Massive Jump In Competitor Domain Authority In 1 year...How?!
-
We have noticed a competitor of one of our clients has leapfrogged massively in terms of their Domain Authority, Links, actually pretty much everything in the space of a year. We have been working diligently with our client building up a solid seo strategy based on content and organic link backs, but we're at a loss of how to try and explain the gains by the competitor over them.
I have attached the competitor analysis from April 2012 and Feb 2013 below.
Any help, ideas, conspiracy theories etc. are welcome!
Thanks
-
Don't be surprised by Google's inability to penalise obvious breaches to its TOS. So many sites slip under the radar.
Case in point, after looking through the top backlinks in OSE and MajesticSEO after you sent me the URL (thank you very much by the way), I think it's clear how they've done it.
There is an absolute ton of links coming from high PA/DA .jp and other Japanese domains pointing to the site.
Furthermore, it looks as though the site may have been hacked at some point, because there's a load of high PA/DA viagra links as well - most of which look deleted now.
Both of these sort of links, while without question unnatural, would pass page and domain authority to the site. As for why it hasn't been penalised yet? Well, you may be able to see that the linking anchor text to the site is 95% raw URLs (as in: http://www.example.com/). This means that they would not have triggered any Penguine threshold for over optimised anchor text, leaving it to the algorithm to work out the spam another way, and perhaps it will only be penalised when reviewed manually.
It's an absolute ton of raw URL links coming from high PA/DA, but completely suspicious and irrelevant, websites that has caused the site's authority to sky rocket.
Hope this helps clarify a few things.
-
Hi Tom, thanks for the reply. Yes I went through the competitor backlinks to see if there were any spammy type links but there doesn't seem to be, also I'm assuming that at this stage Google would have well penalised them for spammy .edu links with the various updates throughout the last year...
It's definately not quality content, the site is stuck in the late 90's in terms of design and there is absolutely no new content being posted to the site at all...
-
Without knowing the competitor, it's impossible to say how it was done. Could be a number of things - some legitimate, some not.
All I can do is refer to the Moz document on Domain Authority so you can run through your competitors backlinks and see how that score was increased. Could just be quality content marketing to the homepage and a number of internal pages, could be something more sinister like .edu blog spamming.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
'spammy' domains redirecting to website
Hi Everyone, I hope that someone will be able to help us with this one as we have trawled the internet looking for a solution! We have multiple domains (.com/.co.uk/.net versions) which all point to the one website, however, some of these domains have a high spam score - 9-11. Our first initial reaction would be to remove the auto redirects, but, the other domains have been a source of conversion in previous months (or so analytics tells us). So what I'm wondering, is do we remove the 'spammy' links from redirecting to our site, or do we leave them there? We certainly don't want to risk a penalty. Thanks for reading!
Link Building | | hydra_creative0 -
Case Study of Massively Successful Tool?
Hi, all. I'm working with a client and trying to come up with an example or two of a tool that attracted huge numbers of inbound links. What come to my mind is the original Zillow home pricing tool. When that came out, it kind of blew people's minds that you could put in any address in the United States and you'd get a (moderately) accurate assessment of a home value. If I recall, they got a bajillion links overnight. I don't need an example quite at that scale (in fact, a smaller success might be better), but I definitely want something a little more recent (even if just the last five years). Any suggestions for me? Much obliged. -Erik
Link Building | | JB_Upstart1 -
When a competitor site jumps from 4000 to 10000 links in 2 months are they most likely spamming?
One of my competitors site's jumped from about 4000 links 2 months ago to about 10000 links today. That seems REALLY unnatural to me given the market (roofing products), but if it isn't what are they doing? My gut tells me it's fake, but I'm just curious what some of your takes on it are.
Link Building | | kadesmith0 -
Keyword strong domains`and Good Link Building Techniques
Is it still a vital tactic if you can get a keyword strong domain in your seo strategy. I have been using an outsourced link building company and we have been soing social bookmarks and directory listings and forum posts. What i sthe best way to check if a link is good ? Look forward to any help, I am a new member
Link Building | | simon.paul0 -
Where I need to jump? Web OR Social OR Local Directories
I am working on patio umbrellas keyword to achieve top 3 ranking in Google. I have achieved top 30 ranking with help of on page optimization and want to achieve top 3 ranking with help of link building. Today, I was checking SEO web directories on SEOmoz. Now, I can't make any changes on live website exclude content. So, I have only one option to deal with link building. There are 3 sections over there including Web Directories, Social Directories & Local Directories. So, which is best one to improve my ranking on Google? If anyone have additional inputs for link building so eager to know that. I want to achieve top 3 ranking with my keyword by next 2 months.
Link Building | | CommercePundit0 -
Confused why wesbite is number 1 in Google
Hi All, Wonder if you can help someone who is not a SEO professional? I am trying to optimise my website for the term "driving lessons brighton" and when i search on this keyword with &pws=0 the following website http://strictly-driving.co.uk/ is number 1. However I cant see why they are number 1? As they dont really have any links etc. Any advice on why they are so high would be appreciated. Thanks a lot.
Link Building | | Ant710 -
1 million links can harm your site?
I have a client that bought a link for his site on a non related site with the anchor text for main KW. That site brought over 1 million links to my client's site. Now what should i do? Should i let the link there? Or should i remove it? The age of the link is more than 1 year, and the link is placed in top menu, under the header.
Link Building | | maldiniii0 -
Ranking above Auth domains question?
Hi, How difficult would it be to rank a new page above the likes of Wiki, About, Squidoo etc? I have a keyword I would like rank but most of the domains on first page are the likes of the above, wiki, about, squidoo etc. The pages themselves dont have a high Page Auth its just the root domain. Will it still be very hard to rank above these types of sites? Cheers
Link Building | | activitysuper0