Skip to content
    Moz logo Menu open Menu close
    • Products
      • Moz Pro
      • Moz Pro Home
      • Moz Local
      • Moz Local Home
      • STAT
      • Moz API
      • Moz API Home
      • Compare SEO Products
      • Moz Data
    • Free SEO Tools
      • Domain Analysis
      • Keyword Explorer
      • Link Explorer
      • Competitive Research
      • MozBar
      • More Free SEO Tools
    • Learn SEO
      • Beginner's Guide to SEO
      • SEO Learning Center
      • Moz Academy
      • SEO Q&A
      • Webinars, Whitepapers, & Guides
    • Blog
    • Why Moz
      • Agency Solutions
      • Enterprise Solutions
      • Small Business Solutions
      • Case Studies
      • The Moz Story
      • New Releases
    • Log in
    • Log out
    • Products
      • Moz Pro

        Your all-in-one suite of SEO essentials.

      • Moz Local

        Raise your local SEO visibility with complete local SEO management.

      • STAT

        SERP tracking and analytics for enterprise SEO experts.

      • Moz API

        Power your SEO with our index of over 44 trillion links.

      • Compare SEO Products

        See which Moz SEO solution best meets your business needs.

      • Moz Data

        Power your SEO strategy & AI models with custom data solutions.

      NEW Keyword Suggestions by Topic
      Moz Pro

      NEW Keyword Suggestions by Topic

      Learn more
    • Free SEO Tools
      • Domain Analysis

        Get top competitive SEO metrics like DA, top pages and more.

      • Keyword Explorer

        Find traffic-driving keywords with our 1.25 billion+ keyword index.

      • Link Explorer

        Explore over 40 trillion links for powerful backlink data.

      • Competitive Research

        Uncover valuable insights on your organic search competitors.

      • MozBar

        See top SEO metrics for free as you browse the web.

      • More Free SEO Tools

        Explore all the free SEO tools Moz has to offer.

      What is your Brand Authority?
      Moz

      What is your Brand Authority?

      Check yours now
    • Learn SEO
      • Beginner's Guide to SEO

        The #1 most popular introduction to SEO, trusted by millions.

      • SEO Learning Center

        Broaden your knowledge with SEO resources for all skill levels.

      • On-Demand Webinars

        Learn modern SEO best practices from industry experts.

      • How-To Guides

        Step-by-step guides to search success from the authority on SEO.

      • Moz Academy

        Upskill and get certified with on-demand courses & certifications.

      • SEO Q&A

        Insights & discussions from an SEO community of 500,000+.

      Unlock flexible pricing & new endpoints
      Moz API

      Unlock flexible pricing & new endpoints

      Find your plan
    • Blog
    • Why Moz
      • Small Business Solutions

        Uncover insights to make smarter marketing decisions in less time.

      • Agency Solutions

        Earn & keep valuable clients with unparalleled data & insights.

      • Enterprise Solutions

        Gain a competitive edge in the ever-changing world of search.

      • The Moz Story

        Moz was the first & remains the most trusted SEO company.

      • Case Studies

        Explore how Moz drives ROI with a proven track record of success.

      • New Releases

        Get the scoop on the latest and greatest from Moz.

      Surface actionable competitive intel
      New Feature

      Surface actionable competitive intel

      Learn More
    • Log in
      • Moz Pro
      • Moz Local
      • Moz Local Dashboard
      • Moz API
      • Moz API Dashboard
      • Moz Academy
    • Avatar
      • Moz Home
      • Notifications
      • Account & Billing
      • Manage Users
      • Community Profile
      • My Q&A
      • My Videos
      • Log Out

    The Moz Q&A Forum

    • Forum
    • Questions
    • Users
    • Ask the Community

    Welcome to the Q&A Forum

    Browse the forum for helpful insights and fresh discussions about all things SEO.

    1. Home
    2. SEO Tactics
    3. Intermediate & Advanced SEO
    4. Site Architecture: Cross Linking vs. Siloing

    Moz Q&A is closed.

    After more than 13 years, and tens of thousands of questions, Moz Q&A closed on 12th December 2024. Whilst we’re not completely removing the content - many posts will still be possible to view - we have locked both new posts and new replies. More details here.

    Site Architecture: Cross Linking vs. Siloing

    Intermediate & Advanced SEO
    8
    48
    15973
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as question
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with question management privileges can see it.
    • DonnieCooper
      DonnieCooper last edited by

      I'm curious to know what other mozzers think about silo's...

      Can we first all agree that a flat site architecture is the best practice? Relevant pages should be grouped together. Shorter, broader and (usually) therefore higher volume keywords should be towards the top of each category. Navigation should flow from general to specific. Agreed?

