Best Course of Action For Over Optimized Link Profile
-
I'm working on a few sites right now and before I came on board, they purchased spammy link building packages. For instance, one site shows 3.8k links from 600 root domains. As you can guess, these are ALL spammy pages with dozens to hundreds of links on each. They're all targeted keywords to the homepage. Our other site shows 600+, and again, all spammy links from unrelated spam sites and free link directory packages.
The site in question had duplicate content taken from other sites and about 7 pages total indexed. It has since been updated to a WordPress theme with original content and many additional pages. It also has proper SCHEMA locations as it is a legitimate, local business.
We receive next to no organic traffic, the pages don't rank for the terms (duh), and basically I'm concerned with moving forward. I don't want to spend time building legitimate links to our sites if we're already nuked by Google.
What I'm asking is, do any of you have experience _successfully _using the disavow tool to remove past links? I really don't think a solid link building campaign to our newly updated site is going to undo the thousands of spammy and over-optimized links we have in place already.
How likely is it that Google gets the point that we are a legitimate site with new, fresh content when the site receives legitimate links from related sites and such?
-
Sounds like you're on the right track, nice job! And, I agree with you, I wouldn't pay a company to remove links, even if I paid them to put them up in the first place. Especially since you have the power of the disavow tool.
Good luck!
-
Hi Kristina,
Thanks for the response. Your outline is honestly the exact steps I've taken, only I didn't use RMOOV or any other service to identify the bad links because virtually ALL of our links were bad.
Here's what I did:
I downloaded all of our links from both OSE and WMT and stripped duplicates. I then used an Excel add-in that stripped ROOT domains into the B column. I combined that with some Excel functions to compare a list of domains I'd created (good domains, such as our local citations) and return a result if they showed up. That way I could enter a list with Yelp, Angie's List, etc. and remove the "good" links. So I stripped out duplicates, good domains, and had the rest.
I got all the WHOIS information I could by using this Bulk WHOIS checker and grouped domains together with the same WHOIS information (as well as sites which were clearly part of the same network). I've sent out hundreds of requests and screen shotted all of them for when the time comes to prove our case to Google.
And I've been keeping the disavow sheet current as I go along, noting sites which have no contact information, appear to be down for now (still disavowing in case they return), and sites which demand payment to remove links.
And as you asked about in the end, I contacted the company which purchased/built these links in the first place. They claimed they still had control over them. When I asked them about removing them, they stopped responding. They're shady, and honestly I wouldn't feel comfortable paying them to remove links, because they could just generate more in the future and offer their "link removal services" to us down the line.
Thanks again for the response! I'm still plugging away at removing these crappy links. One day the profiles will be balanced enough to sustain Google's algorithm changes!
-
Unfortunately, I'm not sure of a way you can go about this quickly without a service like Link Detox and RMOOV. But, if I were in your shoes, I would:
- Get a list of all URLs pointing to your site. Sounds like you already have one, based on the question.
- If you're willing to use a service, use Link Detox to identify spammy links. If you'd like to do this on your own, get the PageRank for each link (it'll be quicker with an API, but you can always use Google's toolbar). If it's a PageRank 0, it's probably bad.
- Manually review PageRank 1 and 2 sites. Sorry, no way to skip that without using a tool.
- Get a list of spammy sites that you'd like to remove links from. Use Whois to find the contact information. They have an API as well.
- Email all of them. This needs to be done by you regardless of whether or not there's a tool out there for it, because you're going to need to have those emails as evidence that you're taking steps to clean this up in case you ever get hit by Penguin.
- After giving them enough time to respond, and a few follow up emails, disavow any links that webmasters weren't willing to take links down for.
You didn't make it sound like it's an option, but it's worth mentioning that many of these sites may still be owned by the person who was originally paid to put those links up. Any chance you could dig through finances to get contact information for all paid links and remove them that way?
Good luck!
-
Hey Gary,
Thanks for the helpful response and I'm sorry to hear about your site being hit. I don't think our site was ever "hit" by anything. The only link building that has been done were the spam packages that were purchased before I came on board.
But even if we haven't been hit yet, I really doubt we'll be able to climb too high with these links in place. I guess I have no chance but to start requesting that these links be removed.
Do you have any helpful hints on how I can go about this quicker? Is the Link Assistant tool any good? I see that it has options for importing links and searching their page for contact information w/ a built-in email client. Any ideas?
Thanks all.
Edit: Just to clarify, I know there are services for this like RemoveEm and RMOOV. I'm curious about software being available to do this ourselves. Thanks.
-
You could be just one more Penguin revision away from a penalty.
I would get most of those bad links in a disavow file right away. The start to contact as many as you can and get the worst ones removed. this will safeguard you from a future penalty.
Once this is done you will have to wait for Google to re-crawl all those links to apply the nofollow attribute via the disavow.
While you wait for that to happen you can start by getting some traction on white hat link building / outreach.
This whole process can be done very very quickly. You must also confirm that the issue of rank drop is related to Penguin or you may see very little changes.
I have a site that was hit so hard by panda and Penguin that its been very difficult to recover and a new domain could be on the cards. Its a large site with a big brand that has been around for 10 years but almost 3 years of bad rankings has been a nightmare and very expensive path for the company to have taken up to this point. Who knows where the company would have been if it was moved to a new domain with 3 years of work applied to it.
