Keyword Cannibalization and Targeting Similar Search Terms
-
My website is a collection of educational games for children. We are currently in the process of doing all the onsite page optimization for the individual game pages (they currently have no title tags, meta descriptions, H1, etc.)
We created several different games to teach each particular skill. For example, there are 4 different games children can play to learn vowels. While offering several different games is good for the user, I am concerned as to how best to target a keyword for each particular game page without creating keyword cannibalization.
Being new to SEO, I am not sure how targeting on each page different variations of related terms would affect SEO. For example, if one page were to target the term "vowel games", and another the term "learning the vowels" are these keywords similar enough to cause keyword cannibalization? If yes, would a proper solution be to use a canonical tag and designate one game as the "primary" game page for vowels?
Ideally, I realize that the best SEO solution would be to have a landing page created just for "vowel games." Yet we created our landing pages based upon school level (preschool, kindergarten, first grade, etc) thinking of the user experience where a child only has to navigate to a single page to find all of the games for their age range.
I greatly appreciate any help in better understanding the best way to avoid any potential problems with cannibalization.
-
Apologies I missed your response for some reason - I normally get an email.
You are right in that there is a fine line between each of the games and that sits at the heart of the problem.
1. If it was me I would have a sub-category below Kindergarten games and write 300 words about the benefits of Vowel Games in the description backed up by Meta, title, compelling call to action description and a highly relevant H1. Then write specific content talking about just the benefits of each type of game on the game pages 1-4
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Games>Vowel game 1 etc
And sit all four games on that.
2. If you can't do that then you could have one page for all four games as I suggested (like the Zappos model)
So:
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Games (Vowel Games being the product name)
Then have the four types of vowel game as attributes as a drop down or separate link on the page.
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game (attribute 1 = letter sound)
(attribute 2 = identifying the vowels)
(attribute 3 = matching upper and lowercase vowel
(attribute 4 = letter and image match)Then all of the descriptive text could sit on this on page and the drop downs could be by via ajax (which wouldn't change the URL), or after the URL # or ?
e.g http://www.site.com/kindergarten-games/vowel-game#attribute1=letter sound
http://www.site.com/kindergarten-games/vowel-game#attribute2=identifying the vowelsetc
If you do it this way you risk splitting the juice four ways:
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game1 (attribute= letter sound)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 2 (attribute= identifying the vowels)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 3 (attribute= matching upper and lowercase vowels)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 4 (attribute= letter and image match)It's clear that people are much more likely to type in vowel games so this is not the strongest way when you have 1 or 2 above.
Regards Nigel
-
Hi Nigel,
Thank you so much for the response, I greatly appreciate it. So to be a little more specific, our games are interactive HTML5 games that the child plays on our website. So even though creating a subcategory based off brand does not apply, the same logic still applies for the site structure. So if I am understanding you properly, we are ok keeping the games using the sub category "kindergarten" and then targeting keywords using descriptive content for the games based off their attributes.
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game1 (attribute= letter sound)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 2 (attribute= identifying the vowels)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 3 (attribute= matching upper and lowercase vowels)
Site>Kindergarten Games>Vowel Game 4 (attribute= letter and image match)My only concern though is whether the attributes (long tailed keywords) in the eyes of the search engines are considered semantic variations and still close enough to cause cannibalization. Also, will they compete against each other for the broader, more heavily searched terms, like "vowel games."
Once again, thank you very much for your help. It is very much appreciated when you are trying to learn a new skill to have experienced people share their knowledge.
-
Hi Bza
This is one of the most common problems I come across. I work with a lot of eCommerce sites that face the same problems. Some of them set up all products separately and others group under core products. It also has a lot to do with site structure. It's all to do with how similar the products are.
Example Structure:
Site>Category>Sub-catergory
Site>Game
Site>Games>Vowel Games
Site>Games>Vowel Games>Product1
Site>Games>Vowel Games>Product2
Site>Games>Vowel Games>Product3
Site>Games>Vowel Games>Product4If you are unwilling to set up the Cat Vowel Games then this would be Kindergarten Games (maybe)
So now you have a category - 'Games' - with all of the generic SEO (Title, description and maybe 300 words of descriptive content.)
You also have a sub category of 'Vowel Games' - but with specific SEO (Title, description and maybe 300 words of descriptive content.) all good so far!
You now have 4 games.
Now - if these games are really similar for example 1+2 come from the same brand and have the same name - and the only difference is the size of the game or number of pieces.
Then set it up as 'Brand - Product Name'
The variants 1 and 2 can be in the form of a drop down on the page. The canonical URL on the singe page would be 'Brand - Product Name' and the variants 1 and 2 could be an attribute so hidden behind a # or ? which can be excluded from Google (in the case of the # it is anyway - with the ? you can do it in parameters)
When someone searches for that product and title - yours would likely come up provided you have written some decent product specific content. Yes its a vowel game but there will be features that will distinguish it from other games.
