How do you value a site that generates no income before it's sold?
-
Hi,
I'm currently creating a number of sites which target the wedding market. Each site is localized and specific to a niche within the wedding market.
The intention is to create the site, rank it in the top position of Google and then sell it to a local business within that niche and area.
The problem that i am having is that I don't know how to place a value on each site. I have factors taken from Google (using Market Samurai) so I know the broad and phrase match traffic details as well as the Google PPC average prices.
My initial thought was to use the Google PPC price and multiply that by the number of organic visitors the site would receive if it was ranked #1 on Google. I appreciate that the PPC figures may be higher than what an advertiser would actually pay per click so I conservatively halved the Google PPC figure given in Market Samurai.
Is this a good way of valuing the site or do I need to look at the value per customer to the business that I am trying to sell the site to and work from a conversion factor based on the number of visitors that the site would receive.
If the site received 500 visitors per month and 5% of those became customers multiplied by the average profit per customer - that would give a monthly value of the website.
I am very unsure as to what the best approach is here and look forward to hearing any advice and ideas from fellow members.
Thanks,
Michael
-
The traffic to the site will generate leads for the company who owns the site. If they already have a website that converts then they will know what content to put on this site to create that conversion rate.
The buyer is buying the site knowing the potential that the site will have when it comes to generating business for them.
I've looked at is as the first page results of Google are a line of shops. The shop at #1 is seen as the shop which gets the most visitors to it. Now imagine that shop is currently being refitted - people can still see the shop and what it sells but are unable to actually enter the shop to buy anything.
Now, the person who owns the shop further down the street (i.e is ranked #10 or #12 or #15 etc) - he really wants to own that shop which is being refitted and he knows how much that shop is worth to his business if he owned it after the refit is completed.
Although the site I have created is a basic canvas, all it needs is branding by the new owner and it will then perform as well as their current site when it comes to conversion rates.
Does that make sense with explaining the view point I am taking on this project ?
-
"how to value organic traffic"
That's a different question than "how much can I get for a website?".
But getting to your real question of "how to value organic traffic".... that depends upon what you can do with the traffic (display adsense, sell merchandise, generate leads).
Although you can put a generalized number on that the bottom line for the buyer of your website depends upon how effective your website is at converting customers for a specific service provider. The generic website that you have for sale has zero value for the service provider.
You are selling a sign post without a sign, not a money-making machine.
I think that you have a lot more money making potential selling SEO services than selling pre-ranked websites.
-
And again, the finer points of how to sell the site are something that i have covered from all angles. The part of making the sale and closing the sale isn't an issue.
I appreciate the feedback from everyone here but doubt I'm going to find someone who can actually answer the question of "how to value organic traffic". The matter of the niche or if the potential client already has a site or an SEO company is by the by and not part of the issue. I can deal with all of those parts.
Market Samurai makes a calculation for organic traffic value by taking the average PPC cost and multiplying it by the amount of traffic the site will receive if it was ranked number one on Google.
My question really should have just simply been asked as "How accurate is that figure" ? , <- that's all I needed answering.
-
You get what you can convince someone its worth.
I agree.
I believe that most people who own wedding shops will be much more inclined to invest in having SEO done on their existing website or on a domain that matches the name of their business than they are to buy a website from a Joe Schmoe who is trying to sell them YourPodunkWedding.com.
If they already have a website they probably have a relationship with a local person or company who built the site for them. They will call that person who they know and trust and say... some Joe Schmoe is trying to sell me YourPodunkWedding.com... and he will say.. "They are probably going to sell you the site and then pull the links as soon as they have your money."
-
" All I wanted to know is how a site would be valued when it comes to selling it."
There is no way to tell. You get what you can convince someone its worth. You can like that or not but it won't change it.
-
I feel like your question answers itself, a site that generates no income before it is sold doesn't really have any value to be completely honest. If the site is ranking, and generating leads, then it has an intrinsic value of potential income. I feel it is a gamble and as Ben said "[it] is worth what they buyer will pay for it."
I suppose, if you have qualified leads being generated, you could place a market value on each lead with a realistic conversion rate factored in to get a base sale value. Once you have a base, you could project what it is worth to a company that can build a reputation and stronger business with it.
Using the above example of 500 visitors, 5% to leads, and a 1.5% conversion rate (lets be realistic now) works out to 1 client. So for this venture to be profitiable, you would probably need to generate at least 1000 * 5000 visitors a month, and hope for 5-10 clients. Now if a business buys this and makes it successful, the conversion rate should increase due to reputation. You could build a projected sale price of the 1-2 year projection.
That all being said, you really will need to have a decent amount of traffic coming to the site in order for it to be salable, or follow the old adage 'a sucker is born every minute' and swindle someone into buying based on promised traffic and revenue that is in fact not there (not recommend: very unprofessional and possibly reputation damaging.)
-- edit --
- clearly my math was wrong, it should be 5000 visitors for 5-10 clients, not 1000.
-
Why would they want to buy a website from you? They probably already have a site, have spent a lot of money on it and want to continue using it. Your site would not feature their store or their products or their staff or their salesmanship. The site would need to be built over again. A waste of your time or their money.
I think that you will get a better return selling SEO services to the biz owner who is currently in position #7 who would like to be in position #1.
If the site received 500 visitors per month and 5% of those became customers multiplied by the average profit per customer - that would give a monthly value of the website.
I think that your 5% is really high. In a small town there might only be a few places to buy these products and the shoppers already know about them. Where there is a larger market the buying decision is going to be based more on the products for sale and less on the rankings of a website.