      As Google say's on page 10 of their SEO Starter Guide, "you should think about how visitors will go from a general page (your root page) to a page containing more specific content ." OK, we all agree so far, right? Great!

      Enter my question: Bruce Clay (among others) seem to recommend siloing as a best practice. While Richard Baxter (and many others @ SEOmoz), seem to view silos as a problem.

      Me? I've practiced (relevant) internal cross linking, and have intentionally avoided siloing in almost all cases.

      What about you? Is there a time and place to use silos? If so, when and where? If not, how do we rectify the seemingly huge differences of opinions between expert folks such as Baxter and Clay?

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 7
      • SystemIDBarcodes
        SystemIDBarcodes last edited by

        I am confused. So lets that I have an ecommerce site that has 20 types(books, toys…) / 20 categories each / 20 subcategories each and thousands of products under each subcategory.

        When we say go flat, is it ideal to go all the way like http://www.website.com/type (20 of these), and http://www.website.com/category (400 of these) and http://www.webiste.com/subcategory (8000 of these)and thousands of product pages. So there is no page more than  1 directory level down. Does this mean flat architecture?

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • AlanBleiweiss
          AlanBleiweiss @helpwanted last edited by

          the breadcrumb is one more signal about where you are in the process, on the site, in the section.  Google also likes them and will often show the breadcrumb navigation links right in search results.  They try to emulate breadcrumbs sometimes in search results if you don't have them, but if they do, since you're not feeding them an actual breadcrumb, theirs can sometimes guess wrong at the keywords they show in them.

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • helpwanted
            helpwanted last edited by

            Hi Alan...

            Is there a case study -- where a silo is broken down  and analyzed that I can use to understand this siloing concept !

            My understanding of A Silo is -- you for example if you have a grocery store website - you create a dairy section then all related dairy products are found here and a deli dept then all cold cuts in this section  etcc where all the pages are themed from the top then on downward, and trying to keep the silo 3 clicks from home

            The breadcrumb -- not sure how this comes into play but if I keep the site 3 clicks from home at any time someone needs to get back to where they started from they are able to do it, so how does the breadcrumb help if I am already trying to keep the structure a 3 click structure for easy navigation and easy exit back to beginning.

            AlanBleiweiss 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • DonnieCooper
              DonnieCooper @toddmumford last edited by

              Hey Todd, thanks.

              While I definitely agree about having tightly themed categories, I'm not quite sure I am sold on using a silo. Correct me if I'm wrong here please, but isn't a silo when you don't cross link detail pages (within the same category) with each other? I think Alan feels the same way, or perhaps I've misunderstood.

              Check this post about the importance of link architecture by Google. Specifically, the last Q&A.

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
              • toddmumford
                toddmumford last edited by

                I agree with Alan, and would like to add that I believe that using the silo method can increase the proximity of closely connected clusters of keywords better. In other words, by nature, in a silo structure, tightly knit keywords support each other and pass theme and relevance value to each other by default when a strong supportive breadcrumb is in place. Often with a flat site architecture extra programming needs to be done to establish those relationships as they relate to internal pages.

                DonnieCooper 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                • DonnieCooper
                  DonnieCooper last edited by

                  Anyone have anything else they'd like to toss into the discussion?

                  Any examples you'd like to share of detail page linking vs. silos?

                  [edit] Just found this (old) blog post by Google about the importance of (internal) link architecture... I quote:

                  Q: Let's say my website is about my favorite hobbies: biking and camping. Should I keep my internal linking architecture "themed" and not cross-link between the two?

                  A: We haven't found a case where a webmaster would benefit by intentionally "theming" their link architecture for search engines. And, keep-in-mind, if a visitor to one part of your site can't easily reach other parts of your site, that may be a problem for search engines as well.

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                  • AlanBleiweiss
                    AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                    exactly.  "Tags" and "materials" are not exactly top level category stuff 🙂

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                    • dignan99
                      dignan99 @DonnieCooper last edited by

                      I found a relatively "ghetto" approach to silo using wordpress, since I don't have the time or technical skill to implement it perfectly.  Using a specific plugin, it will compare posts and reference a set number of related at the bottom, creating a link structure similar to a silo.  It's not perfect but it is easy.

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • DonnieCooper
                        DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                        Yeah, your right. I would image those links aren't relevant when on store pages, and would definitely distract some people 🙂

                        On their product pages though, they use some cross linking to relevant topics. But I'm sure it's at the bottom- out of site- as to not distract people. So I would image those are mostly there for SEO. Would you agree?

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                        • AlanBleiweiss
                          AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                          Etsy's got a good structure with their category and sub-category sidebar that balances SEO and user experience.  note though that when you get deep into the individual Etsy stores, that's gone, because it would dilute the individual store owner's account focus and distract users.

