Duplicate Content Question
-
My understanding of duplicate content is that if two pages are identical, Google selects one for it's results...
I have a client that is literally sharing content real-time with a partner...the page content is identical for both sites, and if you update one page, teh otehr is updated automatically. Obviously this is a clear cut case for canonical link tags, but I'm cuious about something:
Both sites seem to show up in search results but for different keywords...I would think one domain would simply win out over the other, but Google seems to show both sites in results. Any idea why? Also, could this duplicate content issue be hurting visibility for both sites? In other words, can I expect a boost in rankings with the canonical tags in place? Or will rankings remain the same?
-
yeah, it's strange...if you look at my reply to the first response, you will see the urls.
the page that copies content shows up #1 for "stem cell transplant boston" while the original page shows up for "stem cell transplant" (page 3) and other searches.
-
Thanks for your reply. The target pages show up.
I recognize that the canonical tag will basically give all teh exposure to the target page. I'm just wondering if the target page will see an improvement in rankings.
-
Thanks very much.
Yes, most of the content on the two sites is unique
The sites do interlink but not on these pages
Not on same IP
Yes, both sites have good authority
Here is the site originating the content:
-
Mark's right, you need to be providing signals to the search engines as to which one is the original. Quite often if most of the metrics are similar, the first article that Google crawls is given the weighting of the original. Linking back from the duplicate will help. I would also suggest leaving a delay before syndicating the content to allow Google to find the original.
With regards to both pages ranking that is slightly odd - is this on a very specific / long tail search? For example have you searched for the whole article title or something like that?
-
When you say both sites show up in results, but for different queries, are you referring to the actual duplicate content pages/articles, or the homepage and other target pages. These pages/sites may be ranking for these different terms due to strength of the site/page and backlink profiles.
In terms of canonical tags, if one site is going to be doing a cross domain canonical to the other site, I don't see how this could help the site that is doing the cross domain canonical. The site receiving the canonical tag and being credited as the source of the original content, I could see this helping them and helping the page of content to rank higher, but I don't see why this would help the site linking out with the cross domain canonical.
My suggestion - the site producing the content should get the credit, cross domain canonicals should be used to associate the credit for the content with the site producing the content, and you should also include a piece of text in the content piece that says this originally appeared on xyz website, or something along those lines. I'd provide as many signals to the engines as possible as to where to attribute this content.
-
I have seen that happen sometimes. There could be multiple reasons. Here are the questions I would suggest you look into to get a better read on the reasoning behind it:
1. Is there any other content on the 2 websites that is independent and not duplicated between the 2 sites ?
2. Are the 2 sites interlinking to each other ? (I am guessing not.)
3. Are the 2 sites on the same IP ? (I am guessing not.)
4. Are both the domains/sites pretty established, authority, with tons of unique backlinks from industry sites ?I am sure answers to the above questions would lead you to a better read on the original question. If not, let me know what the answers are and if you'd like to share the URLs, I would love to look at them.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Please provide solution for my website? Duplicate content Problem
I have 2 Domains with the same name with same content. How to solve that problem? Do I need to change the content from my main website. My Hosting is having different plans, but with the same features. So many pages were having the same content, and it is not possible to change the content, what is the solution for that? Please let me know how to solve that issue?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Alexa.Hill0 -
How to avoid duplicate content
Hi there, Our client has an ecommerce website, their products are also showing on an aggregator website (aka on a comparison website where multiple vendors are showing their products). On the aggregator website the same photos, titles and product descriptions are showing. Now with building their new website, how can we avoid such duplicate content? Or does Google even care in this case? I have read that we could show more product information on their ecommerce website and less details on the aggregator's website. But is there another or better solution? Many thanks in advance for any input!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Gabriele_Layoutweb0 -
A lot of news / Duplicate Content - what to do?
Hi All, I have a blog with a lot of content (news and pr messages), I want to move my blog to new domain. What is your recommendation? 1. Keep it as is. old articles -> 301 -> same article different URL
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | JohnPalmer
2. Remove all the duplicate content and create 301 from the old URL to my homepage.
3. Keep it as is, but add in the meta-tags NoIndex in duplicate articles. Thanks !0 -
Same content pages in different versions of Google - is it duplicate>
Here's my issue I have the same page twice for content but on different url for the country, for example: www.example.com/gb/page/ and www.example.com/us/page So one for USA and one for Great Britain. Or it could be a subdomain gb. or us. etc. Now is it duplicate content is US version indexes the page and UK indexes other page (same content different url), the UK search engine will only see the UK page and the US the us page, different urls but same content. Is this bad for the panda update? or does this get away with it? People suggest it is ok and good for localised search for an international website - im not so sure. Really appreciate advice.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | pauledwards0 -
How much (%) of the content of a page is considered too much duplication?
Google is not fond of duplication, I have been very kindly told. So how much would you suggest is too much?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | simonberenyi0 -
Duplicate content question? thanks
Hi, Im my time as an SEO I have never come across the following two scenarios, I am an advocate of using unique content, therefore always suggest and in cases demand that all content is written or re-written. This is the scenarios I am facing right now. For Example we have www.abc.com (has over 200 original recipes) and then we have www.xyz.com with the recipes but they are translated into another language as they are targeting different audiences, will Google penalize for duplicate content? The other issue is that the client got the recipes from www.abc.com (that have been translated) and use them in www.xyz.com aswell, both sites owned by the same company so its not pleagurism they have legal rights but I am not sure how Google will see it and if it will penalize the sites. Thanks!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | M_81 -
I try to apply best duplicate content practices, but my rankings drop!
Hey, An audit of a client's site revealed that due to their shopping cart, all their product pages were being duplicated. http://www.domain.com.au/digital-inverter-generator-3300w/ and http://www.domain.com.au/shop/digital-inverter-generator-3300w/ The easiest solution was to just block all /shop/ pages in Google Webmaster Tools (redirects were not an easy option). This was about 3 months ago, and in months 1 and 2 we undertook some great marketing (soft social book marking, updating the page content, flickr profiles with product images, product manuals onto slideshare etc). Rankings went up and so did traffic. In month 3, the changes in robots.txt finally hit and rankings decreased quite steadily over the last 3 weeks. Im so tempted to take off the robots restriction on the duplicate content.... I know I shouldnt but, it was working so well without it? Ideas, suggestions?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | LukeyJamo0 -
Should I do something about this duplicate content? If so, what?
On our real estate site we have our office listings displayed. The listings are generated from a scraping script that I wrote. As such, all of our listings have the exact same description snippet as every other agent in our office. The rest of the page consists of site-wide sidebars and a contact form. The title of the page is the address of the house and so is the H1 tag. Manually changing the descriptions is not an option. Do you think it would help to have some randomly generated stuff on the page such as "similar listings"? Any other ideas? Thanks!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | MarieHaynes0