Bogus Crawl Errors in Webmaster Tools?
-
I am suddenly seeing a ton of crawl errors in webmaster tools.
Almost all of them are URL links coming from scraper sites.that I do not own.
Do you see these in your Webmaster Tools account?
Do you mark them as "fixed" if they are on a scraper site? There are waaaay too many of these to make redirects.
Thanks!
-
Thanks, Marcus,
My numbers are rising rapidly right now... but hopefully the trend will reverse.
I'll let you know if I learn anything.
-
Hey, I know, it's kind of bonkers but I certainly think that assuming Google does not know what they are doing is a good place to start.
For us they just cleared up in time, obviously, this is webmaster tools so it was a good old bit of time (months rather than weeks) but it did sort itself out.
Take care!
Marcus -
Hello Marcus,
Thank you for sharing your experience and finding those posts. I appreciate it.
I think I am going to ignore these and assume that Google doesn't know what they are doing.
It surprises me that the URL errors on spammer sites are being presented to me as something that should be fixed.
Thanks again!
-
Hey EGOL
I have seen this in the past on my own site and on a few client sites in the past (which is not to say I have an answer here).
We were seeing completely random looking URLs that at first made me think the site had been somehow hacked or compromised but further investigation revealed that was not the case. We were just getting the strangest of links to pages that did not exist like xhyx.php?id=jamesbrown (that kind of thing).
We did nothing here and over time it seems to have resolved itself and these pages are not listed any longer. I tend to think of the webmaster tools data as diagnostics and it is telling me these pages don't exist so I can check for problems. Well, there is no problem, they don't exist and I am happy about that. Still, whether to mark them as fixed or not, I am unsure and would err towards not doing anything with them as they are not 'errors' as far as I am concerned. Likewise, I don't want to redirect them in most cases as I don't like the linking sites and have better things to do with my working day (I am not getting that time back - it's the digital equivalent or ironing clothes or some such laborious grind).
I had a look around again and whilst I can't find any specific answers regarding whether to mark them as fixed the following posts are of interest:
- http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/webmasters/3GTOLCE-8pk
- https://productforums.google.com/forum/?hl=en#!category-topic/webmasters/webmaster-tools/rKI-38ohfbc
Particularly this quote from John Mueller at Google (webmaster tools guy I believe):
"In general, if a URL is really a 404, that's fine for us, and not something that would cause your site any problems in the long run. At any rate, you don't need to "fix" this problem (eg with a 301 redirect), if you're sure that the URL should really not exist. Having 404s listed in Webmaster Tools will generally not affect your site's crawling, indexing, or ranking; it's normal for websites to return 404 for URLs that don't exist."
So, my take is not to bother but would be interesting to ask the question in webmaster tools section of the Google product forums: https://productforums.google.com/forum/?hl=en#!categories/webmasters/webmaster-tools
Not an answer as such but hope that helps.
Marcus
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Can you have 2 different websites on 1 webmaster tools account
Someone set up both our sites on the one webmaster tools account is this the best way to do it or should we have 2 different accounts. We are having problems with our site verification not working and our google shopping feeds not working could this be the cause.
Technical SEO | | CostumeD0 -
How to Remove a website from your Bing Webmaster Tools account
I have a site in Bing Webmaster Tools that I no longer work on. I can't seem to find where to delete this website from my webmaster tools account. Anyone know how (there doesn't seem to be anything obvious under Bing Help or on a Google Search).
Technical SEO | | TopFloor0 -
Google Webmaster Tools: MESSAGE
Dear site owner or webmaster of http://www.enakliyat.com.tr/,
Technical SEO | | iskq
Some of your site's pages may be using techniques that do not comply with Google's Webmaster Guidelines.
On your site, in particular, does not provide an adequate level of innovation in low-quality unique content or set of pages. Examples of this type of thin affiliate pages, pages, bridge pages, it will automatically be created or copied content. For more information about the unique and interesting content, visit http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=66361.
We recommend you to make the necessary changes to your site to fit your site's quality guidelines. After making these changes, please submit your site for reconsideration in Google's search results.
If you have questions about how to resolve this problem, please see our Webmaster Help Forum for support.
Sincerely,
Google Search Quality Team **After this massege ve find our low quality pages and we added this urls on Robots.txt. Other than that, what can we do? ** **Our site is a home to home moving listing portal. Consumers who wants to move his home fills a form so that moving companies can cote prices. We were generating listing page URL’s by using the title submitted by customer. **0 -
Why is google webmaster tools ignoring my url parameter settings
I have set up several url parameters in webmaster tools that do things like select a specific products colour or size. I have set the parameter in google to "narrows" the page and selected to crawl no urls but in the duplicate content section each of these are still shown as being 2 pages with the same content. Is this just normal, i.e. showing me that they are the same anyway or is google deliberately ignoring my settings (which I assume it does when they are sure they know better or think I have made a mistake)?
Technical SEO | | mark_baird0 -
Webmaster tools
Hello, My sites are showing odd "links to your site" data in WMT. Its not showing any links to the homepages and reduced links for other pages. Anyone else seeing this? Penguin refresh maybe?
Technical SEO | | jwdl0 -
RSS Feed Errors in Google
We recently (2 months ago) launched RSS feeds for the category pages on our site. Last week we started seeing error pages in Webmaster Tools' Crawl Errors report pop up for feeds of old pages that have been deleted from the site, deleted from the sitemap, and not in Google's index since long before we launched the RSS feeds. Example: www.mysite.com/super-old-page/feed/ I checked and both the URL for the feed and the URL for the actual page are returning 404 statuses. www.mysite.com/super-old-page/ is also showing up in our Crawl Errors. Its been deleted for months but Webmaster Tools is very slow to remove the page from their Crawl Error report. Where is Google finding these feeds that never existed?
Technical SEO | | Hakkasan0 -
Duplicate Content Errors
Ok, old fat client developer new at SEO so I apologize if this is obvious. I have 4 errors in one of my campaigns. two are duplicate content and two are duplicate title. Here is the duplicate title error Rare Currency And Old Paper Money Values and Information.
Technical SEO | | Banknotes
http://www.antiquebanknotes.com/ Rare Currency And Old Paper Money Values and Information.
http://www.antiquebanknotes.com/Default.aspx So, my question is... What do I need to do to make this right? They are the same page. in my page load for default.aspx I have this: this.Title = "Rare Currency And Old Paper Money Values and Information."; And it occurs only once...0 -
Google Webmaster Creation
When creating Google Webmaster Account is it advised to create 2 accounts for the 1 domain. one for non www and one for www?
Technical SEO | | daracreative0