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                          • dignan99
                            dignan99 @DonnieCooper last edited by

                            I found a relatively "ghetto" approach to silo using wordpress, since I don't have the time or technical skill to implement it perfectly.  Using a specific plugin, it will compare posts and reference a set number of related at the bottom, creating a link structure similar to a silo.  It's not perfect but it is easy.

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • DonnieCooper
                              DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                              I think you're right Alan, that makes great sense. Thanks. Do you think Etsy's sidebar is a good compromise between the two? I'm sure testing each site is the best way to figure out what users prefer on that specific site. But in general, do you think that's a good balance to use in order to keep too many links off the page, yet still keep detail pages within a category linking to each other?

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                              • AlanBleiweiss
                                AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                Having all listed and linked is ideal for SEO, however you rapidly cross into usability problems if there are more than a handful. (Would you want 50 or hundred links in a sidebar nav? ) When a site is so big that there are more than a handful that could be linked from that sidebar, it's actually best practice to NOT have any others linked from the sidebar, else you confuse users even more (listing only some, but not all). User Experience is paramount when making these decisions. Even at the expense of SEO in some cases. And if that happens, other tactics need to be employed. Like having a separate, dedicated funnel for "featured properties". Which requires even more unique content in that funnel. But it at least boosts the ranking value for those properties included.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                • dignan99
                                  dignan99 last edited by

                                  Agreed.

                                  I spent some time working on a hybrid silo structure in my blog, and proper cross linking on the main area of the site thanks to the discussion here.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                  • DonnieCooper
                                    DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                    Sorry for the confusion Alan, and thank you very much for the discussion.

                                    To help clarify for others reading this discussion (and for myself), are we both agreeing that: in the attached image it is an 'SEO AND usability best practice' for the hotel detail pages inside the Tallahassee category/directory to link to each other?

                                    *Of course, there are always caveats,  such the maximum outbound link limit recommended by Google, etc.

                                    But as a general practice, would you have "Hotel 1", "Hotel 2" and "Hotel 3" (inside the "Tallahassee" category) link to one another?

                                    D1i8j.jpg

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                    • EGOL
                                      EGOL last edited by

                                      This is a great question and an even better discussion.

                                      Special thanks to Alan for sharing all of the details.  🙂

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                      • DonnieCooper
                                        DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                        Indeed Alan, that's good advice we all should follow. Thanks. I'll follow suit from here-on 🙂

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • AlanBleiweiss
                                          AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                          You're dead on accurate in the need for and importance of how "consensus" can help new people get started.  The trick is helping them find enough truly experienced people who have done that testing on a wide enough variety of sites, as well as lots of disclaimers being plainly stated on all such discussions.  It's why I strive to always refer to "in my experience"... 🙂

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                          • AlanBleiweiss
                                            AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                            If I have a category California Hotels, sub-category San Francisco Hotels, then having links in a sub-navigation bar to each (if there's only a handful), each of those links reinforces the strength of the top level Hotels, 2nd level California, and third level San Francisco related phrases.  They all support each other.

                                            If, on the other hand, I have a link to "nearby hotels", that implies I'm going from a single hotel details page to a uniquely filtered "geo" category page that shows hotels based on some criteria - it might be all San Francisco, or all within a distance radius, or all within a zip code radius.

                                            Even if it's all other hotels in San Francisco, it's not a link pointing to another (or several) same-level page(s).  It's pointing one layer higher.

                                            That's a filter more than a properly constructed category drill-down.  And it implies that the page I'm on will NOT be listed on that target of the "nearby" link.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                            • DonnieCooper
                                              DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                              Also agreed. However, when new SEOs enter the sphere, they must start somewhere. And, clearly there's value in studying other's work to help clarify, expand or even challenge one's own hypothesis and practices. I also avoid implementing a tactic/ strategy on a paid client project, if reputable SEO's and/or the community as a whole, recommend against it. I may try it on my personal site, but not a customer's. Thanks for all your help Alan.

                                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                              • AlanBleiweiss
                                                AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                just to clarify regarding my input - my perspective is based on my experience with client sites on all scales, small, medium, large and mega sites.

                                                To me it's more important to see how things work on our own sites and evolve them over time as compared to purely looking for what others do or say as it's own reason for taking action.

                                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                • DonnieCooper
                                                  DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                  Respectfully, what's the difference between the nearby hotels example and the cars example?
                                                  More specifically, If these 'nearby hotels' links might dilute that articles topical focus, why wouldn't a link to 'mercedes' from a 'BMW' page?
                                                  Thanks Alan.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                  • DonnieCooper
                                                    DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                    I actually don't, because I've always thought it was a bad idea. But it seems other folks don't think it's so bad under the right circumstances.

