Mobile First Index: What Could Happen To Sites w Large Desktop but Small Mobile Sites?
-
I have a question about how Mobile First could affect websites with separate (and smaller) mobile vs desktop sites. Referencing this SE Roundtable article (seorountable dot com /google-mobile-first-index-22953.html), "If you have less content on your mobile version than on your desktop version - Google will probably see the less content mobile version. Google said they are indexing the mobile version first."
But Google/ Gary Illyes are also on the record stating the switch to mobile-first should be minimally disruptive.
Does "Mobile First" mean that they'll consider desktop URLs "second", or will they actually just completely discount the desktop site in lieu of the mobile one? In other words: will content on your desktop site that does not appear in mobile count in desktop searches?
I can't find clear answer anywhere (see also: /jlh-marketing dot com/mobile-first-unanswered-questions/).
Obviously the writing is on the wall (and has been for years) that responsive is the way to go moving forward - but just looking for any other viewpoints/feedback here since it can be really expensive for some people to upgrade. I'm basically torn between "okay we gotta upgrade to responsive now" and "well, this may not be as critical as it seems". Sigh...
Thanks in advance for any feedback and thoughts. LOL - I selected "there may not be a right answer to this question" when submitting this to the Moz community.
-
Update: I just tweeted Gary Illyes about this, and he confirmed that even though Google will index desktop content, desktop versions will be devalued in favor of the mobile version. So if your mobile version is smaller than desktop, that's a big problem.
-
WORD. I think we're just going to have to see what happens, and in the meantime, be open w clients about all possibilities. I wish Google could clarify this more, but sounds like they also are still working everything out.
Think about the backlash Google might get if thousands of webmasters with smaller mobile sites suddenly saw traffic plummet bc their desktop content was being devalued in desktop search.
We know that the mobile user experience is suffering because Google mobile SERPs are based on desktop content first. It makes total sense to try to adapt that to Mobile first - especially since now, more searches are from mobile.
But there should be a way to move to Mobile First without having the desktop experience suffer in consequence. NEITHER EXPERIENCE should suffer.
Google needs to match the searcher with the best content. And for many desktop searches - at least in this interim era where many mobile sites are different from desktop sites - the best desktop content may very well be on the desktop site. Not the mobile one.
Really hoping Google figures out a way to work it out.
-
Hey Mirabile, it's a good question and definitely fun to think about. Honestly, I think it's going to be a bit like "Mobilegeddon" last year which ended up being a whimper at the time, but has set Google up to do this. They've been moving in the mobile direction for quite a long time, and this is a further step.
Unfortunately, we don't yet know how all this is going to work. I think we can be certain that Google doesn't want to make their search results worse by hurting e.g. large companies that deserve to rank simply because they move at glacial speeds (super slow) and don't have a mobile friendly site yet. I think we'll also see that in verticals that have way less mobile traffic (eg very B2B niches) there will be much less of an effect.
If it's anything like Mobilegeddon, we'll only really see the effect a year-ish on as they slowly crank up the dial. Specific questions like which content will be used for ranking, how important internal links become, and all of that can only be answered after the fact.
That said, I'll be watching all of this closely
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Improve First Contentful Paint (FCP) and First Input Delay (FID)
Please suggest me how to improve First Contentful Paint (FCP) and First Input Delay (FID) for my website (http://www.mastersindia.co/) on mobile. All the java scripts moved into footer, added async and defer on JS. Also, apply all the possible ways suggested buy the Google pagespeed insights tool but we did not see more improvement. We tried to defer and async all the CSS but while doing this our website gets break. Please help me to solve it. thread-18712370-27405935606745616.png
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | AnilTanwarMI0 -
Google cache is showing my UK homepage site instead of the US homepage and ranking the UK site in US
Hi There, When I check the cache of the US website (www.us.allsaints.com) Google returns the UK website. This is also reflected in the US Google Search Results when the UK site ranks for our brand name instead of the US site. The homepage has hreflang tags only on the homepage and the domains have been pointed correctly to the right territories via Google Webmaster Console.This has happened before in 26th July 2015 and was wondering if any had any idea why this is happening or if any one has experienced the same issueFDGjldR
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | adzhass0 -
Site Migration of 4 sites into 1?
Hi Guys, I have a massive project involving a migration of 4 sites into 1. 4 sites include: **www.MainSite.com ** www.E-commerce.com www.Membership.com www.ResearchStudy.com Goal of this project is to have 1-4 regrouped into Main Site I will be following the best practice from this post https://moz.com/blog/web-site-migration-guide-tips-for-seos which has an awesome checklist. I am actually about to start Phase 3: URL redirect mapping. Because all of these sites have hundreds of duplicates, I figured I should first resolve the Main Site dup issues before creating the URL redirect mapping but what about the other domains (2,3,4) though? Should I first resolve the Dup issues on those ones as well or it is not necessary since they will be pointing into the Main Site new domain? I want to make sure I don't overwork the programming team and myself. Thanks For sharing your expertise and any tips on how should I move forward with this.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Ideas-Money-Art0 -
Spammy sites that link to a site
Hello, What is the best and quickest way to identify spammy sites that link to a website, and then remove them ( google disavow?) Thank you dear Moz, community - I appreciate your help 🙂 Sincerely, Vijay
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | vijayvasu0 -
Merging 11 community sites into 1 regional site
I am merging 11 real estate community sites into 1 regional site and don't really know what type of redirect should I use for the homepage?, for instance: www.homepage.com redirect to www.regionalsite.com/community-page Should I 301 this redirect? If yes, how could I 301 redirect a homepage to an internal page in my new site? Cheers 🙂
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | mbulox0 -
Any Suggestions For My Site?
I've recently started a website that is based on movie posters. The site has fundamentally been built for users and not SEO but I'm wondering if anyone can see any problems or just general advice that may help with our SEO efforts? The "content" on the website are the movie posters. I know Google likes text content, but I don't see what else we could add that wouldn't be purely for SEO. My site is: http://www.bit.ly/ZSPbTA
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | whispertera0 -
First eCommerce site, any tips on how to increase rankings would be appreciated.
As I mentioned I'm working on a new eCommerce site and just want some hints and tip on how I can potentially get the most out of ranking it. http://fuchia.co.uk/ I've meta titled / tag most of the products with relevant keywords, we have a good social standing so far with growth on Twitter + facebook but conversions are currently low or only coming through the website's eBay store (that has no connection on the site)
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | SEOAndy0 -
Can Someone Provide an Example of a Site that Indexes Search Results Successfully?
So, I know indexing search results is a big no-no, but I recently started working with a site that sees 50% of its traffic from search result pages. The user engagement on these pages is very high, and these pages rank well too. Unfortunately, they've been hit by Panda. They already moved the section of the site with search results to a subdomain, and saw temporary success. There must be a way to preserve their traffic from these search result pages and get out from under Panda.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | nicole.healthline0