How can I best handle parameters?
-
Thank you for your help in advance! I've read a ton of posts on this forum on this subject and while they've been super helpful I still don't feel entirely confident in what the right approach I should take it. Forgive my very obvious noob questions - I'm still learning!
The problem: I am launching a site (coursereport.com) which will feature a directory of schools. The directory can be filtered by a handful of fields listed below. The URL for the schools directory will be coursereport.com/schools. The directory can be filtered by a number of fields listed here:
- Focus (ex: “Data Science”)
- Cost (ex: “$<5000”)
- City (ex: “Chicago”)
- State/Province (ex: “Illinois”)
- Country (ex: “Canada”)
When a filter is applied to the directories page the CMS produces a new page with URLs like these:
- coursereport.com/schools?focus=datascience&cost=$<5000&city=chicago
- coursereport.com/schools?cost=$>5000&city=buffalo&state=newyork
My questions:
1) Is the above parameter-based approach appropriate? I’ve seen other directory sites that take a different approach (below) that would transform my examples into more “normal” urls.
coursereport.com/schools?focus=datascience&cost=$<5000&city=chicago
VERSUS
coursereport.com/schools/focus/datascience/cost/$<5000/city/chicago (no params at all)
2) Assuming I use either approach above isn't it likely that I will have duplicative content issues? Each filter does change on page content but there could be instance where 2 different URLs with different filters applied could produce identical content (ex: focus=datascience&city=chicago OR focus=datascience&state=illinois). Do I need to specify a canonical URL to solve for that case? I understand at a high level how rel=canonical works, but I am having a hard time wrapping my head around what versions of the filtered results ought to be specified as the preferred versions. For example, would I just take all of the /schools?focus=X combinations and call that the canonical version within any filtered page that contained other additional parameters like cost or city?
-
Should I be changing page titles for the unique filtered URLs?
-
I read through a few google resources to try to better understand the how to best configure url params via webmaster tools. Is my best bet just to follow the advice on the article below and define the rules for each parameter there and not worry about using rel=canonical ?
https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/1235687
An assortment of the other stuff I’ve read for reference:
http://www.wordtracker.com/academy/seo-clean-urls
http://www.practicalecommerce.com/articles/3857-SEO-When-Product-Facets-and-Filters-Fail
http://www.searchenginejournal.com/five-steps-to-seo-friendly-site-url-structure/59813/
http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2011/07/improved-handling-of-urls-with.html
-
I think you have your answer then on how you want to focus your URLs and your site!
-
Absolutely helpful. I really appreciate it. I think one real use case that I may want to solve for is the "focus" plus "city" combo. Ie: "data science schools in chicago". Based on the research I've done thus far I think that may be the only permutation really worth worrying about. Again - thanks a lot!
-
I am not going to be very helpful here.
Looking at those parameters and all the options you would have for URLs, yes you are ripe for duplicate content issue and a whole mess of search engine problems/confusion.
I read this the other day in the QNA forum here at Moz and I wish I could remember to give them credit for the quote, they said "Don't submit search results to the search engines" - so true - so true ....
Why? You end up with an almost infinite number of thin, duplicate pages that Google then does not know which ones to rank. Even if you put all the parameters into a static URL you still have the same problem.
I think you need to step back a sec
Are people searching for "data science schools in Chicago Illinois that cost less than $5000"?
Why would you even want to attempt to setup pages that could potentially rank for those terms based on the URL?
Launch the search function on the site, but hide all the search URLs behind robots.txt
Just setup things like
/search/?focus=datascience&cost=$<5000&city=chicago
/search/focus/datascience/cost/$<5000/city/chicago
put /search/ in robots and you are set
Another option (from one of my favorite WBF http://moz.com/blog/whiteboard-friday-using-the-hash)
Hide all the parameters behind the hash and they stay hidden from the search engines
/schools#?focus=datascience&cost=$<5000&city=chicago
Then go back, do your keyword research and build helpful static URL pages around what your users are searching for and then get those pages to rank. If that ultimately is the type of page above, I would bet you $3,141 plus an apple pie that you need to setup a simpler organization of pages and urls around location say /il/chicago/school-name or type /data-science/school-name and then all the other iterations, you would hide behind a hash etc.
Maybe this did help - I hope so.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How to handle one section of duplicate content
Hi guys, i'm wondering if I can get some best practice advice in preparation for launching our new e-commerce website. For the new website we are creating location pages with a description and things to do which will lead the user to hotels in the location. For each hotel page which relates to the location we will have the same 'Things to do' content. This is what the content will look like on each page: Location page Location title (1-3 words) Location description (150-200 words) Things to do (200-250 words) Reasons to visit location (15 words) Hotel page Hotel name and address (10 words) Short description (25 words) Reasons to book hotel (15 words) Hotel description (100-200 words) Friendly message why to visit (15 words) Hotel reviews feed from trust pilot Types of break and information (100-200 words) Things to do (200-250 words) My question is how much will we penalised for having the same 'Things to do' content on say up to 10 hotels + 1 location page? In an ideal world we want to develop a piece of code which tells search engines that the original content lies on the location page but this will not be possible before we go live. I'm unsure whether we should just go and take the potential loss in traffic or remove the 'Things to do' section on hotel pages until we develop the piece of code?
