International SEO - Hreflang tags and URL Structure
-
Hello, I wonder if any SEO internationalisation experts can help.
We are a UK centric business with a .com domain which all our traffic currently goes to. We have been growing in the US and are therefore looking to internationalise our website by building out some US pages using the subfolder .com/us.
Since the keywords we wish to target in the US are different to the keywords we are targeting elsewhere, when implementing hreflang tags is it possible to use a different URL for the US page?
So let’s say we are targeting ‘estate car’ generally but want to target ’station wagon’ as the keyword for the equivalent US page, can the URLs be different?
Example:
- General page: www.example.com/estate-car
- US: www.example.com/us/station-wagon
Hreflang tags:
Would that be the correct implementation?
Any help or guidance would be much appreciated!
-
Thanks for your thoughtful reply.
Great - that makes sense. I will add en-gb hreflang markup too.
You raise some really good points about organisations having to think clearly about the need to undertake multi-regional / multi-lingual SEO and the potential implications of this. In our situation we've come to the conclusion that there is a business case to undertake this venture. When I joined there was already a US office and a few pages written for the US already published on our website in a different design language. Fortunately these pages were recently created and set not to allow crawling. If they were to be indexed at best they may not rank and at worst they may actually interfere with our other page rankings - as well as causing confusion for users (duplicate product / contact / client pages, different navigation structures, designs etc). In the end we decided the best approach would to be to internationalise our website and target these pages to the region / language they were designed for. But yes definitely has been a challenge!
-
In your original post, you wrote that you are a "UK-centric business". I would think you would want to be as specific as possible to make sure the search engines know to serve the most relevant pages to the UK audience. So, yes, I would definitely include a self-referencing hreflang tag. It also simplifies your process because you can just copy-and-paste the hreflang tags between the versions of the page, with no editing (you put the same exact set of tags on the British page as you do on the American).
However, I'm really only responding to your "how" question. There is also an implicit question of whether you should be doing this. I have to say that from recent experience, no matter how thorough we are with hreflang tags, the search engines inevitably serve up pages across the desired locales. For my brand, I have Australian links showing up in US searches, and US links showing up in British searches, etc. This is even with correct hreflang implementation. In our case, it is a necessity to have multiple localized sites, because we carry different inventory, at different prices, and with different policies in each region. But if that wasn't the case, I would not localize my site between US, British, and Australian English just for language variances. That is a subjective decision, but I have so many problems coming from the wrong pages being served in the wrong geographies, despite thorough hreflang tagging, that I would be very hesitant to create more localizations than absolutely necessary. This wasn't your question, I realize, and also this is purely subjective, but passing along for consideration.
-
Great - thanks for your response.
So we should include x-default markup on the relevant pages (in addition to en-us hreflang tags) to signal to the search engines to show the .com urls to those who do not have the browser language setting set to US-English and the .com/us urls to those who do?
If we don't have specific UK pages do we need to add href lang en-gb markup since x-default covers it?
-
You would want the exact same hreflang tags on both versions of each page. So, that means each has a self-referencing tag, plus an alternate tag pointing to the sister page in another locale, plus an x-default tag. The hreflang tags basically tell the search engines whcih version of the page is appropriate for which locales, and when they are on a page in one locale, it tells the search engine where it can find the equivalent pages for other locales, as well as which one is the "x-default" for any locales you haven't specified.
-
Thanks for your quick reply seoelevated! We don't actually have any specific UK pages at the moment. The main site (written in British English) is www.example.com and is where all our traffic currently goes. We have decided to build specific US pages at subfolder www.example.com/us.
I presume in this scenario it would be good practice to add x-default markup on the .com while adding hreflang en-us to the US pages?