                                                    I'd be interested in seeing a good example of an effective silo as well....
                                                    anyone?

                                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                    • DonnieCooper
                                                      DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                      Thanks Dave. This is exactly why I posed this discussion.... it seems as if a lot of us are getting something different from these architecture type posts.

                                                      I think it has to do with making same-level detail pages link to each other. Especially if you link to them using the anchor text they're trying to rank for.

                                                      For example, what I get out of an article like Richard Baxter's post on SEO Architecture, is that detail pages should link to each other, and that Silos should not be used. And the more architecture posts I read on SEOmoz, SEOgadget and Distilled... the more I think it's a 'best practice'.

                                                      That said, it seems from these comments that some folks read those articles differently. I think this is a serious discrepancy that we SEOs should address 🙂

                                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                      • AlanBleiweiss
                                                        AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                        The slides will be going up at some point in the next few days.  And I'll have a follow-up post that includes the notes for each slide.  In the mean time, I did an article on Search Marketing Wisdom yesterday directly related to the last slide in that deck.

                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                        • AlanBleiweiss
                                                          AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                          The "nearby hotels to consider" feature is a user thing.  It may or may not pass quality page rank.

                                                          In some cases, that extra link could dilute the topical focus / strength of the page it's on.

                                                          So if I get to resort X's page, and there's a link to "nearby hotels", there's an implied relationship.  Good for users.  But for SEO, sure it's related stuff, yet maybe not laser focus related.

                                                          Another example is blog posts that end with a following box "related articles" and that box contains three or five links to other articles.  Maybe they're highly related, maybe loosely.  If they're loosely related, sure it MIGHT be good to help users.  Yet it probably dilutes this article's topical focus.

                                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                          • DonnieCooper
                                                            DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                            Agreed, absolutely agreed! Thank you very much Alan!

                                                            PS. Could you share the slides from your presentation at SMX Advanced please? If not, how about a link to a post of yours?

                                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                            • AlanBleiweiss
                                                              AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                              Well it depends. Is there only one BMW or are there several? If there is only one, then yes - cross link all the luxury detail pages.  If there are several, then that's the level for cross linking detail pages, even though it's so deep.  If that's the case though, you'd better get inbound links pointing to the parent luxury category page.

                                                              And in any regard, don't just have a bunch of links on those category pages - have descriptive paragraph content focused on that category's primary topical focus.

                                                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                                                              • blackballonline
                                                                blackballonline @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                Great find on that post. It lays it all out. As long as the silos are thin (not more than 2 layers beneath the home page) it can bring a benefit to adding extra ranking pages with minimal work comparatively. Rand talks about eliminating the bottom layer of the hierarchy to push the content up a level and make the resulting pages extremely stout. The major problem is always going to be the end of the chain. He calls them PageRank sinks.

                                                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                • dignan99
                                                                  dignan99 @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                  Ultimately,  the silo process just takes a bit of time for each new post making sure it links to another category?

                                                                  I know there are plugins for wordpress that will do automatic linking based on any word you input, and it will link a set or random number of times throughout your site.

                                                                  It could be worth setting up for me and just include some keyword phrases in the correct articles just to get the link process going properly.

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                  • DonnieCooper
                                                                    DonnieCooper @dignan99 last edited by

                                                                    Take for example, a resort detail page on oyster.com. They have a section called "nearby hotels to consider", which I believe serves two purposes...
                                                                    #1) it's likely helpful to users, as most people don't restrict themselves to staying at just one specific resort, and
                                                                    #2) it helps search engines flow PageRank, crawl and index other pages in the 'Aruba' category.

                                                                    What I can't figure out is, what benefit would it have to not include these links to nearby hotels? (Except perhaps, on checkout process pages of course.)

                                                                    What if the 'Raddison' Resort for example, got a ton of inbound links and the 'Westin Resort' had only a few? Well, you could cross link them and help the Westin Resort page rank... and simultaneously show your users more relevant options.

                                                                    dignan99 AlanBleiweiss DonnieCooper 12 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                    • DonnieCooper
                                                                      DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                      Yeah, I agree Alan. I don't usually think it's a good return on invested time to practice PageRank sculpting either. One could for example, being building links or generating content with the time/ resources instead 🙂

                                                                      I just re-read what you said, "Individual services details pages should cross-link to each other within that service section at that level though, for usability." To be sure I understand what you're saying.... if your architecture is for example
                                                                      vehicles -> cars -> luxury -> bmw
                                                                      vehicles -> cars -> luxury -> mercedes
                                                                      vehicles -> cars -> luxury -> jaguar
                                                                      then bmw, mercedes and jaguar would link to each other... correct?

