Google seems to be penalizing my site for some reason
-
I recently took control of a website which did have some pretty big SEO problems, duplicate content being one of the main ones!!
Looking back at ranking data the website ranked very well for it's main keyword, #5 for Google, Yahoo and Bing.
The ranking then dropped in February 2012 for Google to #64 but stayed the same for Yahoo and Bing.
I scrapped the dodgy content and completely rewrote it using a Wordpress framework about 6 weeks ago, still targeting the same keywords and 301 redirecting the old pages to the new pages where applicable.
My rankings for Yahoo and Bing are still maintaining their page 1 rankings but Google is still ranking the website on page 5/6.
My question is. Is the website getting punished for something that was part of the old website? If so how can I find out what it is and fix it?
This website ranked on page 1 for Google for most of it's popular keywords but now it doesn't.
I appreciate any feedback
Many Thanks : )
-
Hey Alex
Is it possible to get a link so we can review in more detail? Without a link, I can give you some general feedback and I am sure we can try to flesh this out a bit further.
If you had tons of duplicate content and had a traffic drop in Feb then Panda is a likely candidate but if you have removed the duplication and built a new site then that should have resolved those issues.
There is nothing to say you have not picked up another penalty though or have some other problem and Penguin is the next likely candidate to review. So, check your analytics and see if there were further traffic organic traffic drops from Google on April 24 and/or May 25.
If so, then you likely have external issues (links) that may be effecting your chance to rank.
Action Points
1. Set up a new campaign for the site in the SEOMoz tools and be fastidious in resolving any reported errors
2. Review the traffic losses in Google analytics and compare against the dates of known algorithm changes here
3. Review any messages and or problems in Google Webmaster Tools
4. Once you have identified any Panda / Penguin problems or any other issues then attempt to resolve them. There are several good guides online and I have a few simplified ones over at my site or check out the posts on Penguin and Panda over at Distilled.
Summary
Ultimately, it is really hard without a link to give a specific review but it sounds like some kind of penalty or devaluation to drop from page 1 to page 6. Likewise, the fact you still rank in Yahoo & Bing would indicate that the site is being penalised. It could be a manual penalty or one of the algorithmic penalties. If you have resolved the duplication issues (check against copyscape and the moz tools) and have no manual penalty (check in webmaster tools for messages) then the likely candidate is external issues so a spammy or manipulative link profile.
Hope this helps and feel free to fire over a link so we can give some feedback specific to your site.
Marcus
References
1. Simple Google Penguin Audit
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
I added a WP Customer Reviews plugin but nothing seems to appear on Google search
Hi, I've added the wordpress Wp Customer Reviews plugin to a my client's website and we brought some past clients to put on reviews in order to empower the hReview factor. Google as scraped the website several times since but we don't see any change in the organic serp. Can you please tell me if I've done something wrong or I forgot something? That's the website - Capital Garage Door Thanks!
Technical SEO | | captainjoe0 -
How could you make a URL/Breadcrumb structure appear different in Google than when you click into site?
I'm seeing a competitor be able to make their URL/Breadcrumb stucture appear different in Google than on the site. Google shows a 3-4 category silo for the page but once clicked the page is off root. How could you do this?
Technical SEO | | TicketCity0 -
Unnatural links from your site
Hi, 24 February got this penalty message in Google webmaster tool. Google detected a pattern of unnatural, artificial, deceptive, or manipulative outbound links on pages on this site. This may be the result of selling links that pass PageRank or participating in link schemes. Already removed all the link on the blog and sent reconsideration request to Google spam team. But request is rejected. Please help me on this or share link with me on same case. Thanks,
Technical SEO | | KLLC0 -
Searching in Google using the Site:www.example.com specification - is it in an order?
Hi Gurus, Just a quick searching question. If you do a Google search using the site: specification eg. site:www.example.com Is the list returned by Google in an order of something similar to 'Page Authority' or some other order eg. page first seen date etc. Because you are looking at your single site, is Google listing your pages back to you in it's perceived order of current 'popularity'? Thanks, Brad
Technical SEO | | BM70 -
Hit by Google
My site - www.northernlightsiceland.com - has been hit by google and Im not sure why. The traffic dropped 75% last 24 hours and all the most important keywords have dropped significantly in the SERP. The only issue I can think of are the subpages for the northern lights forecasting I did every day e.g. http://www.northernlightsiceland.com/northern-lights-forecast-iceland-3-oct-2012/ I have been simply doing a copy/paste for 1 month the same subpage, but only changing the top part (Summary) for each day. Could this be the reason why Im penalized? I have now simply taken them all down minus the last 3 days (that are relevant). What can I do to get up on my feet again? This is mission critical for me as you can imagine. Im wondering if it got hit by this EMD update on 28 sept that was focusing on exact match domains http://www.webmasterworld.com/google/4501349-1-30.htm
Technical SEO | | rrrobertsson0 -
Site Categorization?
I know getting site categories to appear under the site are dependent on a lot of factors including site mapping. We have a site that does the categorization thing when you type in the sites url name however more people search for the name of the talent to find the site and the short url on the site is just his name, but shorter. However I was just wondering is their a way to optimize the site so that way we could get categorization to show up under the sites URL when they search for the talents full name I ask because the amount of people looking for the talents full name rather than the short name is a lot larger and I would like to see if we can take advantage of the real estate, but I honestly don't think there is a way, however I figured I would open it up to discussion to see if anyone has any ideas. Example: Site name is ABCD you type this into Google and you get ABCD.com about blog how to contact However the actual person whose site it is is ABCDEF and when you type that in you just get: ABCD.com without any of the categories appearing below the url. And that is what I'm asking about. Thanks as I can't seem to find a lot of information on this. However if there is another spot on the site talking about this please let me know I may just not be searching with the right terms.
Technical SEO | | KateGMaker0 -
Google Shopping Australia/Google Merchant Centre
So Google Shopping has finally landed in Australia so we've got some work todo hooking it up to our client ecom sites. Right now we have a handful of clients who are setup, the feed is getting in their ok but all products are sitting in "disapproved" status in the dashboard and clicking into each individual product the status says awaiting review. I logged a support ticket with Google to get some more info on this as it doesn't look right to me (ie the disapproved status in dashboard) and got a useless templated answer. Seems that if I switch the country destination to US the products are approved and live in google.com shopping search within the hour. Switch back to Australia and they go back to disapproved status. Anyone having the same issue/seen this before? I simply don't trust Google support and wondering if there's other factors at play here.
Technical SEO | | Brendo0 -
Google Website Optimizer
So if you are AB testing two pages: index.html and indexB.html Shouldn't I nofollow indexB.html? It has all the same content, just a different design.
Technical SEO | | tylerfraser0