-
Yes, that looks correct. However, I would suggest adding two more hreflang tags to each page. One for "en-gb" (pointing to your UK desired version) and one for "x-default" (pointing to whichever version you would prefer for any other nonspecified locales. You will want all 4 of these on each of the two pages (so each page would include a self-referencing tag. These 2 additional ones are optional, but I think would provide a bit more clear direction to the search engines about which page to present for which locales.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Japanese URL-structured sitemap (pages) not being indexed by Bing Webmaster Tools
Hello everyone, I am facing an issue with the sitemap submission feature in Bing Webmaster Tools for a Japanese language subdirectory domain project. Just to outline the key points: The website is based on a subdirectory URL ( example.com/ja/ ) The Japanese URLs (when pages are published in WordPress) are not being encoded. They are entered in pure Kanji. Google Webmaster Tools, for instance, has no issues reading and indexing the page's URLs in its sitemap submission area (all pages are being indexed). When it comes to Bing Webmaster Tools it's a different story, though. Basically, after the sitemap has been submitted ( example.com/ja/sitemap.xml ), it does report an error that it failed to download this part of the sitemap: "page-sitemap.xml" (basically the sitemap featuring all the sites pages). That means that no URLs have been submitted to Bing either. My apprehension is that Bing Webmaster Tools does not understand the Japanese URLs (or the Kanji for that matter). Therefore, I generally wonder what the correct way is to go on about this. When viewing the sitemap ( example.com/ja/page-sitemap.xml ) in a web browser, though, the Japanese URL's characters are already displayed as encoded. I am not sure if submitting the Kanji style URLs separately is a solution. In Bing Webmaster Tools this can only be done on the root domain level ( example.com ). However, surely there must be a way to make Bing's sitemap submission understand Japanese style sitemaps? Many thanks everyone for any advice!
Technical SEO | | Hermski0 -
URL is invalid: Why?
Hello everyone, I am currently listing my company on business directories. For some websites however when I add my website URL, it comes up as URL is invalid. What could be the reason for this? I have tried different variations like www., http:// and https://. Kind Regards,
Technical SEO | | SMCCoachHire
Aqib0 -
HREFLANG No Return Tag Error
Keep getting WMT no return tag error. Also got an email today on this issue. Here are a couple pages showing up in the error report: Originating URL: /hawaii/kauai-real-estate/ Alternate URL: /jp/hawaii/kauai-real-estate/ Here are the hreflang tags for each page: /hawaii/kauai-real-estate/ /jp/hawaii/kauai-real-estate/ The only thing I can see is the hreflang= is at the end of the snippet but doesn't seem like that would matter. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Technical SEO | | SoulSurfer80 -
SSl and SEO
Does the type of SSL used on a site have any significance to trust and seo ranking?
Technical SEO | | unikey0 -
If Google's index contains multiple URLs for my homepage, does that mean the canonical tag is not working?
I have a site which is using canonical tags on all pages, however not all duplicate versions of the homepage are 301'd due to a limitation in the hosting platform. So some site visitors get www.example.com/default.aspx while others just get www.example.com. I can see the correct canonical tag on the source code of both versions of this homepage, but when I search Google for the specific URL "www.example.com/default.aspx" I see that they've indexed that specific URL as well as the "clean" one. Is this a concern... shouldn't Google only show me the clean URL?
Technical SEO | | JMagary0 -
Canonical tag problem
Hello I'm newbie here i dont know very well about seo but i would like to ask your help? I'm running report about my website and on report I dont have canonical tag on my products. But if i check from on page report link by link it shows that I have canonical tag. At the same time if i check my pages code i can see below canonical tag codes? Do we use canonical tags wrong? What can cause this different information? Could you please help me? Is it important to use canonical tag beginning or end? I'm using now trial version and trying to understand report is correct what is my mistakes. Thanks in advance My code is
Technical SEO | | FRUTIKO0 -
Expressionengine SEO
One of my clients is using expressionengine CMS, and even the simplest things like creating unique page titles seem to be a nightmare. When I try to change page title via cms it also changes navigation menu. Any help will be appreciated.
Technical SEO | | Thommas0 -
What are the SEO implications of URLs that use a # in them?
I have several clients who have begun to ask questions about sites that are designed to look like a single page. When you click on a link, the URL changes but it uses a # before (i.e. http://www.kelloggs.com/teamusa**/#**/teamusa/athletes/kerri-walsh.html. What are the SEO implications of having a page set up this way? I noticed that Google has indexed this page but the indexed URL does not include a #. Is Google indexing a separate version of this page? Any insights would be really helpful! Thanks
Technical SEO | | VMLYRDiscoverability0