Is being in position 1-3 without a featured snippet better for conversions?
-
I'm a cosmetic dental practice so we're local and want people to visit our website, look around and make a booking.
I've followed very closely the featured snippet debate on WBF and in the blogs here and everywhere else on the web. I've got many 1-3 positions and have been optimising for featured snippets with great success.
I have noticed though that once I get a featured snippet the CTR of the page that the snippet is taken from drops significantly. This can often put me from position one into two or three. The same thing happens sometimes on the local listings. You get in the pack and people start visiting your homepage rather than the particular services page in the SERP.
At a conference I was at, here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1iXlVcbpvd0 (11:14) there is a suggestion that Vodafone de-optimise because a position one or two is better for their sales than a featured snippet.
After all my interests are not the same as google. They want to answer questions and I want to sell cosmetic dentistry. So is answering a question without bringing a user to my site a good idea? I've certainly seen the amount of enquiries drop once the category has a number of featured snippets.
Are they as good as everyone says they are? I think possibly not from my data and this Vodafone talk is the first time i've heard anyone agree.
I've scoured the web for answers and it's all just "GET FEATURED SNIPPETS", "HERES HOW TO GET THEM" etc. But my business is not about getting more traffic it's about selling. Could someone please point me to research on conversion rate and featured snippets. or ROI and featured snippets?
Thanks.
-
Yes you are right realises own confirmation bias I love how new this all is, it's so interesting and I feel we're on the cutting edge of something. I'll get some more data together and do my own little study. #alwaysbetesting
-
_Do you find that the FS can so detrimentally affect the CTR that you drop out of 1-3 altogether? I've seen that happen a couple of times but can't say for certain it's because of the FS. _
It depends on the topic and niche you are in. Can't say anything exact, in my experiences works better being in the tops positions WITHOUT a FS rather than having a FS and being the chosen one.
_Check out search console data. It all goes 100% haywire when I got the snippets. CTR right down and impressions through the roof. Clicks are stable (ish). That research you recommended looks great. Thanks so much. _
Yeap, the effect in the impression with the FS is fantastic. Be cautious, you do have more clicks even dropping down the CTR.
If I were you, I'd try to de-optimize one FS and test the results.
SEO is tough and many times is just trial and error -
Thanks Gaston, I'll test that out. I'm also thinking that you're right about the nature of the FS being question answering. It's almost as though local traffic is still visiting the site but the national traffic is just looking at the snippet and leaving. So it's worth looking at the location demo too I think.
Do you find that the FS can so detrimentally affect the CTR that you drop out of 1-3 altogether? I've seen that happen a couple of times but can't say for certain it's because of the FS.
Check out search console data. It all goes 100% haywire when I got the snippets. CTR right down and impressions through the roof. Clicks are stable (ish). That research you recommended looks great. Thanks so much.
-
Hi Ed!
Definitely **YES! ** Being position 1-3 _without_a featured snippet will drive more visitors to your site. You are clearly seing that.
The math here is simple: less visitors to your website, less conversions.
There are 2 clear studies to show here:Ahrefs’ Study Of 2 Million Featured Snippets: 10 Important Takeaways
MozCon Slide: Reverse-Engineer Google’s Research to Serve Up the Best, Most Relevant Content for Your AudienceIn the last one, the key information to extract is that google chooses more often FS that contains rather informational keywords than transactional ones.
As you say that mastered the process to win FS, there might be a chance to optimize (if that's even possible) the information shown in the snippent to include a text telling the searcher to go in the site and buy.Hope this helps.
Best luck.
GR.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Conversion Rate Benchmarking and Optimization
Hey everyone! I run the marketing for an ecommerce marketplace and we're doing good on the SEO front of things, with 60%+ of our traffic coming in via search and we're ranking for some competitive keywords. I'm really curious about the conversion rate though. Despite intensive googling, I've not been able to find a rough benchmark for conversion rates. Our conversion rate is about 1.2%, increasing as we continue to do more optimization work with regards to the site's usability. While we track other forms of conversions, the 1.2% conversion rate is for bookings through the site, which is our main source of revenue. Does anyone have a reference guide for conversion rates, particularly for ecommerce marketplaces? I'd like to know if we're doing ok or really bad, and also to take reference from other similar sites to improve our conversion. Thanks!!