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                      • AlanBleiweiss
                                                                        AlanBleiweiss @dignan99 last edited by

                                                                        If anything, sometimes silo structure is not the best for user experience, or the drill down too deep, into ever more thinner content to the point where it's so thin as to have a negative impact on SEO and user experience.

                                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                        • AlanBleiweiss
                                                                          AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                          I agree with Rand's '09 article in general, however there are some things I think take it a bit too far (such as redirecting PDF documents for link juice).  If a PDF is truly the most relevant content on a topic, I believe it should be indexed.

                                                                          The biggest factor is that if we get completely bogged down in this process just for SEO sake, we lose focus on user experience.

                                                                          It's right up there with page and link sculpting - to me, it's a waste of time and harms user experience.  And the time spent going that far is, in my opinion, in 2011 much better spent on other SEO tactics.  Not just because Google has changed how they deal with nofollow links.

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                          • dignan99
                                                                            dignan99 last edited by

                                                                            What are the perceived negative effects, if any, of doing a silo structure?

                                                                            AlanBleiweiss DonnieCooper 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                            • dignan99
                                                                              dignan99 @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                              I spent some time using a silo plugin for a wordpress site early on, and also spent some time with a theme that had a silo format, but ended up switching over to a flat site architecture, I just did like the theme for wordpress that used silo, and the plugin seemed like junk.

                                                                              I'd love to take a look at a well run silo site if you know of one.

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                              • DonnieCooper
                                                                                DonnieCooper @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                                Not at all, thanks Alan. I think we're in agreeance.

                                                                                As long as one is not exceeding Google's approx. outbound links per page... and as long as the the navigation make sense to the users.... specific detail pages within the same category should be linked to each other. Is that what you're saying as well?

                                                                                Here's one example of why I think this is best for indexation reasons. I've attached an image of the page where I circled some stuff 🙂

                                                                                What do you think Alan?

                                                                                nHQf2.jpg

                                                                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                                • AlanBleiweiss
                                                                                  AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                                  Oh - wait I just re-read your question as to not wanting detail pages to link to one another...

                                                                                  If I'm at a sub-category, I would not want, nor need, every individual product/event page in that group to link to each other.  Individual services details pages should cross-link to each other within that service section at that level though, for usability.

                                                                                  Does that make sense? Or did I just confuse you?

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                                                                  • AlanBleiweiss
                                                                                    AlanBleiweiss @DonnieCooper last edited by

                                                                                    Yes - if there are X number of pages within a section, it becomes too many to reasonably link from a sub-nav.  X being a subjective value that needs to be determined case by case.

                                                                                    Ideally, it might lead to yet one more sub-level (such as in sub-sub categories), or in pagination (not blocked from search.  That itself is challenging to do in the right manner so as to avoid going too deep or too thin.

                                                                                    There's no other reason I can think of though, and no other method I'd consider a best practice.

                                                                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                                                                    • DonnieCooper
                                                                                      DonnieCooper @dignan99 last edited by

                                                                                      Thank you dignan99. What's your opinion of silos? Do you like to cross link detail pages within a category to each other, or even category pages to each other?

                                                                                      dignan99 DonnieCooper 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                      • DonnieCooper
                                                                                        DonnieCooper @EGOL last edited by

                                                                                        I definitely agree EGOL. We like to meticulously plan out sites and SEO/PPC campaigns prior to launch, but over time a site's architecture definitely needs to be revisited. Usually at that time, we try to also implement any more advanced programming knowledge we might have accumulated to help ease the pain as well 🙂

                                                                                        Thanks EGOL!

                                                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                        • DonnieCooper
                                                                                          DonnieCooper @blackballonline last edited by

                                                                                          Thank you Dave.

                                                                                          I guess it comes down to flowing PageRank within a category vs. restricting PageRank to the pages that have more links. Any idea why would someone prefer the latter?

                                                                                          blackballonline DonnieCooper AlanBleiweiss 6 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                          • DonnieCooper
                                                                                            DonnieCooper @AlanBleiweiss last edited by

                                                                                            Thanks Alan. You mentioned, "where all the pages in that section have a link to all the other pages in that section".........

                                                                                            Can you think of any reason why you would not want detail pages within a category to link to one another?

                                                                                            AlanBleiweiss DonnieCooper 8 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                                            • dignan99
                                                                                              dignan99 last edited by

                                                                                              I really enjoy topics like this, thanks for asking such a great question.

                                                                                              DonnieCooper 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                                              • EGOL
                                                                                                EGOL last edited by

                                                                                                The problem that a lot of people have is that their site grows in unexpected directions.  So the problem is not so much deciding upon the structure but more a problem of making the most of the expanding beast!

