Would you instinctively mistrust a company that has the top 5 or more search listings?
-
I have seen a few "lucky"(?) companies dominate spots 1-5 of search results. When I see that, I generally go to #6, 7, or even 10 before clicking. My gut reaction is that the company with 1-5 has manipulated content just to pull me in - much like the guys on the streets of NYC or Vegas shoving handbills at you.
Is there any evidence/research/poll about the consumer/user reaction when this occurs?
-
Oh erm..me neither
cough
-
I tend to have serious trust issues in general.
However, I don't normally suspect any problems with sites that the top of the SERPs.
I might have trust issues in the SERPs if I was looking for something like "cheap airline tickets" or "escort services" but I am not looking for either of those.
-
I hope you're right Tom! I'd hate to have to go and start de-optimising
-
As an SEO professional? Yes, absolutely.
As a general searcher or consumer? Well, it's been a long time, but I think you could make a case in saying the opposite is true. "These guys have the top 5 results, they must be legit".
Might be a CS case on this, will see what I can find.
-
One of mine does that for a particular search term...I haven't manipulated anything just followed the best practises of SEO across each piece of content. If I had done any sort of dodgy manipulation, I would have been picked up by panda and penguin.
I hope they are not mistrusted because of it. If it were me experiencing it, I'd definitely remember them and probably look.
Let's face it, all SEO is manipulation of search results! Anybody who follows the best practises is hoping that their competitor is not and will therefore rank below them.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
List all keywords from a website per page in a table??
Hi all, Very basic question I know but strangely cannot find a solution to it? (its 20:40 on a Fri-night! 😉 ) I am working on a website that has over 100 pages and would like to see all the keywords associated with each page maybe in a table report of some kind? Is this at all possible? Heres an example URL KEYWORDS /index.html Moz, Moz local, London /aboutmoz.html Moz. Moz SEO, London and so on....
Search Behavior | | darrenbooy0 -
MozPoints end of year 2015, top 50 aggregated
On December 30th, 2015 I decided to look at the Moz Community Rankings, I find it fun to do for time to time, and I always like to see how close I am to getting that special dinner with Rand I have heard so much about in the past. One thing I noticed right away is that Moz ranks members just on MozPoints, and not on other factors like, how helpful they tend to be. This means had I joined in a few years earlier, I could be at the top.. or could I be??? Again, it is just something I did for fun, but I decided to look at a few additional factors to get my True MozRank 🙂 By examining just the top 50 active members I added some additional ranking factors and aggregated them to find a true Rank. The ranking factors are.. Moz Points Per Month (Using the users points divided by months they have been a member) Thumbs Up percentage (Using the percentage of Thumbs Up they receive per point) Good Answer percentage (Using the percentage of Good Answers they receive per point) Endorsed Answer percentage (Using the percentage of Endorsed Answers they receive per point) After that I gave each of the top 50 a rank in each category based on their respective scores. I then totaled the ranks, and assigned a new final rank based on the lowest totals (which means they ranked the best).
Search Behavior | | donford
Edit (01/18/2016): With the help of Peter Nikolow I aggregated all active users as per this post.
Link to all 4291 active users ranks For example EGOL category ranks: MozPoint Rank (1) Points Per Month Rank (2) Percent of Thumbs Up Rank (27) Percent of Good Answers Rank (29) Percent of Endorsed Answers Rank (23) Total = 82
Final Rank = 5 His closest competitor RyanKent MozPoint Points rank 2 MozPoint Rank (2) Points Per Month Rank (3) Percent of Thumbs Up Rank (39) Percent of Good Answers Rank (9) Percent of Endorsed Answers Rank (20) Total = 73
Final Rank = 2 Well it was a fun experiment for me, a couple people are out of place in the rankings based on other factors but for the most part MozPoints are pretty accurate. You can view the spread sheet on Google Docs and play around with the data as you wish. Don EDIT: After looking at the document again I noticed an error with rank assignments I have since fixed it. Edit (01/18/2016): With the help of Peter Nikolow I aggregated all active users as per this post. Link to all 4291 active users ranks13 -
Search Analytics update in Google Webmasters Tools? Where can we find search queries bringing traffic to website?
I just got up and see Search Analytic's being updated today totally. Their is no option to see old reports. As Search Analytics only share 999 keywords.
Search Behavior | | csfarnsworth
Whats next now?
How can a webmaster finds all search queries bringing traffic to his website?
Any paid or free tool?
Google Analytic's > Acquisition > Search engine optimization > search queries will this area helps? Whole question revolves around. Any good tool that will help you find all the queries bringing traffic to my website?0 -
Store locator searches online and offline store visits
Hi All, What is the accepted % for visitors that conduct a store locator search online actually visiting that particular store for the nutrition industry? (For example if 50 people used the store locator search on the website , we can confidently say that 25 of them actually went to that store) Any input or reference to studies/white papers on this topic would be appreciated. Cheers, SEO5..
Search Behavior | | SEO5Team0 -
Safari Has Top Browser in Google Analytics?
I find this hard to believe but it looks to me as though Safari has jumped ahead as our top browser in the month of January. At first glance I would think it was combining mobile safari with desktop safari numbers but then on the 5th spot I see Safari(in-app) which after looking into could be multiple things from safari mobile, bookmarked pages, or Chrome for ios. Just looking for thoughts on this, are others seeing a large uptick in Safari traffic for desktops?
Search Behavior | | sknott0 -
Google Instant Search? REALLY?! Why is this the result???
First, this is one I thought I would never ask, but: Could this be true? I had noticed my MacBook Pro was eating some power and wanted to see if I could optimize my settings so to take advantage what battery life was available. (I swear that is the truth). So, I am at a Starbucks on someone and typed into Google search bar the following query - Best way to conserve - and, received the following instant search results before I could type - power on a macbook pro I am not putting it here as I want you to ask yourself what came up. I have attached a screenshot. My colleague arrived and without prompting she retried and got the same. So I am curious: Do you get the same result and why do you think that result is so predominant? This is funny. efuts.png
Search Behavior | | RobertFisher2 -
Local search advice?
Some sites i promote limit their services to 50 miles around their location how best is it to optimise their websites. Currently they don't rank very well for non localised search terms but they do very well for term which include their local area. is this something they should be concerned about? Any tips and advice on optimising for local search are greatly appreciated. thanks
Search Behavior | | Bristolweb0 -
Website coming up in omitted results for search term?
Hi, My website is coming up in omitted results for search term. Now I have heard before if this is the case then its mainly due to a duplicate content penalty. But the content I used is unique and produced by a copywriter so its good. Its a new site and was in the results for about 2 weeks, I changed the non www to www in webmaster tools 1 day ago and now its sitting in omitted results. In webmaster tools I had to add the domain twice one non www and one www. Both accounts I hooked up a sitemap. Is it just because the site is new and its just working out where to rank me? Just so you know the non www was indexed for the 2 weeks changed it in webmaster tools so I wanted the www one indexed and now gone into omitted results. Cheers
Search Behavior | | activitysuper0