WP Permalinks, categories, and organic ranking impact
-
Hello. this is my first post here, so I hope it to be a question with an easy answer...
I am working on a site that has an established domain, but has recently suffered significant ranking decline. one of the problems I have found involves over-use of categories and tags - making the actual content 3 to 4 clicks deep within any given post URL.
My question involves the restructuring of category / tag use for improved page content and SEO organic rank impact. Here is an example:
domain.com/blue-shoes/blue-shoes-tampa
I want to target this specific post and optimize for "blue shoes tampa". I have used the Wordpress SEO plugin by Yoast to help achieve balanced optimization on the on-page post content itself, but now am struggling with the best approach for the URL...
also, the site has about 80 (62 posts and 18 pages) total items with similar issues, , so I am hoping that any answer / opinion offered here might also be applicable to the rest of the site.
thanks in advance for your time & comments.
-
Thanks everyone for your comments and insights. I think given the feedback here coupled with my own thoughts, I will NO INDEX the tags altogether.
That brings up one additional question in my mind, which may be addressed in the 2 posts referenced in this thread by Dan Shure - about how to "disconnect the existing tags". I'll read through Dan'e posts and update this thread with any noticeable results on the site's page rankings.
Finally, let me just say that as a relatively new member here as well as to being a new "SEO" on my own, I love the robust nature of the SEOMoz tools and the community itself. In a way, I feel like I have access to very esteemed professors who are leading the planet in this space, not just in evolving this scientific art form, but also in de-mystifying it for newer folks like myself. So for that, I offer a warm and sincere "THANKS"!
-
Ian
I'd completely agree. As I said to Patrick above, I've been deindexing tag archives like mad on my clients sites, with NO negative consequences, if anything the results are very positive. They're thin pages, with not much going on and often the titles get duped.
Check out this post I did which shows how to safely determine if tag archives can be de-indexed and how to do so.
Noindexing tags of course doesn't prevent Google from crawling them. If they're linked to it can still be good for Google discovering your content.
-Dan
-
Hi Patrick
Welcome! Thanks for the question. Everyone else pretty much got you in the right track here. The structure is good. Avoid too much redundancies and avoid too many folders (depth).
I'd like to add that I too feel very strongly about NOT indexing tag archives. If a blog is set up how it WordPress intended, you'd have about 5-8 categories, and an infinite amount of tags. You index the categories, as they act as the main buckets of content, but you don't index tags - because you could end up with 500 tags, and have half of them with only one post in them. Then they look an awful lot like a duplicate of the post. Not to mention tag archives are pretty thin, and Google is returning them much less in the SERPs now.
I had a client with 9,000 (yes... NINE THOUSAND) tags indexed. I zapped em all out of the index and his traffic actually went UP. Not entirely sure if it was due to the tags being removed, but it sure as heck didn't hurt traffic.
Feel free to check out my SEO for WordPress post on Moz as I think it covers a lot of the things you may have questions about.
-Dan
Edit: Ohhh I meant to add... noindex your subpages too.
-
Been thinking a bit about tags myself. Time was (not very long ago) when tags were great. They gave alternate page titles and Google never seemed to mind the duplicate content under separate headings. Add six tags to a post and you got 7 pages indexed essentially, each with meaningful headings.
It does still work, but less so, and I'm noticing a lot of changes with how wordpress behaves in the SERPS now - particularly with new sites.
I used to always write a post about each page I created too and link to it. So with tags and categories, each page would then be starting out with an extra 10 or so internal links (each tag and category having a different url). Google used to seem to go "oh, a page with links from 10 other pages... it must be the most important". Now it goes "huh, what do I do here? I think the blog post is maybe the most important this week, but I'll try out a tag next week, and hey, lets devalue the page because it has internal links with the same text from multiple pages".
Love to hear your thoughts....
-
If the keyword you want to target is already in your URL and Title it's spammy to do it if in the category as well.
domain.com/blue-shoes/blue-shoes-tampa
Flat structure such as /%postname%/ gets you indexed faster.
Never use tags - you will be creating too many link paths, and on page links, which devalues the internal links you do have, such as categories.
-
Yeah, stick with either:
/%category%/%postname%/
or
/%postname%/
Personally, I like %postname% but if you don't plan on adding new posts, you might be better off taking some time and choosing the perfect category slugs to give you bonus keywords in the URL.
-
What has worked best in the WP world for me is always sticking with a www.somedomain.com/{category}/{page}. This seems along the lines of what you have shown with domain.com/blue-shoes/blue-shoes-tampa. I like this permalink structure.
Definitely avoid going too deep: www.somedomain.com/clothing/lowerbody/feet/shoes/blue-shoes-tampa
And avoid being too repetitive: www.blue-shoes.com/blue-shoes/blue-shoes
Other than that, I think you are on the right track.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Is The Moz Community Rankings broken?
