Conflicting data in Google Analytics
-
Hi Guys
I've been looking at the data for a client in Google analytics and I was wondering if anyone knows why some of the data doesn't tally up. In my case its the following:
Under Aquisition
No of Sessions for a Keyword shown in Organic Search tab (compared to)
No of Clicks for a Query in the Search Engine Optimisation tabFor example, for a brand term, Google are showing 17 Sessions in Organic Search.
For the same term Google are showing 90 Clicks in the Queries section of Search Engine OptimisationOK, we know that Google are a little cloak and dagger regarding keyword data but surely Sessions and Clicks for the same keyword should be identical unless I'm missing something.
-
There are few things that could be varying the data.
The first thing to remember is that Webmaster Tools is only showing data for the URLs in the index they associate with that account. This data is different if you are looking at domain.com or www.domain.com. If you had a few subdomains on the same root domain and on the same analytics tracker, but were looking at WMT for www.domain.com, you would be missing information from those subdomains.
In addition to that, there might be issues with your GA tracking code firing. It could be missing from some pages in the index. You could have a number of PDFs on your site that would incur clicks, but would not be tracked in GA.
The other issue is the difference in the data sets. WMT shows clicks only, not visits to your site. People can be clicking a result in Google and immediately changing their mind. That would result in a click but no visit. WMT also doesn't distinguish between returning and new clicks. It's just total.
The two data sets are completely off and each have their own drawbacks. To get the best data, you'll need to ensure there is a tracking code on every page. Then account for files like PDFs that can get clicks, but not visits in GA. That's a place to start. But it's still different data and not ever going to be the same.
These are some big differences and that does point to something being wrong, but there would need some in-depth analysis to point to exactly what is causing it.
-
Hi Kate and thanks for your reply.
I completely agree. Reporting on a keyword basis is a little old hat now and we should look at overall visits to the site along with other pre defined KPI's agreed with our client (nice article Kate). However; the question remains.
Google provide 2 sources of overall traffic volume (GA and WMT) and they seem to show completely different results.
(Copied from above)
Here's another one for 1st May - 25th May:
GA - Organic search - Total sessions - 874
GWT - Search Analytics - Total Clicks - 431 (New System, all filters removed)
GWT - Search Analytics - Total Clicks - 1755 (Old System, all filters removed)
CRAZY RESULTS!A lot of the data provided by Google is calculated on No of Visits. If the data showing No of visits is incorrect then the rest of the data becomes incorrect. Taking the results above and using GA as a benchmark, the two results shown in WMT are approx 50% more and 50% less than the bechmark. So the results you report could be 50% either side from the actual. Does this make sense? If WMT is more accurate then I would have to recalculate the results provided in GA.
Example (using data above)
if Total Sales = 10
(GA Results of 874) Conversion Rate = 1.14%
(WMT New Results of 431) Conversion Rate = 2.32%
(WMT Old Results of 1755) Conversion Rate = 0.57%The old saying of "You can't argue with maths" is only applicable if the data you're working with is correct in the first place.
-
This isn't actually an issue of Google hiding or not reporting accurately. Bing and Yahoo also have started not processing any keyword data to analytics sets. Google still shows some, but it's only for non-logged in users.
The reports for WMT are more accurate, but you should not try to report on a keyword basis. It's a losing battle. I wrote an article on how to change up reporting and analysis in today's world. https://moz.com/blog/stop-thinking-keywords-think-topics
-
Thanks for your replies Martijn and Alick300.
I know they hide the keyword data but why show it in the first place. If Google want to give their users the best possible user experience then why show conflicting data and confuse their users?
The issue I have with this is that if this brand term in question is showing 17 sessions in GA but 90 clicks in GWT, which system is showing the correct overall Session Volume or does that metric simply not exist?
