How do you deal with comment spam: wordpress?
-
I have akismet installed on my Wordpress blog, and it does a great job of filtering the spam comments, but for some reason my site (and server) gets slammed by the amount of spam comments akismet blocks. If I check my spam folder there will be over 100 spam comments in an hour. (which in turn puts a load on my server.)
Does anyone have any thoughts on how to put a stop to this? (Or at least slow it down?) I know I could use a captcha, but I really don't want to put any barriers on people commenting and I don't even like using those captcha's myself.
Thoughts?
By the way, does anyone know how spam like this works? This has been going on for sometime now. Are spammers just using automated software to do this?
-
By far the best site availability monitoring tool I can recommend is Pingdom.
Signing up for an account is free to monitor one website. You can have it email you or send a text message/tweet when your site goes down. You can also configure how long your site must be out before you get alerted, and how often to be alerted while your site is still down.
Indispensable for understanding what's actually going on with your site.
Paul
P.S. Use the customizations when setting up the monitor so it's actually checking for the existence of a particular word on your page - that way you're testing whether your site is actually rendering, as opposed to just responding to a ping.
-
Thanks for the reply, very helpful info.
As far as server monitoring I don't think I have anything in place. Any suggestions?
-
Sorry - guess should have made that clearer, Rick. There will be a definite reduction in server resources used. The comment still gets partially processed in order to send it to Akismet, but that new setting tells your system to just discard it if it comes back marked as spam. That way, no database writes occur for that spam, which will definitely reduce server load (database reads and writes are fairly "expensive" in terms of added server processing needed).
Without that setting, spam comments that come back from Akismet get written to your database under the Spam table. That's a lot of extra processing for something you were going to throw out anyway.
This won't save as many resources as actually blocking the spam before it even starts to get processed (as the other suggested plugin would do) but you should notice lowered demand on your server resources with this setting. Not to mention a whole lot less crap to clean out every day, as you point out
Paul
P.S One side effect to that setting is you won't be quite as aware of just how much spam you're actually getting since you won't see a lot of it. This means a spam run against some older posts could start really hitting server resources hard but you might not be aware. (Remember, this setting doesn't eliminate the processing demands completely.)
So keep an eye on the stat that shows how many spams Akismet has handled. If you see a prolonged surge, and/or have further server load problems, it will be a signal that more drastic protection methods have become necessary.
Do you have a server monitoring/alerting system in place?
-
Thanks for your very helpful post! It was great!
I never thought of selecting the option to auto delete spam comments on posts older than a month old. Once I did that, it cut down on 80% of the spam I was getting! So thanks!
Quick question on that. Does enabling that option cut down on the server resources? In other words, let's say it cuts down on 200 spam comments a day because they are auto deleted, do those 200 spam comments still get entered in as comments and therefore use server resources? Does this just save me the step of having to go through and delete them / clear the spam folder? Or does this save a huge amount of server resources? Either way it's a huge win!
-
Just wondering if these responses helped answer your question, Rick?
If not, what else might you need clarified tht we may be able to help with?
Paul
-
Ahh... comment spam - the bane of every successful website with an active blog. It's actually a signal of your success that your getting that much spam
I fully agree though - captcha is NEVER the answer if you want to maintain high visitor engagement. You shouldn't be offloading your spam problem onto your visitors to solve. There are better options.
So let's dive in.
How the spam gets generated There are two types of comment spam: bot-generated and manual. The first is created by software "bots" that have been programmed to crawl the web looking for the scripts on a website that allow content submission e.g. comment forms, contact forms etc. The software then accesses the script directly and submits its crapload. WordPress (and othe CMSs) are especially vulnerable because these scripts have the same names on every single install - the bot only has to look for a few very specific filenames in a few standard places.
Because this is two pieces of software talking directly to each other, hundreds, or even thousands of submissions per hour can be generated. The bots generally have no limits on them, so eventually they'll consume so many server resources they degrade or even completely consume the server's ability to do the rest of it's job. (This is considered to be at least 65% of all spam.)
With manual spam, an actual human in a very cheap labour market is paid to go through the posts on a website and manually enter the crapload, entering whatever info into the fields is necessary to make the comment system think it's a legit human-generated comment.
