At a Loss With What to do With This Site
-
Hi people, a friend of mine runs a payday loan site with a very valuable domain name: http://bit.ly/1lyJgME
The site was penalised by Google about 18 months ago, up until then it ranked #1 for payday loan and on the 1st page for the plural, payday loans in the UK. Now the website is nowhere in the top 200 results for either of the phrases, but he has not received any notification from Google and if he checks in webmaster tools in the manual actions section there is nothing there.
He has gone through all of the links to his site several times and attempted to remove any unnatural links, those that he could not get rid of after emailing twice he disavowed - about 800, a lot were not even built by him.
He has sent 2-3 reconsideration requests to Google and every time they said that the site had not been penalised, or something to that affect.
The site does have lots of quality organic links from websites like Wired Magazine and the National Geographic, more then enough decent links to rank somewhere on Google for its keywords.
I feel that the site may have been held to a higher standard because a lot of people think that payday loan websites are unethical.
What do you think he should do? Can you spot anything on site that is wrong? He has definitely tried to remove every single unnatural link and the ones he could not he disavowed.
-
Hi guys, thanks for the responses.
We have used the Screamingfrog tool and spotted a bunch of 403 pages so we are looking into that.
Images were all used with permission.
I have mentioned the telephone number and address thing to the guy.
I have checked about the national geographic link and there was definitely no bribe involved.
-
Perfect! You think he'd take $100 to link to me? And, do you promise not to tell Google?
EDIT: That page has a meta robots nofollow on it. That sneaky devil.
-
-
Very interesting! But the important question is how I can get a payday loans link from the pope's site. Have you mastered that yet EGOL?
-
Looks like one of the NG bloggers got some infographics from paydayloans.co.uk and posted them on the NatGeo blog
http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2012/09/28/is-it-green-to-be-green/
http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2012/07/24/great-depression-vs-great-recession/
Even though NG is a white hat site (almost up there with the Pope's site), it is possible that Google thought that the loan guys were sneaking in some spammy infographic links. One of those posts give two links to paydayloans.co.uk and to another site in the loan sector. If I was the editor at NG those posts would not have been approved.
NatGeo looks to be a favorite target of the payday loan linkbuilders.
-
Just a quick question, what have National Geographic and Wired Magazine got to do with payday loans? Obviously I haven't seen them but if they are just random links then I'd count them as spammy even though they are on highly authoritative websites. If you look at the distribution of anchor text as well it is heavily weighted to keyword anchor text links (payday loans) rather than branded links.
Exact Match Domains took a bit of hit as well so the benefits that the website would have received from having an EMD would have been devalued. I'd say to work on building some quality and relevant links because the website is lacking in them.
-
Payday loans sites are notoriously difficult to recover because of the widespread spam in the industry.
Do you have any manual action at all in Webmaster Tools? To check, go to Search Traffic --> Manual Actions.
If there is no manual action then it's possible that the site is affected by the Payday Loans algo: http://searchengineland.com/google-pay-day-loan-algorithm-google-search-algorithm-update-to-target-spammy-queries-162941. Unfortunately we don't know a lot about this algorithm and how to recover.
One of the things that I think is vitally important is that in order to rank as a payday loans site you have to be a legitimate brick and mortar business. (This is just my opinion. I don't have proof of this.) When I go to the site, the fact that there is no phone number published raises flags for me. When I Googled the address I got a building that primarily has a carpet store in it. I found this site that shows me businesses near 928 High Rd and there is no mention of a Payday Loans company: http://www.192.com/places/n/n12-9/n12-9rw/
I think that Google only wants to rank Payday loan sites that are legitimate businesses and don't just exist online. Don't get me wrong - You still could be a legitimate business, but from Google's standpoint the site looks like many of the hundreds of other payday loans sites that exist only on the internet and are affiliates of well known trusted businesses.
If that's not it, then it's possible that the Penguin algorithm is affecting the site. What I have found is that recovery from Penguin is EXTREMELY hard for a payday loans site. When we have removed manual penalties from Payday loans sites, Google has given us remote example links that were nowhere to be found on any backlink checkers. Penguin is slightly different because Google won't give you example links, but if Penguin was the issue then you have to find close to every bad backlink ever made in order to see recovery and you have to have a good base of truly natural links.
We've recovered payday loans sites from manual penalties, but have learned that these cases are significantly harder than other sites. As such, we now only take clients in the loans vertical that have true brick and mortar businesses and we charge significantly more for these sites.
I wish I had more encouraging advice for you. If the site is truly a legitimate business outside of the internet, then I would work hard to establish that fact so that Google can recognize you. I'd focus next on doing everything you can to find additional unnatural backlinks that you can disavow. Make sure that you are disavowing on the domain level as well.
-
just sayin.....
This site is displaying a lot of images that they probably do not own... images owned by companies who are really really aggressive in going after infringers. In 2012, Google said that they were getting millions of DMCA notices EVERY MONTH and were taking action against sites that get repeated complaints. The Pirate Update. More here.
