Unique businesses - unique domain names?
-
A client of mine owns a studio space where he teaches yoga and martial arts. It's a new business and we're deciding how to create the website(s) and which domain(s) to buy. The idea right now is to have 3 websites for each side of the business, and I'm looking for validation of this idea. I haven't been able to find an answer in the Q&A forum that quite applies to our situation.
Website 1: for the studio itself. The audience is other yoga teachers, martial arts teachers, or personal trainers. He will rent out the studio space to them and they bring in their own clients. Content and keywords will relate to this.
Website 2: yoga classes. The audience is members of the public who want to take yoga classes. Content and keywords will relate to this.
Website 3: martial arts. The audience is members of the public who want to take martial arts classes. Content and keywords will relate to this.
We will make certain there's no duplicate content on the sites, but it makes sense for them to link to each other because they're similar in nature (personal health and fitness at the studio), and the latter 2 services are offered at the studio, of course.
Question 1: (a) is it a good idea to get a separate domain for each site? for example: www.city-studio.com, www.unique-name-yoga.com, www.unique-name-martial-arts.com (b) Or would it be better to keep it all under city-studio.com and use subdomains like yoga.city-studio.com and martial-arts.city-studio.com? In either case, the keywords "yoga" and "martial arts" would be in the domain name, which has benefit. Does that still apply for subdomains? (c) Or would these services even be considered similar enough that I just use www.city-studio.com/yoga.php and www.city-studio.com/martial-arts..php There will of course be several pages on yoga and several on martial arts.
Question 2: if registering multiple domains, they will interlink as much as possible. (a) what do we consider when buying the domains? (b) use a different address for WHOIS of each domain? (c) can technical contact be the same address (mine, the consultant)? (d) use a different credit card for each? (e) ok if the name on the credit card is the same? (f) can we register them all the same day? (h) same domain registrar? (i) same host? we don't want to appear black hat by having multiple sites, but I think it's very legitimate to have the business split into 3 sites like this just because they're separate sides of the business with different audiences, content, keywords.
Question 3: when the domains come up for renewal in 1 year (or more), would it be safe to switch them all over to one credit card then, for convenience to the owner?
Question 4: is there anything important I haven't mentioned here?
I appreciate any input and discussion.
-
Now I know! Thanks Ryan!
Advertising would sound so much better as yoga dot my studio dot com, though lol.
-
Very informative, you are a master of the Q&A forums! I appreciate the thorough response - you've ensured that I'm really picking up what you're putting down. You and Ressler have really helped me on my path to making this site awesome (and high-ranking). Thank you!
-
The recommended solution would be directories on your main domain, not sub-domains. Sub-domains are basically viewed as additional domains and your DA does not accumulate for the various sub-domains.
Ressler is correct in that "www" is a sub-domain, but then all of your site information is presented on that one sub-domain so you are fine. This reasoning is why we ensure websites choose either the "www" version of their URL or the "non-www" version, never both.
Another advantage of having everything on one site is the internal site linking. Your studio is in a unique situation offering two forms of physical exercise and training. There are many opportunities where you can suggest "before or after a martial arts workout, you may want to try some yoga" with the word "yoga" being an achor text link to the proper page on your yoga site. Or there can be packages where the wife can do yoga while the husband is learning martial arts. Not to be sexist, the scenario can be reversed as well!
-
Personally, I would do subdirectories just because its easier to say. "yoga (dot) DenverStudio (dot) com" instead of "denverstudio (dot) com forward slash yoga"
However, I've only read about the benefits of sub-directories within very large websites, and wouldn't know what the benefits of a smaller website would be with it. Although, www. is technically a sub-directory, and most websites use it.
-
Thanks Ryan, you've really helped to solidify my decision on this one.
There are two reasons for the multiple domains: keywords in the domain name, yes, but also each aspect of the business seems distinct and we thought having a separate site devoted to each offering (yoga, martial arts, studio rental) would be the most clear for customers. I will just ensure that the design and navigation of the site gets that across properly, and having one site will encourage brand solidarity too. Another plus.
What you said about partial match domain boosting was new to me though. Very good to know.
Q1: Oh, the hyphenated names were just for example purposes. Yuck, I'd never do that. (but you never know, so thanks for mentioning it)
Q1: As I asked Ressler above, do you think subdirectories or subdomains are the best option? Would the different subdomains share the DA or is this essentially the same as having three websites?
Q2 and Q3: Solid thinking. If it seems manipulative, it's probably best to avoid. All of those ideas I had do seem manipulative alright.