-
Thanks for the response. I agree. One thing I want to mention is that each of these sites are connected to Webmaster Tools and none of them have alerts for unnatural or spammy link building.
Also, one of the sites in question ranks for a bunch of keywords in spots 40-80, so Google hasn't totally devalued the domain.
To answer your question, yes, it would be worth it if it would have an impact on the rankings. What I'm curious about is how damaging these links can be. I mean, obviously they're bad, no questions about that. But if Webmaster Tools hasn't sent a message and we currently have some rankings, we can't be totally screwed, can we?
Thanks again for the response. Bah, such a difficult situation.
-
This is really a question of labor versus value. You can use tools as well as contact other sites that have bad links and disconnect that way. It can be done but it takes a lot of time. If it is worth the labor cost do it. If it is not, don't
-
Thanks for the response, Jeff.
I actually meant to include a bit about starting over in the original post as I'd considered that. These sites are for local businesses which have LOTS of local business situations throughout the web. They're legitimate businesses with Yelp reviews and Google+ pages and such and the search engines have absolutely linked the sites with the businesses. I feel like this is the only reason why they're not completely sandboxed and crushed in Google's eyes because they're legit, solid businesses.
So the domain name isn't AMAZING, but it's the company name and lots of legit, local "building" has been done in the previous years just by it functioning as a legitimate business. We have many citations throughout the web that link this business NAP to the site and correcting all of these would be kind of a hassle (even with a service like Yext).
Another site has 375 links, nearly all from directories. I know these links suck, but a small site shouldn't be completely crushed by a directory link package, should it?
-
Unless it's a particularly amazing domain name, this is an issue that's going to follow you for quite some time. The disavow link system can be helpful in circumstances like this, but it's always been promoted by Google as a tool of last resort.
Not knowing much about the site, my $0.02 would probably vote for a clean slate with a new domain name, and shut down the older site.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Backlinks vs External Links vs Referral Links vs Outbound links
Hello all, I was just wondering if you could explain the difference between all the links above? I'm confused as they all seem to be the same or similar and I would just like to clearly know what distinguishes them from eachother. Thanks for your help, Jayne
Link Building | | NCOREGSEO0 -
Am I better off with ten links from one site or one link from ten sites?
I am writing a series of linked-back articles for a highly-ranked web publisher, but wonder if I'd be better off sharing the articles across different sites. My goal is to grow our domain authority and SEO rankings.
Link Building | | Lysarden0 -
Are links from charities really better than 'normal' links.
Hi Guys. Just wondering about this idea that links from Charities are particularly good. I've heard people say that links from .org sites are particularly strong. But anyone can get a .org domain, it's just that charities tend to use them more often. Right? I just don't get the logic. Can anyone give more detail about this? Is it a myth? Is there quality info on this topic I can check out? We're working with several charities at the moment, and they all seem happy to blog and link to us...so I just wanted to know a little more. Isaac.
Link Building | | isaac6630 -
Best way to regular check backlinks & identify low quality and spammy links?
Previously my site was under manual penalty and then 80% of the links i removed and my penalty lifted. ( I am talking about 1 year before) Now i have few queries - What is the best way to regular check backlinks? what to do if a spammy link appears What to do about directories that link to us What to do with old links that are not good quality Now I have to check number of links and quality of links of website so which is the best method check? Thanks! dev
Link Building | | devdan0 -
Internal Links - How to Increase them, Categories not being considered as Internal Links
Hi All: As per my understanding, Internal Equity Passing Links is a metric defining PA. Now my website has around 65 internal links while few of my competitors have more than 180 links. I am unable to understand how to increase the internal links passing equity on my website, because I can see, more number of links on my website than my competitors but opensiteexplorer does not show that. I am really confused. Please help out if anyone knows something about this issue. Thanks in advance.
Link Building | | sidjain4you0 -
How much time does it take for the links to be forwarded to redirected link?
Hi there,
Link Building | | MoeezLodhi
Thank you for taking out some time for this question; I have changed the permalinks last week for a website.. I forgot to redirect old permalinks to the new one.. So I did 301 redirection, it has been 4-5 days since I did that but the links are not forwarded to the new Permalink so far.
How much time should I wait for the links to be forwarded to the new permalinks? Secondly, I am sure I have done the 301 redirect correctly, as when I go to the old url / permalink it directs me to the new permalink. So I am sure 301 is done correctly. Do I need to submit the sitemap again?0 -
What is the Best Tool to Identify Toxic Links?
I've been using Link Detox from linkresearchtools.com against the list of back links provided in my GWT account although it seems it is not enough. What tools are the best at identifying toxic links?
Link Building | | sbrault740 -
Which Links to Disavow!
We just took over SEO for a new client who is being penalized for a bad link profile. They've asked Google to reconsider multiple times, and Google still claims that the links are bad. Because of this, and because I don't have direct access (logins, etc.) to what the former SEO did, I am considering using the disavow links tool. The most obvious links to disavow are a group of almost 1000 links that come from the same forum. However, when viewing the links on this forum they actually seem natural. People are reviewing the product (ipod cases), both negatively and positively. While this could have been an SEO tactic for link building, I don't want to disavow these links if they're not the problem, even though this domain is the source of almost all the low-quality links. Another site that has more than 200 links is Askives. Do any of you have experience with links from Askives, or removing these links? Thanks again!
Link Building | | newwhy0