Not as active as I would have liked recently but still visit and login, answering a question now and again, yet I can see my profile is still listed as unranked. until recently I was somewhere around 45-49 and have been for many years - the criteria appears to be what it has for the last ten years or so. I see people with lower moz points outranking members with far more points. I can even see one with 0 points now appearing in the top 50 so my question is - is the moz community rankings broken or have I missed something? I know once before I pointed it out and it had to be fixed...input from all welcome 🙂
SEO Learn Center | | Matt-Williamson2 -
Backlink From Different Language Sites Will Spoil My Ranking?
Hi there! Excited to joining this community. The main question is that if I get backlinks from different language sites then that backlink will be worthy or non-worthy in the eye of search engine? I know if I target international market by presenting my content in different languages then of course it will be worthwhile for me. But what will be happened if I do not represent content in different languages on my site but get the backlines from other language sites such as: Chinese, Russian or any other? Also I have seen many sites which are getting backlinks from different language sites and they are just getting high authority. Is there any expert?
SEO Learn Center | | mianarfan3331 -
Trying to rank my personal business website
Hi, Guys I run a small company in england. I've been constantly ripped off by other seo companies. Im have my 1st child and really cannot afford the cost of a company to do this. I have just joined SEO mom look like a really great platform. Is there any advice on how i can rank my website. I am willing to put the time in myself and can devote late nights to try and succeed. Any advice on where to start links etc would be really greatly received. Thank you all.
SEO Learn Center | | letsrent0 -
Anyone else want to add a webmaster tools category to Q&A?
This could be all inclusive of both Google and Bing (a la webmaster tools), or, add more specificity with two additional categories:
SEO Learn Center | | EEE3
"Google Webmaster Tools"
"Bing Webmaster Tools" (It was suggested I post this on the forum and see if anyone else would upvote this.) Thanks! D7s6zJm0 -
What keywords will this page possibly rank for ... tool?
Hi all, I'm looking for a tool that will look at a web page that you submit to it and tell you what keywords it thinks the page is targetted towards and thus hopefully rank for. Does anyone have any suggestions please? Hopefully this type of tool will help us understand why page A is being ranked for keyword X when page B is actually the page that should be being ranked for that keyword. The only tool I have really found so far is http://www.ranks.nl/tools/spider.html I dont want to tell the tool what keywords I am looking at, as with Moz On page grader. Background reason (and possibly some one maybe able to shed some light on this also). We list a group of products... Nextbase Click 9 Lite, Nextbase Click 9 Lite Duo and Nextbase Click 9 Lite Duo Deluxe. All 3 are similar but very different products and each has its own page on our site. For the keyphrase "Nextbase click 9 lite" currently in Google we are listed for the pages containing the "Nextbase Click 9 Lite Duo" and "Nextbase Click 9 Lite Duo Deluxe"... but not the actual specific product page that targets the "Nextbase Click 9 Lite" product. Thus my reason for wanting to try such a tool that may help me understand why this is. Thanks for any hints, tips or pointers.
SEO Learn Center | | jasef0 -
My Wordpress Organic Blog traffic disappeared and Google is indexing Viagra and Online Med titles for some articles. How to fix that?
Hello, I'm worried that all my organic traffic has disappeared according to Analytics from past friday and now Google is showing results from my title tags in the last days as you can see here: http://goo.gl/QFSgy Is there any additional resources I can read apart from Google Clean Your site Guidelines here https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/163634 or the Wordpress FAQ for hacked sites here? http://codex.wordpress.org/FAQ_My_site_was_hacked Very much appreciated all of your help! Regards.
SEO Learn Center | | viventuraSEO0 -
Are there any plans for a new SEOmoz ranking factors report?
The latest SEOmoz search ranking factors report I seem to find is dated 2011 http://www.seomoz.org/article/search-ranking-factors - any plans for an updated version at all?
SEO Learn Center | | Clicksjim2 -
Machine Learning - Randomness in Search Engine Ranking Algorithms
I believe, sometimes you may 'deserve' the first position, but get #3. And of course, sometimes you may deserve #3 and instead be #1. All due to a 'randomness factor' in search engine algorithms. I've been holding this hypothesis for quite sometime. Really, it started when I learned about SEOmoz using machine learning to better investigate SEO best practices. I suddenly found myself wanting to learn more about machine learning, and the implications of using it for SEO. I'm by no means able to utilize machine learning myself, but I it appears unsupervised learning would have a real chance of cracking search engine algorithms. Hey, even Stuxnet was cracked! Surely Google/ Bing would know (and account for) this, right? We can agree they'd obviously prefer a highly skilled mathematician not be able to crack the code. Therefore, I'm led to believe that search engines use some sort of randomness in their rankings. Maybe not much. Perhaps not all the time. But if a random percentage of search results, had a random variable of sorts included in their calculations... wouldn't that be enough to prevent the vast majority of cracking attempts? Thoughts, opinions, criticism? Thanks.
SEO Learn Center | | DonnieCooper0