Switched From Wordpress, Traffic Dropped In Half
-
Hello,
Thank you for taking a look at my issue.
My site: http://www.getrightmusic.com
A month ago, I switched from Wordpress to ExpressionEngine. The reason being I wanted a more powerful membership functionality with media uploading. After I switched, my traffic basically dropped in half. I was averaging around 4-6,000 unique visitors per day and now I am at about 2,000 per day.
I resubmitted a new sitemap to Google webmasters. I also set up 301 redirects on my top 80 urls that were ranking well and driving traffic in Google.
Not only did Google kick me off of my top spots in the SERP's, but I no longer get indexed as quickly as I used to. With the old Wordpress site I would get url's indexed within minutes. Now they aren't even getting indexed really at all.
Is this a normal occurrence when switching site designs and systems?
Do you think Google will just take a little time before they give me back some respect?
Is there anything I should be doing to get back to ranking and getting indexed faster?
Thanks for any help or any insight you may have.
Jesse
-
Thanks Chris! I did get the NSM Better Meta plugin installed and I really like it. So, I have a new sitemap with Google created. I love Wordpress as well, I just felt that all of my competitors were using it and I needed to stand out from everyone else Plus I wanted complete control over where and how my content is presented . It has been trickier even with good designers and developers, but I'm hoping in the end it will pay off. I was just pretty surprised at how fast Google broke up with me. I guess it's time for me to go back and wine and dine again for some G Love. Next time this situation occurs I will focus more on 301'ing each url before the switch. Thanks for the reply Chris!
-
I totally agree. Every URL is precious... Every one deserves a 301. In terms of indexing, WordPress has a built in ping feature for whenever content gets published, but so does EE... It just needs some configuration. Look for it in EE docs. Also, consider using LG Better Meta for EE. It gives you nice control over metadata plus if you work at it you can use it to help auto generate an accurate XML sitemap. This helps with indexing significantly IMHO. I love EE's power, but after our last few projects with it I would rather stick with WordPress for content publishing and custom code any needed features rather than fight with and pay for EE.
-
If you value your site's SEO, you should properly redirect your pages as much as possible. The method of redirection is dependent on your server and the technologies involved. For example, if you are using an Apache server in a shared environment, you would need to add a redirect to your htaccess file using a proper regex expression.
I tried to check your site to compare URLs but it is currently unavailable. In short, try to determine a pattern between your old URLs and new URL structure, then map them over.
Example:
OLD URL: mysite.com/music/mix/artistname
NEW URL mysite.com/album/artistname
In the above example you would write an expression which would replace /music/mix/ with /album/ so your old URLs would smoothly redirect to their new URL. You would make this change using the 301 code so browsers clearly identify the links should be updated.
-
Thanks for the response Ryan!
-
My content is identical to the content that was on the WP site. I used a plugin to export my Wordpress posts to the EE site.
-
I was using the Joast SEO plugin while on WP. I have a similar SEO plugin installed now with EE though for the meta data.
-
My URL structure did change from the Wordpress site.
I think I do have all url's redirecting to the homepage. Should I have set it up differently? My top 80 urls redirect to their respective posts on the new EE site.
Do I have to go in and redirect all of my old urls to their individual corresponding new EE urls?
Should I just wait it out and hope Google gives me some love back?
Thanks for the help Ryan!
-
-
Hi Jesse.
WordPress and EE both offer quality CMS solutions. Search engines don't care at all how your site is developed, but instead will focus on your content and how it is presented with respect to tags and so forth.
Some questions for you:
-
is your current content 100% identical when compared with when your site was on WP?
-
did you use any SEO plugin while you were on WP?
-
what other changes have been made on your site around the same time period?
-
you mentioned 301 redirects. Did your URLs change during the switch?
Your site seems pretty solid on the basic SEO factors. You should NOT experience this issue purely from moving your site to a new CMS unless something else is wrong.
EDIT: Jesse, you have an issue with the redirects on your site.
http://www.getrightmusic.com/robots.txt returns a normal page from your site, and provides a "200" response showing it is the intended page.
I also tried http://www.getrightmusic.com/robots.txt123 as a URL, and also received a web page along with the "200" response.
After taking a closer look it seems to be your home page. So it seems you redirected all URLs without a page on your site to your home page? And you provide a "200" (page found, all ok) code rather then a 301?
Based on your above reply the reason for your drop in traffic is you lost the majority of your pages during the CMS change. While the pages still exist on your site, you lost any links to those pages and redirected users to your home page. The loss in traffic would be expected based on this method.
-
-
Thanks Daniel.
I've added the Google+ to all of my new posts hoping to help get indexed. I would have loved to stick with Wordpress, but I'm not a fan of using plugins and then worrying about them breaking when Wordpress updates and keeping on track of all that.
I chose my top 80 urls to 301 because I had over 3000 posts from my previous site. I just didn't have the time or resources to individually 301 them each.
I also haven't gotten my RSS set up yet. I'm hoping once I do (next week), I'll get that back into Feedburner, which I think should help get indexed faster again. Right?
