Site relaunch and impact on SEO
-
I have some tough decisions to make about a web site I run. The site has seen around for 20 years (September 1995, to be precise, is the date listed against the domain). Over the years, the effort I've expanded on the site has come and gone, but I am about to throw a lot of time and effort back into it.
The majority of the content on the site is pretty dated, isn't tremendously useful to the audience (since it's pretty old) and the site design and URL architecture isn't particularly SEO-friendly.
In addition, I have a database of thousands vendors (for the specific industry this site serves). I don't know if it's a factor any more but 100% of the links there have been populated by the vendors themselves specifically requesting inclusion (through a form we expose on the site). When the request is approved, the vendor link shows up on the appropriate pages for location (state) and segment of the industry. Though the links are all "opt-in" from vendors (we've never one added or imported any ourselves), I am sure this all looks like a terrible link farm to Google! And some vendors have asked us to remove their link for that reason
One final (very important) point. We have a relationship with a nationwide brand and have four very specific pages related to that brand on our site. Those pages are essential - they are by far the most visited pages and drive virtually all our revenue. The pages were put together with SEO in mind and the look and feel is very different to the rest of the site. The result is, effectively, a site-within-a-site. I need to carefully protect the performance of these pages.
To put some rough numbers on this, the site had 475,000 page views over the last year, with about 320,000 of those being to these four pages (by the way, for the rest of the content "something happened" around May 20th of last year - traffic almost doubled overnight - even though there were no changes to our site).
We have a Facebook presence and have put a little effort into that recently (increasing fans from about 10,000 last August to nearly 24,000 today, with a net gain of about 2,500 per month currently). I don't have any sense of whether that is a meaningful resource in the big picture.
So, that's the background. I want to totally revamp the broader site - much improved design, intentional SEO decisions, far better, current and active content, active social media presence and so on. I am also moving from one CMS to another (the target CMS / Blog platform being WordPress).
Part of me wants to do the following:
- Come up with a better plan for SEO and basically just throw out the old stuff and start again, with the exception of the four vendor pages I mentioned
- Implement redirection of the old URLs to new content (301s)
- Just stop exposing the vendor pages (on the basis that many of the links are old/broken and I'm really not getting any benefit from them)
- Leave the four important pages exactly as they are (URL and content-wise)
I am happy to rebuild the content afresh because I have a new plan around that for which I have some confidence. But I have some important questions.
- If I go with the approach above, is there any value from the old content / URLs that is worth retaining?
- How sure can I be there is no indirect negative effect on the four important pages? I really need to protect those pages
- Is throwing away the vendor links simply all good - or could there be some hidden negative I need to know about (given many of the links are broken and go to crappy/small web sites, I'm hoping this is just a simple decision to make)
And one more uber-question. I want to take a performance baseline so that I can see where I started as I start making changes and measure performance over time. Beyond the obvious metrics like number of visitors, time per page, page views per visit, etc what metrics would be important to collect from the outset?
I am just at the start of this project and it is very important to me. Given the longevity of the site, I don't know if there is much worth retaining for that reason, even if the content changes radically. At a high level I'm trying to decide what questions I need to answer before I set off on this path.
Any suggestions would be very much appreciated.
Thanks.
-
The vendor links are an important factor for me (and potentially lost in this thread, which is broader in scope). For that reason I opened a separate thread specifically to drill down on that aspect:
http://moz.com/community/q/should-i-remove-all-vendor-links-link-farm-concerns
-
Monica,
Thank you so much for your response, which is greatly appreciated. As you might imagine, I have a few more questions.
Can I assume that when you indicate that the old URLs are worth retaining that use of 301 redirects falls into that? Or, instead, are you suggesting that I should actually retain the old URLs (no redirect)?
The content issue is a little more unclear to me. It is true that I get a small percentage (about 33%) from those other pages. But that still adds up to 150,000 page views. Not a ton of activity, admittedly, but also non-zero
My (tentative) conclusion at this point is to port the existing content as-is, but map to a better URL structure, redirecting the old URLs to the new ones (301). Then, as I start creating new, more valuable content (with completely new URLs) I will have pages that effectively supercede the older content, and I'd redirect the older URLs to the new ones. At that point I have new content and a new URL structure, so it's something of a phased approach but doesn't necessitate throwing away all my current content. Anyway, that approach is on my mind.
The SEO story around the vendor pages is not a good one
Here's how it works. Each vendor can submit their details through a form and select a topic and a location (state). Once approved, that vendor would show on a topic page and a separate location page. We don't have pages where we don't have data (so, if Nebraska doesn't have any vendors we don't artificially create an empty page) - but with thousands of vendors we still have thousands of pages. So, numerically, we are probably well over 50% of these "trash" vendor pages. So, we are presumably in the "world of trouble" right now
I have some questions related to these pages:
- Is there a particular metric or metrics that might "prove" that these pages are doing more damage than good? Does Moz expose anything that readily expresses a page like this being assessed poorly by Google?