Conversion Rate Optimization | | NgEF0 -
Any possibility to track goal completions/conversions at a sub-page (non-landing page) level in Google Analytics?
We’re promoting our sub-page it's http://www.flightcentre.ca/flights/london on our homepage under the slideshow so I need to see how many people went to the homepage, then went to this page, and then converted (enquired or booked.) What I can’t see is how many people did that. I know how to look up how many people landed on that page and then converted, but I need to know how many people navigated there and then converted. Is that possible? I can only see Goal Completions if I look at that page as a landing page, but that only presents a very slim view of the total visits when compared to those pages generally. Any way to check the entire behavior or activities happening through this page i.e. /flights/london?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | flightcentre200 -
Facebook Connect login preventing traffic source conversion data. Any solutions?
We're buying traffic to the website via Adwords, and when they hit the website and go to sign up for an application (enter into our conversion funnel), the session concludes as a bounced session, a new session starts and that session now has a referral from Facebook rather than the original referring source. This means we can't monitor adwords conversions properly (or any other traffic source conversions) this seems to be quite a common problem with Facebook/Google account logins, in the case of Google, people block account.google.com but we can't afford to block Facebook outright as we're wanting to see other Facebook referrals. Has anyone come across this problem? Any suggestions of how to fix this?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Startupfactory0 -
Help! Tracking Conversion Source of Specific Users: Possible? How?
Just as an example, let's say we generate a website lead from John Smith. Can we trace John Smith's activity back through AdWords or Analytics to see exactly where he came from and (with AdWords for example) what keyword he typed in before clicking our ad and converting? Thanks for the help!
Conversion Rate Optimization | | RickyShockley3 -
Tracking Adwords Conversions for eCommerce ROI
I'm working with a rather large eCommerce customer who needs to be able to track their Adwords conversions for the purpose of determining the ROI of their Adwords campaigns. I've installed code from Google Adwords Conversions on their eCommerce page, but it doesn't seem to be calculating values correctly. Also, where would setting goals in Analytics come in to play if I'm trying to track the conversions of specific Adwords conversions?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | SmokewagonKen0 -
Rel=author: inactive google+ better than no authorship?
some doubts about implementing rel=author: I have no google+ account so far and I have no intention to start activities in google+. Shall I still add rel=author and create a new empty google+ account (without google+ activity but using gmail) or would you recommend rather not to add rel=author in this case? I have 2 sites ranking in top10 SERP for my targeted keyword. One online shop and on another domain a non-commercial site with information on the topic. Would you rather associate same or different google+ accounts (from different people) with these two sites for both rel=author and rel=publisher? thanks.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | lcourse0 -
Shorter checkout form converts better? Or can it be harmful?
I've frequently read that the shorter the checkout form the better. My checkout form has the following fields: First name Last name Email Username Password Retype password Card number Card expiration date CVV code Billing street Billing city Billing state Billing zip Here's the thing. Since it's a web-app, I don't need the "billing address" as I'm not physically shipping them anything. Should I remove it? The no-brainer answer seems to be "yes", but I'm wondering if folks don't see any billing address fields, it may look suspicious. Conversions for having it and not don't seem to make much difference, so I suppose I'm looking for some tie-breaker opinions. The "password" and "retype password" fields could be eliminated by emailing the user's a system-generated password. But once again, could a user see this as odd or suspicious and then abandon? Even if I tell them I'll be emailing them a password? They could be sensitive thinking we'd email the wrong email address due to system error or their own typo. I could also eliminate the CVV and not validate against that. But once again, could a user seeing the CVV gone become wary? As much as I'd like to have "guest checkout' it's not feasible. The app is tied to a logged in account, which would also make eliminating the "username" impossible. Based on all the above, I could trim down the form considerably, but would I be doing more harm than good? I could A/B test it, but I don't believe I have a sufficient number of users to test against. Everything I buy, physical or online app, has an address field, so perhaps folks are accustomed to filling out this stuff and I should just keep it to align with user expectations? Thanks.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | bluekite770 -
Will adding to a video's length affect my Rich Snippets?
Most people get to the end of my videos, 85% or so, but there's no call to action at the end of them. So I'd like to suggest what they could do or read next; along the lines of 'Add to basket and receive your XYZ tomorrow'. This will make the video longer and therefore google will know it has changed, I guess. I see no reason for them to object to this but you never you.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Brocberry0