If the products are ALL the same brand and title apart from a measurable attribute then they could ALL be grouped under one core product with attributes for 1,2,3,4 as a drop down on the page. e.g. size, number of pieces.
If then they are the ONLY vowel games on website and there are no others then you may wish to set them under games and get rid of the sub-category Vowel Games as there will be canonicalization between Vowel Games and the single game with the 4 attributes. (This would not be an issue if you set them under Kindergarten Games)
If the games are not the same brand and title and you canonicalise them then you run the risk of Google ignoring the canonicalisation and showing them anyway. Here you also run the risk of Google not trusting your canonicalization structure.
By teh way I would never set up Product 1 and canonicailze the other products as that one. I would always set up a non-attribute URL and then canonicalze the attributes to that one.
For an example go to Zappos and look how they canonicalise shoes with different colour attributes and sizes under one core URL. http://www.zappos.com/p/dunham-fitsync/product/8651820
I believe that with the right descriptive content for each game or brand-title game then you would still rank if someone typed in vowel games. The individual products would come up. Remember that most people start a search with Brand-Title then the type and these three pieces would be in the Title of the page. i.e. in this form: Brand Title Vowel Games Attribute
I do this every day so if you need any further explanation just ask.
Regards Nigel
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How come when I create a keyword list, the volume of that keyword per month is not displayed? It is only displayed once the keyword is selected.
Why do we no longer have the ability to view keywords in a list with all of its data? VdhmGmQ
Keyword Research | | solitude15577990 -
International Keyword Research
Good morning! I have a quick question about international keyword research. So, I created a keyword list full of terms that we want to analyze in Latin America. My question is around search results. For example, if the keyword I am analyzing in English is "apples" and I choose the region as Mexico, should I submit the keyword to be analyzed as "apples" or the Spanish translation "manzanas"? I am confused as to whether the results account for the translation of someone searching "manzanas" in Mexico to the English term "apples" and how that whole process works. Let me know if I need to elaborate because I understand that the whole question is super confusing haha. Thanks for any help you can give! 🙂
Keyword Research | | BlakeSmith31 -
YouTube Keyword Research
MOZ has some really powerful tools available to us, but I was wondering if there are any tools for conducting keyword research for YouTube? Thanks!
Keyword Research | | Alaeddin1 -
Keywords/URL
Greetings! I've read previous posts on this topic, but wondering if something has changed recently...On the on-page grading, the following was suggested:Use Keywords in your URL - high importance - easy fix _(In the past it has read difficult fix). _Could it be as easy as creating a new page with the name in the url, then redirecting to it? My site is www.enchantingquotes.com and the keyword that brings in virtually all of business is "wall quotes". I've read in the forum this isn't worth the trouble of trying to do, but the "easy fix" comment has me wondering...?Any help is much appreciated....I'm been trying to recover from a recent unexplained drop in rank. Ugh! (So feel free to analyze my site LOL!) :DA huge thanks for any advise!
Keyword Research | | eqgirl0 -
Keyword limit??
So is it right we are only allowed 300 keywords across all campaigns? if this is right how are we suppose to work with this? is there a way to make it higher?
Keyword Research | | OasisLandDevelopment0 -
Google Keyword Tool: What is considered a unique keyword?
I'm trying to research keywords using Google's Keyword Tool. After looking at results, I have the following questions: 1. Does singular/plurals of a word count as two different keywords to Google (ie: photobooth and photobooths)? Would I need to have a unique page targeting each word or will one page on my site be sufficient for targeting both? 2. I've noticed that different variations of keywords have the same global monthly search results. This leads me to believe that Google see's all of them as one keyword. ie: "photo booth props" and "props for a photo booth" and "props with photo booth", all have 22,200 search global monthly search resluts. On the other hand "moustache prop" and "prop moustache" have different global monthly search results (480 and 590). Can anyone explain this?
Keyword Research | | Alchemist230 -
How trustworthy is Google's Keyword Tool for organic search research?
Can anyone (not Google affliated) explain to me where Google's data really comes from in their Keyword Tool? Is it at all based on organic search? Or only on Google Ads related data? I know there was some controversy back in June '10 and the Google remedied the return of suggested keywords but I can't seem to get a clear answer (other than from the Google blog itself) whether the search volumes returned are truly indicative of organic search. Am I relying on the wrong tool? Do those more savvy than I only rely on the keyword tool for PPC research. Please help! I'm obsessing over my numbers here. 🙂
Keyword Research | | lhutt0 -
Keywords abuse?
WE are using the best keywords all over our eStore: Furnace Filter and Furnace Filters. Is it abusing when we list items like: 10x20x1 furnace filter 10x20x2furnace filter 10x20x4 furnace filter and so on... we have almost 100 different filters on sale. see example: http://www.furnacefilterscanada.com/categories/Furnace-Filter-See-All/ Thank you for your help BigBlaze
Keyword Research | | BigBlaze2050