Duplicate content vs. less content

[SurfingNosara]

Hi, I run a site that is currently doing very well in google for the terms that we want.  We are 1,2 or 3 for our 4 targeted terms, but havent been able to jump to number one in two categories that I would really like to.

In looking at our site, I didn't realize we have a TON of duplicate content as seen by SEO moz and I guess google.  It appears to be coming from our forum, we use drupal.  RIght now we have over 4500 pages of duplicate content.

Here is my question:  How much is this hurting us as we are ranking high.  Is it better to kill the forum (which is more community service than business) and have a very tight site SEO-wise, or leave the forum even with the duplicate content.

Thanks for your help.  Erik

[SurfingNosara]

|

This is from seomoz crawl report.  mostly all of it is forum and user profiles.

Hobie Singlefin 9'4 Takeda Fish 5'7 | Surfing Nosara

http://www.surfingnosara.com/forum/hobie-singlefin-94-takeda-fish-57

Hobie Singlefin 9'4 Takeda Fish 5'7 | Surfing Nosara

http://www.surfingnosara.com/forum/hobie-singlefin-94-takeda-fish-57-0

|

WA Jer | Surfing Nosara

http://www.surfingnosara.com/users/wa-jer

wavekitegirl | Surfing Nosara

http://www.surfingnosara.com/users/wavekitegirl

White Abbot | Surfing Nosara

http://www.surfingnosara.com/users/white-abbot |

|

[mikeusry]

The -0 is Drupal's way of handling duplicate page titles, duplicate file names etc.  You may indeed have an issue where two "nodes" are being generated.  If this is the case you are basically creating a competitor for yourself.

Do you want to share the site and two URL's that are duplicated?

[SurfingNosara]

Thank your for the responses.  We have a popular ride board that is awesome, and some buy and sell... other than that most of our forum has moved to our Facebook page.  About 1/3 of the duplicate content has a -0 after the title.  I am not sure how to take it out from the robots.txt file.

i guess the heart of my questions is I have always thought that all the content from the forum would help us in SEO.  Is it possible that it is really hurting us?  How does google look at a site that has a ton of pages ( we are an old site that keeps all of our content so folks can search it, old surf reports...)  but a ton of errors and duplicate content.  How much will solving errors and duplicate content help vs. just working on more links?  Where do i focus energy?

[Nobody1560986989723]

Don't take down a forum if it has an active community, instead focus on the canonical control of the forum. Depending on your Drupal set-up this could be tricky to implement. That being the case then you could always block Googlebot's access to the duplicated pages then remove the URLs from the index through GWT. The last option would be to review your Drupal template and insert a PHP conditional statement to issue a noindex,follow command in the robots meta tag, for certain pages. Look at the URLs and see if there's a pattern as to which pages are the 'duplicates' and try to match that pattern. Hope something here helped.

[SoftzSolutions]

_I am assuming that you are referring internal duplicate content issue. In that case, I would rather suggest you to fix them by adding canonical or by adding noindex Meta data or by specifying some rules in robots.txt file. No need to remove the forum if it is adding value to user experience. However, if you feel that your forum is getting ruled by spammers and trolls, you should take down the whole thing. I hope that it would do good to your website in the long run. _