Filtering vs Blocking
The problem with Akismet is that it is a spam filtering tool, not a spam blocking tool. Each comment is allowed to enter the blog system where it is then sent to Akismet's server to be assessed. Akismet then sends it back to your site flagged to go into your spam, moderation, or publication queue. This means each spam message receives the same processing as legit comments, so the system is still using processing and database resources for every single message received. (Even spam gets written to the database and stays there until you decide it should be deleted.)
All very processing intensive, and hence why having Akismet doesn't do anything to reduce the server load of a spam run - and may even increase it slightly.
Optimize Akismet's Settings
So what to do? First, there's a simple checkbox in Akismet settings that can make a huge difference. You can tell Akismet that if it recognizes as spam a comment to a post that's more than a month old, it should just automatically discard it instead of adding it to the spam queue and writing it into the database. This greatly reduces the database activity created by the spam, and also helps keep your spam queue clearer so it's easier recognize legit comments that might have been caught from more recent posts. (Spammers tend to focus on older posts for a number of reasons - mostly becasue they're easier to find) The clear disadvantage is that the (very) few comments falsely identified as spam will be irretrievably gone. I know this could be an issue for you as many of your posts continue to get comments for months after, but if you're clearing 100s of comments an hour, chances are that some legit comments are accidentally getting deleted already.
To enable the automatically discard function, simply go to the Akismet Configuration page under your Plugins (where WordPress.com API Key is entered). At the bottom of the page, check-mark the box for Automatically discard spam comments on posts older than a month. Remember to click the Update options button when done.
Stronger Protection
If you need more protection, you're going to need to install a plugin that intercepts the comments before they get into the system and automatically discards the ones that show the characteristics of bot-submission behaviour. Essentially the plugin analyzes how the comment was posted, rather than its content.
The best-known of these is Bad Behaviour, but it's a pretty heavy-handed solution that has been known to even block GoogleBot and hence cause deindexing of many pages. I'd call it a last-ditch solution.
I'd suggest you try WP Captcha-Free which is a small, very lightweight plugin that invisibly creates a "hash" when the comment is created that must also be present when submitted. Most spam-bots fail at this since they're submitting directly to the comment script and so are blocked before the comment really starts processing. Note that commenters must have Javascript enabled using this system. Since only 2-5% of web users don't have JS enabled, this is a reasonable tradeoff (and much better than pissing of 100% of your commenters by enforcing a captcha)
You will still want Akismet active behind this protection to catch the manually-submitted spam.
So to recap - in order to reduce your server load from spam, you need a system that BLOCKS the spam before it starts to get processed in the first place. Just doing more/better FILTERING won't help as the filtering process actually uses up even more server power. You want your server only processing what is likely to be real comments.
Sorry for the loooong reply but comment spam is a big/complicated issue and if it's approached incorrectly, you can make your problem much worse instead of better.
Fire away with the questions
Paul
-
Your blog will have a 'hook' where scripts can automatically insert comments to your site. Check your server logs - you'll probably see one form or another getting hit, a lot, or a script like xmlrpc.
If it's a form, add CAPTCHA, and that'll stop the scripts from auto-submitting.
If it's something else, consider changing permissions so the whole world can't hit it.
-
You may want to check your GA to see if this started all at once. Your site might be under a DDoS attack, but your server is holding up. That sounds like an awful lot of blocking in one hour. Sometimes the ISP has to step in if you host the server inhouse.
-
Is your blog self hosted or hosted by Wordpress.com ? If it's the one in your profile, then it's hosted by Wordpress.com which would then limit your abilities but then probably shouldn't have server "stress" issues. If it's self hosted, then you can try some of these plugins and see if they help (http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/search.php?q=spam) Depending upon the software being used to spam your blog, one of these for sure will be able to reduce the issues. So yes, it's automated tools that do all this comment spam.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Wordpress Tag Organization Tips
Curious if anyone has some good examples of ways to organize your WordPress tags without making your sidebar a football field long and hard to navigate. My blog is https://karmahill.com/blog and I could use some ideas. We have main categories of photo shoot types, for example, "Couples", located on the sidebar. We want to add tags to go with those main categories for further categorization and user experience example: Couples Engagement Proposals Honeymoon Maternity My question is, do I need to make "tag" pages for those posts to reside on or is their another way to get it done with less work, that is much faster? I don't want to have to make 30 tag pages or is that just what you have to do?
