Tracking SEO tests
-
Trying to get some best practices on testing SEO changes.
We are going to make a bunch of changes on subsets of pages. Say testing about 5 different on-page changes.
Originally we were going to submit separate Sitemaps to GWT and see if our test sets get indexed, how quickly, etc. But we noticed that GWT says some pages in our Sitemaps aren't indexed even though we know they are (what gives?).
So we thought, for each test, let's put a unique code on the page so we can see how many get indexed by Google.
But that doesn't solve the issue: how many people clicked on our test pages. So we are thinking of putting a tracking pixel on the test pages, specific for each test. But then I am thinking, why not just create a separate Google Analytics profile and place that code on the test pages (set up goals to track visits per test since we aren't going to change the actual URLs).
and on and on
This is where you come in. What kind of tracking do you implement when you set up tests?
Advice appreciated!
E
-
Google's Website Optimizer is ok and it's free. I also highly recommend https://www.optimizely.com/ it's paid tool but it's really great. For SEOmoz pro members there is 20% off.
-
setting up a 1x1 pixel is simple. Just create it, drop it on the page. In Google Analytics in the content section you can search for that pixel to get your numbers. I really think , without knowing your specifics, that you are over complicating this.
You can run multiple GA scripts, but they of course don't recommend it. Remember, if you are playing around with the main stats account, if you screw anything up, you cannot repair it.
I would at least set up a new profile before doing anything so that your main stats are untouched.
-
That's not really true, especially in the case of Google tools. There are many free tools out there that offer features and functionality far beyond the skill level of most mid-level IM's. Optimizly works well, but it costs. The experiements (new GWO) is more than enough for what most people need.
I have used Optimizly and it was decent, definitely makes testing easy, but I go back to GWO every time. Having the tests integrated into the stats is a godsend. Always be testing.
Your link is broken. I assume you meant http://monetate.com/products/testlab/#axzz1zl1r4yWU
-
You have a better chance of being indexed if you create decent content and have a couple links pointing at the page. Don't speculate about a way to improve your love from Google. Smarter people than us have spent a lot of time removing the predictability of Google.
Create good content, run a clean site, make people happy = get paid.
-
I have personally never seen GWO ever effect rankings or behave in any other way than it should. You can set up multivariate and a/b tests directly in Google Analytics now, much easier than GWO (which was easy) to set up, less code, and it uses your defined goals from Google Analytics.
If you want to see the testing in GA, its in experiments in the content section. Works like a charm. Are you testing if the changes you are making have any effect on the amount of time it takes to be indexed? Or is it about ranking.
Keep in mind, if you are testing very small elements on multiple pages, you are going to have to deal with duplicate content warnings, also if these pages are the same pages, you are going to be competing against yourself in the search engines. Typically, when testing pages, the test pages are blocked from search engines for this very reason.
Don't get too hung up in trying to figure out what you can do to a page to get indexed, getting indexed is the easiest part of the show.
-
The funny thing is that I got 6 thumbs down for that answer - but I think it's still true!
-
David,
I have heard this theory before. If you have adsense on a page, google must visit it in order to determine the content to set the ad properly. But as you said ther eis no evidence for this directly.
It sounds to me like you can just have GA on ALL pages and simply drill down to your subset for testing on what ever group you are interested in in the content view and compare accordingly. No need to get too tricky.
-
It seems to me that your test is a little different than how most people would consider SEO.
Most considering higher rankings and more traffic as a success. You are considering a higher percentage of pages as indexed as a success.
I think you should step back and rethink this test. With millions of pages the indexing of your site might get better and your rankings get worse with the same changes. That would probably turn out to be a net loss in benefits and actionable traffic.
I would use SEO and page content for higher rankings.
I would think of linking patterns (internally and externally), site structure, website coding and less redundant content as the way to increase percentage of pages indexed.
-
Interesting question:
I would set up with goals as you mentioned.
GWO can screw up your rankings and is not advised - speaking from personal experience.
Separately, with tens of millions of pages, maybe the basic problem is
-
getting more links
-
trimming the fat and seeing if you can consolidate certain pages together.