Technical SEO | | CHGLTD1 -
Best Way to Handle Near-Duplicate Content?
Hello Dear MOZers, Having duplicate content issues and I'd like some opinions on how best to deal with this problem. Background: I run a website for a cosmetic surgeon in which the most valuable content area is the section of before/after photos of our patients. We have 200+ pages (one patient per page) and each page has a 'description' block of text and a handful of before and after photos. Photos are labeled with very similar labels patient-to-patient ("before surgery", "after surgery", "during surgery" etc). Currently, each page has a unique rel=canonical tag. But MOZ Crawl Diagnostics has found these pages to be duplicate content of each other. For example, using a 'similar page checker' two of these pages were found to be 97% similar. As far as I understand there are a few ways to deal with this, and I'd like to get your opinions on the best course. Add 150+ more words to each description text block Prevent indexing of patient pages with robots.txt Set the rel=canonical for each patient page to the main gallery page Any other options or suggestions? Please keep in mind that this is our most valuable content, so I would be reluctant to make major structural changes, or changes that would result in any decrease in traffic to these pages. Thank you folks, Ethan
Technical SEO | | BernsteinMedicalNYC0 -
Can someone interpret this entry in my htaccess file into english so that I can understand?
There are a number of entries in my htaccess and I'd like to understand what they are doing so that I can understand if they need to be there or not. So, can someone tell me what this says...in plain english? RewriteCond %{HTTP_HOST} ^legacytravel.com$ [OR]
Technical SEO | | cathibanks
RewriteCond %{HTTP_HOST} ^www.legacytravel.com$
RewriteRule ^carrollton-travel-agent$ "http://www.legacytravel.com/carrollton-travel-agent" [R=301,L] Thank you a million times in advance.0 -
What is the best way to deal with https?
Currently, the site I am working on is using HTTPS throughout the website. The non-HTTPS pages are redirected through a 301 redirect to the HTTPS- this happens for all pages. Is this the best strategy going forward? if not, what changes would you suggest?
Technical SEO | | adarsh880 -
What can i do to get google to visit my site more often
Hi, i am having serious problems since i upgraded my website from joomla 1.5 to 3.0 We have dropped down the rankings from page one for the word lifestyle magazine, and we have dropped down in rankings for other very important words including gastric band hypnotherapy and i am starting to regret having the site upgraded. i am finding the google is taking its time visiting my site, i know this for two reasons, one i have checked the cache and it is showing the 2nd july and i have checked articles that we have written and they are still not showing. example if i put this article name in word for word it does not come up, Carnival Divert Ships In The Caribbean Due To bad Weather this was an article that was done yesterday. in the old days before the upgrade that would have been in google now. these problems are costing us the loss of a great deal of traffic, we are losing around 70% of our traffic since the upgrade and would be grateful if people could give me advice on how to turn things around. we add articles all the time. each day we add a number of articles, i was considering changing the front page in the middle and having a few paragraphs of the latest story to get google to visit more often. i know this would look messy but i am running out of ideas. any help would be great
Technical SEO | | ClaireH-1848860 -
600+ 404 Errors: Best Practice for Redirects?
Hi All, I've just checked my GWMT profile for one of my client's sites and found that there are currently over 600 404 Error notifications! This is not that surprising given that we very recently redesigned and launched their new corporate site, which previously had a ton of "junk" legacy pages. I was wondering if it would work in terms of efficient SEO to simply apply a 301 redirect from the 404 page to our root to solve this issue? If not what would be a good solution? Thanks in advance for all your great advice!
Technical SEO | | G2W1 -
Can Google Anlaytics Segment By Time of the DaY?
Greetings from Latitude 53.92705600 Longitude -1.38481600... Can Google analytics anser this question..."Tell me on the 1st Sept how many visitors landed on my site between 1200HRS & 1300HRS" Grazie Tanto,
Technical SEO | | Nightwing
David0 -
Best way to handle with a Multiple Langue Issue
Howdy everyone! I am having trouble with deciding on how to solve a Multiple Language Issue. I went to several consultants here in Mexico, but i am not totally convinced on their solution. So i am hoping to hear excellent advice (as always) here on the SEOMOZ Forum. I have a website, (www.aceromart.com) an ecommerce site in which to sell materials for the construction industry. My main market is in Mexico, therefore the website is in Spanish. However, the export sales are increasing and some of the suppliers are from USA. I need to include the English version on my website, however i dont know how to do this. The option that they propose is to create an entirely different website with another domain. Entirely in English that links to my existing website. I did not like this at all. Mainly because i would not like to change the brand name or anything. I would like to include the English version within my website. Is it okay, if treat it as a folder withing my website. I.E www.aceromart.com/english/content? What is the best way to do this according to your experience. Best Regards, thanks for your help.
Technical SEO | | JesusD0