Web Design | | photoseo13 -
Drop in rankings after AMP implementation because of lack of facebook comments
Hi, we are amplifying our site, but one of the things we can´t include on our AMP version is the Facebook comment box. Some of our articles have hundreds of comments on them and we noticed that Google was crawling those comments and using them as a ranking signal (the more comments the better we discovered). Now we are wondering if these articles would drop if we launch the AMP version without the comment box. As this would reduce the written content on those pages a lot. Anybody tested this before or has an idea on that would work out? Thanks for your help!
Web Design | | guidetoiceland1 -
I want to create a 301 redirect on a WordPress site, nothing's working...
Hello all, I'm hoping someone out there can give me a hand with this. I'm trying to modify my .htaccess file so that the site will go from maxcarnagemusic.com to www.maxcarnagemusic.com and also, so viewers will be redirected to www.maxcarnagemusic.com/home when they try to access the site. I've tried a few different things, including adding the 301 redirect plugin for Wordpress, but nothing seems to work. Can someone out there show/tell me how to create an htaccess file that will execute as much. I apologize in advance, my Apache experience is very, very limited. Thank you all in advance!
Web Design | | maxcarnage0 -
Does anyone know how to find functions/codes/etc in WordPress?
Right now, I'm working on solving a relatively easy WP issue (easy, because someone told me what to do. Thanks iNetSeo). I have to replace: <span class="post_date"></span class="post_date"> and replace it with <span class="post_date date="" updated"=""></span class="post_date> But, I can't find the "_<span class="post_date">"</span class="post_date">_For a number of my WP problems, the hardest part is just located the code/function/markup I need to replace. Does anyone know where this might usually be stored on a website? Also, does anyone know if there's any tool that would allowed to just put "various function" in a search box, and wordpress take you to where it was on the backend of your site, so you could edit it? I included a screenshot of our editors, but I already opened them all, pasted the code in Ctrl-F to no avail, but maybe I missed something. Thanks for helping with my frustrating scavenger hunt! Ruben ASTPPfA
Web Design | | KempRugeLawGroup0 -
Wordpress Blog Providing SEO to Main Site
Hi, I recently started a very much "learn on the job" SEO position, transitioning from a copywriting background. We currently have a wordpress blog up and running (and producing some decent quality content too I hope!) at example.com/blog/ and a sign up page located at example.com (sorry, can't put the address right now) for a site that is being custom built as it's got some nifty software linking to back end systems. My question is whether the content on the blog will bring SEO benefits to the main domain or whether it'll just be for the blog itself? If the latter, should we navigate the blog onto the a separate page of the main site? Thanks so much! I'm learning as much as I can as quickly as I can, but somethings still get me in a little bit of a tizzy.
Web Design | | LeahHutcheon0 -
Please help. can't change widgets in wordpress
hey everyone, i am having a weird problem. for some reason. all of a sudden (without me changing ANYTHING) my widget page in the admin dashboard will not let me edit anything what i mean is, i login, go to the widgets page, and then the dropdown menus that you drag widgets into will not let me expand to drop widgets in them. was there a wordpress update i missed? who should i contact? what if i delete the theme and re-install. will i have to change ALL the settings back again?
Web Design | | TylerAbernethy0 -
WordPress not man enough...has anybody got experience working with Pryo CMS?
Hey folks I'm working with a small team on putting together a new niche accommodation / holiday search portal here in the UK. We are most likely using PHP / MySQL technology for the site - I am a huge fan of WordPress but not sure its quite man enough for the task (many option search over 10,000 plus properties). We can't afford to pay for a bespoke development, so off-the shelf CMS is the most likely route for release 1, and from what I've been reading Pyro CMS seems a good open source choice... https://www.pyrocms.com/ Has anybody come across this, or know how good it is with regards to on-site SEO? Or maybe WordPress is up to the task? If not, what are other good open source options for sites focused around a search function? Cheers Simon
Web Design | | SCL-SEO0