Q4: I like how you think!
-
Thanks Ressler, you've made some great points that have helped my decision. I will go with 1 website.
Your mention of the link juice was something I hadn't considered enough. Having links between the 3 websites is one thing, but of course they have to pass link juice to be of any value! Links alone don't have the value that I would need, so I would definitely have do 3x the work to increase the domain authority of all 3 sites, to ensure ample link juice is passed to ensure the interlinking adds enough value. This definitely seems like a lot more work.
For the landing pages for each area of his business (studio rentals, yoga, martial arts), do you think it makes sense to use subdomains for each, or keep them all within www.city-studio.com? Perhaps use subdirectories like /yoga? I'm thinking about keywords in the URL, I suppose, but also the best way for the engines to determine the focus of the site, or focus of each section I should say.
-
I agree with Ressler. One site is the best approach.
The sole reason you are seeking 3 domains is to gain the exact match domain benefit. Well, you wont have it because your site name isn't going to be "yoga" or "yoga chicago" which are the likely terms people would use in search. Therefore you will be depending upon the partial match domain boost which is a lot lower then EMD, and it is simply not even close to worth it. You will be sacrificing your DA and the manageability of a single site.
Response to Q1 - first, drop the idea of using hyphenated names. They appear spammy and are undesirable. If you absolutely must use a hyphen, make is a maximum of a single hyphen and understand you will probably regret even that usage. You can separate your functions which categories such as www.mystudio.com/yoga.
Q2 - Again, use a single site and you wont have this worry. You are asking how to manipulate search engines into believing your sites are not related. It wont even come close to working. You want to outsmart a 30+ billion dollar company with an entire team of highly trained professionals who have developed systems designed to prevent you from doing exactly what you are trying to do.
Q3 - same reply as Q2
Q4 - Make one site, put all your time, focus and energy building it to be the best studio site on the planet. Take the money and time you will save from building, hosting and promoting 3 sites and really make your one site fantastic. "Good" is not good enough.
-
Three websites means:
- 3 times the link building
- 3 times the content writing
- 3 times the monitoring
Three websites do sound tempting until you realize that you will not be able to benefit from each area driving its own links. With a single website you will be able to receive the domain benefit for every link you generate, while having multiple domains you will not.
Another problem with linking to other websites all the time is the drop in link juice. While it may seem beneficial to pass links from your websites, you have to remember that you are giving away some of the value of your internal links each time. With just a couple links its no problem, but with dozens you might face a dilemma.
I would stick to the one website with landing pages for each area of interest. I would then do an intense link building campaign for each, and write a very informative blog (to both drive visitors and links). By having high quality landing pages for each "department" you will be able to achieve all your SERP goals, and be able to build on each "departments" success.
The only reason I wouldn't do this is if I was going to have 1000's of pages of content for each department.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Is domain redirection a good method for SEO?
I have a question and need suggestion from you guys. I’ve searched for my question on Google but don’t get exact information what I need. Maybe I can’t search perfectly.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | kamishah
Let me explain my confusion:
I’ve checked backlink profile of a website. He is not using his main domain while doing comment backlink. He put his another domain while doing comment backlink. The another domain redirect to the main domain. Why he use another domain while doing comment backlink?
Is it helpful to get better rank on Google? For example: My Main Domain = solutionfall.com
Another Domain= xyz.com (It redirect to solutionfall.com)
He just uses xyz.com while doing comment backlink. Thank You so much1 -
Moving website and domain name without 301 Redirect or rel=canonical
I do not wish to draw attention to my company, so I am using code names. For the sake of this discussion, we are a new car dealership representing Brand X Cars. The manufacturer of Brand X Cars pushes its dealers toward a website hosting company called CarWebsites in order to maintain a level of quality and control with each dealer. However, we have found the platform to be too restricting, and are switching to our own WordPress site. Unfortunately Brand X is claiming ownership of our original domain, BrandXCarDealer.net, so we have switched to BrandXCarDealer.com (which we prefer anyways). Now both websites are running, and there is duplicate content of everything. Brand X is not cooperative and will not 301 redirect to the new site, and we do not have access to the of the website for a rel=canonical. Brand X is also dragging its feet on shutting down BrandXCarDealer.net. We do still have access to change the content of the pages on the BrandXCarDealer.net site, but that is pretty much as far as our control goes. So my question is, is there anything we can do, without using a 301 redirect or rel=canonical, to tell Google to pay attention to the new BrandXCarDealer.com rather than the old BrandXCarDealer.net? Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | VanMaster0 -
Does Duplicate Content Actually "Penalize" a Domain?