- Given that I am almost certain that the pages are "toxic" (but would like to know for sure - see above), would I be best served by simply deleting them (this is easy to do) and then presumably redirect them to the home page since there will be no obvious replacement content. I basically want them gone!
- If I do delete them, over time would the "penalty" be repaired, in terms of SEO
I have a lot of questions, don't I
Seriously, this is really fascinating to me and I'm eager to understand this before I make any changes. In short, I need a plan.
Thanks again
-
Hi there,
After reading your post i would just like to say, I feel your pain. I have been working the past few months at helping a company out a similar situation. Scrapping a website and starting fresh could be very instrumental in your SEO success, but you have to ask yourself is it the overall best thing for my customers?
The first things I would like to point out (just a little unsolicited advice) is that perhaps moving to a completely new site might be the easiest and most efficient way to do this. You will be able to keep your domain and all of its domain authority while bringing your site into the 21st century. You want to give site structure just as much attention as site content. Is your site mobile friendly? If not, you want to move to a responsive design asap. Now, to answer your specific questions.
- If I go with the approach above, is there any value from the old content / URLs that is worth retaining? - The old URLs are worth retaining absolutely. There is a chance that all of the URLs drive traffic to the site, and you want to preserve that. As far as content goes, you seem to think only the content on your 4 "traffic driving" pages are actually driving traffic, so I would say scrap it. If your customers find no value in it, then there is no value to it. It is probably taking up good real estate on your site.
- How sure can I be there is no indirect negative effect on the four important pages? I really need to protect those pages - _There will be a little give and take when you redesign a site. You might see some ranking fluctuations, but if those pages are great performers now, chances are they will still be if you change nothing. I always believe when it comes to content,you have to keep what works, but also add freshness to it. That is why User Generated Content is so valuable! It lets you keep static, keyword targeting content while adding something uniquely valuable. While those pages are performing well now, chances are they will be outdated one day like the rest of your site's copy. _
- Is throwing away the vendor links simply all good - or could there be some hidden negative I need to know about (given many of the links are broken and go to crappy/small web sites, I'm hoping this is just a simple decision to make) - **I recommend you have someone do an indepth analysis of your link profile before you make any changes. Depending on how many links there are and whether or not you would have to disavow them, it could be extremely negative for your SEO. If these links make up 5% of your link profile, you shouldn't see a huge issue. If they make up 50% of your link profile you could end up in a world of trouble. The most important thing you can do for your link profile is build new links, and diversify your link profile. **
And one more uber-question. I want to take a performance baseline so that I can see where I started as I start making changes and measure performance over time. Beyond the obvious metrics like number of visitors, time per page, page views per visit, etc what metrics would be important to collect from the outset? - Heat mapping would be a great tool for you to use. The click trails will give you great in page metrics. GA offers this for free, and Moz offers HotSpot with a Pro membership. I always measure the following things:
- Organic CTR
- Search Impressions
- Percentage of increase/decrease in clicks
- Percentage of increase/decrease in New Sessions
- Bounce Rate
- Organic conversion rate
- Decrease in PPC spend
- _Increase/Decrease in Phone calls - I measure this because it is one of our Key Performance Indicators. _
I hope that you will get lots of good answers to your questions! These are my professional opinions based on experiences I have had with older websites. Good luck to you!
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Two Tracking for Banners - Internal Promotion & Event Tracking -Any Impact on Analytic Figure or Bounce Rate?
Hi All, I have implemented Internal Promotion - https://developers.google.com/tag-manager/enhanced-ecommerce#promo-clicks for my ecommerce site on homepage banners. Along with this I did event tracking for Banner click. So any negative impact of bounce rate or other reports? Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | Arnold30 -
Longterm wordpress blog not providing seo benefit to main site - help needed please
Hi I have a bigcommerce ecommerce store, with a Wordpress blog on a subdomain. The store and blog have been active for four years, the blog is regularly updated with original content, has many links to the store, is promoted regularly via my brand's social media channels and mailing list, and has the simplest SEO basics covered via a Yoast SEO plugin. But the store sees very little, if any, SEO benefit from the blog. My question is: based on this information, and the details below, is there an issue with the connection between the blog and main site in SEO terms? And if there is, how can I start fixing it? Further info: 1 In my Moz dashboard for the store site, the blog does not show at all as providing any inbound links or linking domains 2 Google Analytics also shows zero referral traffic to the store site from the blog since April 2015 3 Moz crawl issues is flagging ‘duplicate page content issues’ for pretty much every page of the blog, and the analysis provided suggests this may be related to tags but I have only basic SEO knowledge and am fast getting out of my depth here. 4 I have today altered the settings within the Yoast plugin on the blog to ‘noindex’ for Tags, Meta Robots, based on advice I have found in this section but am already well over my head and unsure even this is correct. An agency have been running SEO for the store since 2012 but since uncovering how little they have done in this time for the money paid, I am now taking matters back into my own hands. However I am on a very steep learning curve and this one is beyond me right now - please does anyone have any suggestions where I can start looking to uncover the root issue? Any guidance or advice would be greatly appreciated Thanks very much and hope to hear from someone!
