Has the relevancy of SEOmoz tools disappeared?

[TOPYX]

I have A rankings for my on-site grades for my most important keywords.

I have no Critical issues and no Warnings with my Crawl Diagnostics.

Most of the Competiive Link analysis data shows my site beating out the competition.

If all this is accurate, how can my SERPs continue to decrease and lesser pages with terrible optimization and backlinking be ranking higher?  I even have a facebook page beating me in the results.

If there is nothing left for me to address using SEOmoz, and I keep getting worse & results, doesn't it mean that the SEOmoz tools are not relevant to producing actual results?

Or, am I missing something?

[TOPYX]

Thank you for your response.

I use Alexa audits, Bing and Google webmaster, Google Analytics and SEOBOOK.

While I found the reports in SEOmoz great to use as a roadmap of items to address to improve my optimization, the actual results never materialized., much to my frustration.

I will check into the other tools you stated to see if I can find any additional help there.

Thanks!

[danatanseo]

While I have found SEOMoz tools to be invaluable for tracking results and providing reports to my CEO, I don't rely solely on SEOMoz for everything I need to optimize the sites I manage. Google Analytics data, reports and tracking are a crucial part of the whole picture.

Have you been tracking your visitor engagement and looking at bounce rate, time on page, depth of site visits, etc? There may be an issue there.

I also use SEMRush, Google Webmaster Tools, Ahrefs, Rank Checker, and the SEOQuake Toolbar to help me look at many different things.

Every site is different. E-commerce sites will have specific problems that blog sites don't have, and vice versa.

I think SEOMoz tools are exceptional, but I think even Mozzers would agree that they are not meant as a stand alone, all-in-one, never need anything else kind of tool. It works best when used in combination with the other great tools that are out there.

Hope that's helpful!