-
-
Though I've never personally tested this, technically, multiple tracking codes for different GA accounts should be able to run simultaneously.
http://www.webmasterworld.com/analytics/3781851.htm
http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/Google%20Analytics/thread?tid=608cc854afe9629d&hl=en
I'm not sure if this is the most efficient or effective methodology for a multivariate test, or, rather, for measuring a multivariate test. I generally recommend Google Website Optimizer for most multivariate testing, and Omniture for folks with large, profitable sites.
-
Make life easier on yourself, spend some coin in a solid multivariate testing framework.
Free tools rarely offer the firepower of a commercial product.
This one seems decent: http://monetate.com/features/power-features-list/
-
Well - 6 thumbs down? I guess I was wrong!
I have no proof about what I am about to say, but using logic and a hunch, I would suggest that if one were to have direct links to Google, lets say via AdWords and/or AdSense, then your site has a better chance of getting more of your pages indexed.
In theory.
With no proof at all whatsoever behind this idea.
-
Have you looked into Google's Website Optimizer? It will serve two different versions of a page, roughly half and half, so you can compare which one converts better, which one ranks better, all that good stuff.
-
Hmm, ok.
I understand that linking to deep content will help that content, but we are trying to do discrete tests. My company was founded by a computer scientist, so everything must be scientific, even if my inclination is to simply do all the best practices and expect (hope) for the best. The test sets are too large and not in different directories, so going through logs would be . . . horrifying.
Here's the issue I am curious what peeps think:
What if I set up an additional GA profile and have two sets of GA code on each test page? Then I am getting credit for views in my main GA profile and can easily see if test sets are being viewed in the second profile.
Or, can someone give me info about how to set up a 1x1 pixel and see those stats in GA?
-
CRO = Conversion Rate Optimization.
I only asked as you were looking for link click metrics, which suggested you were looking to get users moving round your site more.
Users visiting specific pages doesn't mean that Google is going to index more of your pages. It's kind of 2 separate tests you want to run.
Your absolute best bet to see what pages Google is visiting is to check your server logs and see what Google is looking at. I appreciate it's confusing looking through them though and it still doesn't show what's being indexed.
I think I understand what you mean by the sitemaps now, treating a subfolder as a different site in WMT and seeing how many pages they index from the sitemap?
Could work...
Eh, normally when I want to see what pages are functionally indexed I would check in analytics to see what pages have actually brought a visitor through search. Anything that's not is effectively not indexed, though I appreciate that's not strictly true.
If a particular section has an increase in the number of landing pages bringing traffic then more pages are being indexed.
I appreciate it's onpage changes your testing but building links into pages further down the site structure should also prod search engines to crawl more pages.
It's not an easy task all in really. I guess sitemaps in WMT, functional indexing and long nights sifting through server logs is my best offer. Sorry it's not quite a solution but something to think about.
-
Basically we are looking to get more of our pages indexed. So rather than do everything to every page (we have tens of millions of pages) we are looking to test ideas on subsets. Whichever test gets indexed faster and more click throughs we will promote to all of the pages.
What is CRO?
-
Are you testing CRO or SEO?
The only reason I ask is that you can only present the search engines with one version at a time for them to index and rank, so the way to tell would be if the pages you've made changes on are getting more or less traffic which is easy enough through analytics.
CRO is an easy thing to test as well but if you could just clarify I'll have a think
-
We are making changes to a subset of our pages that are crawlable by google, but we aren't linking to them in a special way, so I am unsure how the URL builder will help us. But I may be missing something!
-
You could just use the Google Analytics URL Builder that will create some virtual tracking opportunities for you. Are you creating the test, running for a period and altering the test?
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
SEO Keyword Research
Is there a way to insert Google API into Excel? I want to have a search volume column that would automatically fill out with query Another question is that I have a list of keywords in one column in Excel with another column that have search volume. I then go and do some research on keyword groups with a grouping tool but if this tool doesn't find a group for a keyword it removes it. So then when I want to copy and past keywords and match keyword columns in excel that already exist with search volume I have to do it manually because some rows are missing. Is there a way this could be done automatically so that when I paste it in the column with keywords it automatically finds that the current column exists and adds a group column ?
Reporting & Analytics | | aliciaporrata10090 -
I want to track product click so how to create project object or how to pass project object ?
