Google Adwords Quality Score Driving me I-N-S-A-N-E
-
Here's my issue, I have an Air Conditioning client for whom I've been managing their SEO and Adwords PPC for the past year. The SEO is going good, we are seeing tangible results every month will soon be on page 1 for their most competitive keyword.
On the adwords side, we are having some major issues though and I'm racking my brain. We are somehow getting quality scores in the 2's and 3's on the regular. I've streamlined my campaigns down to the city and within those I've streamlined my keyword groups into the following groups:
City (Campaign)
- AIr Conditioning (keyword group)
- AC Repair (keyword group)
- Fix AC (keyword group)
- Contractor (keyword group)
- Air Conditioner (keyword group)
Every keyword we're bidding on falls nicely into one of these keyword groups and we're putting about 10 key words in each. Landing pages have exact phrase match in page title, h1, bold words, contact form and a coupon image with all the meta tags indicating the image offer matches the offer in our ads. We are running 3-4 ads in each keyword and testing new ads almost daily.
Still getting 2s and 3s on the highest trafficked keywords (air conditioning & ac repair). I've read everything out there, I signed up for wordstream which had some decent recommendations (basically break your ad groups into smaller verticals) which I've implemented to no avail. I'm beginning to think Google is just hustling all these companies in service industry who they know rely on adwords to get phone calls in the summer - especially the HVAC industry. I'm running out of ideas here other than just going to Vegas and putting all my client's on black at the roulette wheel. Seems like a much more fun way to piss away thousands of dollars and at least they'll give me some cocktails.
-
No one has mentioned this, but have you thought about making all your ad groups geo-modified?
My guess is this client is targeting a specific location or several specific locations. Like "air conditioning repair miami" and then also tailor your landing pages to target that location too.
-
If you do this you may end up with a very low CTR and lots of impressions at the beginning of a campaign. If that happens then you are playing catch-up for a long time. If you are not in a hurry, run just a fraction of your Adgroups to begin with with phrase and modified broad matching keywords, use the search term report each week to see what the negative keywords are, and then expand.Similar negative keywords will come up for each category.
You'll still need to spend into success because you'll have to wait until you have statistically valid samples before making changes and that costs money one way or another.
I like to have average position land somewhere between 2-4 these days.
-
Here is what I do.
I make a landing page optimized with keywords that I want to rank for. Spend time optimizing just like you would for organic rankings. I don't hesitate to have a couple links out to my homepage and supplemental information pages or even parallel product pages.
Then I open a new campaign and ad group. Enter some keywords that I want to advertise. These keyword must tightly match my landing page. I enter some negative keywords that I know will be duds. I compose six to ten different ads that tightly match my landing page and I think will pull clicks for my offer.
I bid high enough to rank #1... settle for #2 if it takes an insane bid for #1. I hang in there with these high bids to get my CTR healthy. I watch keywords that bring in traffic and make negatives for any that will bring low quality traffic. This will improve CTR and conversion rate. I watch the performance of my different ad copies and drop those that perform poorly... again improving CTR and conversion rate.
I am willing to take a beating on bidding and click costs at the start of a campaign. I do this to establish a strong negative KW list, drop poor ads and get my CTR and conversion rate up. This is really important for your quality score.
After you have a nice amount of data you can start making decisions. Do the math to be sure that you are making money. You can loose your shirt easily with adwords.
Your goal should be to make maximum amount of profit per day. Not max profit per sale or max number of sales.
If you sell at MSRP you better be bidding for top position and hope that nobody in your niche comparison shops. If you sell at deep discount max profit per day will probably not occur with you in the #1 position. Usually a few positions from the top (who you underprice) will be where the sweetspot occurs. Your results could vary.
Take Brad Geddes adwords seminar and read his book if you are spending serious money on PPC. This is not a fluffy course. You will do lots of math and think really hard. If you go there thinking that you will listen, sip coffee and fart then stay home. You also better be a guru with excel because anybody who is not doing lots of heavy math is probably loosing his shirt. Just sayin' that adwords is not easy way to make money for the average person. You gotta be smart and think hard and have a little bravery with your money.
-
I saw my quality scores go up significantly when I added 'in' and 'near' to the keyword phrases. Otherwise, the quality score is supposed to go up for keywords with a good CTR over time. People call it the Google Tax.
I just thought I'd add this. Long term I'm using the search term report to add exact match long tail keywords to the adgroups. I bid lower on these terms. The more of these I have, the less overall keyword cost on the account. Do this over time and you can just remove the low QS keywords (when the LT keywords start driving enough traffic) and still and make money. Slow going, but it works.
-
If you have only 10 keywords for each adgroup it sounds like you need to make more exact/phrase keywords that relate to your ads better -your adgroups are to broad try building more adgroups based on high volume search queries,
-
Of course my CTR is low.. however when I hover over my keywords, most of my keywords say "expected clickthrough: average".
I have almost 2000 negative keywords
I've tried everything on the ads. I've copied my competitors, i've gotten really creative and out of the box, the most boring ads work the best unfortunately.
Also, I've got a bunch of long tail kws but none with any substantial traffic.
-
My bet is that you have a low CTR.....
If you are bidding puny amounts your rankings will be low and that will make your CTR really low. If that is the case then open the throttle on the bidding.
Also, have you implemented negative keywords? Reserving your ad for display for only the most relevant queries will increase your CTR.
