Help - Lost Ranking - What did I screw up?!
-
Hi,
We're working with a local service provider with a location specific keyword (not a real example: "orlando plumbing contractors").
Background:
In recent history the client updated a new site design and upgraded from Joomla 1.5 to Joomla 2.5. Of course there were duplicate content issues which have been resolved with the help of AceSEF. Duplicate content, title tags, and other content issues are handled as soon as they appear in GWT or MOZ.Additionally, a high number of backlinks were lost when the latest Google update hit. Many of these sites were of sites that no longer existed or were spammy and flushed out. Some were lost due to the previous SEO firm literally removing backlinks and switching them to their new client (seo firm was putting all of the work the client paid for under their name to control everything).
Current Situation: The backlink loss seems to have been stopped (hopefully) because we are using a new strategy that relies solely on the quality of the links, surrounding text, varied anchor text, relevancy, etc.) However, we tried an experiment on just one of the clients keywords. That experiment seems to have blown up in our faces evidently.
The landing page for the location specific keyword has dropped from the index completely (it seems), but only when searching broad. When using exact match with quotes like the example quoted above ("orlando plumbing contractors") the landing page appears, but several ranks lower. We were ranked yesterday 6/23/13, but as of today 6/24/13 are no longer ranked.
On broad matches, non-relevant sites and even a site that shows only a broken server configuration is outranking the client (they appear for the broad search, but the client does not).
What Was Done
We recently created a press release for and posted it on a press release site. We then created a link back to the landing page (exact match anchor text). We posted the PR article to several social sites (Google plus, folkd, delicious, twitter, stumble upon, diigo).We also created a blog article (on-site) on site for that, creating links back to the landing page (the links all had exact anchor text). We posted that blog article to social news sites (facebook, stumble, delicious) and included a ping. The PR article was manually rewritten and posted to the PR site (we had to make 2 versions of the PR; one for the blog and one for the PR site).
The Result
The client ending up dropping off the broad search rankings, but only slipped a few for "exact match" (with quotes). The PR article that was created is now ranked on page 3 for the board keyword and is still beat by non working sites.We suspect that the exact anchor text could be causing this problem. Anyone else have an idea (we're scratching our heads and trying not to freak out at the same time).
-
I also wanted to put in a little update that we've noticed in this niche particularly. When we follow the basic outline of the strategy above, we notice that the onsite article gets ranked quickly, while the target landing page drops off out of results for about half a day. No later than the next day is the landing page back in place and the onsite (blog article if you will) is removed from rankings.
I suppose this is just the Google shuffle or something similar happening. Fortunately we've removed all but 8 errors (out of 3000) and we're just waiting for GWT to update to reflect that information.
-
I just saw that as well - good eye!
-
Todd,
I really think you're right on every point there.
1. We have been looking at the backlink profile pretty good. It appears that the first SEO company was just starting out with this site so I see a quite a few paid link directories that were popular a few years back. Fortunately, a big chunk of them have stopped out of violation and the links are slowly being de-indexed altogether. I imagine that the both the quality and loss of the links is hurting us while things sort and readjust. Once all of the links are removed from the index, I believe we can cross this portion of the list (for now - must remain ever vigilant).
2. In progress - takes a bit of time. We're also trying to make sure that the citations are built on local IPs as well.
3. I agree - fortunately the anchor text is varied so I believe that we will be ok here as well. We are updating any gregarious usage of exact match anchor text as well.
4. This was one of the few things that the last SEO company did correctly. The internal link structure is definitely varied.
Thanks for your help on these suggestions. Our client has a pretty good decent branding scheme so its a nice way to build links with that anchor text and variations to use.
-
Google just updated thier link scheme document:
https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66356?hl=en
Links with optimized anchor text in articles or press releases distributed on other sites. For example:
There are many wedding rings on the market. If you want to have a wedding, you will have to pick the best ring. You will also need to buy flowers and a wedding dress. -
I get suspicious anytime I hear about exact match press release links. In my experience they can do little to help you, and everything to hurt.
Whenever I submit a press release I always use url links (example.com) or generic anchors, never a "money" term. This is because Google views press releases as non-editorial, and tends to devalue most links they see coming from these sources.
If that exact match link that you embedded in your press release is widely distributed across multiple sites and distribution platforms, then you're in even deeper.
There's been some talk by Google of late that the newer class of penalties and algorythmic filters can act more at the page level (whereas before they tended to be applied broadly to the entire domain.) This means if you're trying to clean things up, you can start by addressing the one page with the over-optimized links and working your way out from there.
I'd start by trying to remove the links, then possibly using the disavow if you aren't successful. Finally, if the page doesn't have a very strong backlink profile you can simply remove it and serve a 404 or 410 status code, and then remove it from the index using the Remove URL tool in Google Webmaster Tools.