Hi all, Some co-workers and myself were in a conversation this afternoon regarding if duplicate content actually causes a penalty on your domain. Reference: https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66359?hl=en http://searchengineland.com/googles-matt-cutts-duplicate-content-wont-hurt-you-unless-it-is-spammy-167459 Both sources from Google do not say "duplicate content causes a penalty." However, they do allude to spammy content negatively affecting a website. Why it came up: We originally were talking about syndicated content (same content across multiple domains; ex: "5 explanations of bad breath") for the purpose of social media sharing. Imagine if dentists across the nation had access to this piece of content (5 explanations of bad breath) simply for engagement with their audience. They would use this to post on social media & to talk about in the office. But they would not want to rank for that piece of duplicated content. This type of duplicated content would be valuable to dentists in different cities that need engagement with their audience or simply need the content. This is all hypothetical but serious at the same time. I would love some feedback & sourced information / case studies. Is duplicated content actually penalized or will that piece of content just not rank? (feel free to reference that example article as a real world example). **When I say penalized, I mean "the domain is given a negative penalty for showing up in SERPS" - therefore, the website would not rank for "dentists in san francisco, ca". That is my definition of penalty (feel free to correct if you disagree). Thanks all & look forward to a fun, resourceful conversation on duplicate content for the other purposes outside of SEO. Cole
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | ColeLusby0 -
A site is using their competitors names in their Meta Keywords and Descriptions
I can't imagine this is a White Hat SEO technique, but they don't seem to be punished for it by Google - yet. How does Google treat the use of your competitors names in your meta keywords/descriptions? Is it a good idea?
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | PeterConnor0 -
Spammy Links (from .ru) pointing to my domain! How to deal with it?
Hi all, We run an e-commerce store - I am just looking at the apache logs and I am finding a lot of spammy links that have been referrers to our pages - when I check the links, I cannot find our URL in an HREF on their page so I presume they may be using some country based cloaking? These are the domains that are targeting specific pages on our site:
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | bjs2010
http://3xru.ru/
http://saldoconsult.ru/
http://euro-casino.ru/casino/
http://delaymoney.maroderi.ru/
http://intimhot.ru/ How to deal with this? Our site is about cookware and they seem to be pointing these links to very specific products and categories. Never seen anything like this before, help would be appreciated. Thanks, B0 -
Removing a sitewide backlink without damaging the domain
Hello, I have a client that partnered up with a person in his field 4 years ago and got him to place a sitewide link to his site, high domain authority. Now with recent developments this site owner wants to take off these links so that they won't leak pagerank. The person insists in taking all the links off with his next website redesign. I have found several years ago in my own SEO efforts that removal of a sitewide link actually damages the domain. Is this still true? Should he ask for a nofollow or will that change damage our domain as well? Is there any way he can not take a huge hit on this? He doesn't mind the loss of links, he just don't want to be damaged. Please only post if you have recent experience with sitewide link removal, or if you have something related or a solution.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | BobGW0 -
Exact Match Domains - Why are they still dominating?
Fantastic day! I am seeing exact match domains still dominating. SEOmoz has some insight: http://www.seomoz.org/blog/exact-match-domains-are-far-too-powerful-is-their-time-limited But that's from two years ago. Is Google ever going to target the manipulators that buy up all the exact match domains? One of our partners is getting the itch, and I am running out of explanations on why we don't manipulate. But if these practices are dominating their industry, what to do? I have to get paid to feed the family so just telling the client buh-bye isn't going to work. At least not in this stage of agency building. Their root domain doesn't do much for them, however, you know we well optimize those subdomains and rank those fine. But if my client can just buy an exact match domain, and it will take less SEO work to get it ranked then why not? He has the SEO expert in his back pocket to clean up the mess IF they would even get a penalty or drop in rank. Is all SEO really is find algo hole, manipulate, penalty, fix, find algo hole, manipulate, penalty, fix. Wash. Rinse. Repeat. Please share your experiences and insight! Thanks, Ben
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | cyberlicious0 -
Mobile SEO best practices : Should my mobile website be located at m.domain.com or domain.com/mobile?
I'd like to know if there's any difference between using m.domain.com/pages or domain.com/mobile/pages for a mobile website? Which one is better? Why? Does Google treat the two differently? As you can see, I'm new to this! This is my first time working on a mobile website, so any links/resources would be highly appreciated. Thanks!
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | GroupeDSI0