Too Many Links?
-
Search Term is Indianapolis Wedding Photographers.
Site is http://www.tallandsmallphotography.com/
Their metrics are through the roof compared to everyone else's. They've dropped from 27 in May to 40 Now. 'A' Grade on-site optimization.
Either there's too many links, or there's some bad links involved... I don't know which it is...
-
I liked your article. You had a lot of really good points. I think that a lot of non-SEO savvy people are still trying to build links by leaving comments, so it's good to advise people not to do that!
I still think you should go looking for Panda issues for this particular client though. Yes, it's good to get rid of the unnatural links. But, if Penguin was the only issue for this site then you really should have seen your drop at the time of a Penguin update and there was no Penguin update in May of 2014.
-
And... as it turns out, I was part of the problem. I had a DoFollow directory on my site that people could use for a little Blog Love action.
There was also a thread on a photography group that has been going on since 2009, that I encouraged people to use over the years.I've written a blog post here http://flauntyoursite.com/jig-is-up/ denouncing the practice. I have a bit of clout in the photography communities, so hopefully this spreads out there.
Marie, if you wouldn't mind reading this and letting me know if there's anything you think should be added, I'd appreciate it.
I let people down big time. I hope the word can get out there and fix this thing.
-
Thanks Marie,
I will shoot you an email. Most of my clients are photographers (I do custom website design as well as SEO), so if this is something that's happening more and more, it'd be good to have a solution for them.
-
Thanks very much for the recommendation EGOL.
William, I have seen a lot of photographers that have been affected by Penguin. With that being said, your backlink profile doesn't look typical of most Penguin hit sites that I see. The first thing I'd check is whether you have a manual unnatural linking penalty. This is different than Penguin that is an algorithmic issue and not a manual penalty.
If you've traded links with a lot of other photographers than a manual penalty is possible. To check go to Webmaster Tools then Search Traffic and then Manual Actions.
If you see "no manual webspam actions found" then that's not it.
I see a lot of sites that go on a link pruning crusade when really their problem has nothing to do with links. A lot of these sites have issues with the Panda algorithm which really is not a link based algorithm at all, but rather, deals with on site problems.
If you'd like me to have a more detailed look, feel free to contact me via the email on my Moz profile and I can give you a few options.
-
Marie Haynes.
Check out all of these link penalty articles on SearchEngineWatch. http://searchenginewatch.com/author/2779/marie-haynes
Another list of link penalty articles published here on Moz. http://moz.com/community/users/308135
Her site and book are here. http://www.hiswebmarketing.com/unnatural-links-recovery/
Those are just some of what she has published.
-
Thanks EGOL,
I spent a little time investigating to rule out other issues. I didn't want to rush to a conclusion. But I'm fairly positive we're looking at Penguin now.
Since Penguin isn't really my area of expertise, do you have recommendations for good services that are skilled in determining which links would be causing problems?
Thanks!
-
And EGOL, what is it that bothers you about the links to other sites?
The blog looks like a link factory. Are these being sold? Are they being traded? Simply by volume there will be links in there to other websites that have been penalized by Google. Inbound or outbound links can cause a site to have a problem with Google's Penguin algorithm.
Site-wide links in the footer have been a known method of google manipulation for about ten years. If Prophoto and NetRivet have dozens or hundreds of other sites giving them site-wide links in the footer that could cause a problem. I would get rid of those links if this was my website. They are not necessary. The site will look better without these advertising links.
**Most photographers actually do use commenting as a means to up their DA/PA. **
That statement proves an observation that I have made.
I look at Moz Q&A every day and pay attention to sites that see rankings drops. Photographers are waaayyy overrepresented in the sites that post here with problems. If you do a few searches of Q&A you will find lots of photographers in here cryin' because their sites have great metrics but apparently weak competitors are beating them.
**Most photographers do this as a way to promote vendors that were at the wedding. **
Photographers link to other wedding vendors and other wedding vendors link back to photographers... they do this every week. Over and over for hundreds of weddings. It creates a pattern that is easy to spot and looks like manipulation. They, or their agents, have also spent countless hours finding open photography blogs where they can place a ten word comment and get a link or two.
Their metrics are through the roof compared to everyone else's. They've dropped from 27 in May to 40 Now. 'A' Grade on-site optimization.
This sounds exactly like a site that has been penalized for link spam. Great moz grading, great link metrics, rankings lower than expected in Google.
Just offering what I would do if this was my site. No guarantees.
.
-
Thanks Chris and EGOL,
Most photographers actually do use commenting as a means to up their DA/PA. They occasionally get posts from wedding blogs as features with links back to them. But the majority of the industry uses comments. Plenty of sites have maintained rankings with that link strategy (I'm not saying if it's good/bad or even sustainable over the long term, just saying what has worked for years).
Could this just be a situation where having hundreds of more links than your competitors could cause the problems?Also, are there any tools that you'd recommend that could start to actually figure out if the links truly are bad?
And EGOL, what is it that bothers you about the links to other sites? Most photographers do this as a way to promote vendors that were at the wedding. Reading it I admit it's a bit link heavy in the amount of text they have on each post, but is there anything inherently wrong with 5-10 outbound links on posts?
Thanks guys.
William -
I'm not sure there is such a thing as too many good links, which leaves just the bad-links side of your equation. If by "take a sharp ax to what's currently out there," EGOL means to start disavowing those low quality links, I'd agree. Moz's metrics don't really count spammy stuff against you, which can lead to to believe that your ranking factors are through the roof. It might be good idea to bone-up on your knowledge of link valuations.