If I select a date range 1st May - 25th May and the same brand term, here's what I get:
GA - Brand term - 17 Sessions
GA Queries - Brand term - 90 Clicks (shown in GA from webmaster tools)
GWT Search Analytics - Brand term - 111 ClicksEach result would have an affect on Total Sessions for that date range. This is only looking at one keyword and looking at other keywords it shows a similar discrepancy between the two systems.
Here's another one for 1st May - 25th May:
GA - Organic search - Total sessions - 874
GWT - Search Analytics - Total Clicks - 431 (New System, all filters removed)
GWT - Search Analytics - Total Clicks - 1755 (Old System, all filters removed)
CRAZY RESULTS!To me this means Google Analytics isn't reporting accurate visitor data which we use to make data driven decisions. When I'm asked by my client "How many visitors have we had this month", do I reply "Between 431 and 1755"?
-
completely agree with Martijn Scheijbeler
-
Well honestly you're missing something. The clicks and the sessions aren't identical between the two because they hide the keyword data in Google Analytics. That's why it will almost never match again in GA v.s. GWT.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Does applying filters in Google Analytics affect Moz Data?
Hello, I'm dealing with spam in google analytics, applying filters (and using segments for historical data) Does applying a filter in GA affect Moz data, future or historical? Is there a way of doing this? Thank you!
Reporting & Analytics | | wearehappymedia0 -
Adwords in google analytic Transaction showing more than actual adwords
Hello Experts, Compared to my google adwords account , transaction showing more in adwords for google analytic. May i know where i am going wrong? Thanks! Dev
Reporting & Analytics | | devdan0 -
How to exclude IP from Google Analytic?
Hello Guys, I am admin of google analytic, i am trying to exclude traffic in google analytic from admin, view section then filter but not there is no button of save? Can anyone please help me? PFA of image. zOkvX1n.jpg
Reporting & Analytics | | devdan0 -
Google Analytics Event Tracking
Hi Guys, I want to set up a goal in Google analytics for this site http://www.dfrsolicitors.co.uk/contact.php and the contact us form is in php (so there is no thank you html page). I know there is a piece of code "onsubmit" or whatever it is, but I can't find it. I want to be able to track successful submissions. Kind Regards Neil
Reporting & Analytics | | nezona0 -
All goal conversion in Google analytics showing under referral
Hi All, I have switched my website from http to https After switching from http to https all goal conversions in Google analytics showing under referral.I have also updated the GA code for https. Please help me out to fix the issue. Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | Alick3000 -
Stop getting info from Google analytics on purchases in our site
Hi guys, We have eCommerce.
Reporting & Analytics | | WayneRooney
We connected the site to the Google analytic eCommerce.
Everything was work fine until 3 weeks ago. Suddenly we stooped getting purchases information in the analytic although i see purchases in the website. We didn't change anything in the website and i really don't know how to solve this problem.
If someone here can point me where i can get some info on how to fix it it can be great. Thanks a lot!0 -
Un-link Google Analytics
I have set the wrong account/password details for one of my campaigns. How do I 'step back' and choose the correct settings please? Thanks Ian
Reporting & Analytics | | driansmith0 -
Google Analytics - my continuing adventures
Hello I'd appreciate views of the various metrics I'm struggling with in GA: I've run 2 different reports that provide 2 different outputs. 1. In Standard Reporting you can report in Traffic Sources on Organic Search by Keyword, which returns the number of Visits. 2. In Custom Reporting you can define the Keyword dimension and the Organic Searches metric, which returns the number of Organic Searches. This returns 2 different numbers. For example, over the last month for a given term report 1 returns 77,306 visits whilst report 2 returns 52,589 organic searches. I have found some definitions: "Visits represent the number of individual sessions initiated by all the visitors to your site." "Organic Searches: number of organic searches that happened within a session. This metric is search engine agnostic." My understanding of these definitions is that report 2 should return a larger value than report 1 rather than what is happening (i.e. report 1 returns a greater value than report 2). Does anyone have a greater understanding of what these mean and relate to? Does anyone have any views on which metric is more useful? Thanks Neil
Reporting & Analytics | | mccormackmorrison0