                                                                                                DonnieCooper 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                                                                                • blackballonline
                                                                                                  blackballonline last edited by

                                                                                                  Great question. While everyone has their schools of thought; both methods have their benefits. I tend to favor flat architecture with targeted cross linking. I guess you could call it a hybrid strategy. I begin with a totally flat architecture and silo where it makes sense for the rankings and the navigation for the user. It's all about logical grouping and don't forget the pages must all be link-worthy on their own. If the pages are all strong enough to generate links the problem tends to take care of itself.

                                                                                                  DonnieCooper 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                                                                                  • AlanBleiweiss
                                                                                                    AlanBleiweiss last edited by

                                                                                                    There's never one perfect solution, however here's the bigger issue.  Some people hear "flat" and they take it to the extreme. Which is a terrible concept in 2011.

                                                                                                    If you go too flat, you muddy up the proper group relationships.  This is where Siloing comes in.

                                                                                                    In my presentation at SMX Advanced this week, one of the many methods I recommend for "sustainable SEO" is to group your content, and reinforce that group relationship in URL structure, then with breadcrumbs, and finally with section-level navigation, where all the pages in that section have a link to all the other pages in that section, but where that specific sub-navigation is replaced or disappears as appropriate when you leave that section.

                                                                                                    If you've got more than a handful of pages in a section, you should definitely go deeper.

                                                                                                    The trick is knowing how wide, how deep to go.  It's an art as much as a process studying site data over time.

                                                                                                    Another factor is the competitive landscape for a particular niche market.  The more competitive, the more important this concept becomes.

                                                                                                    DonnieCooper 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 12
                                                                                                    • 1 / 1
                                                                                                    • First post
                                                                                                      Last post

                                                                                                    Got a burning SEO question?

                                                                                                    Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.


                                                                                                    Start my free trial


                                                                                                    Browse Questions

                                                                                                    Explore more categories

                                                                                                    • Moz Tools

                                                                                                      Chat with the community about the Moz tools.

                                                                                                    • SEO Tactics

                                                                                                      Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers

                                                                                                    • Community

                                                                                                      Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!

                                                                                                    • Digital Marketing

                                                                                                      Chat about tactics outside of SEO

                                                                                                    • Research & Trends

                                                                                                      Dive into research and trends in the search industry.

                                                                                                    • Support

                                                                                                      Connect on product support and feature requests.

                                                                                                    • See all categories

                                                                                                    Related Questions

                                                                                                    • StevenLevine

                                                                                                      How can I find all broken links pointing to my site?

                                                                                                      I help manage a large website with over 20M backlinks and I want to find all of the broken ones. What would be the most efficient way to go about this besides exporting and checking each backlink's reponse code? Thank you in advance!

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | StevenLevine
                                                                                                      3
                                                                                                    • SolveWebMedia

                                                                                                      My site shows 503 error to Google bot, but can see the site fine. Not indexing in Google. Help

                                                                                                      Hi, This site is not indexed on Google at all. http://www.thethreehorseshoespub.co.uk Looking into it, it seems to be giving a 503 error to the google bot. I can see the site I have checked source code Checked robots Did have a sitemap param. but removed it for testing GWMT is showing 'unreachable' if I submit a site map or fetch Any ideas on how to remove this error? Many thanks in advance

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | SolveWebMedia
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • browndoginteractive

                                                                                                      Avoiding Duplicate Content with Used Car Listings Database: Robots.txt vs Noindex vs Hash URLs (Help!)