Hey, I am reading this post - https://developers.google.com/tag-manager/enhanced-ecommerce#product-clicksIn this there is function like given below - function(productObj) { dataLayer.push({ 'event': 'productClick', 'ecommerce': {.....................................................................................................................Now my developer asking how to create object? or how to pass product object? Like on page we have more than 50 products listed, so if any one clicks on any product from list then how will we know which product has been clicked?Hope you understand what i want to say? Regards,Mitesh
Reporting & Analytics | | bkmitesh0 -
How do you setup a test analytics account?
I have created a test view but that is not helping with skewed data. Do you all just create a total separate profile with a different GA account for a non-indexed domain? How can I test tag manager and other things without messing with our data? I have our IP filtered out so it doesn't show up in reports but other event tags from outsiders will.
Reporting & Analytics | | Sika220 -
Set Up of Goal Tracking with Google Analytics-$750 a Fair Price????
Greetings Moz Community! My firm operates commercial real estate website that contains 3-4 forms. Each form represents a goals. Google Analytics has been set up for years, but it does not track these form completions/goals properly. My SEO firm has offered to configure Goals on Google Analytics for $750. Is this a fair price? If the set up takes one hour, I am really over paying. But if this is a complex project that may take 7-9 hours the pricing seems OK. Also, the SEO firm will require an additional $750 in the future to set up event tracking. Is this excessive? I might add that my developer will need to add code to my web site. My SEO company has proven reliable and accurate. I can go to sleep at night knowing they are doing a good job. Where as my Argentinian developers really try their best, but perhaps because of the language barrier, they can make mistakes from time to time. I am willing to pay a premium to ensure that the job is done correctly domestically, however I don't appreciate over paying. Is the $750 payment for setting up Google Analytics reasonable assuming the job is done well??? Thanks,
Reporting & Analytics | | Kingalan1
Alan0 -
Google Analytics Tracking Code Problems
I am having a problem with my Google Analytics tracking codes. The relevant GA tracking codes have been entered into the source code of certain sites I'm running campaigns on, but Google Analytics is still telling me that the tracking code hasn't been installed - yet it has. What could possibly be the problem here? I have checked that these sites don't run off multiple domains, and that the tracking code has been entered in the correct place within the source code - and yet I am still having problems with GA. Any suggestions?
Reporting & Analytics | | WebhouseISP0 -
Can someone clarify the importance of Scribe SEO?
Hi guys, I was reading The Beginner's Guide to SEO and was confused about the importance of keyword density. As I see it, the main purpose of tools like Scribe SEO revolve around analyzing keyword density, however, Chapter 9 of "The Beginner's Guide to SEO" seems to downplay its importance and says "Despite being proven untrue time and again, this myth has legs. Many SEO tools still feed on the concept that keyword density is an important metric. It's not." If this is true, what is the real value of tools like Scribe SEO? Currently, I follow keyword analysis tools very closely, and try to get the recommended density in my articles to help build back links. Should I be focusing heavily on the density and prominence of keywords like I am in the picture below, or is there another way you suggest I go about using these tools? PhJnV PhJnV
Reporting & Analytics | | samersultan10 -
Tracking clicks from a specific link
Hi all, I'm looking for a bit of help with Analytics. I want to track the number of clicks that my main CTA generates over the course of the month. I've got all my goals set up correctly, but is there some sort of code that I can add to that specific link which will count the goal conversions which it generates? Do I need to set up something specific in GA? Thanks a lot for your help,
Reporting & Analytics | | theshortstack0 -
GoDaddy SEO Services?
So one of my client's wants to know why he shouldn't just hire GoDaddy to "do SEO" for him! He found this page: http://www.godaddy.com/search-engine/seo-services.aspx Without actually trying it, It looks like a bunch of stuff I already do (rank tracking, PR tracking, traffic tracking, ROI projections), stuff I shouldn't do (site submissions to search engines), and stuff I probably don't need ("keyword wizard"). That said, I am intrigued by: the dedicated phone number with track and monitor (is it better than Hosted Numbers?), the business listing (is it a link worth the $6/mo?), site analysis and optimization, and ROI dashboard. Does anyone have any experience with this? Does any piece of it have any value?
Reporting & Analytics | | TheEspresseo1