this going to be in one the reports that comes out every Tuesday (haven't gotten my first one yet)? Sorry for the newbie question. I've been tearing my hair out, searched the forum real quick and didn't see it. It's late and I want to wake up and be productive. Thanks all!
Getting Started | | bbarber570