                                                                                                      Hi Guys, We have developed a plugin that allows us to display used vehicle listings from a centralized, third-party database. The functionality works similar to autotrader.com or cargurus.com, and there are two primary components: 1. Vehicle Listings Pages: this is the page where the user can use various filters to narrow the vehicle listings to find the vehicle they want.
                                                                                                      2. Vehicle Details Pages: this is the page where the user actually views the details about said vehicle. It is served up via Ajax, in a dialog box on the Vehicle Listings Pages. Example functionality:  http://screencast.com/t/kArKm4tBo The Vehicle Listings pages (#1), we do want indexed and to rank. These pages have additional content besides the vehicle listings themselves, and those results are randomized or sliced/diced in different and unique ways. They're also updated twice per day. We do not want to index #2, the Vehicle Details pages, as these pages appear and disappear all of the time, based on dealer inventory, and don't have much value in the SERPs. Additionally, other sites such as autotrader.com, Yahoo Autos, and others draw from this same database, so we're worried about duplicate content. For instance, entering a snippet of dealer-provided content for one specific listing that Google indexed yielded 8,200+ results:  Example Google query. We did not originally think that Google would even be able to index these pages, as they are served up via Ajax. However, it seems we were wrong, as Google has already begun indexing them. Not only is duplicate content an issue, but these pages are not meant for visitors to navigate to directly! If a user were to navigate to the url directly, from the SERPs, they would see a page that isn't styled right. Now we have to determine the right solution to keep these pages out of the index:  robots.txt, noindex meta tags, or hash (#) internal links. Robots.txt Advantages: Super easy to implement Conserves crawl budget for large sites Ensures crawler doesn't get stuck. After all, if our website only has 500 pages that we really want indexed and ranked, and vehicle details pages constitute another 1,000,000,000 pages, it doesn't seem to make sense to make Googlebot crawl all of those pages. Robots.txt Disadvantages: Doesn't prevent pages from being indexed, as we've seen, probably because there are internal links to these pages. We could nofollow these internal links, thereby minimizing indexation, but this would lead to each 10-25 noindex internal links on each Vehicle Listings page (will Google think we're pagerank sculpting?) Noindex Advantages: Does prevent vehicle details pages from being indexed Allows ALL pages to be crawled (advantage?) Noindex Disadvantages: Difficult to implement (vehicle details pages are served using ajax, so they have no tag. Solution would have to involve X-Robots-Tag HTTP header and Apache, sending a noindex tag based on querystring variables, similar to this stackoverflow solution. This means the plugin functionality is no longer self-contained, and some hosts may not allow these types of Apache rewrites (as I understand it) Forces (or rather allows) Googlebot to crawl hundreds of thousands of noindex pages.  I say "force" because of the crawl budget required.  Crawler could get stuck/lost in so many pages, and my not like crawling a site with 1,000,000,000 pages, 99.9% of which are noindexed. Cannot be used in conjunction with robots.txt. After all, crawler never reads noindex meta tag if blocked by robots.txt Hash (#) URL Advantages: By using for links on Vehicle Listing pages to Vehicle Details pages (such as "Contact Seller" buttons), coupled with Javascript, crawler won't be able to follow/crawl these links.  Best of both worlds:  crawl budget isn't overtaxed by thousands of noindex pages, and internal links used to index robots.txt-disallowed pages are gone. Accomplishes same thing as "nofollowing" these links, but without looking like pagerank sculpting (?) Does not require complex Apache stuff Hash (#) URL Disdvantages: Is Google suspicious of sites with (some) internal links structured like this, since they can't crawl/follow them? Initially, we implemented robots.txt--the "sledgehammer solution." We figured that we'd have a happier crawler this way, as it wouldn't have to crawl zillions of partially duplicate vehicle details pages, and we wanted it to be like these pages didn't even exist. However, Google seems to be indexing many of these pages anyway, probably based on internal links pointing to them. We could nofollow the links pointing to these pages, but we don't want it to look like we're pagerank sculpting or something like that. If we implement noindex on these pages (and doing so is a difficult task itself), then we will be certain these pages aren't indexed. However, to do so we will have to remove the robots.txt disallowal, in order to let the crawler read the noindex tag on these pages. Intuitively, it doesn't make sense to me to make googlebot crawl zillions of vehicle details pages, all of which are noindexed, and it could easily get stuck/lost/etc. It seems like a waste of resources, and in some shadowy way bad for SEO. My developers are pushing for the third solution:  using the hash URLs. This works on all hosts and keeps all functionality in the plugin self-contained (unlike noindex), and conserves crawl budget while keeping vehicle details page out of the index (unlike robots.txt). But I don't want Google to slap us 6-12 months from now because it doesn't like links like these (). Any thoughts or advice you guys have would be hugely appreciated, as I've been going in circles, circles, circles on this for a couple of days now. Also, I can provide a test site URL if you'd like to see the functionality in action.

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | browndoginteractive
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • rayvensoft

                                                                                                      Do links to PDF's on my site pass "link juice"?

                                                                                                      Hi, I have recently started a project on one of my sites, working with a branch of the U.S. government, where I will be hosting and publishing some of their PDF documents for free for people to use.  The great SEO side of this is that they link to my site.  The thing is, they are linking directly to the PDF files themselves, not the page with the link to the PDF files.  So my question is, does that give me any SEO benefit? While the PDF is hosted on my site, there are no links in it that would allow a spider to start from the PDF and crawl the rest of my site.   So do I get any benefit from these great links?  If not, does anybody have any suggestions on how I could get credit for them.  Keep in mind that editing the PDF's are not allowed by the government. Thanks.