Thanks for the quick reply Daniel!
Jesse
-
Pretty standard. Site redesigns, especially when new URL's are involved, see immediate drops in rankings and traffic. Going to be a little while until they come back. I personally would never have made the switch. It's rarely worth it for the lost traffic. Isn't there a media uploading plugin or some kind of ftp plugin for wordpress you could have used? Guess it's too late. Just make sure all of your URL's are redirected, not just your top 80, you should be fine in the long run, but it's going to hurt for a little while.
For indexing problems, wordpress automatically pings search engines with new posts, so you likely got indexed very quickly in the past. Try and share a link to your new content on Google+ and that should get it indexed quickly.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Drop in rankings after AMP implementation because of lack of facebook comments
Hi, we are amplifying our site, but one of the things we can´t include on our AMP version is the Facebook comment box. Some of our articles have hundreds of comments on them and we noticed that Google was crawling those comments and using them as a ranking signal (the more comments the better we discovered). Now we are wondering if these articles would drop if we launch the AMP version without the comment box. As this would reduce the written content on those pages a lot. Anybody tested this before or has an idea on that would work out? Thanks for your help!
Web Design | | guidetoiceland1 -
On-page SEO opinion on this Wordpress theme
Hi everyone. As an SEO agency we've been moving more toward genesis themes, however we have a client who really wants to redesign his website using the following theme: http://themeforest.net/item/this-way-wp-full-videoimage-background-with-audio/943634 - the theme would be images with no audio on the homepage. He is a remodeling contractor and likes the design and functionality of the theme. I'd like to get others feedback and opinions on what you think about the on-page SEO of this theme? Thanks.
Web Design | | WillWatrous0 -
Drop Down Menus and Crawlability
Hello, We are working on a complete site redesign. One of the mock-ups that are being reviewed is of a page that encompasses and entire category of products, but the only way the user can see the products is to fill out several drop down menus, and then a subset of products that match that criteria will appear. Once that list appears, the user will then be able to click on each of the products and will then be taken to the product page. I'm concerned that this layout will pose a crawlability issue since click activity and drop down menus have always been a problem for bots in the past, has anything changed? Will the bot be able to follow the links to these product pages if it can't see them since it can't fill out the form? Also, depending on the functionality of this 'form', I'm assuming the product listing will be populated dynamically and pulled from another source, which means that the product links will not live in the html of the page, and hence cannot be crawled. Does anyone know how this is normally handled? Do the actual results usually live elsewhere or does it live in the html of that page? Any thoughts or clarity around this would be appreciated.
Web Design | | Colbys0 -
Are wordpress themes like from themeforest bad?
Hi to all. Ok so as I read around the internet I see a lot of people who dislike theme forest and using their themes. I have a them from them, the Avada theme. Ok so they have made a TON of money. But would so many people buy the theme if it was that bad? Going forward, my question is, are wordpress themes a bad thing to do? I feel like its peer pressure to switch to a framework like Genesis. There are so many people who state that a framework and child theme is the way to go. But I am using this avada theme and having under 2.5 sec load times. A lot of people say the code is bloated and is horrible. I understand this and got a cache plugin that makes a huge difference. But I do want to learn and I do want to approach websites in a positive way. So if you have any thoughts on themes, please tell me your thoughts. I am no developer, so they seem to work, but is it at a price? Like bad seo and serps? Thank you chris
Web Design | | asbchris0 -
Responsive Web Design WordPress Template Suggestions
Does anyone have any RWD WP templates they would suggest? It's for a friend of mine that is starting a local solar panel installation company. For the beginning, he likely will not have more than a handful of categories and subcategories. I'd say no more than 50 total pages. Any suggestions would help. He doesn't want to spend more than $50 - $100, but he's not married to that figure if it's worth it. Thanks everyone, Ruben
Web Design | | KempRugeLawGroup0 -
Site is losing traffic after relaunch
Hello, We've just relaunched this site in the last several days, and we're seeing some small (but stead) traffic decreases, as well as engagement decreases. We're aware that page speed (about 4 seconds from a non-cached browser) and some 404s are an issue, our team is currently working on both. But we're really looking for some constructive criticism here as to what we need to improve. Other issues to be aware of: lots of our social counts went back to 0s, as lots of URLs changed, and it wasn't possible to migrate comments from the old system, so those have gone back to 0 as well. We wonder if this might be affecting both users and search engines perception of the site. Your input would be greatly appreciated. Thanks,
Web Design | | FishAcct
Paul0 -
Optimizing a Wordpress Blog For SEO
Besides the standard Yoast for SEO plugin tweaks, I'm researching best practices when setting up a wordpress blog. In this instance, the "front end" of the site would be hardcoded static pages designed for an e-commerce site, while there would also be a /blog/ attached to the site - for blog posts, fresh content, etc.
Web Design | | GKLA0 -
How do I learn how to build custom wordpress websites?
Is wordpress a good platform to build websites with? If so, what are some good resources to learn how to build custom websites using wordpress?
Web Design | | Lael0