This might not be the problem you are seeing at this time... but if they don't have permission for the images would be a good thing to get under control.
-
He needs to start with the obvious first. Take a look at Webmaster Tools to make sure Google is indexing his pages. Do a Fetch on some pages to see what Google sees. Next move would be to have a full, in depth site audit done to review all the elements of the site. Screaming Frog is a good tool for that. Then he needs to go back and explore his links again. Adding some new, relevant links will help.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
A website scaped my site
Hello this website https://theraphy24.co.uk/ scapred my home page with my canonical, so the website is linking to https://prayer-time.uk/ The probleme is the guy is linking to theraphy24 with bad links and Moz show that thats links are linking to my domain (spamy links). I disavoed all the links. Is that enought? What can I do more? Thank you
Link Building | | Gislene320 -
Domain Change, loss of inbound links ...
We're strongly considering a domain name change; this is purely for marketing reasons. We think in the long term, this will be a good thing. I believe we can mitigate the page redirection, branding changes, etc. My concern are the inbound links: from 200+ domains, 3,000+ links. So, I guess we can contact each of the top sites linking to us and hope they update our links. I'm not hopeful. I believe we'll loose must of the links. Has anyone been down this road and have experience to share?
Link Building | | jmueller0823
What should I expect, worst case? Is there a way to mitigate? Thanks much.
Jim0 -
Backlinks from Open Site Explorer not updated
Hi folks! I was checking the backlink profile for my website - wishpicker.com - we got linked to by a large number of prominent websites in the last couple of months. For some reason, this does not seem to show up when I do a backlink search on OSE. Is there something that I need to do here/ fix? Thanks in advance!
Link Building | | AB_Newbie0 -
On-Page E-commerce Site Optimization
Hello everyone! Just started on a new job as in house SEO and PPC but it is also my first job as such, got little experience and for what I know the site needs a lot of work in terms of optimization. I would like to ask some help and some opinions about what I think should be done in order to rank higher because at the moment the highest ranking page doesn't go higher than the third page for general but high traffic volume keywords. All the titles tag are too long, some of them are up to 100 characters The meta tag isn't optimized properly to attract people and get clicks the content on the product pages is laid out badly and there aren't many keywords a lot of duplicate content there are little inbound links there isn't a section for content such as a news page, a blog or anything like that which makes link building even harder Here my challenges: Create well optimized product, category , subcategory pages to improve also the PPC landing pages Improve the rankings at least to get on the first page for general keywords Choose the right keywords to optimize the site for increase the number of inbound links. I also have to manage adwords and given my little experience I can't seem to prioritize things so any suggestions would be really appreciated. Also if you don't mind to take a look at the site and leave me comments on things that I should improve, I'd be grateful . The main problem also is the niche I work in is not the best, I know nothing about it which makes things worse. repsole.com Thank you for reading Oscar
Link Building | | PremioOscar0 -
Penguin: Carry On & Hope Or Start A New Site
I'm at a loss and no so-called SEO agency/expert I've hired appears to know the main causes of our post-Penguin downfall of our traffic. To set the scene, I set up a voucher code site (www.ozvouchercodes.com.au) in Australia 3 years ago and since, it's been growing very well up until Google launched the Penguin update in April. Having read as much as I could on the update my understanding is toxic links cause the slap. For on-site I've checked the site and tried to reduce keywords [spamming], increased [unique] content across the site and made sure there are as few instances of duplicate content as possible. To attempt to understand my back link profile I've used SEOmoz & Link Detective as the current SEO agency give me little visibility on this. It appears we're a little top heavy with 32% & 11% of are keywords containing 'coupons' and 'promotion codes' respectively. Consequently we no longer appear on those two terms but also hundreds of other terms we once appeared in the top 3 postitions. The Link Detective report downloaded also appears to have a number of back links with the words 'Penalized' and 'Banned' next to them. Unfortunately there is no explanation on Link Detective whether this needs action or not. My current SEO agency suggest that we have been too focused on a limited number of keywords and that a few more months of diversifying the range will solve it. So do I spend another £X amount for 3-6 months of SEO or drop the site on a new URL and start again. Any ideas? Any help is very welcome & appreciated. Henry
Link Building | | henryboyson1231 -
Link to my site not showing up in Open Site Explorer
If a link to my site on another domain does not appear in the list of links gathered by the Open Site Explorer, does that mean that this backlink will not be crawled by search engine bots? Is there anything I should do to make sure that this link IS crawled and/or recognized by search engines coughGooglecough?
Link Building | | robgleslie0 -
Hey guys wondering which is more important getting links from authority sites or relevant sites?
basically a site that has really high authority but not that relevant or medium authority pages but relevant. an example an authority site with a mozrank of 80 or a relevant site of 20.
Link Building | | shrikey0