Finally, do you have an ad that really pulls in the clicks? If your ad is a sleeper and everyone around you is getting the clicks and you are not then that will drop your CTR and result in low QS.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google-powered search bar suddenly returning totally different results than usual - User Intent?
Our website has a Google powered search bar and for some popular keywords it has always returned the same results but for the past week it has been returning totally different and nonsensical results with the previous top 2 entries now on the 2nd and 4th pages of the results. It seems to be mixing up two separate keywords which the same user may search for but which both mean two very different things. Is this a User Intent issue do you think? Anyone know if there's anything we can do to stop it? I'm guessing not...
Conversion Rate Optimization | | missus0 -
Google showing in snippets last individual rating instead of aggregate rating
the product pages of my ecommerce site contain schema markup.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | lcourse
according to rich snippet tool from google all looks fine and properly formatted
however in the SERP google shows the last rating in the snippet instead of the aggregate rating. any idea how to show the aggregate ratings? URL: https://www.humidordiscount.co.uk/adorini-triest-deluxe-rosewood-humidor below extract of schema code as recognized by the rich snippet tool: Product name:adorini Triest Deluxe Rosewood Humidor image:https://www.humidordiscount.co.uk/952-large_atch/adorini-triest-deluxe-rosewood-humidor.jpg description:High-quality multiple ..... brand [Organization]: name:Adorini offers [Offer]: price:141 priceCurrency:GBP availability:http://schema.org/InStock aggregateRating [AggregateRating]: worstRating:1 ratingValue:4.5 bestRating:5 ratingCount:460 review [Review]: description:It 's my first .... reviewRating [Rating]: ratingValue:4 worstRating:1 bestRating:5 author [Thing]: name:Alessandro M review [Review]: description:excellent ... reviewRating [Rating]: ratingValue:5 worstRating:1 bestRating:50 -
Does anybody know of a reliable website phone call lead tracking service that integrates with Google Analytics?
We are trying to get more detailed data about where direct website phone calls are coming from (not just Adwords call extensions). We know there are a few services available that do this. However are there any recommendations for a reliable one? We would like to show our clients Google Analytics conversion metrics that shows incoming phone calls from different campaigns.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | RosemaryB1 -
Adwords Advice
Hi. I have a few questions regarding Adwords set up. I typically follow a highly targeted model with Ad Groups consisting of a few ads and keywords. I have a client who offers multiple services across multiple towns/cities/counties but what I want to know is the best way to structure this at campaign level. Say they offer carpet cleaning, window cleaning and car cleaning. In cities London, Birmingham and Leeds. Now when setting the campaign up, would I be better served to set up a Campaign at: City Level. Eg London location settings, london keywords, london in Ad copy. Service Level. London, Leeds & Birmingham in location setting. Ad Groups for each city with Ads aimed at each city/keywords. Or City & Service level. Eg. London location settings. London Car Cleaning. The Ad Group, Ads, Keywords. What is the best structure to use? I see location as important but if I restrict settings to 1 city, am I doing myself out of some searches from regions on the border of London that might be interested in the service? I want Ads, Keywords to be highly targeted but the best way to play it. Thanks
Conversion Rate Optimization | | YNWA1 -
Adwords Tracking
Hi, With Adwords conversion tracking is it worth allow Analytics data in as well? Does that confuse the adwords tracking data? Does it only include Analytics data that has been set up for conversion tracking? I hope i am asking the right questions 🙂
Conversion Rate Optimization | | wood1e19680 -
What's the best thing to put in the footer on a PPC landing page?
From a conversion perspective what are the best elements to have in the footer of a Paid landing page.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | SirSud0 -
Reviewing my Adwords Strategy
Before I started working on Organic SEO, I did Adwords. Being that I am entirely self-taught with adwords, I am concerned that about what I might not know. From time to time I have looked for outside advice, but I never got very far. It seemed that I would be talking to a salesman, someone who knew less than me, or someone who was horrified that I had 7,500 tracked words. So I am presenting my methods here for comment. Each keyword I have used is placed into an exact match campaign, phrase match campaign, and broad match campaign. Exact match gets the highest bid, broad match the lowest. Every week, I cull new keywords from phrase and broad results. I also create negative keywords each week based on searches that are obviously not looking for my products. Over time, I get very few searches triggered from broad matches. Keywords are kept in ad groups that generally have less than 6 keywords. Acceptable conversion costs are decided based on product category. I have made an assumption that first position adwords results are too expensive (idiots overpay for them). I automatically reduce my bid 10% on any ad that has an average position of greater than 1.5. I automatically reduce my bid 10% on any ad that has a conversion cost greater than my target. I delete keyword that have a CTR below 1%. I generally require 300 clicks to make a determination. All ads have been endlessly split tested to the point I don’t split test them much now. I judged ads for both click through rate and conversion rate. End result: After 4 years of doing this, conversion costs are below target costs. Not sure what else I could do to improve it, but looking for ideas. Management of the system is pretty easy now, as well. Anything I am missing?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | EugeneF0 -
Why does Google only show the review stars for some listings in the Places results
I have a client who shows up in the Places results for his targeted keyword phrase, but one of his competitors' listing shows 5 gold stars next to the reviews which causes him to stand out visually. I was under the impression that at one time the stars only showed for listings that had official Google reviews, but the other listings in the results also have "Google Reviews" but no stars.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | joshualfink0