How does CTR relate to SERPS Position?
-
I'd always though that CTR would increase with SERPS position but my data doesn't really seem to show that.
I used google analytics/acquisition/SEO/Queries and looked at the top 1800 queries. Then I filtered those with a CTR of 0 and for branded keywords.
The result was as shown - a big glob with no real pattern other than a long tail of keywords with a 100% CTR
Does this tell me anything useful or am I just wasting my time?
Its probably worth stating that only 12 of my keywords had over 1000 impressions and none over 10,000 (all in top 10 though) - but thats a function of my industry sector
-
Hi Zippy-Bungle,
If your rankings improve then your CTR is likely to improve too. To affect CTR you can use the meta description and title tags - the more compelling your meta des the more likely it'll get clicks. I sometimes use high performing ad text for this if it's relevant.
As to whether an increase in CTR would relate to an increase in rankings - I don't really know. However, I did notice that our CTR dropped slightly and then our listings dropped a little too - whether this is a coincidence or not I couldn't tell you.
I think it would be very difficult for Google to use CTR, time on site and bounce as ranking signals. For example, if someone just wants my company's phone number, they may do a brand name search, find the number at the top of our pages and call us but analytics/google would count this as a bounce! So, we've been 'useful' but we've not encouraged the visitor to click into deeper pages (they found what they were looking for on the first page they visited) - so how does google know when a page has been 'useful' or not? (obviously I know links play a role here, I'm just speaking from a data perspective).
So, I suspect google doesn't use these signals, because it seems pretty darn difficult to determine what is a real bounce and what isn't (as in a real bounce would be where the site you click on is useless for the query). As for time on site... well, if you follow google's instructions and make your site faster (we halved our site speed in April) then time on site will inevitably reduce (ours did!) so, again I don't know how google would use this (unless it was in conjunction with site speed). As for CTR - that only tells one half of the story, so again, not sure how google could use it. I know they use it for adwords, but it's in their best interests for the most likely to be clicked ad to be highly prominent and any reduction in cpc as a result is easily mitigated by the fact that it gets more clicks (stack 'em high, sell 'em cheap)
However, I do think google probably uses a metric similar to bounce, when users use the back button to immediately leave a page they've just landed on and end up back on the same serp as they started from. This is just my theory, and the reason I think they use something like this is because if I was them I would. I will probably get shouted down here by everyone else, and this is just my opinion so do with it what you will!
-
Hi Tom, yes that's what I meant,. Never thought about it the other way round so I'm glad for the confusion as I learned something that I hadn't expected to learn.
Ive ve still got the issue with the data blob though not seeming to correspond with what other sources show. Is it a function of low search volumes or something else?
-
Beg your pardon, I think I misinterpreted your initial question. My answer addressed "Would an increase in CTR result in an increase in rankings" (No), but I think you meant "Would an increase in rankings result in an increase in CTR" (Usually yes)
Sorry about that, was that what you meant?
-
Thanks. That's good to know. I thought there was a case a few years ago where some Yahoo data got into the open and it showed that there was a correlation.
Checking on that I discovered this Moz article (which is more recent) which seems to imply that there is a relation - or have I misunderstood your answer, the article or both?
-
Your data shows you what is generally accepted - there is no relation between CTR and organic search.
Certainly with what Google tells us it has no baring at all - although we should always take what they say with a pinch of salt, my own tests and most other people I know agree with this. Some people think the time on site/bounce rate may have an affect, but again I don't think this is the case either.
The only time where CTR comes into play is for PPC, where it can affect your cost-per-lick and quality score.
For SEO, it's widely agreed that there is no relation.
Hope this helps.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How Reliable is the Avg Query Position in GA?