Not sure if this relates to what is happening on your site or not - it's pure speculation on my part. Regardless, I hope it helps in some small way.
Cheers,
Cyrus
-
Hi Imedia, thanks for explaining your situation. Hopefully I can be of help:
Inbound link profile
1. In terms of inbound links, my concern would be the quality type of links that can be 'pulled and re-plugged'. Generally, it is difficult to do this with links that are earned or naturally given, as they usually only relate to one client and assets and resources that client has (great web design, awesome guides, white papers, blog posts).
I would focus on first ensuring that the back link profile is natural and correct. Here is a great guide in my opinion to removing poor links and disavowing them. Remember to always first contact webmasters and request irrelevant and low quality links removed first. Google wants to see that you have acted on links.
2. If you want to rank in Google Local: Build local citations. Darren Shaw from Whitespark has plenty of fantastic knowledge published on the Internet and on his blog. Mike Blumenthal is also highly qualified in local.
3. I would recommend staying away from anchor text in press releases altogether. My take on press releases is that the value of the link is really directly proportional to the quality / newsworthiness of the story itself. Great stories are shared and linked to, improving the social signals and engagement signals and inbound links to that piece. Using exact match anchor texts in press releases is probably not necessary and might be working against you because it makes it more difficult to assess over-optimization issues if they happen.
Try and ensure any exact match links are in natural, editorial content, so that you can try to rule out which particular pieces might be counting for and against you when diagnosing over optimization and position drops.
4. Also linking internally with Exact Match can do double damage to rankings if particular thresholds are reached. Because Google updates its complex algorithm a lot, it is difficult to understand what those thresholds are. You might consider utilizing a different internal anchor text in this situation and testing it over a long period. You might also consider changing the press release link if possible. However, it is important to understand that changing links can also send signals to Google that can cause ranking flux (commercialize anchor, effect in SERPs, change in anchor = another net change)
A safe bet for internal links is to rarely use exact match internal anchor text, and opt for natural text, mixed brand and mixed commercialized text, and anchor to text that isn't commercial at all (click here, buy it here, learn more here) Focus on building internal links that are driven from content within the website that is well linked to.
In my opinion this also should apply to inbound link anchor text profiles as well, but you will want to study the top 10-20 competitors in this niche (with a close eye on 1-2-3) in order to better understand both individual and aggregate anchor text usage.
Hope this helps!
-Todd
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How to rank for a keyword
Hi guys, I'm looking to rank a new blog for a search term which we currently already rank #1 for. I want to create a blog which provides a better solution to a searchers query and knock our current #1 page for this new one. Is there a way to do this simply without losing the real-estate the currently ranked #1 page has already accumulated? Or is just a matter of working on this new blog to find it's own way to the top? Thanks in advance, James
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | jameseacott0 -
Help With Href Lang Implementation
Hi, We've received the following Href Lang errors in Google Search Console. After much research and playing around with the tags we're still no closer to fixing the issues. ERRORS; http://prntscr.com/du8ei8 AND http://prntscr.com/du8evi As you'll see, Google is telling us that some URLs do not have return tags, but they do seem to! Does anyone know of a pro that can provide a service to fix this for us? Many thanks in advance, Lee.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Webpresence0 -
Google Indexing & Caching Some Other Domain In Place of Mine-Lost Ranking -Sucuri.net Found nothing
Again I am facing same Problem with another wordpress blog. Google has suddenly started to Cache a different domain in place of mine & caching my domain in place of that domain. Here is an example page of my site which is wrongly cached on google, same thing happening with many other pages as well - http://goo.gl/57uluq That duplicate site ( protestage.xyz) is showing fully copied from my client's site but showing all pages as 404 now but on google cache its showing my sites. site:protestage.xyz showing all pages of my site only but when we try to open any page its showing 404 error My site has been scanned by sucuri.net Senior Support for any malware & there is none, they scanned all files, database etc & there is no malware found on my site. As per Sucuri.net Senior Support It's a known Google bug. Sometimes they incorrectly identify the original and the duplicate URLs, which results in messed ranking and query results. As you can see, the "protestage.xyz" site was hacked, not yours. And the hackers created "copies" of your pages on that hacked site. And this is why they do it - the "copy" (doorway) redirects websearchers to a third-party site [http://www.unmaskparasites.com/security-report/?page=protestage.xyz](http://www.unmaskparasites.com/security-report/?page=protestage.xyz) It was not the only site they hacked, so they placed many links to that "copy" from other sites. As a result Google desided that that copy might actually be the original, not the duplicate. So they basically hijacked some of your pages in search results for some queries that don't include your site domain. Nonetheless your site still does quite well and outperform the spammers. For example in this query: [https://www.google.com/search?q=](https://www.google.com/search?q=)%22We+offer+personalized+sweatshirts%22%2C+every+bride#q=%22GenF20+Plus+Review+Worth+Reading+If+You+are+Planning+to+Buy+It%22 