Does a CMS inhibit a site's crawlability?
-
I smell baloney but I could use a little backup from the community!
My client was recently told by an SEO that search engines have a hard time getting to their site because using a CMS (like WordPress) doesn't allow "direct access to the html".
Here is what they emailed my client:
"Word Press (like your site is built with) and other similar “do it yourself” web builder programs and websites are not good for search engine optimization since they do not allow direct access to the HTML. Direct HTML access is needed to input important items to enhance your websites search engine visibility, performance and creditability in order to gain higher search engine rankings."
Bots are blind to CMSs and html is html, correct? What do you think about the information given by the other SEO?
-
Thank you, Keri! Everyone here is so helpful! This was my first Q&A and it certainly won't be my last.
-
I received an unsolicited email that told me things that were wrong on the SEO of my site, from a supposed SEO. They included:
7) Website is devoid of Meta keywords which are required for Page 1 rankings. We will add Meta keywords for your website.
Good for you to get a second opinion!
-
p.s. That video is gold! I sent it with my email response to the client for a third-party endorsement.
-
Thanks for you help! Funny enough, it turns out this SEO himself uses WordPress for his own blog, so it must not be that scary.
Anyway, I found this SEO's comments very misleading. To me, this was a reminder of the corny but true sentiment that with great power comes great responsibility. It is easy for SEOs to scare the bejeebus out of people who know very little about the web.
-
Thank you very much! I appreciate the support! This is a great answer and very balanced.
I think you are right that he sounds like a developer. If I give him a very generous read of what he is saying, perhaps he means that CMS get in the way of having full control over the code. As you point, out there are smart, easy ways around that.
Thank you very much! Very helpful!
-
WordPress is considered a solid platform for producing websites. Here is a link to a (long) video from Matt Cutts where he is a presenter at WordCamp. He praises WordPress for SEO and he uses the software himself on his site http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/. Just watch the first 4 minutes of the video and you will have an idea of his position on the software.
To offer a balanced viewpoint, your SEO sounds more like a web developer. There are some developers who don't use a CMS and prefer to code sites from the ground up. There are plenty of advantages to doing such. You have 100% control over every page of your site, you don't have any unnecessary code and you never are restricted from making changes.
The problem is time and cost. I have one client who spent $45k on a custom site which was poorly developed. We replaced the old website with a Joomla site (another popular CMS) for a cost of around $5k. The new site outperforms the old site in every category. The skill and experience of your developer is a huge factor.
-
Yes you are correct.
Tell your client to run far. That SEO has no clue, and is completely wrong. Maybe he's thinking that out of box Wordpress doesn't have Title or Meta Tag management ? That's solvable with Wordpress SEO. [highly recommended]
Wordpress outputs HTML.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
NoIndex tag, canonical tag or automatically generated H1's for automatically generated enquiry pages?
What would be better for automatically generated accommodation enquiry pages for a travel company? NoIndex tag, canonical tag, automatically generated H1's or another solution? This is the homepage: https://www.discoverqueensland.com.au/ You would enquire from a page like this: https://www.discoverqueensland.com.au/accommodation/sunshine-coast/twin-waters/the-sebel-twin-waters This is the enquiry form: https://www.discoverqueensland.com.au/accommodation-enquiry.php?name=The+Sebel+Twin+Waters®ion_name=Sunshine+Coast
Technical SEO | | Kim_Lazaro0 -
Why is robots.txt blocking URL's in sitemap?
Hi Folks, Any ideas why Google Webmaster Tools is indicating that my robots.txt is blocking URL's linked in my sitemap.xml, when in fact it isn't? I have checked the current robots.txt declarations and they are fine and I've also tested it in the 'robots.txt Tester' tool, which indicates for the URL's it's suggesting are blocked in the sitemap, in fact work fine. Is this a temporary issue that will be resolved over a few days or should I be concerned. I have recently removed the declaration from the robots.txt that would have been blocking them and then uploaded a new updated sitemap.xml. I'm assuming this issue is due to some sort of crossover. Thanks Gaz
Technical SEO | | PurpleGriffon0 -
New website's ranking dropped
Hi, Im working on brand new website i didn't even start my link building yet, just added to local directories i slowly started getting my ranking on 3rd page of Google then few weeks ago my ranking fell for all the keywords so now the website doesn't even rank on 10th page. Its been like this for a few weeks now. Here's the website Screenshot http://screencast.com/t/wDWk8sxLw Thanks for your help
Technical SEO | | mezozcorp0 -
My beta site (beta.website.com) has been inadvertently indexed. Its cached pages are taking traffic away from our real website (website.com). Should I just "NO INDEX" the entire beta site and if so, what's the best way to do this? Please advise.
My beta site (beta.website.com) has been inadvertently indexed. Its cached pages are taking traffic away from our real website (website.com). Should I just "NO INDEX" the entire beta site and if so, what's the best way to do this? Are there any other precautions I should be taking? Please advise.
Technical SEO | | BVREID0 -
Removing a site from Google's index
We have a site we'd like to have pulled from Google's index. Back in late June, we disallowed robot access to the site through the robots.txt file and added a robots meta tag with "no index,no follow" commands. The expectation was that Google would eventually crawl the site and remove it from the index in response to those tags. The problem is that Google hasn't come back to crawl the site since late May. Is there a way to speed up this process and communicate to Google that we want the entire site out of the index, or do we just have to wait until it's eventually crawled again?
Technical SEO | | issuebasedmedia0 -
What's the best free tool for checking for broken links?
I'm trying to find the best tool to check for broken links on our site. We have over 11k pages and I'm looking for something fast and thorough! I've tried Xenu and LinkChecker. Any other ideas?
Technical SEO | | CIEEwebTeam0 -
Google.ca is showing our US site instead of our Canada Site
When our Canadian users who search on google.ca for our brand (e.g. Travelocity, Travelocity hotels, etc.), the first few results our from our US site (travelocity.com) rather than our Canadian site (travelocity.ca). In Google Webmaster Tools, we've adjusted the geotargeting settings to focus on the appropriate locale, but the wrong country TLD is still coming up at the top via google.ca. What's the best way to ensure our Canadian site comes up instead of the US site on google.ca? Thanks, Tory Smith
Technical SEO | | travelocitysearch
Travelocity0 -
How to setup tumblr blog.site.com to give juice to site.com
Is it possible to get a subdomain blog.site.com that is on tumblr to count toward site.com. I hoped I could point it in webmaster tools like we do www but alas no. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Technical SEO | | oznappies0