Hi Moz Community, I wanted to know how reliable the average position data is for queries in Google Analytics search console report. I know this report is fairly new this year and the numbers are calculated a bit differently than they were in the old search engine optimization report. I want to know what the biggest differences are between this search console report vs. the old SEO report in GA. I'm also pretty confused about how GA reports on the average position. Obviously it's an average position of whatever date range your choose. But for instance, if your site shows multiples landing pages for one search query will it roll that into the average or just take the landing page that ranks higher? Does the position average take into account video or photo serp results and is this the average across mobile, desktop and tablet? This number has always been a guess since it's sampled data but I want to know how accurate it is. I read this article in 2014 (linked below) but I'm not sure if it all still applies now that that data might be presented differently. https://moz.com/ugc/testing-the-accuracy-of-avg-position-for-search-queries-in-google-webmaster-tools Any answers or discussions would be great here. Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | znotes1 -
Title Tag Capitalization Impact on SERP Rankings and Click Through Rates
My company made a branding decision to use lowercase for all of our title tags. This, of course, means that our titles on SERPs are all lower case. Overwhelmingly, it seems that websites use title case. This makes me wonder if we're shooting ourselves in the foot. Does using lower case titles negatively impact our rankings and/or click through rates? Is there any data out there suggesting that title case has a better click through rate than lower case? Thanks for reading!
Reporting & Analytics | | Solid_Gold0 -
Relation between Page and Landing Page
Hi all, I am looking through the Analytics data on a specific 'page' (404.html which is the Not found page) and as my secondary dimensions, I have Landing Page data. Now am I not sure how the page and the landing page are related here. Is it basically saying 58 Page views of the 404.html were originated by the users who landed on brochures.html? If someone could provide any pointers on it, it would be great. Thank you for your time. uZQJ
Reporting & Analytics | | nirpan0 -
Difference between GWT and GA average position
Does anyone know why there would be a difference in average position from GA and GWT? I am seeing completely different results for the same date ranges. Thank you!
Reporting & Analytics | | bloomingB0 -
GA: How can non related kws show up in the organic report?
Hi mozzers, I have a site A: www.example.com (with its own branded kws) SiteB: subdomain.example.com Site A and B are related and belong to the same company. Site B was released a couple months ago. ISSUE: I have noticed branded kws from Site A showing up on Site B's GA which doesn't make any sense. I try to make searches in the SE with those kws and not a single search showed the Site B(subdomain). What is weird is that 2 months ago had a an issue with bounce rate on site B showing a 0% bounce rate, then I discovered that we had 2 GATC on site, removed the extra code and bounce was back to normal. Since then I have seen a rise of branded kws from Site A to Site B. Can someone help me here figuring out what is wrong? Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | Ideas-Money-Art0 -
Why do we temporarily rank for highly competitive words after writing a related blog post?
I write for a blog that Google probably "likes" at this point because we update so frequently and get a decent amount of traffic. Sometimes this happens and it has always been puzzling to me: Let's use an example. Say I write a blog called "How to eat spaghetti." For the next few days, we will get a ton of traffic for people who type "spaghetti." But when I check us on rank trackers we are nowhere to be found for that term. What is happening here? Sometimes the traffic will all be international and located in some random city in Africa or something. Any thoughts? Super confused by this. We have gotten lots of traffic for extremely competitive words because of this, but it only lasts a couple days.
Reporting & Analytics | | LilyRay0 -
Why is this website with worse metrics performing better on serps?
Hi! I would like to ask if anyone has any ideas on why the second website in this analysis is getting position 2 on google and website 1 is getting position 5: http://www.opensiteexplorer.org/comparisons?site=bonobetfair.info&comparisons[0]=www.bonobetfair.com&=Compare The metrics indicate that the first website is clearly superior in (almost) all metrics. Why could this be?
Reporting & Analytics | | inmonova0 -
Ranking on page 1 position 3 but hardley any visits
in one of my projects the expected vistors is around 23000 weve got the keyword onto the first page position 3 and weve only recieved 30 vistits this month, my qustion is why? are the local searches from google analtics that tell you thier are 23000 searches for that keyword false please can someone shed some light on this, my client is totally over the moon with his ranking but cant believe that hes only recieving 30 visits this month from what we thought was a million dollar keyword
Reporting & Analytics | | Westernoriental0