-
A lot of the links fit the pattern of the examples below. Google probably sees this and thinks that the only reason these links exist is because someone deliberately spent a lot of time finding a couple hundred photography blog posts where they could type less than ten words and obtain a link, or two, or three. They would call it blog spamming because the links were manufactured - not given on merit.
Three examples....
http://paperphotographs.com/blog/2012/04/02/columbus-senior-portraits-carly-whetstone-park-of-roses/
http://alexmillerweddings.co.uk/blog/benjamin-arrives/
http://www.jackchauvel.com/the-year-that-was-2013/
If this was my site I would get rid of the site-wide footer links to ProPhoto and NetRivet. If they are being paid for their service then linking to them is probably not a requirement. If it is a requirement and I am paying I would leave them simply on principle.
Another thing that bothers me is that the blog posts each have a load of links out to other sites. This, I would think, is unnecessary. I would stop doing this and take a sharp ax to what is currently out there.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Bing search results - Site links
My site links in Bing search results are pulling through the footer text instead of the meta description (see image). Is there any way of controlling this? 2L2VusT
Technical SEO | | RWesley0 -
Link building with AddThis URL
We've begun using AddThis for tracking our social sharing. AddThis has been adding the snippet to the end of the URLs on our pages and we've been finding that people linking to us are linking to the URL with the snippet. AddThis says this isn't a problem for SEO. Is this correct? Here is an example: https://www.harborcompliance.com/information/how-to-start-a-non-profit-organization-in-colorado.php#.UunCfPldVig I want to make sure this is not affecting our SEO in any way, particularly that Google would see this as an affiliate or paid link since it has the "#". I may be crazy but I just want to make sure!
Technical SEO | | Harbor_Compliance0 -
How to Break Up a Page with Too Many Links
My client has a live page with 100+ links subdivided into 10 categories that each have great potential keyword targeting opportunities. I'd like to improve this page and my intuition is to split it into 11 pages, one page with links to all the others and a bit of content about each. Here's an example of the potential IA: Dog Rescue Groups
Technical SEO | | elenarox
Golden Retriever Rescue - description
Poodle Rescue - description
Cocker Spaniel Rescue - description
Poodle Rescue - description
Labrador Retriever Rescue - description
etc. --------- Golden Retriever Rescue
Link 1 - description
Link 2 - description
Link 3 - description Is this a good idea and will I see a big traffic drop overall at first? Also, these are all internal links, not external.0 -
Link juice and max number of links clarification
I understand roughly that "Link Juice" is passed by dividing PR by the number of links on a page. I also understand the juice available is reduced by some portion on each iteration. 50 PR page 10 links on page 5 * .9 = 4.5 PR goes to each link. Correct? If so and knowing Google stops counting links somewhere around 100, how would it impact the flow to have over 100 links? IE 50 PR page 150 links on the page .33 *.9 = .29PR to each link BUT only for 100 of them. After that, the juice is just lost? Also, I assume Google, to the best of its ability, organizes the links in order of importance such that content links are counted before footer links etc.
Technical SEO | | sprynewmedia0 -
Too Many Internal Links?
Hi Guys, I'm completing a overhawl of our website at the moment have a certain penguin killed our site for our main keyword. I'm currently working on our internal linking as most of our blog posts have a link back to our home page with the main money keyword. At present we have 3,331 internal links and our site has only 1,000 pages. Can you get penalised for having too many internal links with exact match anchors. Thanks, Scott
Technical SEO | | ScottBaxterWW0 -
Internal links of my website is taken as inbound link ?
Hi, I was checking my links in Open Site Explorer (http://www.opensiteexplorer.org/links?site=www.bons-plans-vacances.fr) this morning and i came up with this: My main domain is taken as outbound links ...! This link : www.bons-plans-vacances.fr/ Anchor Text : (img alt)100% Bons Plans Voyages From this URL : www.bons-plans-vacances.fr/ I have the same problem with my subdomains : voyage.bons-plans-vacances.fr/sejour/Toutes-Destinations I have that HTML code on the link : Any help ? This is very strange .. i have the same result in google webmaster tools. Thanks 🙂 eDE9b.jpg
Technical SEO | | BonsPlansvacances0 -
Redirection help to retrieve broken links
Hi, my hosting company after they updated my joomla website lost thousands of pages of content, i am now searching for all broken links and re doing the content to get my links back, but i am having a problem understanding how to redirect these links. For example, i have now managed to retrieve this page http://www.in2town.co.uk/news/have-your-say/liberal-dem-leader-says-he-will-be-the-next-prime-minister-what-do-you-think but the old url for this page was http://www.in2town.co.uk/Have-Your-Say/Liberal-Dem-Leader-says-He-Will-be-The-Next-Prime-Minister-What-Do-You-Think/menu-id-4953 i do not have the unfriendly url for this page, so what i am trying to find out is, how to tell google that the above page is now http://www.in2town.co.uk/news/have-your-say/liberal-dem-leader-says-he-will-be-the-next-prime-minister-what-do-you-think in my joomla site. if anyone could please explain how to do this with joomla 1.5 then you will make me very happy as then i will be able to retrieve some of my lost links
Technical SEO | | ClaireH-1848860 -
Competition links make no sense
Hello everybody, I used the open site explorer to check where my competitor has links and try to put mine there too. However I am extremely confused with the results. Eg the first link to my competitor coming from a domain with authority 91, is a download file. The other one is a link from ups, the courier service. When I click on it I get an access denied.The other one comes from samsung and when I click on it, I download an swf file. Next one, fcc.gov and it downloads a wp file. If I keep clicking on these links, in the end I am going to get a virus or something and learn nothing about what my competitor does. Any one have a clue how they managed to get linked like that?
Technical SEO | | polyniki0