But overall, I think both the Google bug and the spammy duplicates have the negative effect on your site. We see such hacks every now and then (both sides: the hacked sites and the copied sites) and here's what you can do in this situation: It's not a hack of your site, so you should focus on preventing copying the pages: 1\. Contact the protestage.xyz site and tell them that their site is hacked and that and show the hacked pages. [https://www.google.com/search?q=](https://www.google.com/search?q=)%22We+offer+personalized+sweatshirts%22%2C+every+bride#q=%22GenF20+Plus+Review+Worth+Reading+If+You+are+Planning+to+Buy+It%22 Hopefully they clean their site up and your site will have the unique content again. Here's their email flang.juliette@yandex.com 2\. You might want to send one more complain to their hosting provider (OVH.NET) abuse@ovh.net, and explain that the site they host stole content from your site (show the evidence) and that you suspect the the site is hacked. 3\. Try blocking IPs of the Aruba hosting (real visitors don't use server IPs) on your site. This well prevent that site from copying your site content (if they do it via a script on the same server). I currently see that sites using these two IP address: 149.202.120.102\. I think it would be safe to block anything that begins with 149.202 This .htaccess snippet should help (you might want to test it) #-------------- Order Deny,Allow Deny from 149.202.120.102 #-------------- 4\. Use rel=canonical to tell Google that your pages are the original ones. [https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/139066?hl=en](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/139066?hl=en) It won't help much if the hackers still copy your pages because they usually replace your rel=canonical with their, so Google can' decide which one is real. But without the rel=canonical, hackers have more chances to hijack your search results especially if they use rel=canonical and you don't. I should admit that this process may be quite long. Google will not return your previous ranking overnight even if you manage to shut down the malicious copies of your pages on the hacked site. Their indexes would still have some mixed signals (side effects of the black hat SEO campaign) and it may take weeks before things normalize. The same thing is correct for the opposite situation. The traffic wasn't lost right after hackers created the duplicates on other sites. The effect build up with time as Google collects more and more signals. Plus sometimes they run scheduled spam/duplicate cleanups of their index. It's really hard to tell what was the last drop since we don't have access to Google internals. However, in practice, if you see some significant changes in Google search results, it's not because of something you just did. In most cases, it's because of something that Google observed for some period of time. Kindly help me if we can actually do anything to get the site indexed properly again, PS it happened with this site earlier as well & that time I had to change Domain to get rid of this problem after I could not find any solution after months & now it happened again. Looking forward for possible solution Ankit
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | killthebillion0 -
Homepage is losing rankings...need help!
Hi folks, Our company has been doing SEO for www.3dincites.com since October. Since the website hadn't been optimized at all, one of the first things we did was to add keyword-optimized page title and meta description to the homepage. The person who implemented didn't do it right the first time so we needed to change the page title again after a week or so. We also changed the preferred domain in GWT. Ever since those changes were implemented, the homepage has been decreasing in rankings for the the keywords we optimized it for. This is very surprising as the website has high-quality unique content and pretty solid backlinks. Moreover, the search traffic to other pages is through the roof (2K increase since October) so the client is happy, however, this decrease in rankings for the homepage (from 3d to 6th page for "3d IC technology" which is the main keyword) doesn't let me sleep well at nights. Any ideas why this is happening?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | zoomzoom0 -
Why is my blog out-ranking my main site?
Please see attached ranking history chart. On June 5th the chart shows that my main site is not coming up under our main keyword "door hangers" From then on, our blog took over. Any ideas why? Thanks Andrea lpEBciu.jpg
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | JimDirectMailCoach0 -
If I had an issue with a friendly URL module and I lost all my rankings. Will they return now that issue is resolved next time I'm crawled by google?
I have 'magic seo urls' installed on my zencart site. Except for some reason no one can explain why or how the files were disabled. So my static links went back to dynamic (index.php?**********) etc. The issue was resolved with the module except in that time google must have crawled my site and I lost all my rankings. I'm nowher to be found in the top 50. Did this really cause such an extravagant SEO issue as my web developers told me? Can I expect my rankings to return next time my site is crawled by google?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Pete790 -
Bing Ranking Factors
I have a site and we rank very competitively on Google, but we would like to increase our exposure on Bing and Yahoo. I was wondering if anybody might have some tips or pointers for increasing your ranking on Bing. Also, if anybody knows of any Bing ranking guides or top ranking factors for Bing that would be very useful too. Thanks, Jason
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Jason_3420 -
Pages On Subfolder Not Ranking
A subdirectory/folder on our website doesn't seem to rank for any keywords where the same type of pages on the same competition level keywords rank perfectly fine. For awhile the pages weren't getting indexed but were crawled regularly. Can't seem to figure the problem out.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | bprimeelitellc0