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | rayvensoft
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • underscorelive

                                                                                                      Outbound link to PDF vs outbound link to page

                                                                                                      If you're trying to create a site which is an information hub, obviously linking out to authoritative sites is a good idea. However, does linking to a PDF have the same effect? e.g Linking to Google's SEO starter guide PDF, as opposed to linking to a google article on SEO. Thanks!

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | underscorelive
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • seoanalytics

                                                                                                      Cross linking between categories

                                                                                                      Is it useful for SEO to cross link between TOP level categories, let's say I have a Home page and then 2 sub categories, one about green widgets one about red widgets
                                                                                                      Should i create a link from the green widget to the red widget or should I leave those are separate silos ? I know that within a silo i need to cross link ( from green widget 1 to green widget 2 etc... )  but how about about from the main category to the other main category ?

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | seoanalytics
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • nbeske

                                                                                                      Site wide footer links vs. single link for websites we design

                                                                                                      I’ve been running a web design business for the past 5 years, 90% or more of the websites we build have a “web design by” link in the footer which links back to us using just our brand name or the full “web design by brand name” anchor text. I’m fully aware that site-wide footer links arent doing me much good in terms of SEO, but what Im curious to know is could they be hurting me? More specifically I’m wondering if I should do anything about the existing links or change my ways for all new projects, currently we’re still rolling them out with the site-wide footer links. I know that all other things being equal (1 link from 10 domains > 10 links from 1 domain) but is (1 link from 10 domains > 100 links from 10 domains)? I’ve got a lot of branded anchor text, which balances out my exact match and partial match keyword anchors from other link building nicely. Another thing to consider is that we host many of our clients which means there are quite a few on the same server with a shared IP. Should I? 1.) Go back into as many of the sites as I can and remove the link from all pages except the home page or a decent PA sub page- keeping a single link from the domain. 2.) Leave all the old stuff alone but start using the single link method on new sites. 3.) Scratch the site credit and just insert an exact-match anchor link in the body of the home page and hide with with CSS like my top competitor seems to be doing quite successfully. (kidding of course.... but my competitor really is doing this.)

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | nbeske
                                                                                                      0
                                                                                                    • AndrewY

                                                                                                      Max # of Products / Links per Page on E-Commerce Site

                                                                                                      We are getting ready to re-launch our e-commerce site and are trying to decide how many products to list per category page.  Some of of our category pages have upwards of 100 products.  While I'd love to list ALL the products on the root category page (to reduce hassle for customer, to index more products on a higher PR page), I'm a little worried about having it be too long, and containing too many on-page links. Would love some guidance on: Maximum number of internal links on a page If Google frowns on really long category pages Anything else I should be considering when making this decision Thanks for your input!

                                                                                                      Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | AndrewY
                                                                                                      2

                                                                                                    Get started with Moz Pro!

                                                                                                    Unlock the power of advanced SEO tools and data-driven insights.

                                                                                                    Start my free trial
                                                                                                    Products
                                                                                                    • Moz Pro
                                                                                                    • Moz Local
                                                                                                    • Moz API
                                                                                                    • Moz Data
                                                                                                    • STAT
                                                                                                    • Product Updates
                                                                                                    Moz Solutions
                                                                                                    • SMB Solutions
                                                                                                    • Agency Solutions
                                                                                                    • Enterprise Solutions
                                                                                                    Free SEO Tools
                                                                                                    • Domain Authority Checker
                                                                                                    • Link Explorer
                                                                                                    • Keyword Explorer
                                                                                                    • Competitive Research
                                                                                                    • Brand Authority Checker
                                                                                                    • MozBar Extension
                                                                                                    • MozCast
                                                                                                    Resources
                                                                                                    • Blog
                                                                                                    • SEO Learning Center
                                                                                                    • Help Hub
                                                                                                    • Beginner's Guide to SEO
                                                                                                    • How-to Guides
                                                                                                    • Moz Academy
                                                                                                    • API Docs
                                                                                                    About Moz
                                                                                                    • About
                                                                                                    • Team
                                                                                                    • Careers
                                                                                                    • Contact
                                                                                                    Why Moz
                                                                                                    • Case Studies
                                                                                                    • Testimonials
                                                                                                    Get Involved
                                                                                                    • Become an Affiliate
                                                                                                    • MozCon
                                                                                                    • Webinars
                                                                                                    • Practical Marketer Series
                                                                                                    • MozPod
                                                                                                    Connect with us

                                                                                                    Contact the Help team

                                                                                                    Join our newsletter
                                                                                                    Moz logo
                                                                                                    © 2021 - 2025 SEOMoz, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All rights reserved. Moz is a registered trademark of SEOMoz, Inc.
                                                                                                    • Accessibility
                                                                                                    • Terms of Use
                                                                                                    • Privacy

                                                                                                    Looks like your connection to Moz was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.