Reporting & Analytics | | Warren_331 -
Organic vs SEO in Analytics
In my analytics account, the Acquisition / All Traffic / Google organic searches shows me around 19,000 hits from 1st Jan to 1st Feb. But if I go to the Search Engine Optimization tab / Queries or Landing pages I can only count 1,800 clicks from 1st Jan to 1st Feb. Why such a huge discrepancy ? Am I getting 1800 clicks from the Google organic search, or 19,000 ?
Reporting & Analytics | | coadr930 -
Can 500 errors hurt rankings for an entire site or just the pages with the errors?
I'm working with a site that had over 700 500 errors after a redesign in april. Most of them were fixed in June, but there are still about 200. Can 500 errors affect rankings sitewide, or just the pages with the errors? Thanks for reading!
Reporting & Analytics | | DA20130 -
ROI in SEO
Hi there! I'm just doing the SEO for a client and I just don't know exactly how could I estimate the ROI associated to the SEO actions that are taking place. Should I only consider the conversions made via organic search? Is there another parameter, metric or item I must measure? . Is there something "formal" to follow'? I think I'm missing something. Thanks in advanced.
Reporting & Analytics | | juanmiguelcr0 -
SEO implications of moving from https to http
We're considering moving from 100% https to http to improve performance. What, if any, SEO implications are there? Do search engines need redirects when changing from https to http pages?
Reporting & Analytics | | BlueAcorn0 -
Our SEO is garbage. can someone answer a few questions for me?
I've seen our SEO drop to more or less the bottom of the barrel, and I don't have any answers yet as to why. SEOMoz is running it's crawl currently, and I have a few errors about duplicate titles and content, so I know I have some work cut out for me. But, why the sudden drop? The only change I made at the time was a change to our URL structure, but all links were 301'd to their new location. Does this still hurt SEO that terribly? Also, our robots.txt file is getting indexed and showing up as the first result at times. Very embarrassing. It's doing better than our other pages. 😞 I don't get what's happening here. Yrzu3,fkbYu
Reporting & Analytics | | stagl0 -
Help with local SEO strategy for service industries
Here is the scenario I often wonder about: My client's tree removal service is ranking in #1 in local search for
Reporting & Analytics | | MozMan2
"tree removal town state." His Google Places account is set for a 30 mile radius. He has lots of directory listings and positive reviews. Some inbound links as well. The same client is ranking #1 in organic listing for "tree removal county state" ...I chose to target the county for organic listings because the client was dominating local search for the town. My reasoning: I thought, Google local search would bring all of the local specific searches for "tree removal town state" and organic listings would bring the broader searches for "tree removal county state." That is exactly what's happening and stats show there are some visitors coming to the site searching with the county name. Not a ton of traffic but a lot of keyword variations using the county name. The bulk of the traffic comes from the his Google Places listing for the town the business is located in which is great. Dilemma: My client is not ranking in local search results for neighboring towns just a few miles away and certainly not ranking in organic listings for neighboring towns either because we are targeting the county. He has a long list of town names he services in the footer area and this does seem to help for organic search in neighboring towns with little competition. Broad Question: How can I optimize pages for the same services in neighboring towns without duplicating content. For example, the home page title tag and H1 reads:
Tree Removal, Tree Trimming, Stump Removal, County State It would be very easy to create identical pages with title tags and page headings for the different towns but that would undoubtedly create duplicate content and would look weird to someone browsing the site. Specific Questions: Should I put the town name where the business is located in the title tag even though the site already ranks #1 for that town in local search, without having the town in the title tag? Why not use this importunity for an area that we are not ranking for? Do I nix the county and state and try to insert another town or two in the title and H1? Ideally I would like to have this site rank well in local search for all of the neighboring towns. This may be too broad of a post, (it is my first one) but perhaps there are a few of you out there that can outline strategies that work for service industries like, lawn care, tree removal, landscaping, etc. Thanks for reading.0