Also, I think that your valuation is high.... why should they pay you the entire profit on the monthly sales? They are in business to make money for themselves - not to give all of their profits to you.
-
Oh I did my research on this and looked at the service providers who already have website ranked in the top 30 as well as all those who are currently using Google AdWords. The service providers already understand the value of an online presence, I'm just trying to work out what that value is.
-
there is no calculation that will tell you this. Anything that professes to be an indystry standard or generic answer will be out as your buyers will not be conforming to any standard
Wedding businesses that dont know about the internet are sure as hell not going to know how to value a website, its worth whatever you can get for it as a salesman
Btw, Id suggest finding a market first and then building sites for it
-
Thanks Ben, thanks for your answer. I have thought about different payment options from a "one off - hand it all over" option to a "monthly payment" where they 'rent' the site. Or even break the cost down in to a deposit payment followed by monthly payments until the full amount is paid. Once it's paid I would then sign over the domain ownership.
The main sticking point is calculating a price for the site in the first place.
-
Everything is worth what the buyer will pay for it. Since organic search traffic ebbs and flows, a simple traffic times conversion equals monthly price may to be reflective of what someone will pay for it. You might want to think about offering a lump sum payment where the customer takes control of the domain and a monthly fee where you retain control, but re brand the site for the client.
Good luck
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Contest to generate link building ideas?
Basically, I am looking for new ideas for inbound link generation - WHITE-HAT (merit based links) for the car insurance vertical. E.g. Creating infographics, and promoting them to blogs/news sites. To clarify, the other site is only linking to me because I have something they like about my site, and choose to link to it (so things like guest blogging and directories do not work here, at least in the conventional sense). There are tons of seo blogs that give advice on how to get links, but either: 1. I have already tried, or hired someone, to do them. Those that I hire are specialists (I have hired lots of reputable companies that most people know here, but they always slow down after a few months/years in terms of link volume; 2. Many of the popular methods just don't work in my niche: Take for example one of the more recent ones: skyscraper" method. I really dont think it works in my niche. It only works in niches where "information based content" is vary valuable, like SEO, not car insurance. It is also hard to scale this. 3. The link topics sometimes get too far off-topic. E.g. Links from travel websites is probably not going to work; even car topics can be off-topic wen they get too gimmicky. So my idea is to start a contest here where I basically award the best link building idea $1000, $5000, or whatever amount that would get enough people participating. These ideas have to be relatively proven, and scalable. If it helps to know my background, I am very seasoned at SEO. What do you think of this idea? How can I improve it? Has this been done before (I am not talking about a general SEO contest).
Industry News | | onlinefun0 -
Backlink Query. Unranked pages of High Ranking sites.
Hi, So I was just wondering if someone with more knowledge than myself can answer this question for me. I have a site - currently sat on page 2 of google. On-site optimisation is done, however I am struggling to get backlinks that are from highranking pages. I am new to SEO so need a hand. My understanding of backlinks is that the higher the PR of the site that links to your 'money' site, the better that link is, and that these links are very hard to come by. (something that I am finding). Many times I have found sites that have a high rank and offer for a free listing, only for me to fill in details and get listed on a sub-page that has no ranking whatsoever. So my question is, are these kind of links worth the effort? Do they actually have any effect on rankings? And generally would anyone have any tips on the best sites to get links? Thanks
Industry News | | Chstphrjohn0 -
Getting started with E-commerce sites
Happy new year, Mozzers We are about to take on our first E-commerce client which will be something new for us as we expand in 2014. Being a small outfit, we've never taken on a type of site like this before, which is great for new experiences and challenges. Do you have any advice, recommendations, suggestions, things to look out for etc, etc when working with E-commerce sites for the first time ever? thanks M
Industry News | | Martin_S0 -
What's on your ultimate online marketing wish list?
Hi everyone! I'm one of Distilled's new online marketing analysts and will be writing my first blog post for them right before Christmas! I'm thinking about writing a post that combines the holiday spirit with what we all wish Google would give us. So fine people of Moz Q&A, tell me, if you could have anything from Google, no matter how ridiculous, what would it be and why? Any great quotes may even be featured in the blog post itself and attributed to you! Thanks everyone and happy Friday!
Industry News | | MorganChessman0 -
How does nudity on a site affect search results?
One of my clients sells lingerie and with it being lingerie there are a fair few photos of bottoms and some exposed breasts. Gosh. Anyway I know how this affects Adwords campaigns - Google classifies the site as 'adult' and your ads don't show anywhere. I also know how it affects image searches. However how does it affect text seaches?? Are rankings demoted because of nudity? I've worked with a clothing site with some nudity on it before and this didn't affect it, but would love to hear from anyone with specific experience of thisThanks
Industry News | | neenor0 -
What are other SEO's calling themselves now?
I am piggy backing off of Rand's latest Whiteboard Friday: http://www.seomoz.org/blog/why-we-cant-just-be-seos-anymore-whiteboard-friday (It is an awesome post if you haven't checked it out yet.) I just want to hear some feedback from other industry professionals. Have you started defining/communicating your business as more than just, I do SEO? If so, what are you calling yourselves now and why? How has that been working out for you?
Industry News | | VentaMarketing1 -
Google's New Release "What do you love"
Is this gonna be a game changer for SEO http://www.wdyl.com/ Regards, Shailendra Sial
Industry News | | IM_Learner0 -
What's the oldest "blank" on the Internet?
What's the oldest active domain on the Internet? What was the first registered domain? What's the oldest active link? What other old web stuff can you think of?
Industry News | | Gyi0